Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I have been on a _A Man for All Seasons_ kick lately, and I got to wondering about what movie portrays Catholics the best.

I would say _A Man for All Seasons_ (the original one, with Paul Scofield) wins hands down.

Mel Gibson's portrayal of Hal Moore in _We Were Soldiers_ is great.

_Beckett_ is worth mentioning too. Richard Burton got the idea of finding peace and honor in doing the right thing right for Thomas a'Beckett.

_The Song of Bernadette_ is also outstanding in regards to sactity and suffering.

Any thoughts? I think that Robert Bolt's play is a masterpeice and shows more understanding of Catholicism and respect of heroism than I have seen since (Mel Gibson being the obvious exception).

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

I thought of "A Man for All Seasons" as soon as I read your question.

Posted

JMJ

1/14 - First Wednesday

Man, I LOVE A Man for All Seasons (I'm reading it now). In addition, I think Alfred Hitchcock's I Confess does a wonderful job of portraying the sanctity of the confessional.

Yours,

Pio Nono

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Boy's Town with Spencer Tracy.

Seatbelt Blue
Posted

Hell, I've always been partial to Bless the Child (God only knows why).

Posted

How about Bing Crosby in Goin' My Way? (Or am I the only one to have seen this movie?)

What about the nuns in The Sound of Music?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

Or the Nun's Story.

Posted

the Mission

I second that one. Great movie.

Posted

Sister Act I and II were cool.

Ash Wednesday
Posted

X-Men 2 was alright

Nightcrawler! Aww he's such a sweetie....I like him! :D

(almost as much as Wolverine) hehehehehe.... ;)

As far as modern day non-religious movies go, Sister Act is pretty good. I can't think of anything else right now. Maybe I'll think of more after my coffee sinks in.

Posted (edited)

DOGMA, STIGMATA, AGNES OF GOD, GODFATHER III, THE THORNBIRDS, 40 DAYS and 40 NIGHTS, PRIMAL FEAR

All perfect examples of.......

carp. (can I say that on here?)

Edited by socalscout
Posted

DOGMA, STIGMATA, AGNES OF GOD, GODFATHER III, THE THORNBIRDS, 40 DAYS and 40 NIGHTS.

All perfect examples of.......

carp. (can I say that on here?)

wow you almost got me good with that one. Especially when you said the Thornbirds...ouch. Like that movie helps portray Catholics correctly. You might as well add The Order on there with the rest.

Kilroy the Ninja
Posted

The Mission was an amesome movie... although it's made me rethink my feelings towards the Portuguese (no offense intended....)

Don John of Austria
Posted

Yeah Kilroy has gotten really made at me before because I have shown her entirely to many Good movies which make you reconcider felling torward someone. I would have to agree with the mission, aman for all seasons( theres a newer one?) and Becket.

Don John of Austria
Posted

The Black Robe was also good

hyperdulia again
Posted

Anne of the Thousand Days is good. the Portrayal of poor Queen Catherine was very stirring and it offers some insight into why Bloody Mary was so bloody. It even made me like Charles V---I've never cared for him, he used force to get his will from the Pontiff, he convinced the world his mother was crazy, took her throne, and made her raise his children. bad boy.

hyperdulia again
Posted

adendum diary of anne boleyn NOT anne of the thousand days.

Her Catholic Majesty Queen Claude of France's speach on the virtues of being a wife rather than a mistress is REAL Medieval feminism at its best.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...