Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

The Blessed Trinity


Recommended Posts

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

+JMJ+

I was with a few friends the other day and out of nowhere a debate about the Trinity came up. The debate was between two young men that I know (I was a spectator).

They went through genaration, procession, equality etc.

Eventually they got to God the Holy Spirit.
It went something like this:

[quote]Catholic: The Father loves the Son. The Son loves the Father. This mutual love genarates the Holy Spirit.

Non-Denom.: I see......Does the Father love the Holy Spirit?

Catholic: Well of course!

Non-Denom- Does the Holy Spirit love the Father?

Catholic: Well, sure!

Non-Denom: Then why doesn't thier love generate another person?

Catholic: ........[/quote]

He pretty much trailed off.
I honestly didn't know what to say.

I hate when I can't defend our Blessed Lord......... :(

puellapaschalis
Posted

Do we love the love we have for Christ? I mean, we speak of the Spirit as a Person, but I'm not sure that necessarily implies that the Father "loves" the Spirit in the same way He loves the Son.

But heck, what do I know :D

Love and prayers,

PP

Posted

[quote name='Fulton Sheen Warrior' post='1127979' date='Nov 26 2006, 05:48 PM']
+JMJ+

I was with a few friends the other day and out of nowhere a debate about the Trinity came up. The debate was between two young men that I know (I was a spectator).

They went through genaration, procession, equality etc.

Eventually they got to God the Holy Spirit.
It went something like this:
He pretty much trailed off.
I honestly didn't know what to say.

I hate when I can't defend our Blessed Lord......... :(
[/quote]

There is some cleaning up to do here. Really unless you have a strong grasp of Trinitarian Theology its best not to enter into debates about it. Even though I'm going to attempt to help you beforehand, I do so with the utmost trepidation.

God's enacts His being in vital relational acts: Generation and Spiration. These we attempt to understand by looking at ourselves as the image of God. Man is the image of God because of his rational soul, which contains the three faculties of being, knowing and willing reflecting God's 'inner dynamic'.

In God the Father is analogous to the first of the three faculties. For instance, when we understand things we conceive of them as words. A word is in fact the manifestation of our understanding, when we speak we're giving concrete form to that which we understand. However, humans do not understand the sum total of everything in one act of intellection. In fact we cannot. On the other hand it is actually God's nature to do this. Hence God can only have one Word. As the gospel of John tell us 'In the beginning was the Word and the Word was with God and the Word was God' (Jn 1:1). This last part is crucial because this seperates what makes God the Word truly the Son from eternity. Human words are not our children, they have a different nature to us, but the Word of God can be called Son of the Father because He shares the same nature as the Father. This is because as a result of God's Simplicity 'to be' and 'to understand' are the same, it is God's nature to comprehend infinitely and absolutely. Whatever we generate that is exactly of the same nature as us can be called our offspring and thus the Word of God is also called His Son from all eternity. In knowing Himself the Father loves Himself as an act of neccessity because of His nature. This leads to the spiration of the Holy Spirit via a procession of love. Hence we say the Spirit proceeds from the Father and the Son, the Father first knows Himself, the Word, then loves Himself, the Spirit.

I've tried to be as brief and clear as possible with the result that my answer was fairly poor. The link below will take you longer to read but its better:

[url="http://www.ewtn.com/library/Theology/SIPLIGHT.HTM"]The Holy Trinity. Excerpt from: LIGHT OF FAITH, The Compendium of Theology[/url]

Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted (edited)

+JMJ+

Thank you Myles (for the post and the link ;) )!

Yes.....the Trinity is not a riddle to be solved but a mystery to be adored.

Thanks again.

Edited by Fulton Sheen Warrior
Posted

Myles, what's a good Catholic like you doing in the UK? :lol:

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...