N/A Gone Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 **im not trying to get out of hmwk. Just posting questions that I think are sensitive and I want to convey proper church teaching on. 1.)Do you believe a Christian couple should choose to remain child-free? Give reasons for your answers. 2.)What role do you feel social research findings should play in a couples decisions concerning timing and number of children? Why? 3.)To what extent are humans responsible for the reproductive capacity God has given them? 4.)How would you rate, in order of importance, the advantages and disadvantages of the various birth control methods described? Why? 5.)Do you think Christians should use sterilization as a birth control method? Why or why not? 6.)How do you understand and reconcile God's command to “be fruitful and multiply” with the teaching that people are to subdue nature?
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 I took a bit of a sarcastic tone. You might want to formulate better answers. : These questions were just so...unusual. You'll see what I mean, I think. 1. No, if the Hebrews were to be fruitful and multiply, the Christians are more bound to do so, and with generosity of spirit. 2. Social research is often carp. If it's consistent, it might be helpful, but from what I've seen, it always turns out that well conducted surveys support Catholic teaching on such things. 3. We are responsible. What does it mean about extent? We are to use this gift wisely for good. I'm not sure what else we would use it for. 4. Disadvantages: all artificial birth control is immoral because it violates the plan of God for spacing children naturally, separates union from procreation (and doesn't even unite), and violates human dignity because of these things. NFP is moral when properly used because it does not violate, but upholds, these things. 5. Absolutely not. God made us to be fertile. It's bad enough to use birth control to get in the way of that, it's completely another to have oneself mutilated so that they no longer have one of their human faculties. The very idea is silly, no one would do so with any other faculty. You won't find a person abusing their minds so that they can't think (because thinking gets them into inconvenient circumstances ). 6. How do these people think we're going to subdue nature single-handedly? "Procreate and dominate!" is a good pro-family battle cry. The two are completely in agreement. To imply that controlling nature somehow means replacing it is silly. To imply that controlling nature somehow means overcoming the instinct and will to use nature to produce more people is ridiculous. To subdue nature is to be steward to it; to help it along its own best interests, not to be a tyrant over it. It is in the interests of nature to grow (go to the Amazon and try to stop nature from achieving that task...see how far you get), we just have to make sure it's done in a way that promotes life and wellness. I'm sorry, but these questions are odd. They draw inferences that, to Catholic theology, just don't make sense. Take the last one for instance. Catholic theology would never see the two as opposed.
scardella Posted November 14, 2006 Posted November 14, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1119516' date='Nov 14 2006, 12:34 AM'] **im not trying to get out of hmwk. Just posting questions that I think are sensitive and I want to convey proper church teaching on. 1.)Do you believe a Christian couple should choose to remain child-free? Give reasons for your answers. 2.)What role do you feel social research findings should play in a couples decisions concerning timing and number of children? Why? 3.)To what extent are humans responsible for the reproductive capacity God has given them? 4.)How would you rate, in order of importance, the advantages and disadvantages of the various birth control methods described? Why? 5.)Do you think Christians should use sterilization as a birth control method? Why or why not? 6.)How do you understand and reconcile God's command to “be fruitful and multiply” with the teaching that people are to subdue nature? [/quote] 1. Only if they're in a Josephite marriage. That is, unless they are willing to remain celibate and have their fruitfulness directed towards a spiritual end. For instance, if they were missionaries, it may be prudent to live in a Josephite state. 2. I think they should have as many as they could reasonably afford. If there's any benefits to a certain spacing, then I don't see a problem with that. 3. They are stewards of any gifts that God has given them. They are not to abuse it, twist it, bury it, but bear fruit 30, 60 and 100-fold. (Take that, proponents of birth control!!!) cf Gospel parables: lazy steward, mustard seed, talents. scardella=lazy steward because he's not taking the time to look up the verses of the parables. 4. Any artificial form of birth control effectively says "God's plan smells of elderberries. I'm doing it my own way." Effectively, it is playing God. Basically, it's making the kid fit the clothes, rather than making the clothes to fit the kid. It's backwards. It betrays a lack of trust in God to make ends meet. Oftentimes, it is done with a selfish view in mind. "I can't afford a boat if I have another kid. If we get pregnant again, we'll have to sell my Mercedes-Benz and the house to get a bigger house." Other times it is done with concern only for the material welfare for the child. "If we have more than three kids, we won't be able to send them all to private school. Our house only has three bedrooms, if he have another kid, they'll have to share a room." In today's day and age, not using artificial birth control can be seen as fulfilling the command to the rich young man, "Go, sell all that you have, and come and follow me." 5. Sterilization is self-mutilation. See above answers. 6. Subduing nature is not contravening nature. It does not mean, in a far-fetched instance, that we could destroy all non-human life on earth and replace it with solar-powered machines that process air, food, waste, etc. Industrializing the reproductive process kills the wonder and beauty of it. It makes us desensitized to the inherent value of life.
N/A Gone Posted November 21, 2006 Author Posted November 21, 2006 This week the fetish is divorce...hmm, any ideas here fellas? thanks once again. 1.)Do you believe that no-fault divorce is helpful or harmful? Why? 2.)Should parents who want a divorce but have young children stay together for the sake of the children? Why? 3.)Should divorced couples with children be automatically given joint custody unless there is a compelling reason for one spouse or the other to have custody? 4.)Why do you think so many divorced people remarry soon after their divorce? 5.)Do you believe it is ever permissible for a believer to divorce his or her spouse? Is it ever permissible for a divorced Christian to remarry? On what do you base your views? 6.)What, if any, do you see as biblical grounds for remarriage following divorce?
N/A Gone Posted November 21, 2006 Author Posted November 21, 2006 On a lighter note, I got scolded for saying birth control "violates" human dignity or is against God's plan.. oyoy
jswranch Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 [quote]any help showing church teaching would be great[/quote] A review of the new USCCB document is great. Just sit down and read with couples: [url="http://www.usccb.org/laity/marriage/MarriedLove.pdf"]Married Love and the Gift of Life[/url]
N/A Gone Posted November 21, 2006 Author Posted November 21, 2006 I am gonna flunk my senior year in a blaze of glory..
phatcatholic Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1125054' date='Nov 21 2006, 11:37 AM'] I am gonna flunk my senior year in a blaze of glory.. [/quote] haha, why did i think of Bon Jovi when you said that?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now