Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Could not get a response in Q & A, so I am cross posting this here. She is getting pretty stressed out over it, so could someone in the know please give their opinion?

Thanks :)


[i]I have a friends situation in which I would like a opinion on.

Women A has a "female medical problem". (Very bad hormonal imbalance also known as PCOS) The problem is currently treated with hormones that do not prevent pregnancy and was approved by a priest.
Said medical problem has gone to the point in which treatment no longer works and is seriously affecting her life.

There are two treatment options-

1) Is stronger hormones that will cause serious side effects, eg high blood pressure and will prevent pregnancy.

2) Is hysterectomy.

The women is sterile due to the medical problem in the first place and the longer she is on hormones the higher the risk of cancer and other problems.

In the churches eyes where would she stand?
I have advised her to see her priest, but she does come here and has asked me to ask for her.

Thank you on her behalf.[/i]

Thanks everyone,
Belinda

Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1127374' date='Nov 25 2006, 05:05 AM']
Could not get a response in Q & A, so I am cross posting this here. She is getting pretty stressed out over it, so could someone in the know please give their opinion?

[/quote]
I think the reason you have had trouble getting responses is because this is one of those areas where, if I were a professional Catholic ethicist, which I'm not, I'd still need many more details before I could even begin to attempt an informed decision. Your advice to see a priest, especially if there is a good one you feel comfortable recommending, is the best bet. And put a message on the prayer board so we bug God with so many prayers that He comes to the point of healing this malady, much less give her light on the best course of action.

Posted

Well, your advice was right, she really does need to talk to her priest about this. But if you want an opinion, here you go...

AFAIK, taking neither one of those courses of action is disallowed, when undertaken for health reasons. If she's sterile, and the hormones are dangerous, I don't see any moral reason to not get the hysterectomy.

Prayers for your friend. Sounds awful. :ohno:

Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1127716' date='Nov 25 2006, 09:31 PM']
Well, your advice was right, she really does need to talk to her priest about this. But if you want an opinion, here you go...

AFAIK, taking neither one of those courses of action is disallowed, when undertaken for health reasons. If she's sterile, and the hormones are dangerous, I don't see any moral reason to not get the hysterectomy.

Prayers for your friend. Sounds awful. :ohno:
[/quote]
For what it's worth, that's what I was thinking; but I'd want to be more certain of the medical facts before offering that advice.

Posted
:) Thanks a lot.

She is still freaking out a lot, but as she is 18 and has had it only for three years, its early days for her yet. At her age the doctors are unlikely to go all the way......unlike my case....I have it also. :blush: , but have had it longer and have it worse than her, and now in the same boat as her.

My hormone treatment stopped working and I cannot take the alternative treatment as it raises my blood pressure to dangerous levels.

But unlike her I am off later this coming week to see my Parish Priest.

The full name of the condition is Poly Cystic Ovary Syndrome.
It causes infertility, "female problems of the WORST KIND", [i]and for the sake of the kids here I will leave out the detail.[/i] And a number of other associated problems that need not be gone into. But lets just say it turns your life up side down.

So thank you again for giving your answers :) , you have put my mind to rest.

Bless you,
Belinda
Posted

PCOS [i] can[/i] be treated. It does not always cause infertility. I have experience with it, and my best friend suffers from it quite severely.

I would HIGHLY discourage a hysterectomy. And I would suggest seeing another doctor too. Second opinions are very important in matters of life. There are many other options with this disease. I am shocked that her doctor even suggested that as a first course of action after the pill!!

laproscopy and ovarian drilling, along with laser cervical treatment is one option, but there are more.

Ethically, I am not an expert, but I sure can tell you that you should tell your friend to get a second opinion!

Oh, one more thing, another very close friend of mine suffered from PCOS AND endrometriosis. She had all those problems too. She got married, and was pregnant almost right away. Every doctor told her she would never have children. She now has 2 sons, and the endometriosis seems to have gone away with the second birth.

Posted

Hi,

The treatments you mentioned are usually given to those who wish to marry and have children and are used in the Australian context for that purpose and are not available to either my friend or myself.

In both of our cases we are looking to enter into religious life and from the medical sense at least in my case the better course is to stop it "forever".

I have been referred to the local hospital for an assessment and will see what they say.

Thank you,
Belinda

Posted

You mean that the health system won't really consider other treatments if you're heading into the religious life? That sounds absurd. I would hesitate before doing something as drastic as a hysterectomy, unless it were the only option left; and it sound's like there is at least one or two options left.

Posted

[quote name='p-hawk' post='1128358' date='Nov 26 2006, 07:15 PM']
You mean that the health system won't really consider other treatments if you're heading into the religious life? That sounds absurd. I would hesitate before doing something as drastic as a hysterectomy, unless it were the only option left; and it sound's like there is at least one or two options left.
[/quote]
I suspect the issue is more that a hysterectomy is easy and inexpensive, while more sophisticated therapies are reserved for people who are [i]trying[/i] to have children.

I believe Catholic moral considerations of hormone treatments or hysterectomies only come into play if you're married and sexually active. If you're celibate, the possible contraceptive effects don't matter.

Posted

just remember that hysteroctomies have their OWN side effects that lead to problems later in life, so i think that a second opinion is really the best bet

Posted

[quote name='philothea' post='1128497' date='Nov 26 2006, 09:49 PM']
I suspect the issue is more that a hysterectomy is easy and inexpensive, while more sophisticated therapies are reserved for people who are [i]trying[/i] to have children.

I believe Catholic moral considerations of hormone treatments or hysterectomies only come into play if you're married and sexually active. If you're celibate, the possible contraceptive effects don't matter.
[/quote]
True, but neither of these two are actually in religious life yet, so it's a bit early to reject those considerations outright.

Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1128546' date='Nov 26 2006, 09:15 PM']
just remember that hysteroctomies have their OWN side effects that lead to problems later in life, so i think that a second opinion is really the best bet
[/quote]

I agree... such a big decision could have big side effects even if you don't plan on having children.

Posted

[quote name='kateri05' post='1128546' date='Nov 26 2006, 08:15 PM']
just remember that hysteroctomies have their OWN side effects that lead to problems later in life, so i think that a second opinion is really the best bet
[/quote]

Yes, I wasn't saying to get a second opinion just because of the child factor. Hysterectomies are hard on your body. Very hard. Just do a Google search about the side effects.

Posted

someone send a pm to laudate_dominum about this. he's ur man as far as theology of the body and sexual ethics are concerned.

Posted

I'm gonna pray heaps for you and your friend :sign: and I'm sure our Father [the best physician around] will lead you both to an answer :)

femme_du_noel
Posted

PCOS is highly treatable. I'd recommend seeking an NFP-only doctor for a second or third opinion. It is very likely that a hysterectomy is not her only (or best) option. [url="http://www.omsoul.com"]http://www.omsoul.com[/url] has a list of NFP-only doctors.

--Jessica

Posted

[quote name='femme_du_noel' post='1130563' date='Nov 29 2006, 05:40 PM']
PCOS is highly treatable. I'd recommend seeking an NFP-only doctor for a second or third opinion. It is very likely that a hysterectomy is not her only (or best) option. [url="http://www.omsoul.com"]http://www.omsoul.com[/url] has a list of NFP-only doctors.

--Jessica
[/quote]

Thank you, but as I live in Australia and the not the USA the site is not helpful for me but maybe for others. :)

femme_du_noel
Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1130571' date='Nov 29 2006, 02:07 AM']
Thank you, but as I live in Australia and the not the USA the site is not helpful for me but maybe for others. :)
[/quote]

Then the Billings folks may be of some help. [url="http://www.woomb.org/"]http://www.woomb.org/[/url] They could likely provide a local reference.

Posted

Just posting an update-

Both of us have been to our :priest: :)

In "Kelly's" case she has been told that as her call is untested and as she has had the condition for such a short time she needs to look at other options before hysterectomy would be considered.

In my case my PP is in favour of it (he knows about some stuff I won't put on a public forum) and is behind me 100%.

Thank you all so much.

You ROCK Pham :D:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...