Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Protestant View Of Sharing Communion


Recommended Posts

Posted

This is written by a dear friend of mine. I believe he has posted here a handful of times last year, but nothing consistant. He is 3rd generation pastor and appears to be "catholic-friendly" but sees no reason to convert. Rather thinking he can change more people as a protestant. Anyway. The issue of communion came up in our christology class after a student asked me why I do not take communion at our chapel. Our teacher(*a patristics scholar who's wife is a phd catholic moral theologian) explained a lil bit but the class was very offended that they could not take communion at a catholic church. One of the better pastoral students wrote a short treatise, I was challenged to write a reply as the catholic student.

[quote] A short treatise on the effects of taking communion within a broken church, the possibility of ecumenism through communion, and our decision to participate.

By

B**** Z******

The question has been raised, “Should a person take communion1 inside of a church when taking communion is essentially verifying that particular church’s doctrine as being correct, when the doctrine of the church affirms disunity between Christian denominations?” This is a valid question as unity is an essential part of Christianity and necessary for the correct functioning of the members of the Church.

If we do not take communion because we don’t agree with the separation of the church, we finish by dividing the church even further than it was divided before we stopped taking communion. The decision to stop taking communion sets one apart from the church and introduces yet another schizm into a church that is riddled with canyon sized disagreements.

If you separate yourself from Christian Churches by not participating in communion, the next logical step is to separate yourself from the churches by not attending. Communion is widely accepted as being a very important (if not the most important) section of being a church. Jesus instituted communion in the Lord’s Supper2 and Christians from that time have verified communion as being an integral part of being a church. Abstaining from the church as a whole becomes the logical conclusion of separating one’s self from part of the doctrine, as you can not lend one iota of support to the church once you begin abstaining from elements of doctrine. The only way to stop from appearing to lend support to churches with wrong doctrine is to completely separate from all churches, thereby propogating disunity.

I propose that we do with communion the same as we do with our church attendance. We, as Christians, attend churches for two reasons: 1) to show that we belong to the religion called Christianity and the universal church, and 2) Because we deem church attendance to be an important and integral to the development of a Christian despite the shortcomings and imperfections that exist in the churches attended. If we do not separate from these disunified churches, why should we separate from the communion of those churches. Instead, as churches become more unified, the communion will become more unified, and all will be perfected and we shall not have to worry about this question. However, even within a broken church communion can be a good thing.

I shall use the illustration of our bodies. When human bodies were created, they were perfect. The bodies worked perfectly and all of our organs worked together in perfect harmony. However, after the fall of mankind, human bodies became imperfect and they did not work as well. They became fragmented and disunified. Cancer and other diseases became a problem as the body would attack itself. This is a clear picture of the condition that the church is in today. However, God allows us to use our bodies, despite the sickness caused by disunity of our parts. In fact, good frequently can result from the use of the fragmented bodies. The same is true of communion. At the inception of communion, it was perfect. Communion fostered unity and facilitated the body of Christ. When the church splintered, communion became imperfect and fragmented, but good can still arise from the use of broken communion, much like the use of our broken bodies.

Another illustration is that of the church. We would not say that the church is evil right now, we may say that it is broken and ineffectual, but it still belongs to God. As such, good still results even from the discord that pervades all denominations. If it is possible for good to result from an institution that God has set up, there is no reason to believe otherwise in regard to communion.

There is a flaw in many people’s thinking. People are very concerned about a society having the morals that they believe it should have, and they get ahead of themselves. People expect reform to happen immediately and are not ready to take the intermediate steps that are necessary for societies and large groups of people to change. People want immediate action, and if it doesn’t happen then they will separate themselves from the group in order to form a new group that fits their ideals. If we can’t accept the intermediate steps that lead to the goal, we will not be in a position to rejoin the group when the goal is reached. If we are attempting to foster unity, we can not separate from the group that we are attempting to lead to unity.

For this, I will use the example of slavery. While slavery was abolished throughout the union at the end of the Civil War, blacks were not considered equal until much later. There are several intermediate steps between the beginning of slavery and the acceptance of blacks as equals1. First, slavery had to be abolished. Second, the blacks needed their basic rights as granted them by the government2. Now, we have accepted blacks as leaders within society and they are seen to be within all aspects of society as equals to whites. The intermediate steps were necessary for society to take the next steps. There is no way that society could have proceeded directly from slavery to the acceptance of blacks as leaders in the community. The attitudes of the proceeding generation must have time to change, and only then can the next step toward the goal be taken.

A practical example: Martin Luther King Jr. did not separate himself from society because of the racism toward blacks, instead he actively participated in his culture for change. Martin Luther King Jr. could have sat back and said that he would not participate in any, or even some, of the activities of the imperfect culture and that he would rejoin the nation when it became perfect. If King would have done that, then his dream of abolishing racism may have been set back many years or it may not have been achieved at all. If we want to impact our imperfect church culture, we need to participate in it and not draw back. The taking of communion within a church allows us to have more influence within the church as we are viewed as more active members. We gain trust by participating in a church’s activities and if we abstain from communion it appears as if we disagree with the church on a fundamental level and it will be harder for use to gain trust and influence among the leaders and members within the church. The taking of a church’s communion makes it easier for us to aid a church in the quest toward unity.

Communion is a very powerful tool that can lead to unity between Christian denominations3. Separating from communion is separating from one of the essential pillars of Christendom and one of the most unifying symbols of the church. On the quest to unity, intermediate steps are necessary, as it takes time to change the mindset of a large group of people. It may take many generations to bring about unity within the church, but that is no reason to pull back from the church. If we hold back until the church is perfect, then there will never be unity.

Overview:
Reasons for taking communion despite doctrinal differences with regard to Christian unity:
1) The next logical step after abstaining from communion is to abstain from all other aspects of every church, which does not lend itself to growth of Christians, nor of unity.
2) Good can result out of broken communion, as in the case of the human body or the church.
3) Abstaining from communion leads to a loss of influence and an decreased ability to lead people and teach them about Christian unity.[/quote]

Posted

Here's how I would reply:

[quote]The question has been raised, “Should a person take communion1 inside of a church when taking communion is essentially verifying that particular church’s doctrine as being correct, when the doctrine of the church affirms disunity between Christian denominations?” This is a valid question as unity is an essential part of Christianity and necessary for the correct functioning of the members of the Church.[/quote]It's odd to me to describe doctrine as something that "affirms disunity." Just because I believe something that you do not believe, and I assert my belief to be the objective truth, that doesn't thereby mean that I affirm the fact that we disagree. I would rather us [b][i]both[/i][/b] hold to what is objectively true. It does not mean that I affirm out disunity just because I am unwilling to forsake what is objectively true.


[quote]If we do not take communion because we don’t agree with the separation of the church, we finish by dividing the church even further than it was divided before we stopped taking communion. The decision to stop taking communion sets one apart from the church and introduces yet another schizm into a church that is riddled with canyon sized disagreements.[/quote]I agree that when a Catholic decides not to receive Communion in a protestant church he is showing his state of separation with that church, but I don't think this act is one that "divides the church even further" or "introduces yet another schism." The separation is already present via the doctrinal differences that exist between the two groups. A lack of inter-Communion is just the logical result of that. Are they really asking you to pretend that you are in a state of communion with their church when you obviously are not?


[quote]If you separate yourself from Christian Churches by not participating in communion, the next logical step is to separate yourself from the churches by not attending. Communion is widely accepted as being a very important (if not the most important) section of being a church. Jesus instituted communion in the Lord’s Supper2 and Christians from that time have verified communion as being an integral part of being a church. Abstaining from the church as a whole becomes the logical conclusion of separating one’s self from part of the doctrine, as you can not lend one iota of support to the church once you begin abstaining from elements of doctrine. The only way to stop from appearing to lend support to churches with wrong doctrine is to completely separate from all churches, thereby propogating disunity.[/quote]I disagree. I think that it actually aids ecumenism for Christians from different theological backgrounds to share certain liturgical celebrations with each other. We can have a quasi-liturgy of the Word, where we read the Bible together and sing praise to God together. We can do this b/c it is not necessary for me to believe everything that the other Christians who are present believe in order to celebrate in these things. Any Christian can read the Bible. Any Christian can sing praise to God.

When we come together to do this, we emphasize the points in which we are one with each other.
--we all believe that the Bible is the Word of God
--we all believe that the reading of the Bible is edifying for Christians
--we all believe that God should be praised with song

But, receiving Communion together is a different type of celebration. The reasons he gave for you to participate in it are actually reasons for you not to. It is for the very reason that it is such a special act of communion and so integral to the Church that you are deciding not to participate with them. Reading the Bible and singing songs does not necessarily say, "we agree on all things." BUT, inter-Communion does. Specifically, it says that we agree on how we understand this very Communion we are sharing together. With your actions you are saying, "I agree with you that Jesus is only spiritually present in this Communion in which we partake." Reading the Bible doens't say that. Singing songs doesn't say that. Receiving Communion [b][i]does[/i][/b].


[quote]I propose that we do with communion the same as we do with our church attendance. We, as Christians, attend churches for two reasons: 1) to show that we belong to the religion called Christianity and the universal church, and 2) Because we deem church attendance to be an important and integral to the development of a Christian despite the shortcomings and imperfections that exist in the churches attended.[/quote]As a Catholic, these reasons for attending church are very revealing. No where did he mention, "For love of God, for His sake" or "For worship of the Lord." His reasons were for the sake of the Christian, for what he will receive from attending "church." This seems to be the typical Protestant mindset, but perhaps that it is a broad generalization.


[quote]If we do not separate from these disunified churches, why should we separate from the communion of those churches. Instead, as churches become more unified, the communion will become more unified, and all will be perfected and we shall not have to worry about this question. However, even within a broken church communion can be a good thing.[/quote]I disagree. Inter-Communion does not rectify our doctrinal differences, nor does it bridge the spiritual divine between Christians and non-Christians. Baptism is what makes one a member of the Body of Christ. Communion or Eucharist is not meant to make unity where there wasn't before. Instead, it is to strengthen unity that already exists.


[quote]I shall use the illustration of our bodies. When human bodies were created, they were perfect. The bodies worked perfectly and all of our organs worked together in perfect harmony. However, after the fall of mankind, human bodies became imperfect and they did not work as well. They became fragmented and disunified. Cancer and other diseases became a problem as the body would attack itself. This is a clear picture of the condition that the church is in today. However, God allows us to use our bodies, despite the sickness caused by disunity of our parts. In fact, good frequently can result from the use of the fragmented bodies. The same is true of communion. At the inception of communion, it was perfect. Communion fostered unity and facilitated the body of Christ. When the church splintered, communion became imperfect and fragmented, but good can still arise from the use of broken communion, much like the use of our broken bodies.[/quote]I don't really know what to say here, other than that his illustration was not very helpful for me. I still don't see how "broken communion" can be beneficial or bring about a more profound communion between churches that are separated. To me, inter-Communion among separate churches just brings about the outward appearance of communion without truly effecting anything.


[quote]Another illustration is that of the church. We would not say that the church is evil right now, we may say that it is broken and ineffectual, but it still belongs to God. As such, good still results even from the discord that pervades all denominations. If it is possible for good to result from an institution that God has set up, there is no reason to believe otherwise in regard to communion.[/quote]This is faulty logic. Just because good can come from different denominations working together, that doesn't mean that they should just do [b][i]everything[/i][/b] together.


[quote]There is a flaw in many people’s thinking. People are very concerned about a society having the morals that they believe it should have, and they get ahead of themselves. People expect reform to happen immediately and are not ready to take the intermediate steps that are necessary for societies and large groups of people to change. People want immediate action, and if it doesn’t happen then they will separate themselves from the group in order to form a new group that fits their ideals. If we can’t accept the intermediate steps that lead to the goal, we will not be in a position to rejoin the group when the goal is reached. If we are attempting to foster unity, we can not separate from the group that we are attempting to lead to unity.[/quote]This begs the question. It remains to be seen that inter-Communion is a legitimate "intermediate step" towards unity.


[quote]For this, I will use the example of slavery.[/quote]Protestants sure like their illustrations, huh :D:


[quote]While slavery was abolished throughout the union at the end of the Civil War, blacks were not considered equal until much later. There are several intermediate steps between the beginning of slavery and the acceptance of blacks as equals1. First, slavery had to be abolished. Second, the blacks needed their basic rights as granted them by the government2. Now, we have accepted blacks as leaders within society and they are seen to be within all aspects of society as equals to whites. The intermediate steps were necessary for society to take the next steps. There is no way that society could have proceeded directly from slavery to the acceptance of blacks as leaders in the community. The attitudes of the proceeding generation must have time to change, and only then can the next step toward the goal be taken. [/quote]Again, this begs the question.


[quote]A practical example: Martin Luther King Jr. did not separate himself from society because of the racism toward blacks, instead he actively participated in his culture for change. Martin Luther King Jr. could have sat back and said that he would not participate in any, or even some, of the activities of the imperfect culture and that he would rejoin the nation when it became perfect. If King would have done that, then his dream of abolishing racism may have been set back many years or it may not have been achieved at all. If we want to impact our imperfect church culture, we need to participate in it and not draw back.[/quote]That's why Catholics still participate in legitimate ecumenical services with other Christians. Also, you'll notice that he has contradicted himself now. Earlier he said that if you are not going to participate in inter-Communion then you shouldn't participate in any part of the worship service. But, here, he's saying that you shouldn't draw back, that you should in fact participate in those intermediate steps that aid in communion.

The difference of course lies in what we understand as a legitimate intermediate step:
--Reading the Bible, singing praise to God: legitimate step
--Inter-Communion: illegitimate step


[quote]The taking of communion within a church allows us to have more influence within the church as we are viewed as more active members. We gain trust by participating in a church’s activities and if we abstain from communion it appears as if we disagree with the church on a fundamental level and it will be harder for use to gain trust and influence among the leaders and members within the church. The taking of a church’s communion makes it easier for us to aid a church in the quest toward unity.[/quote]I disagree with the trust issue here. I think it would breed distrust. Imagine this: (here's my own little "illustration" ;) )[list]I am totally new to Christianity and to belief in Christ. I see that alot of people go into this oddly shaped building on Sunday so I want to go to and see what its all about. At the end of the service I see [b][i]everyone[/i][/b] go up and receive bread and wine from the pastor. Everyone seems to be taking this very seriously. By the demeanor of the people and the songs that are being sung I can tell that this is an important event. I am compelled to think to myself, "Man, the Christians on this college campus must be really unified. Look at how they all participate in this celebration together." I'm feeling pretty good about what I just saw, since I'm tired of seeing people fight all the time.

Later on, in one of my theology classes (I'm only taking it b/c my Christian college requires it, of course) I find out that some students believe this, and others believe that, and the professor has his own views, and they all seem to be picking on this one Catholic kid and I'm like, "Dang, what happened to all that unity I just saw. It must have all been a show. I don't know if I can trust these people anymore."
[/list]See what I mean? Inter-Communion does not foster trust in those who view it. It would just make them more inclined to distrust us.


[quote]Communion is a very powerful tool that can lead to unity between Christian denominations3. Separating from communion is separating from one of the essential pillars of Christendom and one of the most unifying symbols of the church. On the quest to unity, intermediate steps are necessary, as it takes time to change the mindset of a large group of people. It may take many generations to bring about unity within the church, but that is no reason to pull back from the church. If we hold back until the church is perfect, then there will never be unity.

Overview:
Reasons for taking communion despite doctrinal differences with regard to Christian unity:
1) The next logical step after abstaining from communion is to abstain from all other aspects of every church, which does not lend itself to growth of Christians, nor of unity.
2) Good can result out of broken communion, as in the case of the human body or the church.
3) Abstaining from communion leads to a loss of influence and an decreased ability to lead people and teach them about Christian unity.[/quote]I've pretty much already responded to all of this.

I hope that helps. Ecumenism is not my thing, so I may not have explained myself well, or supported my points very well. Actually, I usually just stay out of conversations like this b/c I feel like I don't have an informed opinion. But, your my dawg Rev, so I wanted to give it a shot.

Pax Christi,
phatcatholic

Posted

hey dude, check this out:
[url="http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=5151"]http://www.catholicculture.org/docs/doc_view.cfm?recnum=5151[/url]
[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/PCCUCOM1.HTM"]http://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/PCCUCOM1.HTM[/url]

Posted

sweeeeeeeeeet...

thanks Bro.

The issue is a passionate one for me. As I considered the reversion process I did not know that we could not share communion. It hurt deeply knowing that I could not share what is the sacred sign of unity.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...