Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Why was Matthias chosen to replace Judas by lot? It seems rather strange way to do such an important thing. Why didn't the Apostles vote or hand pick him?

Posted

Maybe so that nobody would get jealous. Isn't lots like dice or something? They probably trusted the Holy Spirit and a game of chance more than they did themselves. They had fought before about who was the greatest and what not.

Here's something from a St. John Chrysostom homily:

[quote]Here is forethought for providing a teacher; here was the first who was ordained a teacher. He [Peter] did not say: 'We are sufficient.' So far was he beyond all vain glory, and he looked to one thing alone. And yet he had the same power to ordain as they all collectively. But well might these things be done in this fashion, through the noble spirit of the man, and in regard that prelacy then was not an affair of dignity, but of provident care for the governed. This neither made the elected to become elated, for it was to dangers that they were called, nor those not elected to make a grievance of it, as if they were disgraced. But things are not done in that fashion now; nay, quite the contrary. For observe they were a hundred and twenty, and he asks for one out of the whole body; with good right, as having been put in charge of them; for to him Christ had said: 'And when thou art converted, strengthen thy brethren'.[/quote]

Posted

As strange as it seems to us, it would not have been innovative or unusual for them. Israelite religion made use of the "urim and thummim" which were like dice... they were used as prophetic instruments through which the Lord would reveal His decision. They show up in Ex 28:30, Lev 8:8, also Deut, Sam, Ezra and Neh. I'm not aware of any evidence they were still in use in New Testament times among the synagogues... but at least the idea of casting lots for divine decision is well-rooted in the OT.

son_of_angels
Posted

Well, they had already defined the criteria, and only two were found to fit. They were both equally qualified, but, in their judgment, only one was called to the Apostolate. As such, they let God show his will.

Posted

I don't know how widespread this is, but some parishes have implemented choice by lots for the parish council, or council chairman, etc. I've only witnessed it a few times, but it seemed like a sincere and legit process. They had a nomination process and prayed to the Holy Spirit, then drew a name after Mass one Sunday.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...