Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

What About Dating?


Dating Non-Catholics  

42 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

LuchaporElRey21
Posted

Ok Phat pham, I need your help. I have a general question: what about dating non-Catholics? Should we, or should we not?

My opinion is no. But, I want to hear everyone else's reasons. I think dating leads to marriage, and if that person isn't disposed to convert to the truth, then there is no point in the first place. Who knows? :idontknow: God is mysterious.

Posted

Well it depends on how disposed the non-Catholic is to possibly converting. You never know :idontknow:

If the person is [b]anti[/b]-Catholic, however, that's a different story...

franciscanheart
Posted

I have known far too many people who have married non-Catholics who later converted to say that it is wrong to date and marry a non-Catholic. What we need to discern is the will of the Father. If we are open to life and truth in our relationships, then we are setting ourselves up for good things. No one says that marrying a non-Catholic will be easy but surrendering to the will of the Father hardly ever is.

So I guess my answer is this: yes, it's okay. [size=1](Though if I had more time and patience I would write about my beliefs about seeking out a good and faithful Catholic spouse vs. having a good spouse 'fall into your lap' who is not Catholic and may not seem as though they are open conversion...)[/size]

xTrishaxLynnx
Posted

I voted no, but really that's just me. I wouldn't really want to date someone who was not Catholic. I know relationships between a Catholic and a non-Catholic can work, probably just as well, especially if they have similar views on the important decisions couples make. So I guess it's something that has to be decided on an individual basis.

Posted

I'm dating a non-Catholic. He seemed to be against it when we first met, but now he asks questions and he defends me when someone makes an anti-Catholic remark towards me.

LuchaporElRey21
Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1111238' date='Nov 4 2006, 07:02 PM'](Though if I had more time and patience I would write about my beliefs about seeking out a good and faithful Catholic spouse vs. having a good spouse 'fall into your lap' who is not Catholic and may not seem as though they are open conversion...)[/size]
[/quote]

That is the crux right there. We should seek out those who will build up our faith and help us grow on the path of righteousness. So I suppose them being Catholic helps this process.

Love is a mysterious thing.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='hugheyforlife' post='1111238' date='Nov 4 2006, 08:02 PM']
I have known far too many people who have married non-Catholics who later converted to say that it is wrong to date and marry a non-Catholic. What we need to discern is the will of the Father. If we are open to life and truth in our relationships, then we are setting ourselves up for good things. No one says that marrying a non-Catholic will be easy but surrendering to the will of the Father hardly ever is.

So I guess my answer is this: yes, it's okay. [size=1](Though if I had more time and patience I would write about my beliefs about seeking out a good and faithful Catholic spouse vs. having a good spouse 'fall into your lap' who is not Catholic and may not seem as though they are open conversion...)[/size]
[/quote]

Ditto that. While dating a non-Catholic isn't the ideal, its perfectly acceptable. Like Hughey, I've known way too many people who have been converted by their spouse to say no. Even people who had not converted their spouse (yet) can still have happy marriages, healthy families, and raise their kids Catholic (one of my good friends is from a "mixed-religion" family, and while her dad still hasn't converted all the children are solid Catholics).

homeschoolmom
Posted

I dated a non-Catholic... I even married one. So did my husband.

franciscanheart
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1111467' date='Nov 4 2006, 09:16 PM']
I dated a non-Catholic... I even married one. So did my husband.
[/quote]
:lol:

Posted

Well, I voted no, but like Trisha Lynn thats a just-me sort of thing. I didn't have the greatest experience. My mom, however, married a Lutheran (now Catholic) and I know of other times its worked out fine. I think it depends on you, on the other person- how strong each of you is in your faith, how open to conversion, not anti-Catholic, etc.

~Katie

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1111467' date='Nov 4 2006, 08:16 PM']
I dated a non-Catholic... I even married one. So did my husband.
[/quote]
:shock:





:hehe:

Posted

I'm here because of a Catholic and a non catholic.

Personally I don't think I could do it but thats just me- not to say others couldnt

Posted (edited)

I see nothing wrong with dating a non-Catholic, just as long as you do not let that person compromise your faith. If the individual is anti-Catholic however, I would stay clear from him/her. God can use you as a vessel to show the love of Christ to them, and hopefully positive results will come from that. I'm not implying we should date non-Catholics just so we can "save them", but if you really do like (or love) that person and want to take it a step further, then go ahead. However, pray a lot and do not compromise your faith.

Edited by Paladin D
LuchaporElRey21
Posted

Cool. Then I agree with you guys. There is nothing wrong with dating a non-Catholic so long as it does not compromise your faith.

Case closed!

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

I answered no, cause I am married. I can't date. :lol_roll: :lol_roll: :lol_roll: :lol_roll:

But I see nothing wrong with it otherwise, if conducted in a chaste manner. Dating is the search for your mate. During the process, one learns what qualities one is looking for and also learns how to 'love' another.

That said, my daughter ain't dating till she's 16 and not gonna be alone on a date with a guy till she's 18+. If I had my druthers, she'd start dating at 25....

AND..all prospective dates must be introduced to me BEFORE I concede...er..allow her to date said toad..er...young gentleman. I must have the proper opportunity to introduce him to my shotgun, shovel, and large backyard and the consequences if he makes poor choices regarding my babygirl. :ninja:

Pontifite 7 of 10
Posted

You may date, I think.
But if it gets seirious, try to convert Him or her.
Sooner than later.

Proud2BCatholic139
Posted

If they are interested in the Catholic Faith and want to convert, I say it's ok. But, it's risky. It is recomended no, but there are certain circumstances. You can't marry within the Catholic Church if you are marrying a non-catholic, unless if they convert and recieve the sacraments before marriage.

Posted

That's not true, you can have a Sacramental marriage with someone who is a validly baptized Protestant and I believe you can have a valid marriage with someone who is not a Christian. My aunt and uncle had a Sacramental marriage and my aunt is not a Catholic.

Posted

i see nothing wrong with it as long as they aren't anti catholic and you don't argue over religion and you agree on how to raise the children. I've seen many people of two different denomenations marry and live happily. Also it depends how strong each person is in their faith.

Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1111888' date='Nov 5 2006, 01:24 PM']
I answered no, cause I am married. I can't date. :lol_roll: :lol_roll: :lol_roll: :lol_roll:

But I see nothing wrong with it otherwise, if conducted in a chaste manner. Dating is the search for your mate. During the process, one learns what qualities one is looking for and also learns how to 'love' another.

That said, my daughter ain't dating till she's 16 and not gonna be alone on a date with a guy till she's 18+. If I had my druthers, she'd start dating at 25....

AND..all prospective dates must be introduced to me BEFORE I concede...er..allow her to date said toad..er...young gentleman. I must have the proper opportunity to introduce him to my shotgun, shovel, and large backyard and the consequences if he makes poor choices regarding my babygirl. :ninja:
[/quote]
You sound like my husband. And we dont even have kids!!

He told all his neices this.
And warned his nephews to treat their dates with respect.

He went so far as to drag one poor fellow, who came to pick up a friends daughter for a date, down the basement stairs and place him in a chair with a swinging light over his head while he drilled him concerning his intentions towards the young lady in question.
They only went on that one date. :lol_pound:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...