beatty07 Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 (edited) I give a lot of vocation talks, and this question ALWAYS comes up. I've developed a number of different angles from which to approach it... but I'm usually unsatisfied by my response. It's easy enough to rehearse the "fundamental reasons" listed in Inter Insigniores and elsewhere. I'm pretty good at explaining why women can't be priests. I'm not so good at making 14-yr old girls see this as part of God's beautiful Truth. I'm looking for a way to communicate the splendor of truth. Put another way: I feel like my explanation should result in her walking away feeling like a million bucks, praising God that she is fearfully and wonderfully made, and thinking "wow, I had no idea that our creation as male and female was so wonderful." Maybe that's asking too much, but I actually pulled it off once. My friend cried and said "I'd never thought of it like that before." But that's the exception - it doesn't usually go that well! So I guess what I'm asking is: can anyone point me toward a really good discussion of what it means to be created female in the image of God? I've had some success talking about Our Lady and motherhood in general. The catch there is so many people today...even young girls... have been taught to see motherhood as a burden, an obstacle. Which is really depressing! I don't want to ramble on too much, but I would really appreciate some suggestions, or maybe some books or articles or something. Edited November 6, 2006 by beatty07
Era Might Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 Johnette Benkovic has an apostolate for Catholic women: [url="http://www.womenofgrace.com/"]http://www.womenofgrace.com/[/url] I don't know if they have any resources there, but they might.
Veritas Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 + It's all related to the Theology of the Body. Emphasize the beauty of womanhood and manhood as distinct in practice but equal in dignity. My good friend is an excellent DRE in this area... I'm going to get her advice also. Fight the good fight!
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s=&showtopic=51921&view=findpost&p=971442"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...st&p=971442[/url]
beatty07 Posted November 6, 2006 Author Posted November 6, 2006 That thread has some helpful points (thanks for the link) but I'm looking less for "why women can't be priests" and more for "how femininity specifically and uniquely expresses the image of God." In this, I'm rejecting the notion expressed by one poster in that thread, that women are not created in the image and likeness of God. I think that idea is safely left behind now by, among other things, the Theology of the Body. The Alice von Hildebrand track looks promising...I'll check that out. I'm looking for ideas along the lines of Sojourner's post in that previous thread. We should certainly be willing to say, "only men can be priests." But we should have something to say to the girls after that, other than, as one poster put it, "get over it."
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 [quote name='beatty07' post='1113084' date='Nov 6 2006, 07:03 PM'] That thread has some helpful points (thanks for the link) but I'm looking less for "why women can't be priests" and more for "how femininity specifically and uniquely expresses the image of God." In this, I'm rejecting the notion expressed by one poster in that thread, that women are not created in the image and likeness of God. I think that idea is safely left behind now by, among other things, the Theology of the Body. The Alice von Hildebrand track looks promising...I'll check that out. I'm looking for ideas along the lines of Sojourner's post in that previous thread. We should certainly be willing to say, "only men can be priests." But we should have something to say to the girls after that, other than, as one poster put it, "get over it." [/quote] Have you read Mulieris Dignitatem?
Sojourner Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 [quote name='beatty07' post='1113084' date='Nov 6 2006, 05:03 PM'] That thread has some helpful points (thanks for the link) but I'm looking less for "why women can't be priests" and more for "how femininity specifically and uniquely expresses the image of God." In this, I'm rejecting the notion expressed by one poster in that thread, that women are not created in the image and likeness of God. I think that idea is safely left behind now by, among other things, the Theology of the Body. The Alice von Hildebrand track looks promising...I'll check that out. I'm looking for ideas along the lines of Sojourner's post in that previous thread. We should certainly be willing to say, "only men can be priests." But we should have something to say to the girls after that, other than, as one poster put it, "get over it." [/quote] I was going to dig that thread up, but looks like you've already seen it. Back when I had more time for reflection, this topic (how femininity specifically and uniquely expresses the image of God) is one I thought about a lot. Christopher West has a 2-CD talk on this topic, called [url="http://www.ascensionpress.com/shop/Scripts/prodView.asp?idproduct=102&idAff=1334"]"Woman: God's Masterpiece"[/url] that has some good stuff in it; it's worth listening too. The one criticism I have of this talk is that I am not comfortable with his tendency here to build women up by tearing men down. It's been a while since I listened to it, but I remember being turned off by some of his comments along those lines. I like being a woman, but I don't think women are better than men, or that men are better than women. I think of the genders as being differently situated mirrors reflecting different aspects of the character of God. I can understand your frustration here, though, in providing a positive model for women, something that shows what they CAN be rather than drawing lines around what they CAN'T be. The thing that CW does get right in the aforementioned talk is the focus on Mary as a model for true womanhood. I grew up Protestant, in a small conservative church, and the female role models I knew were by and large married stay-at-home moms. While I admire women who choose that as an option, thus far that hasn't been my calling in life. When it became apparent that wasn't going to happen for me right away, that (with other fun baggage) really made me wonder whether I had a place in the church at all. I know other women struggle with the same feelings, which is, I think, the root of the woman priest movement. You see the same thing in Protestant churches, where women are serving in pastoral roles that were formerly reserved for men. But, if I believe that God has uniquely gifted me as a woman, and that I uniquely reflect certain aspects of the image of God, then my role in the church is not going to be the same role that has been laid out for men. It's going to be something equally beautiful, but beautiful in a unique way. I think the best example of that beauty is Mary. In fact (and I'm sure that this will cement my liberal label here) I have sometimes wondered whether at some point in the future we will see the development of a liturgical role for women that is a fitting representation of the role of Mary in the church, just as priests are Christ for the church. I hope that's not blasphemous, but it's something I've pondered. But at this point, in the absence of such a role, I think the best direction for women to be thinking is to emulate Mary, in her receptivity to the will of God, in her willingness to bring forth and nurture life, and so on.
Piccoli Fiori JMJ Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 [i]The Priviledge of Being a Woman[/i] by Alice Von Hildebrand A wonderful short read that really explains beautifully the wonderful role of women. It is a bit scholarly in language though.
Veritas Posted November 6, 2006 Posted November 6, 2006 + I've got to second Mulieris Dignitatem. It's a must read and very quotable, i.e. a lot of sentances and ideas you can take-out to give to the young women.
Veritas Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 [quote name='Goetian' post='1113174' date='Nov 6 2006, 06:57 PM'] Separate but equal is no equality at all. [/quote] + Totally wrong -and I'm a woman. But, this isn't a debate thread, So start one there if you want.
sweetpea316 Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 This definitely is a Theology of the Body kind of topic... it made me go right to a part of a Christopher West book where this is discussed. There's a lot to be said about it, such as how equality between the sexes doesn't mean sameness, but this part jumped out at me too. "We call priests father for a reason. Priests efficaciously symbolize Christ's giving up his body for his Bride so that she can conceive life 'in the Holy Spirit'. Only men can do this. As John Paul II reminds us: 'It is the Eucharist that above all expresses the redemptive act of Christ the Bridegroom towards the Church, the Bride. This is clear and unambiguous when the sacramental ministry of the Eucharist, in which he priest acts in the person of Christ, is performed by a man.' If the ministry of the Eucharist were performed by a woman, the symbolism would become that of bride to bride. There would be no possibility of effecting nuptial union, and thus no possibility of new life coming to the Church. Here we see again how intimately united the marital embrace is with the Eucharist. John Paul II sums it up this way: 'The Eucharist is...the sacrament of the Bridegroom and of the Bride.'"
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 [quote name='Goetian' post='1113174' date='Nov 6 2006, 07:57 PM'] Separate but equal is no equality at all. [/quote] I wouldn't call this a case of separate but equal, I'd call it a case of different but equal.
Matty_boy Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 (edited) Ephesians 5 lays it out rather well why women can't be priests. It illustrates the Christ is the bridegroom and the Church is the bride. Very gender specific. Edited November 7, 2006 by Matty_boy
Veritas Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 (edited) + Just ran across this article (Make sure to use the bibliography too): [url="http://www.catholicmatch.com/pl/pages/articles/details.html?hc=1;article_id=887"]http://www.catholicmatch.com/pl/pages/arti...;article_id=887[/url] [b]Does The Church Discriminate? by Anna Buckowska Why women are not ordained priests?[/b] Not so long ago, I had a very interesting conversation on The Da Vinci Code and the origins of the Gospels. Discussing many aspects of the teaching of the Catholic Church while jumping from one subject to another, suddenly I heard the final question: "If it is not true that women are discriminated against in the Catholic Church, what is the reason that they are not ordained priests?" I took a deep breath… Although the question seems to be straight forward and simple, the answer is more complicated. Let me start with the first part of the question, which is the aspect of alleged discrimination against women by the Church. A "person" was always in the centre of Christianity. From the very beginning (as far as the Book of Genesis goes) it is clear that there is no difference between man and woman in God’s eyes, since both were created in the image and likeness of God. In the description found in the Book of Genesis (Gen 2:18-25) the woman is created by God ‘from the rib’ of the man and is placed at his side as another ‘I’, as the companion of the man, who feels alone in the surrounding world of living creatures and who finds in none of them the ‘helper’ suitable for himself. And it is not only the case of helping one another in ‘subduing the earth’ but it is also a matter of a life companion – not to exist only ‘side by side’ or ‘together’, but to exist mutually ‘one for another’. Woman must ‘help’ the man – and in his return he must ‘help’ her – first of all by the very fact of their ‘being human persons’. Being a person can only be achieved through a sincere gift of yourself. There were various women who appeared along the path of the mission of Jesus and it is universally admitted – even by people with a critical attitude towards the Christian message – that in the eyes of his contemporaries, Christ became a promoter of woman’s true dignity and of the vocation corresponding to this dignity. It is significant that during his important discussion about marriage and its indissolubility, in the presence of the Scribes, who by profession were experts in Law, Jesus made reference to the ‘beginning’. The question asked concerns a man’s right ‘to divorce one’s wife for any cause’ (Mt 19:3) and therefore also concerns the woman’s right, her rightful position in marriage and her dignity. While they were sure they had on their side the Mosaic legislation followed by Israel, Jesus answered ‘for your hardness of heart Moses allowed you to divorce your wives, but from the beginning it was not so’ (Mt 19:8), reminding them of proper regard for woman and her dignity based on mutual relationships of two people united in marriage. In all Jesus’ teaching, as well as in his behaviour, one can not find anything which would reflect the discrimination against women prevalent in his day. On the contrary, he spoke to everyone no matter whether they were regarded public sinners or adulteresses--e.g. the Samaritan woman, the woman who anointed his feet with perfumed oil or the woman caught in adultery. This latter example is especially eloquent. Before Jesus said to her: ‘Do not sin again’ he evoked an awareness of sin in the men who accused her in order to stone her. His simple words ‘if there is one of you who has not sinned let him be the first to throw the stone at her’ seem to say to the accusers: ‘Is not this woman, for all her sin, above all a confirmation of your own transgressions, of your ‘male’ injustice, your misdeeds?’ [b]Mary Magdalene[/b] This understanding of the position of women has always been present in the teaching of the Catholic Church for the last 2000 years and especially pointed out in the writings and teachings of Pope John Paul II (e.g. ‘Familiaris Consortio’, ‘Redemptoris Mater’, ‘Mulieris Dignitatem’, ‘Christifidelis Laici’, ‘Letter to Women’), as well as in the first ever encyclical letter by Pope Benedict XVI (‘Deus Caritas Est’). If there could have been some misunderstanding regarding the dignity of a woman as equal to a man before, they should not have existed since Jesus Christ had come to this earth and had made a 'woman’s case’ especially explicit. It is worthwhile to mention that if there were some doubts among the Apostles, whether the teaching of Christ and baptism should have ever been spread among the pagans, there was not even one moment of hesitation whether it should include women or not. Before I refer to the second part of the question which is ‘what is the reason, that women are not ordained priests?’ let me give you some basic historical, social and theological background on the subject. First of all, I have to mention that there are two kinds of priesthood in the Catholic Church. The first one, commonly known and which our question is about, is called the ministerial priesthood. This is received by the sacrament of the Holy Orders, and empowers the recipient to celebrate the Holy Mass – the sacrament of the Eucharist and to confer the other sacraments such as: Baptism, Penance and Reconciliation (confession), Confirmation, Holy Orders, and the Anointing of the Sick. However, there is another priesthood called a royal one, which every baptised person (men and women) is called to, and which is to give a witness of our faith in everyday life. There is something particularly interesting about the fact that in all discussions about female participation in the ministerial priesthood, one forgets that in both Cananian religions of the Old Testament and in the religions, which co-existed with Christianity of the first ages, a woman priesthood was nothing unusual (e.g. the cult of Westa, the goddess of hearth and home; Demeter, the goddess of soil and wheat; women were also important in a cult of Dionisos, the god of vine and wine as well as in the cult of Fortune, the goddess of happiness and abundance). In the Cananian cults, where fertility of the earth was ascribed to the temple’s sexual rites, the role of the priestess took on shape of ‘sacred’ prostitution. [b]Cult Priestesses[/b] The supporters of a women’s priesthood claim that the only reason why only men have been ordained priests is a result of discrimination against women. However, a thoughtful person, who considers all the facts I mentioned above, will see easily that it is not a very strong argument and one can refute it easily. With the above knowledge, one can see that the Ancient Christian Church had to have really good reasons not to follow its pagan contemporary customs. The fact, that for Jesus and his followers, who were used to the existence of pagan priestesses there was not even a question about women’s presence as priests in Christianity, despite the highest level of human holiness of the Virgin Mary, who has been called the Queen of Apostles. What was the reason then? One can not also forget that the Church acknowledging her place in the face of God uses exactly a female symbolism as she sees herself as beloved spouse of Christ and the Mother of all the faithful. All the teachers of the faith have always recognized the attributes of the Church in all the women described in the Gospels. The opposing ends of this continuum are depicted in the persons of the woman caught in adultery (as a symbol of sin present in the Church), on the one hand, and in the Virgin Mary, on the other hand, who is considered to be a perfect model of the Church in the end of time. Because the Church (all the baptized, both men and women) is symbolized by a woman, this is the very reason why the sacrament of Holy Orders (through which the ministerial mission entrusted by Jesus to his apostles is fulfilled) is received only by men. It is worthwhile to notice while Holy Orders are conferred to 1 out of 1000 men (in the scale of the whole Church), it does not mean that the other 999 men are disadvantaged on their way to salvation. Neither has it meant that the male sex is more important. Another reason, why only men are ordained priests results from the faith in the mystery of the incarnation. We believe that the Son of God was a particular man, who had lived in a certain place and time, having a particular sex (male). Therefore, if the ministerial priesthood (through the celebration of Holy Mass) makes Jesus’ presence manifest there would not be any natural physical similarity, which should occur between the High Priest (Jesus himself) and his ministers, if women were ordained. Moreover, it would be extremely difficult to perceive Christ’s picture in a person of a priest, if this person is not a man. There is something far more important in our ministry and place in the Church than just affiliation to a particular sex. Unfortunately, a Marxist idea of fight of the classes is too often heard in the statements given on woman’s position within the Catholic Church. The idea does not apply to any of the aspects of human life, and especially to the relationship between man and woman. God created man and woman for their mutual development and having two opposite sex camps fighting each other ought not exist. [b]Bibliography[/b] 1. Collaboration of men and women in the Church, Congregation for the doctrine of the faith, Catholic Truth Society, 2004 2. John Paul II, Mulieris Dignitatem, 1988, www.vatican.va 3. Mullins M., Letter to Marianne on the ordination of women, Scepter booklets no. 174, Scepter Publishers, 1988 4. The Catechism of the Catholic Church 5. The Gospel according to John, Catholic Truth Society, 2002 6. The Gospel according to Mathew, Catholic Truth Society, 2002 7. Salij J., Dlaczego kobiety nie sprawuja Euchrystii?, W drodze, no. 10 (326) 2000, www.mateusz.pl 8. Salij J., Nadzieja poddawana probom. Kobieta i mezczyzna w Ko?ciele, www.mateusz.pl 9. Salij J., Kobieta w chrze?cija?stwie, W drodze no. 2 (366) 2004, www.mateusz.pl Edited November 7, 2006 by Veritas
Tom Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 (edited) I also do a lot of vocation talks and get the same question. I would talk about a lot of the ideas already expressed on this thread, but perhaps also add that as well as the hierachical constitution of the church, there's also a scale of holiness - look who's at the top of that : i'm currently reading Robert Pesarchick's "The Trinitarian Foundation of Human Sexuality as revealed by Christ according to Hans Urs von Blathasar: The Revelatory Significance of the Male Christ and the Male Ministerial Priesthood" which is excellent in drawing together Von Balthasar's fascinating insights into the subject... Edited November 7, 2006 by Tom
phatcatholic Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 you all really need to check out the directory more: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/617"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/617[/url]
beatty07 Posted November 7, 2006 Author Posted November 7, 2006 Does that mean I shouldn't have posted? I'm just asking what people have found to work well... confused. But yeah, the directory listing is great and all.
heyyoimjohnny Posted November 7, 2006 Posted November 7, 2006 see if you can get a third party guy to talk about their dignity and beauty in the deeper sense. if thats plausible.
desertwoman Posted November 8, 2006 Posted November 8, 2006 It takes a strong woman to accept the fact that she can not be a priest or govern over men in the church.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now