Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

When Was The Church Made?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Was the Church made on Holy Thursday, Good Friday or Pentacost?

Fidei Defensor
Posted

It's normally said that the birthday of the Church is on Pentacost.

goldenchild17
Posted

That's what I'm familiar with as well.

Posted

It's Good Friday. I wish I had my CCC or Ott with me.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Holy Thursday was the nuptial celebration where the Bridegroom gave Himself to His Bride, Good Friday is the conception of the Church, and Pentecost is the Church's birth.

:P: Okay, I just made that up...but I like that way of thinking of it.

[quote name='jswranch' post='1117214' date='Nov 10 2006, 10:59 PM']
It's Good Friday. I wish I had my CCC or Ott with me.
[/quote]

[url="http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm"]http://www.scborromeo.org/ccc.htm[/url]

Work-in-progress: [url="http://www.catecheticsonline.com/Fundamentals.html"]http://www.catecheticsonline.com/Fundamentals.html[/url]

Posted

At the Last Supper the priesthood and the Eucharist was instituted. However, Pentecost, when the Holy Spirit comes, is the official birth of the Church.

Posted

[quote name='StThomasMore' post='1117124' date='Nov 10 2006, 07:22 PM']
Was the Church made on Holy Thursday, Good Friday or Pentacost?
[/quote]

While it is commonly held that the "birthday" of the Church is on Pentecost, this is what the Catechism has to say:

[quote name='CCC #766']The Church is born primarily of Christ's total self-giving for our salvation, anticipated in the institution of the Eucharist and fulfilled on the cross. "The origin and growth of the Church are symbolized by the blood and water which flowed from the open side of the crucified Jesus." "For it was from the side of Christ as he slept the sleep of death upon the cross that there came forth the 'wondrous sacrament of the whole Church.'" As Eve was formed from the sleeping Adam's side, so the Church was born from the pierced heart of Christ hanging dead on the cross.[/quote]

[quote name='CCC #767']"When the work which the Father gave the Son to do on earth was accomplished, the Holy Spirit was sent on the day of Pentecost in order that he might continually sanctify the Church." Then "the Church was openly displayed to the crowds and the spread of the Gospel among the nations, through preaching, was begun." As the "convocation" of all men for salvation, the Church in her very nature is missionary, sent by Christ to all the nations to make disciples of them. [/quote]

So, according to the Catechism, the Church was born from the pierced heart of Jesus hanging dead on the Cross. And it was on Pentecost that the Church was sanctified.

Another way of explaining through the Catechism:

[quote name='CCC #1076']The Church was made manifest to the world on the day of Pentecost by the outpouring of the Holy Spirit. The gift of the Spirit ushers in a new era in the "dispensation of the mystery" the age of the Church, during which Christ manifests, makes present, and communicates his work of salvation through the liturgy of his Church, "until he comes." In this age of the Church Christ now lives and acts in and with his Church, in a new way appropriate to this new age. He acts through the sacraments in what the common Tradition of the East and the West calls "the sacramental economy"; this is the communication (or "dispensation") of the fruits of Christ's Paschal mystery in the celebration of the Church's "sacramental" liturgy.[/quote]

[quote name='Lumen Gentium #2']He planned to assemble in the holy Church all those who would believe in Christ. Already from the beginning of the world the foreshadowing of the Church took place. It was prepared in a remarkable way throughout the history of the people of Israel and by means of the Old Covenant. In the present era of time the Church was constituted and, by the outpouring of the Spirit, was made manifest.[/quote]

So, I would say that that in the understanding of "birthday" as we know it, the Church was "born" on Good Friday and "baptized" on Pentecost. But also remember that the idea of celebrating a birthday is first a pagan idea and then readopted by the Protestants of the Reformation. So, I would say that it isn't necessary to equate the term "birthday" with the Church. I would say that the Church was made manifest on Pentecost.

Posted

[quote name='Cam42' post='1118159' date='Nov 12 2006, 10:41 AM']
So, I would say that that in the understanding of "birthday" as we know it, the Church was "born" on Good Friday and "baptized" on Pentecost. But also remember that the idea of celebrating a birthday is first a pagan idea and then readopted by the Protestants of the Reformation. So, I would say that it isn't necessary to equate the term "birthday" with the Church. I would say that the Church was made manifest on Pentecost.
[/quote]
dude, you totally taught me something new just now. i love moments like that :cool:

Posted

I have to give a presentation on this on Sunday night. Here is another thought I came up with (brace yourselves).

The making of the church is the making of a marriage.

Dating= Seth, Noah
Courtship= OT, starting with Abraham
Betrothal= Mary as handmaiden
Wedding= Incarnation
Wedding feast/witness of vows=Eucharist
Copulation=Crucifiction... It is finished.

A marriage is completed at the total self-giving of the spouses. Christ gave himself totally at the cross.

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1122803' date='Nov 17 2006, 11:05 PM']
I have to give a presentation on this on Sunday night. Here is another thought I came up with (brace yourselves).

The making of the church is the making of a marriage.

Dating= Seth, Noah
Courtship= OT, starting with Abraham
Betrothal= Mary as handmaiden
Wedding= Incarnation
Wedding feast/witness of vows=Eucharist
Copulation=Crucifiction... It is finished.

A marriage is completed at the total self-giving of the spouses. Christ gave himself totally at the cross.
[/quote]
are you gonna present that? i wouldn't, since its speculative.

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1122992' date='Nov 18 2006, 01:01 AM']
are you gonna present that? i wouldn't, since its speculative.
[/quote]
No. Just an idea. Since you classified it as 'speculative', I am happy to see you do not think it is errant. :)

I plan to present the CCC version, though edited to a denominationally neutral version. I want to show 'it is finished' was the latest date, then move on to dispute errant claims (Pentacost or Mt16:18).

In theory, could we not say the Church was made at the Immaculate Conception?

Posted

[quote name='Cam42' post='1118159' date='Nov 12 2006, 08:41 AM']
And it was on Pentecost that the Church was sanctified.[/quote]

How about this...

It was on Pentecost that the Church became Catholic. It was there that it went from being a religion for the Jews to a religion for the world?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1123134' date='Nov 18 2006, 12:13 PM']
In theory, could we not say the Church was made at the Immaculate Conception?
[/quote]
In a sort of spiritual, mystical sense that the Church exists where the elect exist, yes, but that is only a sense and a mystical one at that...the Church is visible and truly (not just mystically or spiritually) exists where and when it visibly exists. Be very careful using spiritualized and mystical theology...it gets into a lot of great metaphors, parallels, etc., but it's very tricky to work with without getting into a heresy and it takes a lot of clarification and qualification. Never use such theology for teaching others the faith.

[quote name='jswranch' post='1123142' date='Nov 18 2006, 12:31 PM']
How about this...

It was on Pentecost that the Church became Catholic. It was there that it went from being a religion for the Jews to a religion for the world?
[/quote]
Catholicity is part of the ontology of the Church...I don't think there could be a time when the Church wasn't Catholic.

The Church was formed at the Crucifixion precisely, but you could say that that was the moment it came forth from the womb...the whole labor is the entire Paschal Mystery.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1123144' date='Nov 18 2006, 10:47 AM']
...the Church is visible and truly (not just mystically or spiritually) exists where and when it visibly exists.[/quote]

You are right. I am trying to shake my Protestant roots. I still need deprograming.

[quote name='Raphael' post='1123144' date='Nov 18 2006, 10:47 AM']The Church was formed at the Crucifixion precisely, but you could say that that was the moment it came forth from the womb...the whole labor is the entire Paschal Mystery.
[/quote]

Two things here:

1. Why wouldn't the church be formed at the conception of Christ? Should't we celebrate the incarnation more as a function just after the annunciation rather than the nativity? Did not Christ become fully human at His conception rather than at his birth?

2. What labor of the womb?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1123316' date='Nov 18 2006, 04:29 PM']
You are right. I am trying to shake my Protestant roots. I still need deprograming.[/quote]

:lol:

[quote]Two things here:

1. Why wouldn't the church be formed at the conception of Christ? Should't we celebrate the incarnation more as a function just after the annunciation rather than the nativity? Did not Christ become fully human at His conception rather than at his birth?

2. What labor of the womb?[/quote]

1. I think that in a mystical sense, the Church was born of the whole process of Christ's mission because I think in a mystical sense, all the events of Christ's life were inseparably one. I think that I would compare the whole birth of the Church to Christ's whole life, which brings me to my second point...

2. I was it a metaphor relating the birth of the Church to labor.

I think that the Church existed incarnate in Christ before it was "born" to the world as His Blood poured forth upon the Cross. It makes sense in that view that the Church would be incarnated when Christ was...and the metaphor makes lots of sense when you see the Church as Christ's body...but like I was saying, mystical theology is...different.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1123332' date='Nov 18 2006, 02:40 PM']
It makes sense in that view that the Church would be incarnated when Christ was...and the metaphor makes lots of sense when you see the Church as Christ's body...but like I was saying, mystical theology is...different.
[/quote]

:lightbulb:

Ok, I am starting to get the hang of the mystical vs. visible. The fullness of Christ exists when both are present. Mystically, the Church was established at "Let there be light." Visibly, it could have been established at the nativity.

:lightbulb:

Now the whole incarnation, hypostatic union, theotokos makes so much more sense... ahhh.

Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1123316' date='Nov 18 2006, 04:29 PM']
You are right. I am trying to shake my Protestant roots. I still need deprograming.

[/quote]

Your Protestant roots are probably why you actually know Scripture.

That is likely also the reason many of your big-name Catholic apologists were former Protestants.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1123339' date='Nov 18 2006, 05:13 PM']
:lightbulb:

Ok, I am starting to get the hang of the mystical vs. visible. The fullness of Christ exists when both are present. Mystically, the Church was established at "Let there be light." Visibly, it could have been established at the nativity.

:lightbulb:

Now the whole incarnation, hypostatic union, theotokos makes so much more sense... ahhh.
[/quote]

What I understand to be speculative theology follows. I offer myself completely in subordination to the teachings of the Magisterium if I am in error.

I'm not sure I'd say the Church was mystically established at the fiat lux. My point is that all of Christ's redemptive actions really belong to one redemptive act which has many stages involved in it, stages which are completely inseparable from each other. There are different senses of what consistute the Church. If we speak of the Church in the sense of "made up of the elect," then the Church resided in Mary and Jesus. If we speak of the Church in the sense of "the Body of Christ," then the Church existed in a sort of mystical seminal form in the Person of Jesus Christ and, once the faithful had been incorporated into His Body by the sacraments, in the persons of the faithful. The mystical is a deeper level which is reflected in the visible. Is Mary a part of the Church? Yes. Is she within the visible bounds of the Church? Now, yes. Was she at the time of the Immaculate Conception? No, because there were no visible bounds of the Church. Did the Church exist at that time? That's a hard question to answer...not in itself, I would say, but in its effects, yes, because Mary was already perfectly joined to Christ in a way that anticipated the Church and so, in a sense, the Church could be said to have been there already. At this point, you have to start specifying more...what is the nature of the Church in the Church's own definition?

You see what I mean? You get into mystical theology and it's trying to figure out the mystery...you can only take it so deep and so far before things start boggling your mind. Be content with the limits to which the Church has gone. Mary is a model of the Church. Christ and the Church are one. The Church existed first in Christ and then He opened His Body and poured out His Blood and by taking that blood on ourselves (which occurs in the sacraments), we are united to His Body, which in a mystical sense is the Church. The whole birth of the Church is His whole saving mission on earth...the actual moment where the Church was definitively and visibly born was the Crucifixion. Yet, I just read a passage from St. Augustine this morning that might be helpful. Jacob was born with his arm grasping Esau's heel even before his head came out and so also the Church in Her birth was preceded by the Patriarchs and the Prophets who are in a mystical sense a part of the Church, though not visibly so, because they were in anticipation of the Church, they were attached to their head, who is Christ, and the Church came with Him, when He was born forth, yet they were attached to Him and therefore were a part of His body in a mystical way. Just as Jacob's arm came first and was attached to Jacob's head and belonged to Jacob's head, so some of Christ's mystical members came first, but they were attached and belonged to Christ the Head of the Church, and His Head is followed by the rest of His members, who, being seen connected to His Head, are considered visibly to be members of His Body, the Church.

Those who are mystically united with the Church are not fully in (i.e. imperfectly connected to) the Church because they do not exist within its visible bounds...the question of Mary is one I will not touch with regard to that, though, as her Immaculate Conception may allow her to have been a visible member of the Church in a retroactive way (I can't say one way or the other).

Anyway:

"All men are called to this catholic unity of the People of God. . . . And to it, in different ways, belong or are ordered: the Catholic faithful, others who believe in Christ, and finally all mankind, called by God's grace to salvation." -CCC 836

[quote name='SolaScriptura' post='1123346' date='Nov 18 2006, 05:34 PM']
Your Protestant roots are probably why you actually know Scripture.

That is likely also the reason many of your big-name Catholic apologists were former Protestants.
[/quote]
It is also likely the reason they became Catholic. ;)

Posted

[quote name='SolaScriptura' post='1123346' date='Nov 18 2006, 03:34 PM']
Your Protestant roots are probably why you actually know Scripture.

That is likely also the reason many of your big-name Catholic apologists were former Protestants.
[/quote]


[quote name='Raphael' post='1123367' date='Nov 18 2006, 04:17 PM']
It is also likely the reason they became Catholic.
[/quote]
Actually yes. Believing that 'eat my flesh' really meant it, and that works without faith is dead made me prime for picking.

Of course my biggest hurdle to becoming Catholic... was Catholics.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='jswranch' post='1123385' date='Nov 18 2006, 07:27 PM']
Of course my biggest hurdle to becoming Catholic... was Catholics.
[/quote]
I'm told G.K. Chesterton knew he was in the right church when his umbrella was stolen from the back. The Church is a hospital for sinners.

But yes, you're right...we do stink at personal witness and Christian living, in general.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...