Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey ya'll, I'm new on here, but I'd like some feedback on an issue in my life. My old "boyfriend", whatever you'd like to call him, recently split with me because I told him I was uncomfortable with the movies he watched.( Note: he considers himself a great Catholic). He had no problem seeing things with sexual material in theaters (it is slightly better when you can skip it at home), and even told me several times that he was "above temptation" when I told him he wasn't doing his best to avoid sin. When I tried talking it out with him he'd say I didn't trust him, bla blah blah, he was above the temptation and could handle it.( Which smelled like pride and presumption to me) All of the catechisms say that those movies are forbidden by the 6th Commandment, yet somehow he's made me come off as a control freak to my friends. I really did care about him and that's why I told him about it, but he wouldn't look into it by reading into it. He kept saying he was "above temptation" like that and that the material "didn't affect him". Sorry, but for a young guy, I didn't buy him telling me that that explicit stuff the size of a wall had no impact on him. I really felt that every attempt for me being modest around him was completely pointless if he wasn't going to respect me, much less himself, by not trashing his mind. As you can guess, my circle thinks I'm "reading too much into it" and " need to pick my battles better and not try to mother people". I'm not the coolest cube in the freezer right now =P I was even told that my standards were too high. I am still trying my hardest to stay my personal purest by avoiding the junk in the media (switching trashy music and tv stations thinking of "mr. right"), and it kinda hurt that he wasn't willing to look into this for his sake, as well as mine. I'd really like some Catholic imput, so shoot...

Posted

Dump the bum.

Modern American courtship is overrated at best and twist at worst. If a guy (not your husband) builds up you spiritual walk, you can keep him close. If he presents a hazard, don't let him close enought to you to bring you down.

Until married or have celibate vows, you are a free agent for Christ.

Posted

sorry about the split, doesn't sound like much fun. Just a few cents worth from me, first of all a big "attagirl" for taking your and your potential husbands' chastity so seriously! That's wonderful to see. It's too bad it scared someone off, but if that's really why it ended, then maybe it was for the best ya know? It's hard only knowing one side of the story, but the way you describe it, it doesn't sound like you were asking too much at all.

Can standards be too high? absolutely. If you want to marry, your only options are fallen human beings! But given that, it's NOT unreasonable to insist on a high level of respect for chastity, which is so critical to marriage.

If only every woman insisted on this from potential boyfriends, just imagine how quickly men would fall into line. I really thank you for taking a stand... good luck Old-fashioned Girl!

Posted

Too bad you couldnt be a tad bit more explicit. seriously.

What kindof movies?

Ugg, not those trashy teen movies that are out there? They're garbage anyway. Do they even have a sense or meaning to them or are they simply made for shock value?

I mean, Im not as young as you so you wont offend me. But I just wonder by what you mean when you say that "explicit stuff the size of a wall"?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

We're not above temptation until we're dead.

I think we can be scrupulous about some of these things and take them a little too seriously. Violence and swearing in movies is one thing, but sex is another. You can live with violence and swearing, perhaps offering a small penance for each curse word, because the movie as a whole might be really good. However, sex in films usually is so degrading (and sneaks so well into the mind) that it's not tolerable. Even then, though, I wouldn't necessarily abandon the whole movie. Many very good movies have one or two sexual scenes done in a relatively decent manner, but even these scenes shouldn't be viewed, in my opinion, because even if we won't go imitating them, we don't need those images in our heads. If two sinless people were engaged in the purest intercourse imaginable (I'm not implying that you should imagine), that's something between two people and we shouldn't be seeing it. Our seeing it violates the dignity of the act and allows those images into our minds for concupiscence to manipulate in order to get us to sin. However, in such cases, I usually close my eyes or my fiancee covers them for me, because usually the movie is otherwise fine (although sometimes not--I walked out of "Click" this summer). Whether or not something is an occasion of sin for someone, sometimes those things are sins in themselves and we need to avoid them for the sake of our modesty.

Posted

Well, I wouldn't insist that your former boyfriend is lying -- those scenes really might not affect him. (I do know people like that.) But, if you told him you were uncomfortable with him watching that, and he didn't respect your feelings, he wasn't right for you.

And you certainly weren't unreasonable for not being pleased with him watching that stuff.

I am curious, along with Quietfire, about what exact sort of movies we're talking about.

Posted

Standards can almost never be too high. He sounds like..

Why is he watching them if they "don't affect him" anyway??

Posted

I occasionally watch movies with objectionable material. For example, HBO's Rome was interesting and historical, but too many naked people. I usually ffd through such scenes.

Posted

Micah said "fiancee". :hehe:


That's so sweet. :clapping:

Posted

Yes, standards can be too high.

No, yours are not too high, in this case. I know a lot of guys who are dead set against watching trashy, tempting carp. And I don't think it matters how objectionable the material is; if he is trying to say "I'm above temptation," then he's really fooling himself.

Posted

All I would add would be to check the NCCB reviews of movies:

[url="http://www.usccb.org/movies/index.shtml"]http://www.usccb.org/movies/index.shtml[/url]

They are [i]mostly[/i] dead on (they were a liitle weak initially on Brokeback Mountain, but I guess that the public outcry from committed laity turned them around).

This could be a good general guide as to whether you are overreacting or not. If they are deemed morally objectionable by the NCCB, it could serve as an "evangelizing tool" with the guy, and his reaction can tell you a lot about him.

Beatty07...THANK YOU! About time to hear some support from the pulpit (even though you are not ordained yet) regarding wanting high standards in chastity from "[i]spouseabile[/i]"!! I know you're up at Mundelein, so if you're ever up on the NW side of Chicago I owe you a beer (or a trip to the local gun range, since you posted previously about your southern Illinois roots).

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Quietfire' post='1117608' date='Nov 11 2006, 02:54 PM']
Micah said "fiancee". :hehe:
That's so sweet. :clapping:
[/quote]
:huh:

Posted

It is pretty cute Micah! You guys are so sweet together.....

Posted

[quote name='An Old-Fashioned Girl' post='1116927' date='Nov 10 2006, 04:52 PM']
Hey ya'll, I'm new on here, but I'd like some feedback on an issue in my life. My old "boyfriend", whatever you'd like to call him, recently split with me because I told him I was uncomfortable with the movies he watched.( Note: he considers himself a great Catholic). He had no problem seeing things with sexual material in theaters (it is slightly better when you can skip it at home), and even told me several times that he was "above temptation" when I told him he wasn't doing his best to avoid sin. When I tried talking it out with him he'd say I didn't trust him, bla blah blah, he was above the temptation and could handle it.( Which smelled like pride and presumption to me) All of the catechisms say that those movies are forbidden by the 6th Commandment, yet somehow he's made me come off as a control freak to my friends. I really did care about him and that's why I told him about it, but he wouldn't look into it by reading into it. He kept saying he was "above temptation" like that and that the material "didn't affect him". Sorry, but for a young guy, I didn't buy him telling me that that explicit stuff the size of a wall had no impact on him. I really felt that every attempt for me being modest around him was completely pointless if he wasn't going to respect me, much less himself, by not trashing his mind. As you can guess, my circle thinks I'm "reading too much into it" and " need to pick my battles better and not try to mother people". I'm not the coolest cube in the freezer right now =P I was even told that my standards were too high. I am still trying my hardest to stay my personal purest by avoiding the junk in the media (switching trashy music and tv stations thinking of "mr. right"), and it kinda hurt that he wasn't willing to look into this for his sake, as well as mine. I'd really like some Catholic imput, so shoot...
[/quote]

i say we need more "old-fashioned girls" such as yourself!! any man worth his salt will thank God that he has a girl in his life who cares enough about his purity and about the purity of the relationship to talk to him about the movies he watches. he may feel that he is "above it all" but, if you subject yourself to the objectifying of women enough times then you slowly, and often even without your awareness, become numb to the dignity and beauty of women and you begin to objectify them yourself. i would be interested to see how he handled intimate situations in a relationship, but, of course, you don't have to share if you don't want to.

you were wise to consult the documents of the Church to truly see if you were doing the right thing or not. always safeguard your purity and your personal dignity. spend some time in prayer, discerning if and when you should enter into another relationship. when you do, make sure it is with a man who respects you and what you stand for.

pax christi,
phatcatholic

Posted

I'd rather look at a long-distance relationship rather than lowering my standards.

Posted

[quote name='Quietfire' post='1116947' date='Nov 10 2006, 05:06 PM']
Too bad you couldnt be a tad bit more explicit. seriously.

What kindof movies?

Ugg, not those trashy teen movies that are out there? They're garbage anyway. Do they even have a sense or meaning to them or are they simply made for shock value?

I mean, Im not as young as you so you wont offend me. But I just wonder by what you mean when you say that "explicit stuff the size of a wall"?
[/quote]


Sorry, I haven't been on in a while. But yeah, the typical teen movies and action flicks, but the ones that bothered me most were Troy and the most recent Tal. Knights. ( He saw them in theaters so sorry to those who have enjoyed Troy for the action while being able to skip the sex scenes.) I have to say I didn't actually see it ( I read the review on screenit.com and felt my innocence had been scandalized) , but his previous choices in entertainment had not thrilled me so it was a contuing problem which he said he was working on. Then he just got cocky.

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1117934' date='Nov 11 2006, 10:16 PM']
All I would add would be to check the NCCB reviews of movies:

[url="http://www.usccb.org/movies/index.shtml"]http://www.usccb.org/movies/index.shtml[/url]

They are [i]mostly[/i] dead on (they were a liitle weak initially on Brokeback Mountain, but I guess that the public outcry from committed laity turned them around).

This could be a good general guide as to whether you are overreacting or not. If they are deemed morally objectionable by the NCCB, it could serve as an "evangelizing tool" with the guy, and his reaction can tell you a lot about him.

Beatty07...THANK YOU! About time to hear some support from the pulpit (even though you are not ordained yet) regarding wanting high standards in chastity from "[i]spouseabile[/i]"!! I know you're up at Mundelein, so if you're ever up on the NW side of Chicago I owe you a beer (or a trip to the local gun range, since you posted previously about your southern Illinois roots).
[/quote]


Thanks! Which do you like better, that sight or Screenit.com? (they're a tad severe occasionally)

[quote name='jswranch' post='1117152' date='Nov 10 2006, 09:11 PM']
I occasionally watch movies with objectionable material. For example, HBO's Rome was interesting and historical, but too many naked people. I usually ffd through such scenes.
[/quote]


Yeah but you were able to ff that stuff. He'd watch it in theaters or not.

[quote name='Kosh' post='1117115' date='Nov 10 2006, 08:02 PM']
Standards can almost never be too high. He sounds like..

Why is he watching them if they "don't affect him" anyway??
[/quote]


you've got me =P

[quote name='Raphael' post='1116962' date='Nov 10 2006, 05:29 PM']
We're not above temptation until we're dead.

I think we can be scrupulous about some of these things and take them a little too seriously. Violence and swearing in movies is one thing, but sex is another. You can live with violence and swearing, perhaps offering a small penance for each curse word, because the movie as a whole might be really good. However, sex in films usually is so degrading (and sneaks so well into the mind) that it's not tolerable. Even then, though, I wouldn't necessarily abandon the whole movie. Many very good movies have one or two sexual scenes done in a relatively decent manner, but even these scenes shouldn't be viewed, in my opinion, because even if we won't go imitating them, we don't need those images in our heads. If two sinless people were engaged in the purest intercourse imaginable (I'm not implying that you should imagine), that's something between two people and we shouldn't be seeing it. Our seeing it violates the dignity of the act and allows those images into our minds for concupiscence to manipulate in order to get us to sin. However, in such cases, I usually close my eyes or my fiancee covers them for me, because usually the movie is otherwise fine (although sometimes not--I walked out of "Click" this summer). Whether or not something is an occasion of sin for someone, sometimes those things are sins in themselves and we need to avoid them for the sake of our modesty.
[/quote]



Thanks, right on!

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1118630' date='Nov 13 2006, 12:50 AM']
i say we need more "old-fashioned girls" such as yourself!! any man worth his salt will thank God that he has a girl in his life who cares enough about his purity and about the purity of the relationship to talk to him about the movies he watches. he may feel that he is "above it all" but, if you subject yourself to the objectifying of women enough times then you slowly, and often even without your awareness, become numb to the dignity and beauty of women and you begin to objectify them yourself. i would be interested to see how he handled intimate situations in a relationship, but, of course, you don't have to share if you don't want to.

you were wise to consult the documents of the Church to truly see if you were doing the right thing or not. always safeguard your purity and your personal dignity. spend some time in prayer, discerning if and when you should enter into another relationship. when you do, make sure it is with a man who respects you and what you stand for.

pax christi,
phatcatholic
[/quote]


Thanks so much! I'm sooo happy to know there are people who understand where I'm coming from. You've pretty much nailed everything I've learned from this pretty crummy experience. I realize that I need someone I can respect and who will respect me, as well as bring me up spiritually. I don't feel the need to pursue guys right now. Like you say I've prayed about it and trusted Jesus with my heart, and I know He'll make sure it winds up in the right place! God Bless!

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1118630' date='Nov 13 2006, 12:50 AM']
i say we need more "old-fashioned girls" such as yourself!! any man worth his salt will thank God that he has a girl in his life who cares enough about his purity and about the purity of the relationship to talk to him about the movies he watches. he may feel that he is "above it all" but, if you subject yourself to the objectifying of women enough times then you slowly, and often even without your awareness, become numb to the dignity and beauty of women and you begin to objectify them yourself. i would be interested to see how he handled intimate situations in a relationship, but, of course, you don't have to share if you don't want to.

you were wise to consult the documents of the Church to truly see if you were doing the right thing or not. always safeguard your purity and your personal dignity. spend some time in prayer, discerning if and when you should enter into another relationship. when you do, make sure it is with a man who respects you and what you stand for.

pax christi,
phatcatholic
[/quote]


Thanks so much! I'm sooo happy to know there are people who understand where I'm coming from. You've pretty much nailed everything I've learned from this pretty crummy experience. I realize that I need someone I can respect and who will respect me, as well as bring me up spiritually. I don't feel the need to pursue guys right now. Like you say I've prayed about it and trusted Jesus with my heart, and I know He'll make sure it winds up in the right place! God Bless!

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1117934' date='Nov 11 2006, 10:16 PM']
All I would add would be to check the NCCB reviews of movies:

[url="http://www.usccb.org/movies/index.shtml"]http://www.usccb.org/movies/index.shtml[/url]

They are [i]mostly[/i] dead on (they were a liitle weak initially on Brokeback Mountain, but I guess that the public outcry from committed laity turned them around).

This could be a good general guide as to whether you are overreacting or not. If they are deemed morally objectionable by the NCCB, it could serve as an "evangelizing tool" with the guy, and his reaction can tell you a lot about him.

Beatty07...THANK YOU! About time to hear some support from the pulpit (even though you are not ordained yet) regarding wanting high standards in chastity from "[i]spouseabile[/i]"!! I know you're up at Mundelein, so if you're ever up on the NW side of Chicago I owe you a beer (or a trip to the local gun range, since you posted previously about your southern Illinois roots).
[/quote]
I disagree. I think the USCCB movie reviews are close to worthless.
They are ridiculously inconsistant, and seem to usually be driven more by political correctness and the reviewers' personal tastes than by Catholic morality.
(Blasphemous homo movies are rated acceptable, but squeaky clean fare like Nacho Libre get rated "O" - objectionable.)

The USCCB is a bad joke. I ignore their silly reviews.

Posted

[quote name='Socrates' post='1120277' date='Nov 14 2006, 09:05 PM']
I disagree. I think the USCCB movie reviews are close to worthless.
They are ridiculously inconsistant, and seem to usually be driven more by political correctness and the reviewers' personal tastes than by Catholic morality.
(Blasphemous homo movies are rated acceptable, but squeaky clean fare like Nacho Libre get rated "O" - objectionable.)

The USCCB is a bad joke. I ignore their silly reviews.
[/quote]

Well, it's free, better than nothing, and a good starting off or additional resource if you cannot find what you are looking for in a secular newspaper review. And it will give a summary of what is found objectionable (whether it be sexual content, violence, or drug use). Keep in mind too it tries to judge age-appropriateness as well.

Screenit is probably more detailed in enumerating what is objectionable, from what I remember. But I just checked it, you have to subscribe now; I remember it used to be free!

But I really don't go out to movies much, lately it's only for when a new Star Trek film comes out.

Posted

[quote name='Norseman82' post='1120474' date='Nov 15 2006, 01:47 AM']


Screenit is probably more detailed in enumerating what is objectionable, from what I remember. But I just checked it, you have to subscribe now; I remember it used to be free!

[/quote]


You can just scroll down to the bottom of where it says you have to join and click "no thanks", but you don't have access to movies released that week. So it's still free depending on how recently the movie was released.

Posted

You did the right thing girl.

Dont worry.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...