curtins Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 I'm in a relationship with this girl (we're not dating) and I love her very much. Recently basically she has come into a dry period in her faith and prayer life etc (shes a catholic). Shes doubting some important church teachings, saying things like what matters is that you believe in God and all the world's religions could just in fact really be the true religion. When I try to tell her the importance of prayer, of the church, she said I'm being too preachy and trying to change her beliefs. We've gotten into some serious debates and I'll be the first to admit I have been preachy at times rather than understanding. She told me that during that time she saw the worst of me. My best freind gave me some wise words that that may not be the approach to take with her, rather instead letting God handle it, that He would not let his sheep stray far. BUT ITS FREAKIN HARD!!!! I've always been the one to obnoxiously and unceasingly defend the faith to the best of my ability and when people are in error try and correct them (isnt it in the Bible that its a loving thing to do to correct your brother's error?). So sitting on the sidelines and watching is really hard. I mean she just told me she hasnt been to confession in a long time and she doesn't like going and that God forgives her anyways. I've been praying for her and just either thought of or was inspired to just pray the rosary every night as possible for her. Is it right for me to be passive like this and pray and let God handle it?
Lucy Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 You should continue to pray for her. Praying the rosary is one of the greatest tools to use when dealing with someone who is slipping away from the Catholic faith. I think one of the most important things you can do is to be a good Catholic example for her. She will remember how you act rather than what you say. A great saint once said, "Preach the gospel at all times, if nessessary, use words." I know what it feels like to want someone to know the truth. I also have a friend who is slowly slipping into the worldly view of things. I can't force her to do and believe what is right in the Catholic Church, but I can be there for when she has any questions about her faith.
Tink Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 Well, I can tell you that, if she's only 15 going on 16, she isn't lost, even if she appears so at the moment. Girls that age are, pardon the generalization, [i]insane.[/i] These years will form her, however, so the important part is not necessarily teaching her the importance of doctrine but merely leading by example and teaching with love. Yes, it says to counsel the doubtful and instruct the ignorant and correct your brother's error, but here's how I see it... "Preach the Gospel at ALL times, IF NECESSARY, use words." Right now, that isn't necessary. She merely needs a good example of what it means to be Catholic. Yes, pray that the Blessed Mother might wrap her daughter in her holy and precious mantle and pour forth all graces of conviction and courage that were so vital to her here on earth. Mary will give her the strength to say Yes.
Norseman82 Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 [quote name='curtins' post='1124760' date='Nov 20 2006, 09:14 PM'] 15 going on 16 [/quote] Does she goto public or Catholic school, and how is her family on religious issues? Maybe it is just a phase?
Catholictothecore Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 I think every person around that age should be allowed to fall in love, under certain conditions. What I mean is, I think it's the natural age for the first time (in love), and while you can't "arrange" it, if it happen's, it should be figoursly encouraged...and controlled. I don't mean to sound preachy from here on, but I'm someone who knows where you coming from, even if I've never been in the same situation. (The one girlfriend I've ever had was, if anything, more Catholic than me.) But I know the pain. The seperation, the distance, feels like there a javlin stuck in your heart. And there's no promise, no forseeable futrue that it's ever...ever...going...to...end. You love her. Don't doubt that which you're smooching on Saturday night when you're so far away from her it feels like you're being torn in two. Don't. Just don't. God doesn't work that way. We all have lessons to learn. God doesn't want there to be pain, but it's the natural consequence to sin. Read in the Maccabees, when the family of seven brothers is being martyred. (By the way, think of that mother too. 7 was the symbol of completion. Her family was complete, and she saw them all butchered.) The family did not say they were being killed for their amazing amounts of faith. They were being allowed to suffer because they had all sinned. Again, I say, DO NOT DOUBT THAT YOU LOVE HER. I think it might help to almost think of yourself as her husband now. (WARNING! Let me explain.) Think of yourself as St. Joseph to her. Women are wired differently than us. They want us to be near them. To be someone that is there for them. Period. Be that for her. Swallow the pill, ask Jesus' help and drink the Cup to the dregs. Trust with every ounce of your strength that he will give you every grace you need to get through this. "Any one who asks believing they have recieved will not be denied." Perhaps it might be best to explain that you do in fact love her. You love her enough to just be there for her. You have my prayers. Peace be with you. Remember, DO NOT BE AFRAID! Alex
Thy Geekdom Come Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 [quote name='Balthazor' post='1125206' date='Nov 21 2006, 02:59 PM'] She is Young. Don't give up. [/quote] Ditto. People that young need constancy, security, and love. Don't try to prove the doctrines to her for their own sake, try to prove them to her in a way that makes her see their importance and relevance and how they will help her to have the constancy, security, and love that only God can provide, ultimately in eternity...but also make sure she understands that they are true and beautiful in themselves and therefore must be believed. Always defend the faith in a way designed to make the other person fall more in love with God.
suuran Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 Lord knows I sometimes have trouble accepting the importance of prayer, but it's probably the single most important thing you can do. You can't convert her back. Only God can do that. You can help her answer God's call--hopefully--but, in the end, no amount of debating on your part is going to bring her back to Catholicism. (Here, I'm assuming she's pretty far gone, rather than just having doubts about a teaching or two. Answers can be found for those.) When you're discussing things (I'd recommend thinking about it using that term rather than "debating", remember that she's probably got problems which go beyond the intellectual plane. And I definitely agree with what MI Knight said about being an example for her. I might even suggest inviting her to mass with you, to Confession, etc. Make it easy for her. Definitely pray those rosaries.
Jaime Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 [quote name='curtins' post='1124734' date='Nov 20 2006, 08:29 PM'] I'm in a relationship with this girl (we're not dating) and I love her very much. Recently basically she has come into a dry period in her faith and prayer life etc (shes a catholic). Shes doubting some important church teachings, saying things like what matters is that you believe in God and all the world's religions could just in fact really be the true religion. When I try to tell her the importance of prayer, of the church, she said I'm being too preachy and trying to change her beliefs. We've gotten into some serious debates and I'll be the first to admit I have been preachy at times rather than understanding. She told me that during that time she saw the worst of me. My best freind gave me some wise words that that may not be the approach to take with her, rather instead letting God handle it, that He would not let his sheep stray far. BUT ITS FREAKIN HARD!!!! I've always been the one to obnoxiously and unceasingly defend the faith to the best of my ability and when people are in error try and correct them (isnt it in the Bible that its a loving thing to do to correct your brother's error?). So sitting on the sidelines and watching is really hard. I mean she just told me she hasnt been to confession in a long time and she doesn't like going and that God forgives her anyways. I've been praying for her and just either thought of or was inspired to just pray the rosary every night as possible for her. Is it right for me to be passive like this and pray and let God handle it? [/quote] First (and let's get this straight) there is nothing passive about prayer. Nothing Second of all, I understand you worries about your friend. But most of us go through periods in our life when we question our faith or go through a "dry spell". Thomas Merton (really smart guy) was a trappist monk. One time a brother monk came to him and confided that his faith felt dead. That he had no connection with God and doubted everything. Merton told him that faith is often like a rose. In the winter, when it appears dead, that is the time when its gaining its nutrients for spring. Questioning isn't a bad thing. Its when you quit looking for answers... that's when you get into trouble.
Balthazor Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 Yeah, besides right now she is at an age when all this is worse. I mean puberty can make even the most level headed a little crazy. Suddenly new questions arise, and that faith that you took for granted when you were little suddenly needs to be worked on and consoled with your intellect.
Sojourner Posted November 21, 2006 Posted November 21, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1125328' date='Nov 21 2006, 03:49 PM'] First (and let's get this straight) there is nothing passive about prayer. Nothing Second of all, I understand you worries about your friend. But most of us go through periods in our life when we question our faith or go through a "dry spell". Thomas Merton (really smart guy) was a trappist monk. One time a brother monk came to him and confided that his faith felt dead. That he had no connection with God and doubted everything. Merton told him that faith is often like a rose. In the winter, when it appears dead, that is the time when its gaining its nutrients for spring. Questioning isn't a bad thing. Its when you quit looking for answers... that's when you get into trouble. [/quote] I second all of this. In fact, I think I go through more dry spells than I do rainy seasons (is that the opposite of a dry spell? You get the point.). And prayer is huge, both praying yourself and being the intention of prayers by others. I think praying for someone is one of the most important things you can do as a friend.
curtins Posted November 21, 2006 Author Posted November 21, 2006 [quote name='Catholictothecore' post='1125193' date='Nov 21 2006, 02:48 PM'] I think every person around that age should be allowed to fall in love, under certain conditions. What I mean is, I think it's the natural age for the first time (in love), and while you can't "arrange" it, if it happen's, it should be figoursly encouraged...and controlled. I don't mean to sound preachy from here on, but I'm someone who knows where you coming from, even if I've never been in the same situation. (The one girlfriend I've ever had was, if anything, more Catholic than me.) But I know the pain. The seperation, the distance, feels like there a javlin stuck in your heart. And there's no promise, no forseeable futrue that it's ever...ever...going...to...end. You love her. Don't doubt that which you're smooching on Saturday night when you're so far away from her it feels like you're being torn in two. Don't. Just don't. God doesn't work that way. We all have lessons to learn. God doesn't want there to be pain, but it's the natural consequence to sin. Read in the Maccabees, when the family of seven brothers is being martyred. (By the way, think of that mother too. 7 was the symbol of completion. Her family was complete, and she saw them all butchered.) The family did not say they were being killed for their amazing amounts of faith. They were being allowed to suffer because they had all sinned. Again, I say, DO NOT DOUBT THAT YOU LOVE HER. I think it might help to almost think of yourself as her husband now. (WARNING! Let me explain.) Think of yourself as St. Joseph to her. Women are wired differently than us. They want us to be near them. To be someone that is there for them. Period. Be that for her. Swallow the pill, ask Jesus' help and drink the Cup to the dregs. Trust with every ounce of your strength that he will give you every grace you need to get through this. "Any one who asks believing they have recieved will not be denied." Perhaps it might be best to explain that you do in fact love her. You love her enough to just be there for her. You have my prayers. Peace be with you. Remember, DO NOT BE AFRAID! Alex [/quote] Thank you so much for that dude- and to the rest of the pham for their replies and support (just this one stood out at me). You guys are right- girls at this age are insane. One thing I don't have is patience and so God and how he works in mysterious ways can be making this a time for me to gain patience and trust in him. As for how far 'gone' she is its not super super drastic, to the point of denying God or Jesus or anything, but she I would say has serious questions and doubts about certain aspects of the faith. Heck she teaches 5th grade religious ed, which is more than I can say for myself, so shes certainly not down the path of no return (not that there is one). hot stuff ur right prayer is active. Thanks really a million again guys this is really uplifting and very helpful. pham = the shiz peace -curtins
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now