Norseman82 Posted November 18, 2006 Posted November 18, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1123159' date='Nov 18 2006, 12:03 PM'] That's horrible! shopping on sunday unless it's an emergancy is mortally sinful! Also, I think it is very evil to regulate public smoking. [/quote] Man, talk about having one's priorities backwards! You'd have a very different attitude if you lost your immediate family due to tobacco-related diseases. Don't ask me for help when you're orphaned at 14 because your parents die from cancer or heart attacks and you need to get an ox out of a ditch on a Sunday.
Dudette Posted November 19, 2006 Author Posted November 19, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1123150' date='Nov 18 2006, 11:53 AM'] Have you ever been to the US? I don't think we could ever go back on the whole Sunday shopping thing...do everything you can to keep it from taking control...we treat Sunday like "a regular day off unless you're in the service or sales industries" here...I wish everyone would take the day to rest. [/quote] I lived in the US for a year. I know how the US treats Sunday shopping. I plan on going to college in the US and when I get there, I have 6 days a week to do my shopping, and no one will find me near a mall on the Lord's Day. Smoking in general is bad, people don't want to acknowledge it, but I think the NS government is being charitable to the people that smoke (they definitely won't admit THAT) and is helping them out. The whole plan is for the health of everybody, second hand smoke can cause just as much harm as the person smoking the cigarette.
CrossCuT Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 [quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1123178' date='Nov 18 2006, 12:18 PM'] I think cigarettes need to be cleaned up and all the nasty stuff taken out of them. I mean, it's ridiculous. But smoking is enjoyable. I can understand banning smoking inside restaurants and the like, but not outside. There's plenty of room outside. Move ten feet away if you don't like how a person smells. That's what I do when I meet homeless people . Should we pass a law saying homeless people must be deloused and do their laundry at least once a week? It's no different from targeting smokers with legislation. It's all just big gov't, and people with agendas using gov't to get their way. [/quote] [size=1]The last time I checked homeless people smell wasnt life threatening. [/size]
XIX Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1123159' date='Nov 18 2006, 01:03 PM'] That's horrible! shopping on sunday unless it's an emergancy is mortally sinful! Also, I think it is very evil to regulate public smoking. [/quote] .... ya know.... People like you almost caused me to lose my faith a few years ago (thank God I was deeply rooted in Catholicism to begin with.) I almost bought into radical Traditionalist lies, and simply put, I didn't think God wanted me to be pissed off my whole life. As it is, I now believe the latter but not the former. Praise God.
Resurrexi Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 [quote]I don't know that I'd call it mortally sinful. We're not to do work on Sunday that is a continuation of the kind of work we normally do...I don't think most people make a living out of shopping.[/quote] I should rephrase myself, maybe "all shopping unless it's an emergency" was a little too strict. All unnecessary shopping is mortally sinful on Sundays beucase it hinders us from keeping the Lord's Day holy. If you have nothing to fix dinner with, then, go get some food at the store, but don't go buy the whole week's worth of groceries while you're there. If you [i]have[/i] to have a new tie for Monday beucase the one you were wearing got stained after Mass on Sunday, then by all means, go get a tie, but don't do all you're Christmas shopping while you're at it. Also, if you have to buy something that you need for Tuesday, then don't buy it on Sunday, want till Monday unless you have no time whatsoever to buy it on Monday. [quote]I'd like to see something from the Church on how to obey the commandment in the context of modern society.[/quote] Yes, that would be nice, but you still have the numerous Catechisms' definitions of the Third Commandment to guide you: [quote name='Catechism of Pope St. Pius X']The Third Commandment 1 Q. What does the Third Commandment: Remember thou keep holy the Sabbath day, command us to do? A. The Third Commandment: Remember thou keep holy the Sabbath day, commands us to honour God by acts of worship on festivals. 2 Q. What are festivals? A. In the Old Law they were Saturdays and certain other days regarded as specially solemn by the Jews; in the New Law they are Sundays and other festivals instituted by the Church. 3 Q. Why is Sunday sanctified instead of Saturday in the New Law? A. Sunday, which means the Lord's Day, was substituted for Saturday, because it was on that day that our Lord rose from the dead. 4 Q. What act of worship is commanded us on festivals? A. We are commanded to assist devoutly at the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass. 5 Q. With what other good works does a good Christian sanctify festivals? A. A good Christian sanctifies festivals: (1) By attending Christian Doctrine, sermons, and the Divine Office; (2) By frequently and devoutly receiving the sacraments of Penance and the Blessed Eucharist; (3) By the practice of prayer and works of Christian charity. 6 Q. What does the Third Commandment forbid? A. The Third Commandment forbids servile works and any other works that hinder the worship of God. 7 Q. What servile works are forbidden on festivals? A. The servile works forbidden on festivals are those works called manual, that is, those material works in which the body has more part than the mind, such, for instance, as are ordinarily done by servants, labourers, and artisans. 8 Q. What sin does one commit by working on festivals? A. One commits a mortal sin by working on festivals; brevity of time, however, will excuse from grave sin. 9 Q. Is no servile work at all permitted on festivals? A. On festivals those works are permitted which are necessary for life, or for the service of God; as well as those done for a grave reason, with leave, when possible, from the Pastor. 10 Q. Why is servile work forbidden on festivals? A. Servile work is forbidden on festivals in order that we may the better attend to divine worship, and to the care of our souls; And to enable us to rest from toil. Hence innocent recreation is not forbidden. 11 Q. What else above all should we avoid on festivals? A. We should above all avoid sin and whatever leads to sin, such as dangerous diversions and dangerous places of amusement.[/quote] [quote name='Catechism of the Council of Trent']WORKS FORBIDDEN Thou shalt do no work on it, says the Lord, thou, nor thy son, nor thy daughter, nor thy man-servant, nor thy maid-servant, nor thy beast, nor the stranger that is within thy gates. These words teach us, in the first place, to avoid whatever may interfere with the worship of God. Hence it is not difficult to perceive that all servile works are forbidden, not because they are improper or evil in themselves, but because they withdraw the attention from the worship of God, which is the great end of the Commandment. The faithful should be still more careful to avoid sin, which not only withdraws the mind from the contemplation of divine things, but entirely alienates us from the love of God.[/quote] [quote name='Catechism of the Catholic Church']A day of grace and rest from work 2184 Just as God "rested on the seventh day from all his work which he had done,"121 human life has a rhythm of work and rest. The institution of the Lord's Day helps everyone enjoy adequate rest and leisure to cultivate their familial, cultural, social, and religious lives.122 2185 On Sundays and other holy days of obligation, the faithful are to refrain from engaging in work or activities that hinder the worship owed to God, the joy proper to the Lord's Day, the performance of the works of mercy, and the appropriate relaxation of mind and body.123 Family needs or important social service can legitimately excuse from the obligation of Sunday rest. The faithful should see to it that legitimate excuses do not lead to habits prejudicial to religion, family life, and health. The charity of truth seeks holy leisure- the necessity of charity accepts just work.124 2186 Those Christians who have leisure should be mindful of their brethren who have the same needs and the same rights, yet cannot rest from work because of poverty and misery. Sunday is traditionally consecrated by Christian piety to good works and humble service of the sick, the infirm, and the elderly. Christians will also sanctify Sunday by devoting time and care to their families and relatives, often difficult to do on other days of the week. Sunday is a time for reflection, silence, cultivation of the mind, and meditation which furthers the growth of the Christian interior life. 2187 Sanctifying Sundays and holy days requires a common effort. Every Christian should avoid making unnecessary demands on others that would hinder them from observing the Lord's Day. Traditional activities (sport, restaurants, etc.), and social necessities (public services, etc.), require some people to work on Sundays, but everyone should still take care to set aside sufficient time for leisure. With temperance and charity the faithful will see to it that they avoid the excesses and violence sometimes associated with popular leisure activities. In spite of economic constraints, public authorities should ensure citizens a time intended for rest and divine worship. Employers have a similar obligation toward their employees. 2188 In respecting religious liberty and the common good of all, Christians should seek recognition of Sundays and the Church's holy days as legal holidays. They have to give everyone a public example of prayer, respect, and joy and defend their traditions as a precious contribution to the spiritual life of society. If a country's legislation or other reasons require work on Sunday, the day should nevertheless be lived as the day of our deliverance which lets us share in this "festal gathering," this "assembly of the firstborn who are enrolled in heaven."125 [/quote] [quote]Okay... here's the thing.... In general, HS_Dad and I are pretty good about resting on Sunday... hanging out, relaxing etc. However, there are times when it is necessary to spend the entire day cleaning. (It's my plan for tomorrow). It's going to make our household run better, make us happier and just make everything hunky dory. HSDad is taking the kids away for the afternoon. And runny errands will probably be on the list-- if I have time. Besides anyone who is so strict on "No work on the Sabbath or Holy Days" better figure out how Christmas dinner's going to get on the table.[/quote] It would be best not to clean on Sunday unless it was just a little straightening up so that you could rest (some people can't rest when their homes are very messy) or it's an emergency or it's absolutely necessary. It would be best to clean on Saturday. Also, a cool thing to do for Christmas dinner would be to fix it before Midnight Mass on Christmas Eve, then go to the Midnight Mass (which would be, since it is at midnight, Christmas Day after you returned from Mass) and then you could eat dinner after Mass. Then again, this would not work out for people with young children. [quote]Exactly. We're not Hasidic Jews...we don't need to pay one of their kids to come in and turn the lights on for us on our Sabbath.[/quote] Yes, I realise we're not Jews, just as Christ said "5 And answering them, he said: Which of you shall have an ass or an ox fall into a pit, and will not immediately draw him out, on the sabbath day?"
toledo_jesus Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 I agree that smokers should be considerate and not block doors. But as for the whole 'killing you' thing, so does everything. I heard once that drinking out of an aluminum can takes off seven seconds of your life. I heard orange juice prevents cancer, then I heard that it might cause cancer. Cancer cancer cancer. All I hear is cancer this and death that. It's gonna happen no matter what you do. I think people should stop worrying so much about what's going to kill them. If you are square with God then who cares if you die? And if you smoke then don't smoke too much. And we should be able to smoke in bars, because drinking and smoking are made for each other.
Fidei Defensor Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1123159' date='Nov 18 2006, 11:03 AM'] Also, I think it is very evil to regulate public smoking. [/quote] You really throw around the word 'evil' too much.
KnightofChrist Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 "Anyone who smokes should be drug out into the street and shot" [img]http://www.cartonionline.com/tv/italia1/garfield/garfield.gif[/img] Garfield [i]the Cat[/i] Ahh the good ol' days of Saturday morning cartoons...
homeschoolmom Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 [quote name='StThomasMore' post='1123512' date='Nov 19 2006, 01:21 AM']It would be best not to clean on Sunday unless it was just a little straightening up so that you could rest (some people can't rest when their homes are very messy) or it's an emergency or it's absolutely necessary. It would be best to clean on Saturday. Also, a cool thing to do for Christmas dinner would be to fix it before Midnight Mass on Christmas Eve, then go to the Midnight Mass (which would be, since it is at midnight, Christmas Day after you returned from Mass) and then you could eat dinner after Mass. Then again, this would not work out for people with young children.[/quote] Thanks for the tip. I'm pretty sure I can figure this one out on my own, though.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 STM, I consistently noticed those passages only forbidding work that "hindered the worship of God." [quote]6 Q. What does the Third Commandment forbid? A. The Third Commandment forbids servile works and any other works that hinder the worship of God.[/quote] I don't think shopping does that (although it might add to the load the employees are forced to bear, but perhaps I, being a nice customer, can use the occasion to help brighten their Sunday and bring them closer to God). Furthermore, the Catechism recognizes the legitimate need for going to restaurants, sporting events, etc.: [quote]Traditional activities (sport, restaurants, etc.), and social necessities (public services, etc.), require some people to work on Sundays, but everyone should still take care to set aside sufficient time for leisure.[/quote] As you can see, it recognizes that some things are okay Sunday work and only requires that workers "should still take care to set aside [b]sufficient[/b] time for leisure." Like I said, we're not Hasidic Jews. Telling HSmom to prepare the meal on Saturday seems to reflect that you think we are. As a matter of fact, some people enjoy cooking and even cleaning as a sort of recreation. You're young...don't get caught up in legalism. It will only make you bitter as you grow older.
Balthazor Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 There once was a Brother that loved to smoke cigars. One day the Abbot found him kneeling , with his hands folded, eyes closed and head bowed, and a fat cigar clasped between his teeth. Once in a while a puff of smoke would be expelled from his lips as he prayed. The Abbot, less than thrilled, approached him later in the day and asked him "Do you think it is respectful to be smoking while you pray? I would think that it takes away from the reverance you pay God." The Brother 's humble reply was "Yes, Father." And the Abott instructed him to pray on the issue. Two days later the Abbot found the Brother once again, head bowed in prayer, and hands folded with a wreath of smoke encirlcing his presence as a large Cuban dangled from his lips. The Abbot very annoyed, interupted the Brother's prayers, "WHat have I told you about smoking during prayer?", he gasped. The Brother looked up and a large smile broke across his face. "I have spent a lot of time in prayer asking out Lord about this very issue. He said that it is indeed very disrespectful to smoke while you pray....but He said it would be quite alright if you prayed while you smoked."
Resurrexi Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 [quote] Like I said, we're not Hasidic Jews. Telling HSmom to prepare the meal on Saturday seems to reflect that you think we are. As a matter of fact, some people enjoy cooking and even cleaning as a sort of recreation. [/quote] I never told her to prepare the meal on Saturday. I said it's a cool thing to eat the Christmas meal after Midnight Mass... And no, I don't think we're Jews.
Pio Nono Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 JMJ 11/19 - Thirty-third Sunday Is this really the responsibility of the government? Regardless of what we might think of smoking, it's pretty creepy when governments start to regulate stuff like this. This should be left up to individual bars and restaurants. Some might say that it would be financial suicide to bar smoking if it were left up to individual establishments, but there would always be a few places that could capitalize on the whole non-smoking thing. Besides, we have more important things to tackle instead of smoking - like pornography on billboards and housewives using meth, for instance.
Mercy me Posted November 19, 2006 Posted November 19, 2006 Let's follow this a little...smokng is bad and should be banned even it you are only in the same room with it could kill you. Beer is a leading cause of drunk driving. I think that we should ban it even it you are not planning on driving because you might have to run out and get something. It is possible to get drunk on wine and other alcohol, too. We need to ban these too. Plus after doing for some time cirosis of the liver can set it. Greasy foods cause elevated cholestoral levels and heart disease. We need to do something about that too. Pesticides and fertilized are destroying the environment and cause cancer to those who eat food grown this way. We should ban these things even though it would dramatically reduce our food production. Cars kill more Americans every year that anything else. Should we ban them too? We are restricting smoking to "protect innocent people." Yet, people who don't come from homes with smokers still get lung cancer. The point is that there is not a one of us that is getting out of this place alive. We have a duty to take care of the bodies that God has given each of us. But relaxing with a cigar, a drink with friends, a drive down to Disney, a fresh apple etc. are things that many enjoy. At what point does the government trying to protect us from ourselves encroach on our personal liberties? We need to remember that with freedom comes much responsibility. But it also means that you have the opportunity to live your own life.
Socrates Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 (edited) [quote name='Raphael' post='1123224' date='Nov 18 2006, 02:27 PM'] Economically, I would agree with you. Morally, I would not...I just can't see any benefit in smoking and can only see moral difficulty in doing something that's going to kill you. [/quote] The problem is that it would be more accurate to say smoking is an unhealthy or risky behavior, rather than killing. It can't really be compared to murder or suicide. I think this is proven by the fact that smokers have lived into their 90s and beyond. (And everyone dies sooner or later anyway) And many other things can increase risk of death by cancer, etc.: fatty foods, excessive sugar, excessive alcohol, etc. I really don't think it is the place of government to ban everything deemed unhealthy or risky. Now, I personally don't smoke (though I on rare occasion enjoy a cigar), and don't advocate smoking. But I think this is a case of the government overstepping its bounds, and an example of the "nanny-state" mentality. Edited November 20, 2006 by Socrates
ardillacid Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 Government has no buisiness regulating smoking in private establishments. I bet that within ten years, they will ban smoking in private homes if there are children under 18 in it.
homeschoolmom Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 In case anyone cares... my kitchen floor is so clean, my duaghter and I have both slipped on it. We're used to a more sticky texture....
rollingcatholic Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1123902' date='Nov 19 2006, 08:58 PM'] In case anyone cares... my kitchen floor is so clean, my duaghter and I have both slipped on it. We're used to a more sticky texture.... [/quote] eww...
Lil Red Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 [quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1123178' date='Nov 18 2006, 10:18 AM']But smoking is enjoyable. I can understand banning smoking inside restaurants and the like, but not outside. There's plenty of room outside. Move ten feet away if you don't like how a person smells. That's what I do when I meet homeless people . Should we pass a law saying homeless people must be deloused and do their laundry at least once a week? It's no different from targeting smokers with legislation.[/quote] [quote name='toledo_jesus' post='1123537' date='Nov 19 2006, 12:21 AM'] I agree that smokers should be considerate and not block doors. But as for the whole 'killing you' thing, so does everything. I heard once that drinking out of an aluminum can takes off seven seconds of your life. I heard orange juice prevents cancer, then I heard that it might cause cancer. Cancer cancer cancer. All I hear is cancer this and death that. It's gonna happen no matter what you do. I think people should stop worrying so much about what's going to kill them. If you are square with God then who cares if you die? And if you smoke then don't smoke too much. And we should be able to smoke in bars, because drinking and smoking are made for each other.[/quote]Agreed with both points above [quote name='Balthazor' post='1123651' date='Nov 19 2006, 09:00 AM']The Brother looked up and a large smile broke across his face. "I have spent a lot of time in prayer asking out Lord about this very issue. He said that it is indeed very disrespectful to smoke while you pray....but He said it would be quite alright if you prayed while you smoked."[/quote] [quote name='Pio Nono' post='1123750' date='Nov 19 2006, 12:59 PM']Is this really the responsibility of the government? Regardless of what we might think of smoking, it's pretty creepy when governments start to regulate stuff like this. This should be left up to individual bars and restaurants. Some might say that it would be financial suicide to bar smoking if it were left up to individual establishments, but there would always be a few places that could capitalize on the whole non-smoking thing.[/quote] [quote name='Mercy me' post='1123774' date='Nov 19 2006, 02:03 PM']At what point does the government trying to protect us from ourselves encroach on our personal liberties? We need to remember that with freedom comes much responsibility. But it also means that you have the opportunity to live your own life.[/quote] [quote name='Socrates' post='1123894' date='Nov 19 2006, 06:40 PM']But I think this is a case of the government overstepping its bounds, and an example of the "nanny-state" mentality.[/quote] agreed to the points above.
Matty_boy Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 If smoking only had a negative effect on the smoker, then they can do whatever they want as long as I don't have to pay for their medicare/medicaid. Smokers have no Constitutional or moral right to smoke BECAUSE it negatively effects the health of those around them. I predict someone somewhere will even win a court case based on suing/charging a person with assault for secondhand smoke attack.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now