heyyoimjohnny Posted November 24, 2006 Posted November 24, 2006 My family has been talking 'bout this, looking at the different sides of it, and I'm confused about it myself. Can lying be justified? A objective moral evil justified by conditions? For example, those who hid Jews and those persecuted by the Nazi regime and lied to keep them safe. Would lying to the Nazis be justified? Is it OK to lie so as to save someone from death, especially a completely unjust death? Also, a similar situation. Would a father whose family is starving be justified in stealing food, even though stealing is objectively wrong? Would doing evil be the morally right thing to do in either of these cases? I'm sure this has been visited and re-visited a million times, but please, enlighten us! Thanks, God bless!
heyyoimjohnny Posted November 24, 2006 Author Posted November 24, 2006 K, just a thought... would the principle of double-effect apply here, especially in the case of lying to save innocent life, where the intent isn't primarily to deceive but to save life?
jswranch Posted November 24, 2006 Posted November 24, 2006 Someone remind me of the name of the German saint. She would take food from her wealthy castle against the will of the father to give to the poor. Her father sent some of his assistants to catch her daughter handing out the food in town. When they found her, they asked what was in her basket. She replied, "flowers." They opened it, and the food had transformed. Was she lying?
karin Posted November 24, 2006 Posted November 24, 2006 I am not sure about lying, but I do know that the stealing food for your starving family is justified and is not a sin. I have asked my priest about it before. As long as you dont take anything that is unneccesary and you dont hurt anyone in the process. If you have no other choice , but to steal it or your family will die then it is not considered a sin. I am not 100 % on the lying thing or I would say something. God Bless and Mary keep
p-hawk Posted November 26, 2006 Posted November 26, 2006 [quote name='heyyoimjohnny' post='1126863' date='Nov 23 2006, 08:38 PM'] My family has been talking 'bout this, looking at the different sides of it, and I'm confused about it myself. Can lying be justified? A objective moral evil justified by conditions? [/quote] Testifying against the Truth, especially since He is Jesus, is never justified. [quote] For example, those who hid Jews and those persecuted by the Nazi regime and lied to keep them safe. Would lying to the Nazis be justified? Is it OK to lie so as to save someone from death, especially a completely unjust death? [/quote] The trick in this situation is to tell the Nazis truths that don't give them the information they're looking for, [i]because they have no right to that information[/i]. They shouldn't be told where Jews are, since in a sense you would become complicit in someone's torture and exploitation. Rhetorical questions are great in these situations. "Do you have any Jews here?" "Why would I have any Jews? How dare you question my love of the fuhrer!" IIRC, the lady hiding Corrie Ten-Boom had so much faith that God would protect the Jews she was hiding that when the Nazis came a'knockin', she answered, "Oh, they're behind this false wall". They all came through the war alive, by the grace of God. I still think that risks complicity with torture and exploitation, so I wouldn't have tried it myself. [quote] Also, a similar situation. Would a father whose family is starving be justified in stealing food, even though stealing is objectively wrong? Would doing evil be the morally right thing to do in either of these cases? [/quote] To make myself perfectly clear: doing evil is never morally justified. If evil is a privation of a due good, why would one think depriving God of the good owed Him a morally permissible act? [quote name='karin' post='1127002' date='Nov 24 2006, 11:41 AM'] I am not sure about lying, but I do know that the stealing food for your starving family is justified and is not a sin. I have asked my priest about it before. As long as you dont take anything that is unneccesary and you dont hurt anyone in the process. If you have no other choice , but to steal it or your family will die then it is not considered a sin. I am not 100 % on the lying thing or I would say something. God Bless and Mary keep [/quote] Stealing food for your starving family isn't actually stealing; it means that there is an unequal and unjust distribution of basic necessities that needs to be righted, and "stealing" is the only viable method of achieving that goal. If someone has excess food and doesn't give it to you, then you are correcting this injustice by "stealing" it.
phatcatholic Posted November 27, 2006 Posted November 27, 2006 [quote name='heyyoimjohnny' post='1126876' date='Nov 23 2006, 09:11 PM'] K, just a thought... would the principle of double-effect apply here, especially in the case of lying to save innocent life, where the intent isn't primarily to deceive but to save life? [/quote] yes, i think that it would
stuckinamo Posted November 28, 2006 Posted November 28, 2006 we have talked about this at DTS once or twice. while i have a hard time understanding it at times, the general concensus with which we came to was that a lie is a lie and should never be justified because someone can be hurt by it and usually is. Ex: you lie to a friend. -How is my new hair cut? -you lie, "Oh, it's...awesome!" -Gee thanks!! The person later finds out that you didn't really like it and that they look bad in it. It ends up hurting someone, which sin always does. When we sin (lying included!) we damage the entire body of Christ. I suppose, however, that there are different levels of gravity upon which a lie might fall for sin. Like...lying to your friend saying her hair looks great or you know lying that like i dono you're saying you didn't kill someone when really you did. Maybe I'm not making sense and I'm totally wrong...but this is what I have understood of it. In regard to the Jews & Nazis and people lying, what we learned is that though the death was unjust for the person, God very well could have willed that to be the death of that person. The reasoning is that thta would be the death that would best aid him in his Salvation. If that makes sense to you? Like -- that was the death that God had chosen that would help the person to have a better chance at making it to Heaven. Anywho. I could be wrong! But that's just what we have discussed at DTS before!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now