Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Self-denying The Eucharist


Recommended Posts

Posted

Right now I see myself possibly in conflict with a church teaching. There is an issue of conflict that is strong and I am trying in all honesty to work on. But I am not in clear submission on this issue, thus not clear communion.

I am also finding myself bouncing back and forth from my evangelical background and my newfound catholic aspects of my faith. Different life situations are putting a lot of preasure on this situation.

So what do I do. I feel that I should not be partaking in the Eucharist I am not in clear conscience communion. I cherish the sacraments as one of the primary reasons for my conversion. In discrediting the union I feel I would be doing the same harm a standard protestant would be doing.

any thoughts would be great...just please dont mock like it is common on the debate board.

Posted

St Clare had great devotion to the Sacrament of the Eucharist.
During her times there was an attitude of personal unworthiness and sinfulness which discouraged people from frequent reception of the Eucharist. Contrary to this practice, Clare encouraged her sisters to receive Eucharist frequently, indicating accessibility of the Eucharist as a desirable experience for herself and her sisters.

She approached the sacrament in trembling and upon receiving the Body of Our Lord shed tears. She reverenced Him who was hiding in the sacrament no less than Him Who was ruling heaven and earth.

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1127914' date='Nov 26 2006, 04:29 AM']
Right now I see myself possibly in conflict with a church teaching. There is an issue of conflict that is strong and I am trying in all honesty to work on. But I am not in clear submission on this issue, thus not clear communion.

I am also finding myself bouncing back and forth from my evangelical background and my newfound catholic aspects of my faith. Different life situations are putting a lot of preasure on this situation.

So what do I do. I feel that I should not be partaking in the Eucharist I am not in clear conscience communion. I cherish the sacraments as one of the primary reasons for my conversion. In discrediting the union I feel I would be doing the same harm a standard protestant would be doing.

any thoughts would be great...just please dont mock like it is common on the debate board.
[/quote]
I'm slightly confused by your question. Are thinking of refraining from the Eucharist because you aren't quite there on a particular dogma of the Church? Or because you feel personally unworthy? Or because you have committed a grave sin? If you've committed a grave sin, go to confession and then start receiving again, of course. And if you're feeling unworthy, but are not conscious of any grave sin after your last confession, by all means receive. If you're not quite there on a particular dogma of the Church, well, I'd hesitate to abandon the grace of the sacrament when trying to sort something like that out. If you're going back and forth on an issue, then I'd [i]generally[/i] and [i]not necessarily in all cases[/i] recommend sticking with it while you work on the issue. If you're firmly convinced that a dogma of the Church is wrong, then I'd politely ask you to stop receiving until your position on the dogma changed.

I must say, though, it shows great diligence and humility to even broach this topic. I know many Catholics who, from appearances anyway, receive communion without giving a thought to whatever serious sins they may have (or may be) committing. You are to be commended.

Posted

Having just read the openness thread; if that is the topic you are worried about, you are certainly striving to gain a Catholic understanding. I see no need in that case to avoid the Eucharist.

Another quick thought: Christ may be asking you to accept the Catholic position on this issue without fully understanding it. That doesn't mean you shouldn't try to understand it, but that you can still accept what you don't understand by accepting that it is the teaching of Christ and His Church.

Posted

[quote name='p-hawk' post='1127958' date='Nov 26 2006, 11:18 AM']
Having just read the openness thread; if that is the topic you are worried about, you are certainly striving to gain a Catholic understanding. I see no need in that case to avoid the Eucharist.

Another quick thought: Christ may be asking you to accept the Catholic position on this issue without fully understanding it. That doesn't mean you shouldn't try to understand it, but that you can still accept what you don't understand by accepting that it is the teaching of Christ and His Church.
[/quote]
AMEN on all counts.

Posted

Understanding white as black your whole life it is hard to imagine white in a context as completely different than black. No matter what words or wisdom will be used part of you has been developed to see black in it. You can desire to see white, agonize about it, but what do you do if you still see black? What if the logic doesnt just "not" make sense, but to the point that blind submission seems repressing.

/rant

Posted

Why not discuss privately what's troubling you with one of the really smart people on this forum? If it's a doctrinal concern, or theology, you can go to one of the priests or Raphael. Do you have a Catholic spiritual director? Being a Catholic in a Protestant theology program is tuff. You need strong support and an ear for your struggles.

--------------------------------------
Blessed Father Damien, pray for us!

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Katholikos' post='1129422' date='Nov 27 2006, 11:10 PM']
If it's a doctrinal concern, or theology, you can go to one of the priests or Raphael.
[/quote]
:ninja: Why am I being singled out? I know my theology, but there are others who know it better. I hardly even do my homework.

Posted

squeeky wheel?

Thanks for the concern btw..the theology is being talked out on various other threads. (*TWT is a new four letter word)

Posted

Ok, so based on the view of my Phriends here. Even if someone is consciously objecting to a church teaching they are still encouraged to take part in communion? Why cant protestants than?

Posted

I was told once that if I've examined my conscience thoroughly and am not sure whether what I did was mortal (and I have no chance to get to Confession), I should still take Communion and then hit up the Confessional when I can get there. The Grace received could very well help resolve the problem.

Course, I could be in error, but I presume one has practically scoured their conscience...

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1131309' date='Nov 29 2006, 08:06 PM']
Ok, so based on the view of my Phriends here. Even if someone is consciously objecting to a church teaching they are still encouraged to take part in communion? Why cant protestants than?
[/quote]
We never said that. If you are consciously objecting to a church teaching, then you shouldn't receive the Eucharist. However, if you want to have the same mind as the Church, but you are struggling with how to understand what she believes, or with how to accept it, then you can receive. In your heart, you are still trying as hard as you can to be in union with the Church, its just hard for you right now. No one said it would always be easy.

Posted

I luv ya 2 bro...

yea, it isnt a matter of sin, as much as a matter of disunity. like I said, black to white

  • 2 months later...
Posted

yea, I am really struggling with this again. I was thinking about going to confession tonight and to mass. But I feel disrespectful. I dont feel like I am approaching in full submission. Then little things creep in like not liking the modern feel of the mass here in town.

i dunno...tension smells of elderberries

Posted

Rev,

This is really something that you have to discuss with a Priest who you can confide in with specifics. I think it may be prudent to abstain from the Eucharist if you really feel that you cannot assent to the teaching of the Church. But, it's hard to say what you should do, because we don't know what you are struggling with, how you are struggling with it, and so on. It may be pride, it may be doubt, it may be temptation against faith. Talk to a Priest, I think that's the best advice.

Posted

The best priest I knew told me I didnt have an issue.

Let me get this straight...if I cannot assent to the teaching of the church then it is better for me to obstain from communion? thats kinda what I was worried about

Posted

ok, I counciled with a few friends in the faith with various opinions on this. I decided to spend this time in prayer instead of attending mass tonight. Pray for me. I am not sure where to go from this.

Posted

No matter what, continue to attend Mass. You don't need to receive communion in order to attend Mass.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...