Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[url="http://www.independentcatholics.org/"]http://www.independentcatholics.org/[/url]

Whats the story with this? I have a friend of mine with a non-credited degree (phd in less than 2 years..good stuff) and started calling himself priest because he works with the ICCI..

something just doesnt seem right.

Posted

[quote]We are Catholic Churches but not Roman Catholic Churches. There are many similarities as well as many differences. The Roman Catholic Church is rigidly hierarchal in political structure. Independent Catholic Churches are radically independent and interdependent. We are free of hierarchy. We are an organization of mutual cooperation between clergy, congregations and ministries. We are, however, fully Catholic in liturgy and sacrament. Priests and Bishops are, however, free to choose, with their congregations and dioceses, their own rite. We have clergy and churches that use the Roman Catholic Novus Ordo, Anglican Book of Common Prayer, Western Orthodox and others as appropriate to the congregation its language and culture[/quote]
There is no such thing as an "independent" Catholic Church. If you are not under the jurisdiction of a Bishop who has full communion with the Holy See, then you are not a Catholic Church.

Posted

It's amazing how unclear some people are about this. Here's a conversation with two "seminarians" from Protestant groups at Eden Seminary in St. Louis.

Them: Oh you're Catholic? That's cool. We have a Catholic seminarian at Eden.

Me: Really? That's a surprise. What's his name?

Them: Jessica.

Posted

[quote name='beatty07' post='1113071' date='Nov 6 2006, 05:49 PM']
It's amazing how unclear some people are about this. Here's a conversation with two "seminarians" from Protestant groups at Eden Seminary in St. Louis.

Them: Oh you're Catholic? That's cool. We have a Catholic seminarian at Eden.

Me: Really? That's a surprise. What's his name?

Them: Jessica.
[/quote]
Maybe it was a semantics issue. I attend a seminary (actually, an accredited graduate school and House of Formation) and am a woman. In Protestant circles, it's very easy to call myself a "seminarian" or to say I'm "in the seminary." But I clarify by telling them than I'm non-ordination. So... yeah... :idontknow:

Posted

true dat. Actually, this woman is with the Ecumenical Catholic Church, a more recent split. It's a real heartbreaker because she grew up Roman Catholic, attended two World Youth Days, and still ended up leaving. I don't think she really understands the whole schism thing. I mean, she understands that we think that, but I think she really considers herself to be part of the Catholic Church moving forward. Kind of like a reform movement within the Church.

Similar groups include the Liberal Catholic Church and the Old Catholic Church. In a way, I think these groups might be good in the long run. They function like a pressure valve, providing an escape for the most radical element that otherwise might worsen divisions within our congregations. Just a thought.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='beatty07' post='1113308' date='Nov 6 2006, 10:46 PM']
true dat. Actually, this woman is with the Ecumenical Catholic Church, a more recent split. It's a real heartbreaker because she grew up Roman Catholic, attended two World Youth Days, and still ended up leaving. I don't think she really understands the whole schism thing. I mean, she understands that we think that, but I think she really considers herself to be part of the Catholic Church moving forward. Kind of like a reform movement within the Church.

Similar groups include the Liberal Catholic Church and the Old Catholic Church. In a way, I think these groups might be good in the long run. They function like a pressure valve, providing an escape for the most radical element that otherwise might worsen divisions within our congregations. Just a thought.
[/quote]
They're certainly not good. I understand what you mean, but I don't think we can ever call them good.

I have friends who attend "independent Catholic churches"...I never understand what they mean when they try to describe the hierarchy to me...it's always like, "well, our bishop is in [insert foreign country here] and we belong to his diocese, even though we're here" or "well, we're an independent parish in the _____ diocese and we celebrate the Tridentine Mass."

:wacko:

Posted

[quote name='beatty07' post='1113308' date='Nov 6 2006, 09:46 PM']
true dat. Actually, this woman is with the Ecumenical Catholic Church, a more recent split. It's a real heartbreaker because she grew up Roman Catholic, attended two World Youth Days, and still ended up leaving. I don't think she really understands the whole schism thing. I mean, she understands that we think that, but I think she really considers herself to be part of the Catholic Church moving forward. Kind of like a reform movement within the Church.

Similar groups include the Liberal Catholic Church and the Old Catholic Church. In a way, I think these groups might be good in the long run. They function like a pressure valve, providing an escape for the most radical element that otherwise might worsen divisions within our congregations. Just a thought.
[/quote]
Jessica and I (we took classes together last year at my school) have had a number of talks on this very matter--both inside and outside of class. I can't judge her or speak for her soul, but I do feel inspired to live my faith in a radical way when I am with her. Her prayer life truly sustains her life.

As for groups acting like a "pressure valve" I don't see the need for an "escape." The Church--in it's 2000 year history--has always had radical elements to it. Indeed, extremes on both/any/all ends of the spectrum have been present. I would hate to lose some of the diversity that we have in our unity (or the unity we have in our diversity, etc).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...