Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

If you wanna get rid of something, just get rid of the term "X-mas" :detective:

That takes Christ out of Christmas more than Santa

Posted (edited)

[quote name='VeniteAdoremus' post='1130175' date='Nov 28 2006, 07:20 PM']
We don't NEED Santa Claus. We got St. Nicholas. So, presents on December 6th, and, lo and behold, celebrating the birth of Christ on the 25th!

(I'm sorry, I shouldn't post while this tired... but Europe isn't all bad, y'know?)
[/quote]

I am sorry, I didn't intend to say that Europe is all bad. Europe has such a rich tradition and it tears me apart from the inside to see it abandoned. I have been in great cathedrals in Italy for Sunday mass with fewer that 100 people. I have seen the same in France, Spain, Austria...it is all so sad. Seeing this and the declining birth rates, it starts to dawn on me that the culture of death has cast its shadow upon Europe.

There are some bright spots in Europe. There are some amazing groups working in Italy, Spain and Portugal. I pray that the fire in Poland will spread and set the rest of Europe on fire for Christ.

For me it is hard to watch what is happening in Europe because I see those cultures as the parent cultures of my own culture. There are those who will disagree with me but the American culture is based on the Judeo-Christian culture formed in Europe and spread by the great saints. So when I go to Europe and see empty churches when my own parish is full, it really hurts. It makes me want to reach out and do something so I pray. I am very much hoping that the WYD will have had a big impact on Germany.

By the way, when I lived in South America presents came not only on Christmas but also on 12th night, the feast of the Epiphany. The deliver looked different than our standard issue American Santa but then my friends in the British ex-pat community had a differnet looking gentleman too. I was taught that Santa looks different and is called by different names around the world. It makes it all so much cooler. It is like going to St. Peters to see the Pope and everyone is there for the same reason but they come from so many different cultures. You really feel the universiality of the church. To a much lesser extent the same is true of good old St. Nick.

So, if Santa is starting to look a little more like the American version and not so Austrian then say it. Try to get him to look like he should in Austiria but don't throw him out altogether.

Edited by Mercy me
VeniteAdoremus
Posted

[quote name='Balthazor' post='1133677' date='Dec 2 2006, 08:19 PM']
Dutch people aren't that tall. At least the ones I know, Americans even tend to be taller than Europeans in general. [/quote]

I think PP, who has to strain her neck all day, would beg to differ... As a nationality, we're the tallest in the world (the Masai are on average taller, but they don't have their own country, which is why they're not on the list). I'm 6'5" (and a girl). How tall are you? ;)

[quote name='Balthazor' post='1133677' date='Dec 2 2006, 08:19 PM']
I know that some people don't like Santa but I do, in all of his forms. As long as you keep the spirit and holiness of Christmas what is the Problem?

I like The American Santa, because I am American and it is part of my culture. I find nothing worng with having him, even if he is a recent invention. Why not? I do not see anyone boycotting Kwanza after all and that is an even more recent invention of American culture.

Obviously someone in Europe and in the rest of the world must like the American Santa clause other wise like American Root beer, he would have stayed exclusively in America.

I find this banning of Santa Clause a riddiculous xenophobic act. Are they afraid of the "Amercian Menace" of Santa Clause will wipe out the traditional Saint Nicolous version? I really do not understand. I am sorry.
[/quote]

I understand that he's part of your culture, and I must say that I do like Santa, too. What's not to like about him?

What I -do- dislike is something I see in shops and on Christmas markets: less and less "Christian" decorations, almost no stables anymore, and more and more Santas. The Christmas feast is really turning secular, and [b]in Europe[/b], Santa Claus is one of the epitomes of non-Christianness. "Your" Christmas can be Christian -with- Santa because he's part of your culture. Here, he comes [i]instead[/i] of the Christian feast. And that's what we have problems with.

(By the way, St. Nicolaas already gave me a present: a book on Darwin's theory of evolution! The good Saint obviously thinks my apologetics would be better if I knew "the enemy", and I think I agree with him.)

Posted

May I ask one of European Phamily members if the American Santa is pushing out the other Chistmas figures or if have they been changed? I am really curious.

VeniteAdoremus
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1133770' date='Dec 2 2006, 10:41 PM']
May I ask one of European Phamily members if the American Santa is pushing out the other Chistmas figures or if have they been changed? I am really curious.
[/quote]

Changed, not so much - in my country St. Nicholas (not really a Christmas figure) is still really big.

But yes, Christmas is partly about Santa now, though without presents, in most families. As far as I know it's the same in France (my godchild gets a special visit from St. Nicholas because of his Dutch godmother ;) ): the traditions have stayed the same, but Santa is replacing the Christian symbols.

Posted

That is sad that Santa Claus is invading. Maybe it is me but it drives me crazy to go somewhere and find alll the same things that I left at home. I mean try going anywhere that doesn't have Benetton or McDonalds or in the US Walmart they are everywhere.

Have you seen a revitalization of the faith since WYD?

VeniteAdoremus
Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1133778' date='Dec 2 2006, 10:57 PM']
That is sad that Santa Claus is invading. Maybe it is me but it drives me crazy to go somewhere and find alll the same things that I left at home. I mean try going anywhere that doesn't have Benetton or McDonalds or in the US Walmart they are everywhere.

Have you seen a revitalization of the faith since WYD?
[/quote]

Let me get PP for you... "revitalization" is her subject :D:

puellapaschalis
Posted

Let me first say this: I had a reply to Mercy Me and Balthazor all typed out when I decided it wasn't charitable enough to get past my wireless card, so that firefox tab didn't survive. VA is a better person than I am; I stand by and agree with what she says (ESPECIALLY on the height of Dutch people thing - I live here, hello?). Actually, that goes for a lot of stuff on Phatmass.

Europe is her own beast and there is more going on here than North Americans on the internet (including some currently in Europe itself) tend to be aware of. Things like WYD, whilst sometimes cringeworthy, are powered by a deep grace given by God which works its way into people and does Great Things, particularly in the area where the event actually takes place.

My diocesan group travelled to WYD with a group of Filipinos; within the last year some of the Dutchies travelled over to the Philippines to strengthen their bonds with the friends they had made, both during WYD and over the last few years (the two dioceses have had a link for ages). The people I travelled with came back (as I did) different people, and we couldn't [i]help[/i] but share it with others, at least in a non-conscious manner.

A friend of mine who I randomly (!) bumped into at Marienfeld emailed me afterwards to relate how her group had been changed once they got back. There was a bit more drive, purpose and focus in the rosaries they prayed together on the coaches; people came together and made more of an effort to get to Mass whenever they could and not just when they had to or felt like it (I saw this too); people encouraged each other to go to Confession more often, and to make better Confessions.

Prayers were answered when I wasn't fully aware I was praying them; on one afternoon the small group I was with went into the church in Cologne that Youth 2000 had taken over, and shortly afterwards Vespers began. Now the music wasn't anything like my style - but it was Adoration, 24/7, for the whole week, who's going to complain? We all came out feeling rested, a little restored, and whatever I had prayed for I had left on that church's floor (because we were on the floor...no seats left).

A few months later a friend of mine - previously atheistic and anti just about everything - asked if he could come to Mass with me. He's now preparing for Baptism. Did I pray for [i]him[/i]? Did I pray for [i]that[/i]? I cannot say.

I'm not trying to claim here that the things I've seen and done and heard of in the last sixteen months are exclusively due to WYD. In any event, we don't believe that causality is so neatly pinned down. What I am saying is that things are stirring here which I can't quite get a hold on, other than that they're Great Things, symptoms of the Spirit, the signs of the new springtime.

Slowly you begin to realise that whilst there are plenty enough nutcases over here, often in government unfortunately enough, where hearts are open to God, they will never be abandoned by Him. The scandal and mystery of the Passion give rise to a tide of hope that swells up in your heart, and it's a joy to up your prayer life to feed it, because you [b]know[/b] that it's happening in other people, and that we must deepen our bonds with each other if the trickling streams in each individual are to merge and become a flood.

And then...you come to Phatmass and read a whole bunch of people reading the negativity and letting it take over their hearts with regards to WHAT IS YOUR HOME, and you get exasperated. No, I can't show you all on the internet what is going on in my heart - but that gives you no right to assume and harp on as though it isn't there, either in my heart, or in any other European's heart.

So before you want to type a Europe-bashing post, stop, drop to your knees and pray a decade of the Rosary instead.

Love and prayers,

PP

Posted

this is a pretty funny news story

im in germany and hadn't heard

we have a big santa claus in our dept. store

santa is around here! of course not like in the US but...

i'll be in austria and will have to get some stickers!!!

thanks for the heads up!!

Posted

[quote name='puellapaschalis' post='1133812' date='Dec 3 2006, 12:13 AM']
Let me first say this: I had a reply to Mercy Me and Balthazor all typed out when I decided it wasn't charitable enough to get past my wireless card, so that firefox tab didn't survive. VA is a better person than I am; I stand by and agree with what she says (ESPECIALLY on the height of Dutch people thing - I live here, hello?). Actually, that goes for a lot of stuff on Phatmass.

Europe is her own beast and there is more going on here than North Americans on the internet (including some currently in Europe itself) tend to be aware of. Things like WYD, whilst sometimes cringeworthy, are powered by a deep grace given by God which works its way into people and does Great Things, particularly in the area where the event actually takes place.

My diocesan group travelled to WYD with a group of Filipinos; within the last year some of the Dutchies travelled over to the Philippines to strengthen their bonds with the friends they had made, both during WYD and over the last few years (the two dioceses have had a link for ages). The people I travelled with came back (as I did) different people, and we couldn't [i]help[/i] but share it with others, at least in a non-conscious manner.

A friend of mine who I randomly (!) bumped into at Marienfeld emailed me afterwards to relate how her group had been changed once they got back. There was a bit more drive, purpose and focus in the rosaries they prayed together on the coaches; people came together and made more of an effort to get to Mass whenever they could and not just when they had to or felt like it (I saw this too); people encouraged each other to go to Confession more often, and to make better Confessions.

Prayers were answered when I wasn't fully aware I was praying them; on one afternoon the small group I was with went into the church in Cologne that Youth 2000 had taken over, and shortly afterwards Vespers began. Now the music wasn't anything like my style - but it was Adoration, 24/7, for the whole week, who's going to complain? We all came out feeling rested, a little restored, and whatever I had prayed for I had left on that church's floor (because we were on the floor...no seats left).

A few months later a friend of mine - previously atheistic and anti just about everything - asked if he could come to Mass with me. He's now preparing for Baptism. Did I pray for [i]him[/i]? Did I pray for [i]that[/i]? I cannot say.

I'm not trying to claim here that the things I've seen and done and heard of in the last sixteen months are exclusively due to WYD. In any event, we don't believe that causality is so neatly pinned down. What I am saying is that things are stirring here which I can't quite get a hold on, other than that they're Great Things, symptoms of the Spirit, the signs of the new springtime.

Slowly you begin to realise that whilst there are plenty enough nutcases over here, often in government unfortunately enough, where hearts are open to God, they will never be abandoned by Him. The scandal and mystery of the Passion give rise to a tide of hope that swells up in your heart, and it's a joy to up your prayer life to feed it, because you [b]know[/b] that it's happening in other people, and that we must deepen our bonds with each other if the trickling streams in each individual are to merge and become a flood.

And then...you come to Phatmass and read a whole bunch of people reading the negativity and letting it take over their hearts with regards to WHAT IS YOUR HOME, and you get exasperated. No, I can't show you all on the internet what is going on in my heart - but that gives you no right to assume and harp on as though it isn't there, either in my heart, or in any other European's heart.

So before you want to type a Europe-bashing post, stop, drop to your knees and pray a decade of the Rosary instead.

Love and prayers,

PP
[/quote]

:applause: Well said.

Posted

[quote]So, if Santa is starting to look a little more like the American version and not so Austrian then say it. Try to get him to look like he should in Austiria but don't throw him out altogether. [/quote]

See what he should look like: [img]http://www.g-o.de/redaktion/focus/bild2/christ5m.jpg[/img]

Will be hard to get him there. :lol_roll:

Posted

[quote name='VeniteAdoremus' post='1133763' date='Dec 2 2006, 04:22 PM']
I think PP, who has to strain her neck all day, would beg to differ... As a nationality, we're the tallest in the world (the Masai are on average taller, but they don't have their own country, which is why they're not on the list). I'm 6'5" (and a girl). How tall are you? ;)
I understand that he's part of your culture, and I must say that I do like Santa, too. What's not to like about him?

What I -do- dislike is something I see in shops and on Christmas markets: less and less "Christian" decorations, almost no stables anymore, and more and more Santas. The Christmas feast is really turning secular, and [b]in Europe[/b], Santa Claus is one of the epitomes of non-Christianness. "Your" Christmas can be Christian -with- Santa because he's part of your culture. Here, he comes [i]instead[/i] of the Christian feast. And that's what we have problems with.

(By the way, St. Nicolaas already gave me a present: a book on Darwin's theory of evolution! The good Saint obviously thinks my apologetics would be better if I knew "the enemy", and I think I agree with him.)
[/quote]

I was just about to say that about the Masai. I judge based on my experiences, all my Dutch friends and classmates here are short, they must keep the tall ones there and not let them out. :mellow:
I am short too only 5'2" I hem everthing but I rarely get neck cramps as I do not try to be taller than I am.....it is much easier for a tall person to stoop to look me in the eye than for me to try and stretch out ;)
So yup I am a shortie :D: but I am Polish ancestry which doesn't say much....all of my Uncles are over 6'3" so is my brother, my great uncle, grandfather, great grandfather..... I have had boyfriends ranging from 6'0" to 6'8" in the States all Polish in Background.... yet when I got to Poland.... normal sized people. :idontknow: You got me I don't know what happened there. How did this become a height competition anyway and who cares?


I am in Prague right now. There is little to no American Santa here they have chocolate angels, chocolate devils and Saint Nick....but the really funny thing is is that most people are Atheist.....without American Santa ;).

"My Christmas" will be in Germany, very near Koln.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...