Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I seem to get myself in quite a few debates with my father anymore. He is a lapsed Catholic, sadly, and cannot understand why prostitution cannot be legalized. He thinks that it would be great cause then the prostitutes would be "protected" in some ways, and it would be that much harder for others to take advantage of them. They would take tests often so as not to pass on diseases and it would also protect them from getting any diseases cause their "johns" would need prior testing also.

I cant even begin to explain some of his other ideas, but I am just grateful that he isnt a politician.

It isnt the only debate Im involved with him, but Cam answered one on Debate in reference to two single same sex folks living together, no funny business, and trying to receive benefits the same as a married couple. I doubt my Dad will agree, but it is a start. Kudos to Cam for keeping it simple on that one.

I tried my hardest to explain that evil cannot be controlled, that legalizing prostitution is trying to control an evil and that we would fail at it. He brought up places like "The Mustang Ranch" as part of his arguement that it can work if it is controlled properly.

I also pointed out that it is so demeaning to "encourage" some to sell their bodies, and they would only be viewed as a possession...something to own. They wouldnt be seen as a person, but rather a tool to selfishness. His response was that, "They're doing it to themselves, and their already doing it....no one is forcing them".

He honestly feels that it would benefit society.

It went on for a good fourty minutes and I finally said enough, that I would find sound reasons why his arguement is full of poo.

Again, if we can keep the wording as simply as possible I would be grateful.

Thank you so much.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

moved for a response

Posted

The CCC has some good paragraphs for you to look up and review.


2353 Fornication is carnal union between an unmarried man and an unmarried woman. It is gravely contrary to the dignity of persons and of human sexuality which is naturally ordered to the good of spouses and the generation and education of children. Moreover, it is a grave scandal when there is corruption of the young.

2354 Pornography consists in removing real or simulated sexual acts from the intimacy of the partners, in order to display them deliberately to third parties. It offends against chastity because it perverts the conjugal act, the intimate giving of spouses to each other. It does grave injury to the dignity of its participants (actors, vendors, the public), since each one becomes an object of base pleasure and illicit profit for others. It immerses all who are involved in the illusion of a fantasy world. It is a grave offense. Civil authorities should prevent the production and distribution of pornographic materials.

2355 Prostitution does injury to the dignity of the person who engages in it, reducing the person to an instrument of sexual pleasure. The one who pays sins gravely against himself: he violates the chastity to which his Baptism pledged him and defiles his body, the temple of the Holy Spirit.140 Prostitution is a social scourge. It usually involves women, but also men, children, and adolescents (The latter two cases involve the added sin of scandal.). While it is always gravely sinful to engage in prostitution, the imputability of the offense can be attenuated by destitution, blackmail, or social pressure.


I am sure there are more.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote]His response was that, "They're doing it to themselves, and their already doing it....no one is forcing them".[/quote]

Many prostitutes [i]are[/i] being forced to do this - but not necessarily by people. Some women feel that this is the only way they can reach a decent standard of living. They sell themselves in order to survive with a semblance of dignity. (I say 'semblance', because there is no dignity in selling your body.) For a lot of women out-and-out prostitution is not a choice. It's a last resort that often disguises cripplingly low self-esteem.

In the case of women who genuinely do choose to become prostitutes, what would your father say to women who 'choose' to starve themselves? Or slash themselves with razors? Or pull out all their hair piece by piece? Should they be stopped or should they be allowed to continue, given that it is their 'choice'?

No 'choice' that damages a person's precious body should ever be permitted.

Posted

[quote name='Cathoholic Anonymous' post='1126660' date='Nov 23 2006, 08:49 AM']
Many prostitutes [i]are[/i] being forced to do this - but not necessarily by people. Some women feel that this is the only way they can reach a decent standard of living. They sell themselves in order to survive with a semblance of dignity. (I say 'semblance', because there is no dignity in selling your body.) For a lot of women out-and-out prostitution is not a choice. It's a last resort that often disguises cripplingly low self-esteem.

In the case of women who genuinely do choose to become prostitutes, what would your father say to women who 'choose' to starve themselves? Or slash themselves with razors? Or pull out all their hair piece by piece? Should they be stopped or should they be allowed to continue, given that it is their 'choice'?

No 'choice' that damages a person's precious body should ever be permitted.
[/quote]
I think the fact is than in America and other "developed" countries, very few women are actually forced into prostitution by necessity of extreme poverty and the like. (And I've heard this from those more knowledgable on the subject than myself.) That may be the case in Southeast Asian and third-world countries, but I really don't think this is usually the case with most prostitutes in America and western Europe.
I'm not saying everything is always rosy for these women, but I think in most cases it is the result of bad choices, rather than economic necessity. Of course, one can make a buck quicker working the street, rather than a dreary job at the factory, just as people are similarly drawn into dealing crack or knocking over convenience stores rather than working low-paying jobs.
Across the board, people are often too quick to blame poverty for every crime, rather than deal with the fact of personal responsibility. I'm afraid that in most cases in America women are whores because, well, they are whores.

Posted

[quote]I seem to get myself in quite a few debates with my father anymore. He is a lapsed Catholic, sadly, and cannot understand why prostitution cannot be legalized. He thinks that it would be great cause then the prostitutes would be "protected" in some ways, and it would be that much harder for others to take advantage of them. They would take tests often so as not to pass on diseases and it would also protect them from getting any diseases cause their "johns" would need prior testing also.[/quote]

Hmmm I see what you mean Quitefire. Many of friends are relatives have this exact same mentailty with various narcotics. Humans have their reasons. But if prositution was leaglized pregnacy rates would sky rocket and almost every third person out of 4 would test positive for AIDS.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...