Era Might Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 I get the impression that some non-Catholic visitors don't feel that we are being respectful and welcoming, particularly in the debate phorum. To get it out in the open, what do you think? Are we welcoming to others? Are we becoming too polemical and perhaps not returning kindness and patience to those who disagrees with us? I realize that trolls sometimes appear and we lose our patience, but are we writing people off as trolls because they disagree with us? Do we have a tendency to gang up on non-Catholics and argue (as opposed to discuss) with them without realizing it? Do we need to step back and reevaluate the tone of the debate phorum? All opinions are welcome.
prose Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 yes. I have to say I was pretty frustrated with how the new visitors are being responded to. I have youth group members that I suggest to come here, and they have heard many of the same "debate topics" that these people are bringing up. By demeaning them, the people that I send here are not learning anything. We need to ADDRESS questions or close the thread. Period. If someone posts 14 questions in one post, we need to close the thread, and open a new one with one thing to debate. Above all, we need to give answers in this forum , not sarcasm. Isn't the point of even having this forum for people to be able to learn? When is the last time you learned something through sarcasm? I want to just brush some of these people off too. And frankly, some of them deserve to be brushed off. In particular the ones who are just spouting anti-catholic nonsense without any debate. But we can't, and shouldn't write them all off. And we can't expect everyone that comes here to search through all the history of old threads when they want a "debate". It just wouldn't make sense to have this forum then. If the FBC was being treated like this, they would be offended and write off other forums, why should these people feel any differently? The debate forum needs to be moderated differently from other forums. Topics that are not being debated should be closed. Topics with multiple debate items should also be closed and told to reopen as one item at a time. That is my 2 cents. Do what you want with it.
Mary-Kathryn Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 (edited) There is a vast difference between a non-Catholic with questions/doubts and one who starts out with "Catholicism is such a joke!" That's asking for blood and it results in an all-out sour mood. Respect needs to go both ways at all times. One can say "I don't believe and here's why...why is it you believe..." There is no need for "You losers are going to hell for being statue-worshipping heathens" and then give 50 pages of cut and paste quotes and pictures. On the other hand, we don't need to do the troll patrol automatically. The rules of respectibility should be enforced on all sides. If non-Catholics come in and start a thread in an aggressive way, perhaps a moderator could talk to them, give an example of how to re-arrange the post and go from there. [Sometimes a person isn't used to forums or chatboards] If they refuse, then it's up to the mods. just my two...oh it's only lint in my pocket Edited November 22, 2006 by Mary-Kathryn
prose Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 That sounds right. If someone posts like that, a mod can kindly suggest to rephrase. But let's not just go off the deep end with freaking out.
Guest Rick777 Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 Heres an idea! While were rolling out the red carpet for them why don't we give them all welcome bags! Then those flaming heretics will feel right at home man! Yay!
dUSt Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 I don't believe respect needs to go both ways at all times. We cannot control how non-Catholics come in here and behave. I generally believe that respect needs to only come from [b]one side[/b]--the Catholic side. This is the line of thinking that I hope all phatmassers can embrace. I have told the mods that I am against banning or editing non-Catholics because of attacks against the church. I mean, that is why we're here. That's why phatmass exists--to [b]defend[/b] the church. How will we do that if we don't allow the attacks? Why should we not welcome these people and do everything we can for them to stay, only for them to go off and attack the church someplace else--someplace not as well equipped as phatmass to defend them? I have said this in the past, so let me repeat it. There is a double standard here at phatmass. I expect better behavior out of Catholics than I do non-Catholics. Non-Catholics will be able to bend the rules and get away with more things than Catholics. Don't like it? Then what does that say about you representing Christ's church? God bless.
prose Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 Good call putting this in Open Mic by the way. As for the "flaming hereitcs", the forum says [quote]Debate Table (interreligious dialogue) AKA: Super Happy Dialogue Corner. Non-Catholics are welcome and encouraged to come on in to discuss our differences. Please practice charity. Phorum guideline violations WILL result in suspension.[/quote] So they are welcome. Not much of am interreligious debate with only one religion. I hope that you don't ban me from Unphania for this disgreement ....
Balthazor Posted November 22, 2006 Posted November 22, 2006 I will try to do better at being welcoming to visitors at phatmass.
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 Some of the threads recently have brought the worst out in everybody.
Balthazor Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 YIKES@ I have seen the "quick question" thread on Debate. Man I have to say that I am not proud of a lot of the responses on there. I will take credit for my "pray for tact" on the molestor line. But wow, maybe tone it down a bit? I mean if even one of us loses it that colors visitors veiw of all Catholics.
goldenchild17 Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 (edited) I don't expect this to be addressed, but it's all good. I love ya guys anyways : . But, I understand the reasoning behind forbidding Catholic vs. Catholic debate. It is scandalous and allows for confusion among those who know no better. But why shouldn't Catholic vs. Catholic debate be defined as debate about doctrine between people who are considered orthodox Catholics? But why is it any different for a non-Catholic (in the eyes of Phatmass anyhow) to be not allowed to discuss things just because his primary source of argument is in Church documents? Is Scripture in any way inherently more, or less, authoritative than Church Tradition that makes it okay to debate Scripture, but not the other source of Divine Truth? If I am not considered Catholic, then why do my grievances fall under Catholic v. Catholic debate? If I am considered Catholic (and thus fall into the category of Catholic v. Catholic debate) then why do I have a phishy label? Isn't the very idea of the phishy label to point out who here is not Catholic and thus who is not always supporting Catholic teaching? If so, then why are such people not allowed to debate their issues. There should be no scandal as people should see the label and know that we are not holding orthodox positions. After seeing some of the craziness that has gone on in that forum as of late, I can't help but thing I would be much more calm and respectful than some of the non-Catholic posters have been... I'm done . Don't worry I'm not mad and I'm not leaving (sorry : ), and don't expect this to change. But since the thread existed, I figured I'd throw in a post before it got closed. Peace Edited November 23, 2006 by goldenchild17
Lil Red Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='1126247' date='Nov 22 2006, 02:34 PM']The debate forum needs to be moderated differently from other forums. Topics that are not being debated should be closed. Topics with multiple debate items should also be closed and told to reopen as one item at a time.[/quote] agreed
Mary-Kathryn Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 (edited) [quote name='dUSt' post='1126281' date='Nov 22 2006, 06:23 PM'] I have said this in the past, so let me repeat it. There is a double standard here at phatmass. I expect better behavior out of Catholics than I do non-Catholics. Non-Catholics will be able to bend the rules and get away with more things than Catholics. Don't like it? Then what does that say about you representing Christ's church? God bless. [/quote] I haven't been around long enough to have seen that [if I did, it didn't sink in].....I did not mean to contradict your rules in my post. I will fix that immediately! ~sorry, it won't let me edit again for some reason.~ Edited November 23, 2006 by Mary-Kathryn
Lil Red Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 you can only edit your own posts within a certain amount of time
cmotherofpirl Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 [quote name='dUSt' post='1126281' date='Nov 22 2006, 06:23 PM'] I don't believe respect needs to go both ways at all times. We cannot control how non-Catholics come in here and behave. I generally believe that respect needs to only come from [b]one side[/b]--the Catholic side. This is the line of thinking that I hope all phatmassers can embrace. I have told the mods that I am against banning or editing non-Catholics because of attacks against the church. I mean, that is why we're here. That's why phatmass exists--to [b]defend[/b] the church. How will we do that if we don't allow the attacks? Why should we not welcome these people and do everything we can for them to stay, only for them to go off and attack the church someplace else--someplace not as well equipped as phatmass to defend them? I have said this in the past, so let me repeat it. There is a double standard here at phatmass. I expect better behavior out of Catholics than I do non-Catholics. Non-Catholics will be able to bend the rules and get away with more things than Catholics. Don't like it? Then what does that say about you representing Christ's church? God bless. [/quote] Sorry, but I disagree. There has to be a minimum standard of good behavior for everyone. You would not tolerate anybody walking into your house and spitting into your wife's face, and the catholics who call this place home should not have to tolerate it either. A lot of people call this place home, but when the neighborhood gets filled with hoodlums and the authorities do nothing, then people move out.
dUSt Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1126478' date='Nov 22 2006, 09:48 PM'] Sorry, but I disagree. There has to be a minimum standard of good behavior for everyone. You would not tolerate anybody walking into your house and spitting into your wife's face, and the catholics who call this place home should not have to tolerate it either. A lot of people call this place home, but when the neighborhood gets filled with hoodlums and the authorities do nothing, then people move out. [/quote] But this should not be the green light to act uncharitable and disrespectful. Of course, I agree that there should a standard of good behavior. All that I am saying is that phatmassers are held to a higher standard. If I'm at a park, I'm not going to discipline every little brat running around--but let it be [b]my[/b] kid that is acting a fool? Uh uh. Nope.
cmotherofpirl Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 [quote name='dUSt' post='1126489' date='Nov 22 2006, 11:00 PM'] But this should not be the green light to act uncharitable and disrespectful. Of course, I agree that there should a standard of good behavior. All that I am saying is that phatmassers are held to a higher standard. If I'm at a park, I'm not going to discipline every little brat running around--but let it be [b]my[/b] kid that is acting a fool? Uh uh. Nope. [/quote] : So if someone shows up and starts with disrespecting Catholicism from the start, can we tell them to re-phrase or close the thread?
dUSt Posted November 23, 2006 Posted November 23, 2006 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1126497' date='Nov 22 2006, 10:23 PM'] : So if someone shows up and starts with disrespecting Catholicism from the start, can we tell them to re-phrase or close the thread? [/quote] I'd prefer that the falsities are addressed in a charitable manner. If the poster is in violation of a phorum guideline, issue a warning. I don't like closing threads.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now