N/A Gone Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 Some of you might remember this emotionally draining hateful man. Sadly, he is highly influencial and has decided to debate me in a relatively public arena. As before, his writing is in [color="#FF0000"]red[/color] [quote][color="#FF0000"]Dear Jon, Yeah, I know, it has been a LONG time, sorry about that. However, the new satellite internet service was just connected to my house two days ago and now I have 24/7 internet access, which is great. I have been trying to create my real estate site and reformat my books and since I'm not all that good with computers, it has been a bit taxing. Anyways, enough bable[/color] 4. Polygamy vs. manditory marriage (Please stop calling us Roman Catholics, as not all Catholics are Roman but can be Marianite, Eastern etc.) Okay, I will just say Catholic from now on, however refrain from saying that "catholic" means Universal, for you know that is not how I am using it in this discussion. No can do. The word 'catholic' means universal. Using it contrary to the greek according to your request would be just furth nonsense. [color="#FF0000"]Ahhhh.... you can be difficult when you want to be can't you young pup? The thing is, if you want me to stop using "Roman Catholic" and only "Catholic" then you need to stop pretending that when ** I ** use the term "Catholic" I am talking about just all general "Christians" for I am not. How about I use the term Babylonian cultists instead? [/color] This passage says he is not to be a man of multiple wives (ie polygamy or remarried after divorce which is just another form of polygamy). The verse is not saying he must be married before ordination. WOW .... RE-READ THE VERSE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I have repeatedly. Still never says 'must.' Perhaps you should study the culture and times Paul was involved with so you can understand what he is talking about. [color="#FF0000"]HAHAHA ... I think after my last reply, you might want to re-answer that without lying. It most definitely uses the word MUST, unless you completely mutilate the verse to fit your Babylonian doctrines.[/color] Do you not realize that Paul was writting to Greeks deep in the Hellenistic culture which allowed polygamy? They allowed men to get married, divorce, then remarry contrary to the words of Jesus. Yup, I am aware of that. However, this doesn't change the clear meaning of the verse whatsoever and you know it! Sure it changes the meaning to some extent! First, it still does not say 'must.' Second, to reject the know context of a ruling is scholastic ignorace. [color="#FF0000"]It does use the word MUST so your argument is illegitimate.[/color] 5. The Celibacy of Paul To answer your question, I would say YES, the apostle Paul WAS married. Paul is the one who wrote this, therefore he wouldn't disobey it himself. If I read you correctly, Paul 'had' to married because 1 Tim 3:2 said a bishop 'must' be married. I see two errors. First, 1 Tim 3:2 is not a matter of must. Second, Paul made himself celibate for the kingdom (MT 19:12). We know this from 1 Cor 7:7. You have built up your own private doctrine from 1 Tim 3:2, and now you are forcing this doctrine against 1 Cor 7:7. It is not a private doctrine as the Bible says a Bishop is to be married (husband of one wife, faithful in marriage, etc., etc., etc.,)! Paul was not in a physical marriage at the time he wrote to the Corinthians, this is clear, however to say he was not widowed (which you are claiming) is to indeed "build up a private doctrine"! First, Dr. Robinson, THIS IS THE MOST ERRANT THING YOU HAVE EVER SAID!!! 1Cor was written in spring of 57 AD. 1 Tim was written in 65AD. He was celibate before he wrote 1 Tim. This means he was unmarried at the time of writting 1 Tim. [color="#FF0000"]What nonsense! If the apostle Paul were married AT ANY TIME while he was a Christian leader, then the timing of when he wrote 1 Timothy is completely irrelevant! For example, if the Lord called me to be a Bishop or deacon right now at this moment, in my MARRIED state, it doesn't matter if 75 years from now, when I am a widow, I were to write that ALL Bishops and deacons MUST be married. Don't be so silly Jon![/color] Second, you are the one who asserts Paul was ever married!!! You have no scripture to support. The only thing you use is your logic alone 'must' doctrine not seen in scripture. [color="#FF0000"]I think if the apostle Paul wrote that a Bishop and elder MUST be married, then one MUST be married. If somehow the office of "apostle" is different and doesn't require God, then so be it, however in the case of the POPE (General BISHOP) the statement MUST still stands and he (Pope) is nothing more then a unBiblical wolf and cultist.[/color] Third, if 1 Tim 3:2 meant 'a bishop must be of one wife' then Paul violates his own rule by being a widower. He is no longer married!!!! [color="#FF0000"]Oh, stop, that is just childishness. I know your a young pup, but come on, save that kind of twisted logic for the choir boys.[/color] 6. Millingo, Moonies, excommunication, correct way for the Vatican to 'correctly' present its self imge ...My point is that he did come under sactions for siding with the moonies and he was not excommunicate for getting married but for other offenses: ordaining Moonies to the Catholic priesthood. That is not what the press reported. They simply said he was excommunicated for getting married. Had the Vatican wanted to avoid this, they could have easily stated that he was ecommunicated for apostasizing to the Moonie religion, however they did not! Uhhhh... is what any public figure like the Pope publishes in a press report and what the media actuall tells you on TV always going to be the same? [color="#FF0000"] Seriously, I would say about 95%! The press adores the Pope (just another proof he is an antiChrist)![/color] How about you doing some real homework and actually reading the excommunication document for yourself. We members of the Universal Hierarchy (Catholic Church) immediately knew he had excommunicated himself even without the Vatican making any ruling. You would know this also if you actually were knowledgeable about the subject you are rejecting ... instead you are relying on what you think the Catholic Church is and teaches. [color="#FF0000"]I would be happy to. However, this really is beside the point. The fact remains that the vatican could have easily told the press he had been excommunicated for converting to the moonies, but it didn't, it mentioned the marriage! When one considers the FACT that the Vatican has been absolutely pandering to false religions for years, this makes sense, as it fits their m.o. perfectly![/color] "Trust not in your own understanding" Prov 3:5. [color="#FF0000"]Amen .... however read that again. YOU may not trust in YOUR own understanding, but you are just as guilty of putting your trust in HUMAN UNDERSTANDING as if you did, for you pu your trust in an organization made up of human's with conflicting "understandings".....now that is truly a WEAK FOUNDATION![/color] I stand on the Word of God, and not some cheap knock off of this Word which, built on a sandy foundation of Sola Scriptura and Sola Fide has split thousands of times into its own little cults. [color="#FF0000"]HAHAHAHA, sir, you have proven many times you don't even know the word of god and have a better grip on the word of man and religious custom then on God's word. Also, I have said many times that I am NOT a "Protestant and therefore am not grounded on sola anything, but on the word of God itself, the Holy Spirit Himself, the father Himself and Jesus Christ, the true ROCK and ONLY foundation, Himself! YOU, on the other hand are founded on a human organization, human leader and pagan religion.[/color] I hereby accuse you, Dr. Robinson, of being part of an unBiblical, man-made religious cult. [color="#FF0000"]Yeah right.[/color] You represent some form of Protestantism which has: [color="#FF0000"]I am NOT a Protestant. This word in itself upsets me, for it was just a "label" the Babylonian cult used to make their torture and mass extermination of true Biblical Christians sound more acceptable to the rest of the world they controlled. Just like when a nutcase militia in Rwanda slaughters "Tutsi's" rather then simple Rwandan's, or when the US government murders "Communists" rather then Cuban women, etc.,. The fact is that TRUE BIBLICAL CHRISTIANS were around BEFORE Constantine's gang, however when his gang become the majority through ungodly FORCE, the true Christians were minimalized into "Protesters" to make their extermination acceptable, and CULTISTS LIKE YOU BOUGHT IT![/color] -Tossed 7 books of the bible based on what some Jews who rejected Christ profess, even though the early church used them. [color="#FF0000"]WOW! B--R--A--I--N--W--A--S--H--E--D! Do some research and you will see you just LIED through your teeth![/color] -Ignored the writtings of the Christians who knew the teachings of the Apostles personally from about 80 AD on. [color="#FF0000"]I don't have much respect for your grasp of the apostolic or even the early church fathers at all, after rdeading your real presence paper. You sound like a brainwashed JW who just regugitets what his cult headquarters have taught him and can't sift through the writings to find the truth himself. While it is true that the vast majority of "Protestants" can't tell the difference between the writings of the early church fathers and that of a Stephen king novel, I do not fit that mold and therefore your ridiculous rebuke bears no weight with me! Save it for their tongues speaking, Protestant loony! [/color] -Belived doctrines contrary to scripture which have been invented for the first time in the last few hundred years just like all the old heretics such as the Gnostics, Doceitists, Arians, Manicheans, Donatists...etc. They too broke from the Universal Hierarchy by attempting to support their new doctrines from the bible. [color="#FF0000"]HAHAHAHAHHAHAHA! This is the silliest thing you've said yet. Just take a look at your own CULT, and you will see that just about 80% of your present beliefs were NEW INVENTIONS based on the will of man and not the word of God. You sound like the closet sodomite ranting in opublic about the evils of gay marriage .... a total HYPOCRITE![/color] I have no idea who the SDA or what the EGW is, but you certainly have gotten ugly in defense of your cult's beliefs. [color="#FF0000"]Your an ECUMENICAL SCHOLAR and you don't even know what the SDA and EGW stand for? What a joke! Hear I am, a normal guy, living a quiet life with his family in the islands and casualy meeting normal folks, some of which just happen to belong to a cult and I am busting my butt trying to learn all I can about every cult out there so that I can BE ALL THINGS TO ALL EN, SO THAT I CAN SAVE A FEW and you claim to be an ecumenical scholar and don't know anything! SICK, SAD, I WANT TO THROW-UP! The SDA is the "Seventh day Adventist's" and EGW is their revered "prophet" "Ellen G. White" .... you might want to learn that info Mr. Ecumenical scholar if you ever hope to reach these people .... don't worry, there is no charge this time![/color] I look forward to your reply I look forward to your response. I am having fun! [color="#CC0000"]I hope your still having fun and can take my heat in the spirit it is given[/color] I usually refrain from responding to questions in such a harsh tone, but it seems this might be the only thing which might actually get you to read my replies. Besides, if you can dish it out, I figure you can take it without getting sore. [color="#FF0000"]NO PROBLEM, I ENJOY IT[/color]![/quote] This man drains me...completely...any help is greatly appreciated.
jswranch Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1124440' date='Nov 20 2006, 01:39 PM'] Some of you might remember this emotionally draining hateful man. Sadly, he is highly influencial and has decided to debate me in a relatively public arena. As before, his writing is in [color="#FF0000"]red[/color] This man drains me...completely...any help is greatly appreciated. [/quote] Always. Give me a bit.
N/A Gone Posted November 20, 2006 Author Posted November 20, 2006 You rock... whats your story sir. I know you were anglican. Care to share either here or on pM?
Mateo el Feo Posted November 20, 2006 Posted November 20, 2006 One [i]ad hominem[/i] after another. Is it any wonder that you're tired of him? When you take away his name-calling, what text remains that actually has substance that merits a response? Personally, I started getting tired of his constant confusion between "your" and "you're"; but I guess we're supposed to be forgiving and overlook that kind of thing on the internet. [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1124440' date='Nov 20 2006, 03:39 PM']Some of you might remember this emotionally draining hateful man. Sadly, he is highly influencial and has decided to debate me in a relatively public arena.[/quote]In what circles is this man influential? Do you have any web links to him? PS: If he plays the [i]ad hominem[/i] card in a public (real world?) forum, he'll hang himself without any help from you. You just need to calmly cite the personal attacks (not to mention the attacks against the ECF, etc), and the listeners will see him for the mean-spirited person that he is.
jswranch Posted November 30, 2006 Posted November 30, 2006 (edited) I am still trying to work up the boredom/patience to respond, but it is still on my mind. Edited November 30, 2006 by jswranch
N/A Gone Posted December 1, 2006 Author Posted December 1, 2006 thanks bro... finals are killin me, so I havent done much with it
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 [quote name='Mateo el Feo' post='1124568' date='Nov 20 2006, 06:10 PM'] PS: If he plays the [i]ad hominem[/i] card in a public (real world?) forum, he'll hang himself without any help from you.[/quote] Not if the public forum is also anti-Catholic.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now