Nathan Posted November 5, 2006 Posted November 5, 2006 I entered university with an eye toward focusing on philosophy and/or Classics (with an eye toward PhD studies in one of those fields), but more and more lately I've been feeling that the field of history is my academic calling. I like philosophy and I really like Classics (the literature, not so much the study of Greek and Latin language, which nearly destroyed me), but my history courses are what is really "lighting my fire," so to speak. It is the subject that comes most naturally to me, that I am the best at; I LOVE the process of spending weeks and months on end at libraries, painstakingly producing long historical research essays. Yes, I am a history nerd. I've been thinking a lot lately about the role of the academic Catholic historian in the Church and in the world, namely what a remarkable opportunity it can be to clear up widely-held misconceptions against the Church and reveal the truth to the general public through historical evidence. It can be a very real form of evangelism. An example might be clearing up a lot of the preconceived and often false notions about the Crusades, or the Inquisition, or the whole "Hitler's Pope" slandering. Another might be a book focusing on the early decades and centuries of Christianity, and how it becomes clear that the early Church was the Catholic Church. In short, the Catholic historian can be a real Defender of the Faith, and has the opportunity of reaching a lot more people than the average theologian or philosopher can. I'd like to hear some of your thoughts about this. Thanks, Nathan
Justified Saint Posted November 5, 2006 Posted November 5, 2006 Well, I think my experience has almost been the opposite of yours. I have always liked history and when I started getting seriously involved in my faith, I thought studying history would be a great academic pursuit in order to defend the faith against common misconceptions. But the fact is, history can't prove faith and it just seems like to me the strangest way to approach the matter. Don't get me wrong, this is to say nothing against history, in fact history is all we have. But if faith is hope in things unseen, then history can only tell us about what we have created (which is to say quite a bit!). This was Vico's great distinction, history is for man but the Truth is for God alone. Clearing up misconceptions about the Catholic Church's history is a great and noble thing I think, but if its part of some larger agenda to prove that the Church is always right, then I think its hopeless from the start. Now, I am actually much more interested in getting a Classics degree for my PhD with an emphasis in history.
Era Might Posted November 5, 2006 Posted November 5, 2006 Every historian starts with a perspective. For a Catholic historian, his perspective is founded on the truth that God became man in the person of Jesus Christ. All history is understood in light of this truth, including the nature of the Church as the Body of Christ. A good Catholic historian is objective with the facts, but the role of any historian is not only to provide facts, but to put those facts into context. So, for example, a Catholic historian writing about the rise of Christianity in first three centuries would put it into the context of God's providence, whereas a secular historian might put it into the context of social factors alone. Either way, any historian is going to be biased to a certain extent when he puts history into context, depending on how he sees the world. It's not disingenuous for a Catholic to write history from his perspective. I disagree strongly that history cannot prove faith. History, like creation itself, is filled with the proof of God's love. Why has Israel endured all these millenias? Why has the Church endured 2,000 years despite sin and scandal and all kinds of persecution? Is this a coincidence? History can't "prove" faith in a legalistic sense; ultimately you have to make the leap from evidence to faith. But history is an important tool in discerning why Catholicism is true. A modern example would be contraception; is it just a coincidence that Catholicism has stood so firm against contraception when other Christian bodies have caved? This suggests that God really is guiding the Church and the Papacy. It's not a piece of absolute scientific evidence, but it is very significant.
Justified Saint Posted November 5, 2006 Posted November 5, 2006 Of course I think history supports faith and vice versa -- faith broadly speaking as well as the particular truths of Christianity (indeed, the substance of faith is mostly historical). But its asking too much of history to make it prove that Catholicism is the only true religion -- that is an ahistorical claim.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now