Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

homeschoolmom
Posted

I was going to make this a poll, but it would be too confusing.

If you were in band in school, I'm interested in knowing what instrument you played, when you started and whether you can still play... (yeah, I know most of you are young enough that your instruments are still under the bed somewhere...)

Posted

I was in band from 5th grade through my freshman year in college. I played the clarinet. I sold it probably 5 years ago to a friend.

I was pretty good ... took a Mozart concerto to state competition my senior year and was first chair through all of high school. But ... I hated practice, and really never loved playing the clarinet. When I gave it up, I didn't foresee ever wanting to play again. Every so often, I do get the odd urge to play, but I haven't in years. And my mouth is way out of practice. You build up a callous on your lower lip when you play often, and that's been gone for a while.

Posted

I was in Jazz Ensemble from 9-12th grade - playing guitar, and then bass guitar. I started playing when I was 11, though. I won a couple of awards in my State Jazz Festivals. (brag, brag)

I can still play both fairly well, although I kick myself in the butt daily that I didn't continue in college and minor in music.

I want to learn piano, but the 2 year old puts a crimp in after school activities for Momma.

Posted

[size=1]I wasnt in the band.
I WAS IN CHOIR! Which is better! :P:
[/size]

Posted

I was in choir too, and have sung in choirs as an adult.

I do actually like choir better.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Maybe... I'm looking into that, too...

Posted (edited)

[img]http://www.eryksarina.com/vBulletin/images/smilies/band.gif[/img]

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1122504' date='Nov 17 2006, 02:13 PM']
Maybe... I'm looking into that, too...
[/quote]
you're trying to decide whether hskids should be in band?

choir is much more economical, and less painful for the rest of the family. learning an instrument involves lots of squeaks and wrong notes.

homeschoolmom
Posted

I know... Yes. I am looking for things to get us out of the house so I don't freak out this winter. :rolleyes: I'd forgotten about choir until it was mentioned in this thread. I think there is a HS choir somewhere around here...

Posted

yeah ... if you're looking to avoid being driven crazy, band is not the way to go.

I do think it's a valuable thing to learn an instrument, and can be worth the mental anguish of having a budding prodigy in your home, but I'd personally pick an instrument that would be something they could use the rest of their lives, like guitar or violin or something. In other words, I wish [b]I[/b] had learned guitar or violin or something.

God the Father
Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1122517' date='Nov 17 2006, 04:21 PM']
choir is much more economical, and less painful for the rest of the family. learning an instrument involves lots of squeaks and wrong notes.
[/quote]

There's a lot of other things choir is "much more" than band.

homeschoolmom
Posted
:lol:
I would only do band if HSdaughter really wanted to do it. I haven't even asked her.... She would probably like choir better (and has a far less chance of losing her instrument, but you never know) and probably HSson could be in it too... thus killing two birds with one stone...
Posted

Now now ... lets not do a choir vs band debate!

homeschoolmom
Posted

I think band is really good too. But the memory of my brother practicing his clarinet in the basement... :scream:

That and the memories of his playing his electric guitar all afternoon... :ohno:

But it was good. He still plays the clarinet from time to time....

Posted

[quote name='Azriel' post='1122545' date='Nov 17 2006, 02:33 PM']
Now now ... lets not do a choir vs band debate!
[/quote]
really there is no debate

choir is hands down better


I don't think I have ever been moved to tears in a band performance, but have been so moved on more than one occasion when singing.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Sojourner' post='1122552' date='Nov 17 2006, 03:35 PM']I don't think I have ever been moved to tears in a band performance, but have been so moved on more than one occasion when singing.
[/quote]
Well, you've never watched your baby play an instrument... that would move me to tears. :sadder:

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I was homeschooled (technically not relevant to playing an instrument), I don't know the reasoning why or difficulties that were involved but my mom never got us started on any instruments until I'd left for college (1998)... thats when my sisters started violin and clarinet, brothers sax, drums, guitar, and trumpet. Some of them still play, some don't.

homeschoolmom
Posted

See, now while I think choir is great (and probably more to my kids' bent), there's just something very satisfying in being able to play an instrument-- even if you're the only one listening.

Posted (edited)

[size=1]The only catch about choir is that if you really cant sing...there isnt much you can really do to help that.
So choir would not be a good fit.

But with band, you can practice and be awsome at it! You dont need to depend on something like the voice to develop.

But you can still play an instrument and be in choir!
[/size]

Edited by CrossCuT

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...