Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Archdiocese Of St. Paul And Minneapolis


Recommended Posts

Posted

Question for the Minnesotans in the know. I am wondering about quality parishes in the Achdiocese. Which ones promote non-orthodox views and which hold tightly to orthodoxy?

Some particular ones that interest me:

Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton
Saint Thomas Becket
Saint Rita
Basilica of Saint Mary

homeschoolmom
Posted

I think Sojjie goes to the Basilica from time to time.

The other's I don't know about.

But I love my parish. :)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Red Knight' post='1120956' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:23 PM']
Question for the Minnesotans in the know. I am wondering about quality parishes in the Achdiocese. Which ones promote non-orthodox views and which hold tightly to orthodoxy?

Some particular ones that interest me:

Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton
Saint Thomas Becket
Saint Rita
Basilica of Saint Mary
[/quote]

The Basilica is questionable. I don't know about the others.

Epiphany, Holy Family, St. Charels Boremerro I would list among the many good and orthodox ones. There are of course some unorthodox as well such as St. Joan of course, St. Timothy's at least was, Pax Christi is questionable though there current pastor isn't too bad. Things are getting better here I believe.

Edited by thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Red Knight' post='1120956' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:23 PM']
Question for the Minnesotans in the know. I am wondering about quality parishes in the Achdiocese. Which ones promote non-orthodox views and which hold tightly to orthodoxy?

Some particular ones that interest me:

Saint Elizabeth Ann Seton
Saint Thomas Becket
Saint Rita
Basilica of Saint Mary
[/quote]

The Basillica is NOT orthodox.

[b]Other non-orthodox parishes:[/b]
St. Joan of Arc, Minneapolis
Guardian Angels, Oakdale
Pax Christi, Edina
Our Lady of the Lake, White Bear Lake

[b]Stellar orthodox Parishes :)[/b]
The Cathedral of St. Paul
St. Vincent de Paul, St. Paul
Nativity of Our Lord, St. Paul
St. Agnes, St. Paul
Epiphany, Coon Rapids,
St. Paul's, Ham Lake
St. Raphael's, Crystal
St. Peter's, Forest Lake
All Saints, Lakeville
St. Michael, St. Michael
St. Jude, Mahtomedi
Maternity of Mary, St. Paul...
St. John's, Excelsior
St. Peter's, North St. Paul
St. Helena's, Minneapolis
Holy Spirit, St. Paul (is moving swiftly in this direction with new staff)
Holy Family, St. Louis Park
St. Charles Borromeo
The Hamilton Parishes (under Fr. Williams)
St. Louis King of France, St. Paul
St. Olaf, Minneapolis

I work with priests in our diocese on a daily basis, so I speak first hand.

Edited by Veritas
homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1120966' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:28 PM'][b]Stellar orthodox Parishes :)[/b]
The Cathedral of St. Paul
St. Vincent de Paul, St. Paul
Nativity of Our Lord, St. Paul
St. Agnes, St. Paul
Epiphany, Coon Rapids,
St. Paul's, Ham Lake
St. Raphael's, Crystal
St. Peter's, Forest Lake
All Saints, Lakeville
St. Michael, St. Michael
St. Jude, Mahtomedi
Maternity of Mary, St. Paul...
and many more.
[/quote]
:love:

St. Nicholas in New Market.

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1120968' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:29 PM']
:love:

St. Nicholas in New Market.
[/quote]

Hey, Fr. Reiser was there for a while wasn't he? Great priest. He was critical in helping my wife come in to the Chruch.

homeschoolmom
Posted

It's not my parish... Mine was on the list, though. I just wanted to add it because it's a good parish.

Holy Family in SLP, too.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1120977' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:33 PM']
It's not my parish... Mine was on the list, though. I just wanted to add it because it's a good parish.

Holy Family in SLP, too.
[/quote]

+

Yes, St. Elizabeth Ann Seton in Hastings is solid from what I hear.

[quote name='Veritas' post='1120966' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:28 PM']
The Basillica is NOT orthodox.

[b]Other non-orthodox parishes:[/b]
St. Joan of Arc, Minneapolis
Guardian Angels, Oakdale
Pax Christi, Edina
Our Lady of the Lake, White Bear Lake (getting better)
St. Joseph, New Hope


[b]Stellar orthodox Parishes :)[/b]
The Cathedral of St. Paul
St. Vincent de Paul, St. Paul
Nativity of Our Lord, St. Paul
St. Agnes, St. Paul
Epiphany, Coon Rapids,
St. Paul's, Ham Lake
St. Raphael's, Crystal
St. Peter's, Forest Lake
All Saints, Lakeville
St. Michael, St. Michael
St. Jude, Mahtomedi
Maternity of Mary, St. Paul...
St. John's, Excelsior
St. Peter's, North St. Paul
St. Helena's, Minneapolis
Holy Spirit, St. Paul (is moving swiftly in this direction with new staff)
Holy Family, St. Louis Park
St. Charles Borromeo
The Hamilton Parishes (under Fr. Williams)
St. Louis King of France, St. Paul
St. Olaf, Minneapolis
St. Augustine's, South St. Paul
St. Michael, West St. Paul (leftover from Fr. Piche)
Blessed Sacrament, St. Paul
St. Boniface, St. Bonifacius

I work with priests and parishes in our diocese on a daily basis, so I speak first hand.
[/quote]

Edited by Veritas
AlterDominicus
Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1120966' date='Nov 15 2006, 06:28 PM']
[b]Stellar orthodox Parishes :)[/b]
The Cathedral of St. Paul
St. Vincent de Paul, St. Paul
Nativity of Our Lord, St. Paul
St. Agnes, St. Paul
[b]Epiphany, Coon Rapids,[/b]
St. Paul's, Ham Lake
St. Raphael's, Crystal
St. Peter's, Forest Lake
All Saints, Lakeville
St. Michael, St. Michael
St. Jude, Mahtomedi
Maternity of Mary, St. Paul...
St. John's, Excelsior
St. Peter's, North St. Paul
St. Helena's, Minneapolis
Holy Spirit, St. Paul (is moving swiftly in this direction with new staff)
Holy Family, St. Louis Park
St. Charles Borromeo
The Hamilton Parishes (under Fr. Williams)
St. Louis King of France, St. Paul
St. Olaf, Minneapolis

I work with priests in our diocese on a daily basis, so I speak first hand.
[/quote]

Epiphany is where I go!!! And Sister Maria Caritas went there to before she entered. :lol:

Posted

[quote name='AlterDominicus' post='1120992' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:49 PM']
Epiphany is where I go!!! And Sister Maria Caritas went there to before she entered. :lol:
[/quote]


Hi co-epiphanite. I go there as well. :D:

AlterDominicus
Posted

OOOOOOOOOOOOO Then maybe I met you, hahahaha. :lol_roll:

Posted

I do go to the Basilica from time to time ... the liturgy is beautiful -- probably the best music I've heard in a Catholic church since I became Catholic.

Homilies have been good from what I've heard. I haven't witnessed any blatant abuses during the Mass. I know there are some groups that are of less-than-orthodox leanings.

I've gone to a taize prayer and meditation/confession service that was really quite wonderful. The penance I got was creative and tailored to the sins I had confessed ... which was quite a refreshing change from what I usually get.

I haven't participated in any of the extra-curricular groups because I simply haven't had the time (or perhaps, the inclination) to do so. However, at the end of this month the young adult book club is discussing one of my all-time favorite books, and in January they're doing one that I received as a gift from a good friend. I will probably participate in those discussions.

Other than that, I'm really only marginally familiar with the parish. I've been attending off and on for a little over two months.

Posted

hey now, add St Augustine's in South St Paul to the list of good ones. We even still have a Latin mass every sunday! (I'm away at school now in fargo moorhead but good ol' St A's is still home!)

Piccoli Fiori JMJ
Posted

I've been to Nativity in St. Paul... beautiful church and beautiful Mass... :)

Posted

[quote name='Veritas' post='1120966' date='Nov 15 2006, 04:28 PM']
The Basillica is NOT orthodox.

[b]Other non-orthodox parishes:[/b]
St. Joan of Arc, Minneapolis
Guardian Angels, Oakdale
Pax Christi, Edina
Our Lady of the Lake, White Bear Lake

[b]Stellar orthodox Parishes :)[/b]
The Cathedral of St. Paul
St. Vincent de Paul, St. Paul
Nativity of Our Lord, St. Paul
St. Agnes, St. Paul
Epiphany, Coon Rapids,
St. Paul's, Ham Lake
St. Raphael's, Crystal
St. Peter's, Forest Lake
All Saints, Lakeville
St. Michael, St. Michael
St. Jude, Mahtomedi
Maternity of Mary, St. Paul...
St. John's, Excelsior
St. Peter's, North St. Paul
St. Helena's, Minneapolis
Holy Spirit, St. Paul (is moving swiftly in this direction with new staff)
Holy Family, St. Louis Park
St. Charles Borromeo
The Hamilton Parishes (under Fr. Williams)
St. Louis King of France, St. Paul
St. Olaf, Minneapolis

I work with priests in our diocese on a daily basis, so I speak first hand.
[/quote]

[i]What sort of things would make a parish unorthodox?[/i]

Posted

any rochester info?


I found a good one in LaCrosse, but it is a 90min drive

Posted

St Ambrose of Woodbury has consistently been improving! They added adoration about a year ago and I personally think its had a pretty dramatic effect.

Posted

[quote name='hot stuff' post='1121544' date='Nov 16 2006, 09:10 AM']
St Ambrose of Woodbury has consistently been improving! They added adoration about a year ago and I personally think its had a pretty dramatic effect.
[/quote]
I love adoration ... I need to find someplace to do that from time to time.

homeschoolmom
Posted

We're getting adoration. :)

Posted

Maybe I should just go to adoration when I visit you guys or hot stuff.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...