Matty_boy Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='Theologian in Training' post='1126255' date='Nov 22 2006, 04:47 PM'] No offense, but you should really at least watch one episode before making a judgment on the show. I am always reluctant trusting someone else's word until I have seen it for myself... [/quote] I don't have a TV. Also, God does not NEED anything. He was around before we were created, but he created us so we could take part in His glory and majesty.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 [quote name='dUSt' post='1125345' date='Nov 21 2006, 06:07 PM'] [i]Thank you for contacting TLC about The Monastery. We appreciate your interest in the series and apologize for the last minute schedule change. An encore presentation of the final episode, "Exorcising the Demons," can be seen for free on Discovery on Demand through your local cable operator from December 22 - January 18, 2006. A reply to this message is not necessary. For more information about schedules and programming check our website, www.discovery.com. If you have any further inquiries or comments, please contact us via our webform at [url="http://extweb.discovery.com/ViewerRelations"]http://extweb.discovery.com/ViewerRelations[/url]. Again, thank you for your feedback and we apologize for any inconvenience. Sincerely, Barbara Viewer Relations Discovery Networks[/i] [/quote] In other words, they want to charge you for the last episode. Can't judge hearts, but it sounds like they did that on purpose.
Moneybags Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 Done - I sent a message. I missed the last episode for the same reason!
Theologian in Training Posted November 29, 2006 Posted November 29, 2006 Like I said, if you have no moral objections (seems many don't given all the requests) I have the entire show, from beginning to end on my server. All you need to do is dload crossftp and ask me for the IP Username and Password. God Bless [quote name='Matty_boy' post='1130281' date='Nov 28 2006, 09:40 PM'] I don't have a TV. Also, God does not NEED anything. He was around before we were created, but he created us so we could take part in His glory and majesty. [/quote] Yes, but my point is that you may be getting a misinterpretation from whomever it was you read this review. Besides, I don't even remember that being said...and I have watched it. God Bless
Matty_boy Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 (edited) I was just saying... Goofy Theology of "The Monastery" Anyone else watching The Monastery? I saw just about 45 minutes of it tonight and I was struck by the superficiality of the monks' theology! Just about everything the abbot said was New Agey psychobabble. The Asian monk was speaking Buddhist with a Berekely accent. And Br. Gabriel actually said to the big whiney ex-Catholic, "It's like God needs us." What?! The only one I heard tonight that sounded remotely Catholic was the hermit, Br. Xavier. I have to admit that this is the first time I've seen this show. I haven't seen anything about it on the blogs. Is there anyone out there watching this show and critiquing the goofy theology these guys are preaching? by Fr. Philip N. Powell, Campus Ministry and Theology Professor at University of Dallas [url="http://hancaquam.blogspot.com/2006_11_01_hancaquam_archive.html"]http://hancaquam.blogspot.com/2006_11_01_h...am_archive.html[/url] In reading various posts and blogs about [i]The Monastery[/i], all I can think of is Fr. Thomas Dubay's excerpt from [i]Deep Conversion Deep Prayer[/i]: [indent]There is an elephant in the parlor, but they refuse to acknowledge its presence or to talk seriously about it. Let me illustrate with an example from religious life. When the members of a congregation speak of promoting vocations, they discuss endlessly new techniques to publicize their orders and plans for crafting catchy web sites. The real questions to ask are "Why are we not attracting our best young people? Could it be that our elegant dining and drinking and our secular clothes and hairdos and amusements repel them? Why are the orders who are obeying the Church's norms and teaching attracting so many?" These questions and others like them are the top priority issues. They are completely obvious to any honest person, but all the same there is a tacit agreement not to mention them.[/indent] Edited November 30, 2006 by Matty_boy
Theologian in Training Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 Well, you have to remember they were not speaking from a script, they were dealing with people that have no concept whatsoever of God, minus one or two of them, and they were speaking from their heart. The Protestant guy did point out to the Abbot that they were not really deeply theological at which the Abbot responded by explaining to him that these people don't even know what God is. Perhaps, it was not the best approach, perhaps they could have added a little more straight theology into the mix, but, at the same time, you have to remember, this is still a secular show on a secular network. There was probably a lot of editing done and perhaps the monks did not appear to be as theological as they could have been. But again, Fr. Powell who wrote that review had a snap judgment on one or two things that they said that could have been better phrased. However, he also admitted to having seen only one episode. Walking into the middle of the series is like reading the middle of the book. There is no clear context and you judge it based on what you have read, rather than the book as a whole. Like I said, not everything the monks said was excellent, but, at the same time, to make a judgment on something you see after watching it once is also not the most prudent thing to do either. God Bless
Matty_boy Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 If you look at it from the persective of a person who knows nothing about God or the Church, and the casual viewer, it could be taken out of context, just as you say I have done.
Theoketos Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 Matty Boy you know I love you. I even love Father Powell, and actually am acquianted with the good priest, but I have to disagree. It all comes down to semantics in this case or what exactly we mean by need. God needs us in the sense that is through the Church that salvation of souls occurs. However, this does not change anything about God. We all could go to Hell and this would not make God any less, or better if we all go to Heaven this does not make better off. God is infinitely Good, but it is through us that he works. The rest of the series has been pretty Good. The Benedictine Life has been clearly presented.
Starets Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 [quote]In reading various posts and blogs about The Monastery, all I can think of is Fr. Thomas Dubay's excerpt from Deep Conversion Deep Prayer: There is an elephant in the parlor, but they refuse to acknowledge its presence or to talk seriously about it. Let me illustrate with an example from religious life. When the members of a congregation speak of promoting vocations, they discuss endlessly new techniques to publicize their orders and plans for crafting catchy web sites. The real questions to ask are "Why are we not attracting our best young people? Could it be that our elegant dining and drinking and our secular clothes and hairdos and amusements repel them? Why are the orders who are obeying the Church's norms and teaching attracting so many?" These questions and others like them are the top priority issues. They are completely obvious to any honest person, but all the same there is a tacit agreement not to mention them.[/quote] I've been there. I was an observer in the monastery two summers ago. I stayed in one of the old cells behind the cloister area. I don't have a telebision, so I have no idea if the old cells were shown. I didn't find the dining particulary elegant, but it was certainly ample. i helped cook some of it. And I was always in the work habit. the monks were alwys in habit as well. I found them to be thoroughly orthodox and faithful to the church's norms and teachings. and they are getting vocations. I witnessed two peoplke take their solemn profession.
Theologian in Training Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 [quote name='Theoketos' post='1131927' date='Nov 30 2006, 01:58 PM'] Matty Boy you know I love you. I even love Father Powell, and actually am acquianted with the good priest, but I have to disagree. It all comes down to semantics in this case or what exactly we mean by need. God needs us in the sense that is through the Church that salvation of souls occurs. However, this does not change anything about God. We all could go to Hell and this would not make God any less, or better if we all go to Heaven this does not make better off. God is infinitely Good, but it is through us that he works. The rest of the series has been pretty Good. The Benedictine Life has been clearly presented. [/quote] Thank you. I was starting to get tired of having to defend the show alone God Bless Fr. Brian
alicemary Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 I found the series extremely helpful in my approach to religion. I wanted to clone that Abbot and bring him to Virginia. It gave me hope for religious life today. These are good men who opened their monastery and heart to people who really needed them in their life. It showed a segment of society that is not widely known. I found those monks to be truly beautiful men, filled with good common sense. It made sense to me and more importantly brought me closer to Jesus then I have been for quite awhile. I am no theologian but if we were not here there would be no need for a God hence God does need us. Why mess around with semantics. This show was great and it came at a time when I really needed to hear the message.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now