Chiquitunga Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 I heard on talk radio today something like the Catholic Church is having a hard time recommending The Nativity Story, because the young actress that played Mary is now pregnant at 16. (they always take every opportunity to say something negative about the Church ) I didn't think this was true, that the Church did not approve of the film because of this. I know it premiered at the Vatican, and thought they approved and recommended it. I read a little about the young actress that played Our Lady. Her parents were never married and not are together anymore. She did not have all the advantages and role models that many good Christian families have. I think it is best to always look at the good, and it is great this young woman is having her child. I think her experience playing Our Lady will have a positive impact on her life.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 [quote name='Margaret Clare' post='1132495' date='Nov 30 2006, 10:43 PM'] I heard on talk radio today something like the Catholic Church is having a hard time recommending The Nativity Story, because the young actress that played Mary is now pregnant at 16. (they always take every opportunity to say something negative about the Church ) I didn't think this was true, that the Church did not approve of the film because of this. I know it premiered at the Vatican, and thought they approved and recommended it. I read a little about the young actress that played Our Lady. Her parents were never married and not are together anymore. She did not have all the advantages and role models that many good Christian families have. I think it is best to always look at the good, and it is great this young woman is having her child. I think her experience playing Our Lady will have a positive impact on her life. [/quote] The fact that the lead actress made a mistake has no impact on the quality of the film. If the Vatican enjoyed it, go and do likewise.
Chiquitunga Posted December 1, 2006 Author Posted December 1, 2006 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1132508' date='Nov 30 2006, 09:58 PM'] The fact that the lead actress made a mistake has no impact on the quality of the film. If the Vatican enjoyed it, go and do likewise. [/quote] Thanks! I totally agree. I think it's awesome this film was made and just in time for Advent. I was just wondering if you guys had heard anything of this. I was rather annoyed to hear on the radio that the Church was having trouble endorsing it, because I don't think this is true at all. I didn't hear anything like this, but only positive reviews. The only slightly negative thing I read was that, since it was produced with a more Protestant point of view, the translation of the angel's greeting to Mary was not "full of grace" but "Hail, favored one" But anyway, this is only a minor detail, and "favored one" is also an acceptable translation. It's supposed to be a great film, destined to become a Christmas classic. It's awesome that it was premiered at the Vatican. I read somewhere that this was the first film to have debuted there. Edited December 1, 2006 by Margaret Clare
Extra ecclesiam nulla salus Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 Vatican officials give thumbs up for 'The Nativity Story' By Carol Glatz Catholic News Service VATICAN CITY (CNS) -- Vatican officials have given the latest Hollywood re-enactment of the Gospel accounts of Jesus' birth a thumbs up after hosting the film's world premiere Nov. 26. Praise for "The Nativity Story," due out in U.S. theaters Dec. 1, came from the Vatican newspaper, L'Osservatore Romano; the Vatican's secretary of state, Cardinal Tarcisio Bertone; and the head of the Pontifical Council for Social Communications, U.S. Archbishop John P. Foley. "It's well done," Cardinal Bertone told journalists after seeing the film in the Vatican's Paul VI hall together with more than 7,000 other invited guests. Pope Benedict XVI, who was due to fly to Turkey less than 40 hours later, did not attend the evening event. "It retells this event which changed history with realism but also with a sense of great respect of the mystery of the Nativity," said Cardinal Bertone, adding that he found it to be "a good cinematic" feature. The benefit event raised money to build two new schools in the Israeli village of Mughar in Galilee. Christian, Muslim and Druze students will attend the elementary and middle schools. Thunderous applause broke out several times during the film's 90-minute showing, with the most enthusiastic being during the scene of Christ's birth in Bethlehem. Archbishop Foley said Rolf Mittweg, president of the film's distributor, New Line Cinema, told him he was "stunned, but happy" the film generated so much applause. "I told him it was because they were pleased to see an affirmation of (the Christian) faith," the archbishop said. In his opening remarks before the nearly full audience hall, Archbishop Foley said it was "nice to be able to have something religious for Christmas." The film, which revives the true meaning of the season, comes at a time when "people are afraid of saying 'Merry Christmas'" and makes people "proud to say 'Merry Christmas,'" he said. The archbishop told Catholic News Service he found the film to be "very moving" and thought "the part of Joseph was sensitively scripted and played." Cardinal Bertone also praised the way the scriptwriter, Mike Rich, crafted "very beautiful dialogue" between the characters, especially in fleshing out Joseph and Mary's relationship and how "they together accepted the mystery of God's plan for them." "In particular, Joseph is the example of how an honest and righteous man, who undergoes a humanly upsetting experience" -- finding out his betrothed is pregnant -- can still "abandon himself completely to God's plan." Meanwhile, L'Osservatore Romano called the feature film "graceful and unpretentious," praising it for being a light, happy and imaginative retelling of the story of Joseph, Mary and Christ's birth. END
isilzha Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 [url="http://catholicleague.com/06press_releases/quarter%204/061129_media_in_a_stink.htm"]Media in Stink Over "The Nativity Story"[/url]
cappie Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=61149"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=61149[/url]
Aloysius Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 I was very surprised to see the story of the star of bethlehem interpretted with a very obscure rarely known armenian story-- that the wisemen at midday looked down a well and were able to see the star that they had been following at night and that's how they knew they were at the child's birthplace. see, that can actually happen with some of the deep-dug dark wells, they can reflect starlight in the water in the middle of the day. this makes it clear to me that they did their homework on this story.
uruviel Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 when I watched the trailor, my mom pointed out that it seemed to show a scene where Mary's family was treating her like a disgrace, or that she 'disgraced' the family. But I haven't seen it, and I'm definitely not saying I don't trust the Vatican, if the church says it's good, then I'm good. Just thought that part was interesting, because both of Mary's parents are saints, I doubt they treated her like that. If, at all, my mom was correct in that.
Chiquitunga Posted December 1, 2006 Author Posted December 1, 2006 (edited) [quote name='uruviel' post='1132527' date='Nov 30 2006, 10:28 PM'] when I watched the trailor, my mom pointed out that it seemed to show a scene where Mary's family was treating her like a disgrace, or that she 'disgraced' the family. But I haven't seen it, and I'm definitely not saying I don't trust the Vatican, if the church says it's good, then I'm good. Just thought that part was interesting, because both of Mary's parents are saints, I doubt they treated her like that. If, at all, my mom was correct in that. [/quote] That's interesting. Yeah, another thing I did read on this film is that it does fill in parts not mentioned in Gospel to tell the story. [i]The Passion of Christ[/i] had Anne Catherine Emmerich's revelations for this. That's kind of the difference of a more Catholic interpretation vs. a more Protestant one maybe. But anyway, yeah, it's supposed to be a great film. Edited December 1, 2006 by Margaret Clare
uruviel Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 oh ok. Well, I'm glad the Vatican approved it, perhaps I could see it sometime.
Theologian in Training Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 I was talking to the DRE the other day, and I think we are going to organize a viewing of it. The theater is right down the street and they are willing to let us rent out a part of the theater. God Bless
let_go_let_God Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 It's true that the parents condone the pregnancy in the trailer, but it's followed by Joseph waking up. I thought it was Joseph's dream of what would happen if he didn't take Mary as his wife. God bless- LGLG
uruviel Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 ohhh ok. Like I said, I wasn't sure about it since I haven't seen it yet. Thanks
Mary's servant Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 AMDG+JMJ I'm seeing it with my Protestant friend this weekend. Yea for excuses to talk about Mary.
melikalani Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=61149&pid=1130610&st=0&#entry1130610"]Allow me to quote myself! [/url] (I saw the movie at a pre-screening on Tuesday night.) [quote name='melikalani' post='1130610' date='Nov 29 2006, 12:50 AM'] I just got back from watching the film and it's quite beautiful! The portrayal of Saint Joseph was the highlight of the film for me and the actor did a wonderful job! His eyes are so expressive and you could really see the absolute love and dedication Saint Joseph has for Our Lady. If anything, the film strengthened my love for Saint Joseph. They showed his relationship with Our Lady as so real and so sweet. The Magi are quite good and funny, too! One of the best scenes is when the Magi arrive and present their gifts. The one presenting the gold said his gift was for the 'King of Kings' and the one with the frankincense said his gift was for the 'Priest of Priests' (that part went over well with the four priests I went with!). The actress playing Mamma Mary could have been better. She didn't have much personality, in my opinion. One of the priests thought that it was a quite protestant portrayal of Our Lady. He didn't like that they showed Our Lady having labor pains. Saints Anne and Joachim didn't come off as I expected either? Overall, it's a very good film, but there are weaknesses. It would be good for a young crowd, especially one that doesn't know the story very well. [/quote]
cmotherofpirl Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 I have no issues with Mary having labor pains. She was alone and scared with no women around to help her, and about to have the Son of God.
uruviel Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 that's true, but as for St. Anne and Joachim, there's no excuse. I really hope they don't give ppl who see the movie bad impressions.
franciscan13 Posted December 1, 2006 Posted December 1, 2006 Umm, I know the circumstances are way different, but Our Blessed Mother wasnt that much older than the young lady that plays her in the film and she to was pregnat and out of wedlock. We all make mistakes in life. i dont know anything about this girl, but the fact that she's pregnat at 16 isnt going to stop me from watching the movie.
Chiquitunga Posted December 2, 2006 Author Posted December 2, 2006 [quote name='franciscan13' post='1132996' date='Dec 1 2006, 01:44 PM'] Umm, I know the circumstances are way different, but Our Blessed Mother wasnt that much older than the young lady that plays her in the film and she to was pregnat and out of wedlock. We all make mistakes in life. i dont know anything about this girl, but the fact that she's pregnat at 16 isnt going to stop me from watching the movie. [/quote] Me neither, not at all. I just wanted to be sure to say, it's in no way my opinion to look down on this young actress or the film at all - absolutely no way. I have several friends and cousins who are young and unmarried with children. I should have chosen a better thread title than this, to make this clearer. I was commenting on how annoyed I was to hear this on talk radio - that the Church was having a hard time promoting it - because that was totally not true. It was the insult on the Church that I was angry with, and the untruth about this statement, because I was sure the Church highly recommended it. Thanks for all the replies confirming this. And this article, [url="http://catholicleague.com/06press_releases/quarter%204/061129_media_in_a_stink.htm"]Media in Stink ...[/url] was particularly relevant. Thank you. I also heard there was a standing ovation at the Vatican.
Colleen Posted December 2, 2006 Posted December 2, 2006 [quote name='uruviel' post='1132527' date='Nov 30 2006, 09:28 PM'] when I watched the trailor, my mom pointed out that it seemed to show a scene where Mary's family was treating her like a disgrace, or that she 'disgraced' the family. But I haven't seen it, and I'm definitely not saying I don't trust the Vatican, if the church says it's good, then I'm good. Just thought that part was interesting, because both of Mary's parents are saints, I doubt they treated her like that. If, at all, my mom was correct in that. [/quote] I always thought since they were betrothed, it didn't matter. I thought that was common in those days to live together after betrothal. Am I totally wrong here?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now