Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I read [i]Wild at Heart[/i] (author's name escapes me) a few years back. I remember thinking that it was mostly good, but there were a few things that just didn't seem to jibe with Catholic theology. My memory is really fuzzy as to why, though. I recently saw a different book by the same author on the shelf of the local Catholic bookstore, and I caught myself wondering just how off-base is it? If it is? I heard it's been pretty popular at Steubenville, but that's just an unsubstantiated rumor.

Posted

I read the whole series as a protestant. So i do not remember what would be considered non-catholic. The book is devotional in nature. (*protestant devotional concept, not catholic..nothing wrong, just different)

The Author. A John Eldridge (spelling might be off) is a passionate protestant that has the angle of basically "shaking" men out of the zombie-like life we are in. He quotes movies alot and relates very well.

As an author I need to let it be known that he is a staunch open theist, he does not use his theology in his writing, but sometimes it is obvious in his worldview.

oh, and his wife is not a good author to read. Almost emotionally abusive. but dont let that reflect on him.

Posted

I remember not being particularly impressed with it, and there are a few quirks that I really didn't like (mostly towards the beginning), but found that after that most of it was pretty decent. That said, I'm pretty fuzzy on what it was, but I think it had something to do w/ a misunderstanding of celibacy on the author's part.

Posted

It has been referred to me by several Catholic Youth Ministry Coordinators, so I am guessing it is probably sound.

I haven't read it yet though.

Posted (edited)

It is an enjoyable read. He had great advice that seemed to strike the core of my heart. Protestant in certain views yes, however not all is lost.

Edited by GloriaIesusChristi
Posted

[quote name='GloriaIesusChristi' post='1128714' date='Nov 26 2006, 11:45 PM']
Protestant in certain views yes, however not all is lost.
[/quote]


thats protestantism as a whole..

Posted

In the beginning of the book, he claims that males are wild because they were created in the wilderness. This is false according to any Catholic Bible I have. (I didn't check the prot Bibles, cause frankly, I don't care right now).


Adam was created out of the dirt on the sixth day in the first creation account, and Eve was created on the same day. In the same place. According to Eldredge, they were created in two entirely different environments. Wrong. Look up Genesis 1.

In the second accout, Adam was created before anything else was created. He was literally born in the middle of nowhere. :D:

I also took issue with some of the absolutist comments he made about males. For example, he seems to think it's impossible for any guy not to be in love with guns. I literally think he would call me unmasculine because I have never had even a slight inclination towards toy guns or stuff like that. I just don't give a care.

There were a bunch of things that he said that seemed to miss the point of creating us male and female.

Posted (edited)

I read Wild at Heart a couple of months ago, and it really put a lot of things into perspective for me. Not life changing or anything, but it definantly called me into deeper holiness.

One of his main points is that there aren't enough Christen men, who actually act like men. Not in the sterotypical sense, but guys who embrace masculinity in it's true sense. I would recommend it.

Edited by Once Was Lost
Mary's servant
Posted

AMDG+JMJ
I haven't read it, but my best friend loves his wife's stuff. She has mostly focused on his wife's work, but she likes him too. Some of her other friends have recommended him too. They are Protestants though. My best friend is pretty close to believing most Catholic theology, whether she realizes it or not.

Posted

There is a lot to like about the book, too.

Posted (edited)

I've probably bought Wild at Heart half a dozen times because I'm constantly giving it away. I think it's a great book. Not perfect, not immune to any criticism, but very very good.

Interestingly, some of the best responses have come from women to whom I've given the book, who find his vision of sexual complimentarity dead-on.

I was extremely disappointed with "Waking the Dead", and it has some very problematic positions. He really went off the deep end at some point. Nevertheless, "Wild at Heart" is safe even for impressionable Catholics. Check it out.

Edited by beatty07
LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1128921' date='Nov 27 2006, 01:16 PM']
In the beginning of the book, he claims that males are wild because they were created in the wilderness. This is false according to any Catholic Bible I have. (I didn't check the prot Bibles, cause frankly, I don't care right now).
Adam was created out of the dirt on the sixth day in the first creation account, and Eve was created on the same day. In the same place. According to Eldredge, they were created in two entirely different environments. Wrong. Look up Genesis 1.

In the second accout, Adam was created before anything else was created. He was literally born in the middle of nowhere. :D:
[/quote]

A bit off topic, but are there any significant translation differences between Catholic and Protestant Bibles? Perhaps John 6, but I can't imagine why Genesis would be any different. I think some of you phatmassers a little to skittish about Protestant things... they are Christians too ;-)

I'm not sure how Adam being created from dirt refutes Eldredge's point? Although he was created in a garden, I think his point may have been that it was the natural environment created by God, in contrast to the tame, artificial, man-made environments of our homes and offices. Something inside the heart of men (or most men, anyway) just isn't at home in these places... and then from there you get the rest of the book.

In the second account, you could say "the middle of nowhere" is the definition of wilderness. :)

"Wild at Heart" is definitely my favorite devotional book. I've never liked devotional stuff... it's so boring. I've read some stuff from Joel Osteen or whoever that others find so insightful and I just don't see what the big deal is. But somehow Eldredge holds my interest, even though "Waking the Dead" and "Epic" repeated a lot of the same themes with just a change of focus from his first book. I very much identified with the thesis of curing the boredom of men in our church culture. During college I was always bored and I think a lot of guys feel the same way (probably girls too, but I haven't figured them out yet so I won't speak for them :) ). I remember asking God why life is so boring. So "Wild at Heart" spoke directly to my situation and offered a lot of insight... I read it two or three times.

On a side not, in "Wild at Heart," I think Eldredge gets about as close as any Protestant to a sexual theology that agrees with Catholicism. He gets into this thing about the man pouring himself out for his bride. There's nothing blatant... I had to re-read to make sure I had just read a whole page about sex :) And being Catholic now and understanding more about the Church's teaching on sexual ethics (not to mention Eucharistic theology), I'd like to go back and read that again. It might serve as a good reference to help Protestants understand where we're coming from.

All that said, I understand the criticisms, but I think the controversy is another reason I like Eldredge. He's one devotional author who does what Joel Osteen won't: start a controversy :)

photosynthesis
Posted

I've never read "Wild at Heart" but if you want to read about authentic masculenity & femininity with more of a Catholic perspective, read the works of Alice & Dietrich von Hildebrand. I particularly recommend "The Privilege of Being a Woman"

Posted

[quote]A bit off topic, but are there any significant translation differences between Catholic and Protestant Bibles? Perhaps John 6, but I can't imagine why Genesis would be any different. I think some of you phatmassers a little to skittish about Protestant things... they are Christians too ;-) [/quote]

--I do not believe so. I have an undergrad in Protestant Biblical theology. There are HUGE differences in hermenutics. I own an American Standard version, Darby Version, King James Version with Apocrypha, New American Standard, New International Reader, New Revised Standard Version, Amplified, Holy Bible King James, Holy Bible New International Version. As well as the Hebraica Stuttgartensia and United Bible Society Greek. On the Catholic side I own the RSV-CE and NAB. I think the NIV might have some minor changes, but nothing major in doctrine, but a word here or there.

[quote]I'm not sure how Adam being created from dirt refutes Eldredge's point? Although he was created in a garden, I think his point may have been that it was the natural environment created by God, in contrast to the tame, artificial, man-made environments of our homes and offices. Something inside the heart of men (or most men, anyway) just isn't at home in these places... and then from there you get the rest of the book. [/quote]

As someone who has read all of Eldredge's books, as well as lead a study group in it I think you are being legalistic here. Eldredge is not a theologian, he is a counciler. He quotes Braveheart...doesnt mean he thinks Jesus painted his face book. DO NOT read his writing as a theological book. Read it for devotional insight. Writers like Eldredge and Luciado have a good heart in this regard, but neither is trying to be a theologian


[quote]"Wild at Heart" is definitely my favorite devotional book. I've never liked devotional stuff... it's so boring. I've read some stuff from Joel Osteen or whoever that others find so insightful and I just don't see what the big deal is. But somehow Eldredge holds my interest, even though "Waking the Dead" and "Epic" repeated a lot of the same themes with just a change of focus from his first book. I very much identified with the thesis of curing the boredom of men in our church culture. During college I was always bored and I think a lot of guys feel the same way (probably girls too, but I haven't figured them out yet so I won't speak for them :) ). I remember asking God why life is so boring. So "Wild at Heart" spoke directly to my situation and offered a lot of insight... I read it two or three times. [/quote]

Joel Osteen is a joke, and is becoming a cancer in the baptist community. I liked waking the dead. It was something I was able to teach well from. I think our culture creates a situation where men can not strive, can not be in an adventure. They go to work, helping someone else's dream. Then go home and play X-box.

kind of embarassing, but on the side I work on my own biz.(check my profile, or myspace) I do some motivational speaking and mentorship and a major part of my focus is waking men and couples from the lifeless existence we have in the american culture. Now, I might not agree with some of Eldredge's believes, but the man has a vision and I respect it.

[quote]On a side not, in "Wild at Heart," I think Eldredge gets about as close as any Protestant to a sexual theology that agrees with Catholicism. He gets into this thing about the man pouring himself out for his bride. There's nothing blatant... I had to re-read to make sure I had just read a whole page about sex :) And being Catholic now and understanding more about the Church's teaching on sexual ethics (not to mention Eucharistic theology), I'd like to go back and read that again. It might serve as a good reference to help Protestants understand where we're coming from.
All that said, I understand the criticisms, but I think the controversy is another reason I like Eldredge. He's one devotional author who does what Joel Osteen won't: start a controversy :)[/quote]

Yes, this was a wild debate at my school..but I enjoyed this portion

Posted

I seem to recall a small mention in the book which talked about contraception as if it were accpeted, but it didn't go into any depth or detail.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1132008' date='Nov 30 2006, 03:10 PM']
Yes, this was a wild debate at my school..but I enjoyed this portion
[/quote]

What exactly are they debating?

[quote name='Matty_boy' post='1132279' date='Nov 30 2006, 07:14 PM']
I seem to recall a small mention in the book which talked about contraception as if it were accpeted, but it didn't go into any depth or detail.
[/quote]

I imagine Eldredge sees no problem with contraception, but maybe he hasn't yet taken his line of thinking to its natural conclusion. I need to get a copy of that book again so I can read that section and see if, in fact, there's anything to be drawn from it. I traded my copy with a friend for Eusebius: History of the Church :)

Posted

sexual ethics...birth control...good stuff,

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...