Twentie Fow Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 Reading through a book on conservative Christians' political views, I have questions on the Catholic position on the following issues. I was unable to find answers on the USCCB website. My efforts via search engine also were unsuccessful. 1. Should there be gay antidiscrimination laws for the workplace? 2. Should there be Christian prayer in public schools? 3. Should the oath to God still be used in the court room? 4. Should gays be allowed in the military? 5. Is belief in God very important for true Americans? 6. Should the ten commandments be displayed by the government? Thank you, Twentie Fow
Matty_boy Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Twentie Fow' post='1119447' date='Nov 13 2006, 11:24 PM'] Reading through a book on conservative Christians' political views, I have questions on the Catholic position on the following issues. I was unable to find answers on the USCCB website. My efforts via search engine also were unsuccessful. 1. Should there be gay antidiscrimination laws for the workplace? 2. Should there be Christian prayer in public schools? 3. Should the oath to God still be used in the court room? 4. Should gays be allowed in the military? 5. Is belief in God very important for true Americans? 6. Should the ten commandments be displayed by the government? Thank you, Twentie Fow [/quote] [mod]Insulting the USCCB. --Era Might[/mod] The best way to find the answers is read the catechism and the corresponding scripture for the issues, the Federalist Papers, the Constitution, and papal encyclicals regarding sexuality, human rights, etc. and decide for yourself. The following are my opinions. 1. In my understanding, no, there should not be gay antidiscrimination laws for the workplace. Homosexual desires are disordered. People are not genetically created that way (Human Genome Project mapped the human genes to determine what was what. Homosexuality wasn't found.) God created people to be black, white, red, yellow, chinese, mexican, english, russian. All of those are "accidents" of a person, whereas homosexual orientation is disordered [u]behavior[/u]. 2. The Constitution allows for a freedom OF religion, not freedom FROM religion. While I am unsure if public schools should force Christianity, I do think that they should allow it to be practiced freely. Students and teachers should be able to pray, silently or aloud (when appropriate), and schools should teach, at the very least, that there is a Creator (basic philosophical concept. No Creator means infinite regression. Ockham's Razor.) 3. I believe the oath to God is simply a tradition and doesn't keep even an ex-President from lying. In the past, swearing on the Bible may have had an impact on the witness if they were God-fearing people. Today, in our Godless society, witnesses may as well click their heels three times. 4. Gays in the military poses the issue of same-sex attraction. I really don't think women should be allowed in the military for anything more than medical support, but that's a different topic. I seem to recall when I took the ASVAB and went through processing, that the military didn't ask if I was homosexual or heterosexual. I think if the job is to fight and kill the enemy, while building infrastructure to rebuild the country, then why should sexual orientation have anything to do with it? Gays made being gay in the military an issue. It's like bringing a bulldozer to a cook-off. It has no place and won't help get the job done. 5. I would say belief in God is essential to "true Americans". The Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Federalist Papers were all written from the perspective of Judeo-Christian beliefs. Our country was founded on the understanding that natural law comes from God and that the law of the land should reflect natural law. If you look at Supreme Court Justices, the ones who understand the Constitution and founding documents most accurately are also those who are strongly faithful. 6. The issue with the Ten Commandments is touchy. While it is good to have a display of natural laws, the Ten Commandments could be considered exclusionary to those who do not believe in God. The issue of Ben Franklin's "separation of church and state", while NOT in the Constitution, was originally used to describe the disdain for the way the head of state was also the head of the Church (Henry VIII and the Church of England). I would argue that the government entity should not display the 10 commandments, but can allow the public to do so, or allow the people to vote and decide for themselves. I hope this helps. Edited November 14, 2006 by Era Might
Groo the Wanderer Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 1. Should there be gay antidiscrimination laws for the workplace? No. Sexual orientation is not defined as a protected class under the Constitution, nor should it be. Allowing this would open the door to protecting all sorts of sexual deviancies. The Church also does not teach protection or special status for moral deviancies. 2. Should there be Christian prayer in public schools? Yes. This country was founded by Christians on Christian principles. That said, nobody should be forced to participate. just remember that 'freedom of religion' does not equal 'freedom from religion'. If you go to Saudi Arabia, you will have to listen to Muslim prayers all day and all night. 3. Should the oath to God still be used in the court room? Yes. 4. Should gays be allowed in the military? Yes, if their orientation is kept private. I do not wear a t-shirt in public proclaiming my heterosexuality. 5. Is belief in God very important for true Americans? Yes. It is important for all people. This IS a teaching of the Church. 6. Should the ten commandments be displayed by the government? Yes. They form the basis of most of our laws. To deny them is to deny our heritage, if nothing else. The Church is silent on all but #5 methinks. The rest are my opinions.
Resurrexi Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 (edited) [quote] 1. Should there be gay antidiscrimination laws for the workplace? 2. Should there be Christian prayer in public schools? 3. Should the oath to God still be used in the court room? 4. Should gays be allowed in the military? 5. Is belief in God very important for true Americans? 6. Should the ten commandments be displayed by the government?[/quote] 1. No. From the Scriptures: [quote name='First Epistle of St. Paul to the Coronthians' date=' Chapter Six']9 Know you not that the unjust shall not possess the kingdom of God? Do not err: neither fornicators, nor idolaters, nor adulterers, 10 [b]Nor the effeminate, nor liers with mankind[/b], nor thieves, nor covetous, nor drunkards, nor railers, nor extortioners, shall possess the kingdom of God.[/quote] 2. Yes, but public schools shouldn't exist in the first place. The following were condemned as error in the Syllaus of Errors which is a long list of modern errors: [quote name='The Syllabus of Errors of Pope Blessed Pius IX']47. The best theory of civil society requires that popular schools open to children of every class of the people, and, generally, all public institutes intended for instruction in letters and philosophical sciences and for carrying on the education of youth, should be freed from all ecclesiastical authority, control and interference, and should be fully subjected to the civil and political power at the pleasure of the rulers, and according to the standard of the prevalent opinions of the age. -- Epistle to the Archbishop of Freiburg, "Cum non sine," July 14, 1864. 48. Catholics may approve of the system of educating youth unconnected with Catholic faith and the power of the Church, and which regards the knowledge of merely natural things, and only, or at least primarily, the ends of earthly social life. -- Ibid. [/quote] 3. Yes. From the Catechism of Pope St. Pius X: [quote name='The Catechism of Pope St. Pius X']5 Q. What is an oath? A. An oath is the calling on God to witness the truth of what one says or promises. 6 Q. Is it always forbidden to take an oath? A. It is not always forbidden to take an oath; an oath is lawful and even gives honour to God, when it is necessary, and when one swears with truth, judgement and justice.[/quote] 4. No, though I have no offocial quote to back me on that. 5. Of course. From the First Vatican Council: [quote name='Canons of the First General Council of the Vatican']1. If anyone denies the one true God, Creator and Lord of things visible and invisible: let him be anathema.[/quote] 6. Of course, though it would be best they be the Roman Catholic numbering of the Commandments, though the Eastern Catholic numbering (the numbering used by the Protestants) is not in any way evil or bad. Edited November 14, 2006 by StThomasMore
Socrates Posted November 15, 2006 Posted November 15, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Twentie Fow' post='1119447' date='Nov 14 2006, 12:24 AM'] Reading through a book on conservative Christians' political views, I have questions on the Catholic position on the following issues. I was unable to find answers on the USCCB website. My efforts via search engine also were unsuccessful. 1. Should there be gay antidiscrimination laws for the workplace? 2. Should there be Christian prayer in public schools? 3. Should the oath to God still be used in the court room? 4. Should gays be allowed in the military? 5. Is belief in God very important for true Americans? 6. Should the ten commandments be displayed by the government? Thank you, Twentie Fow [/quote] 1. [mod]Watch the language. --Era Might[/mod] A personal (or public) vice should never entitle one to legal privileges! 2. Absolutely! Kicking God out of public life is an atheistic innovation. 3. Yes! And if people perjure themselves, it is their own fault, and they will answer to God for their offense. 4. Absolutely not! The armed forces is no place for [mod]Unacceptable. --Era Might[/mod]! 5. Of course! We are one nation under God, and if atheists don't like it, they can get out! 6. Definitely! They should be the basis of all just law and morality, and are part of our Judeao-Christian heritage. Atheistic courts have no right to order them gone. (Atheists want law to be based upon godless principles of man, rather than the Natural Law of God.) Edited November 15, 2006 by Era Might
Twentie Fow Posted November 15, 2006 Author Posted November 15, 2006 On the new guidelines of the USCCB for gay-ministry MSNBC reports [quote]The guidelines condemn discrimination against gays and say it's not a sin to be attracted to someone of the same sex — only to act on those feelings. (MSNBC)[/quote] I wonder if that means for antidiscrimination workplace laws or people making fun of them etc.?
Resurrexi Posted November 15, 2006 Posted November 15, 2006 Why would anyone make antidiscrimination laws against gays? It's against common sense. You'd then have to make antidiscrimination laws against bisexuals, transvestites, pedophiles, zoophiles, necrophiles, adulterers, masturbaters, fornicaters, prostitutes and all other sexual sinners.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now