Jutty1224 Posted December 5, 2006 Posted December 5, 2006 It seems that alot of people in the forums are always saying that they hate the contemporary hymns that they usually sing in their parish. I'm wondering if there is anyone that likes them? I do, I've grown accustomed to them since i've grown up atteneding masses where they're usually sung, the only exception being when i was going to school at Magdalen College. So yes, I like alot of them and Just discovered in the past couple days since installed iTunes on my computer that they have a ton of them on there.
Jabberwocky Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 They are what I'm used to hearing, and some of them I really like. Most of the ones that I don't really care for much are the Marty Haugen, piano-y ones.
Aloysius Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 I don't mind them outside the context of the Liturgy... well, I still mind some of them.
djc08 Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 Outside of Mass, good. Inside of Mass questionable. There are just so many wonderfully written more Traditional Hymns out there that are underplayed and unappreciated.
Sojourner Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 I think it depends on the hymn. Some are good, others just don't seem quite ... respectful enough?
xTrishaxLynnx Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1136018' date='Dec 5 2006, 10:10 PM'] I think it depends on the hymn. Some are good, others just don't seem quite ... respectful enough? [/quote]
veroni213 Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 In general I don't have a problem with them. But, there are a couple I can't stand (in Mass or not). I think the worst is "We are Companions on the Journey." For some reason I used to like it. Then I listened to the lyrics. The coagulated milk factor is unbelievable.
Birgitta Noel Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1136018' date='Dec 5 2006, 10:10 PM'] I think it depends on the hymn. Some are good, others [are just plain carp] [/quote] What she said.
NicholasLarkinIV Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 If lyrics are appropriate, than I may like a contemporary song, in fact, Christian Contemporary is my second favorite type of music to listen to after Gregorian Chant. But, I do not think contemporary is appropriate for the Eucharistic Sacrifice, for the traditional chants & hymns are there already. While there are I am sure exceptions of good contemporary hymns for Mass, I prefer not!
Balthazor Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 Actually I like some of them, but some are poorly done, and evenly more poorly executed unfortunitely. I really think that the lack of a good arrangment and a good choir has a lot to do with it.
son_of_angels Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 I've always "Amen. El cuerpo de Christo" but, even then, I don't really like it's "playfulness" for the Mass itself. Some of the popular contemporary hymns like "All are welcome" etc. have annoying connotations, and are used equally well with bad theology, even if they don't themselves contain objectionable material. On the other hand, there are some really cheesy Latin songs that my choir inisists on singing constantly "O Deus Ego Amo te" ICK! Just stick with good 'ol Gregorian Chant hymns and propers, or write some new ones of the same genre. I would rather just here a plainchant recitation of "Miserere" anyday than "One bread, one body." Then again, I also would prefer if Churches didn't use artificial amplification or lighting...
prose Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 I like contemporary hymns, and get this... I think there is even room for respectful new music. Some of which hasn't even been written yet.
Piamaria Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 [quote name='prose' post='1136475' date='Dec 6 2006, 10:40 AM'] I like contemporary hymns, and get this... I think there is even room for respectful new music. Some of which hasn't even been written yet. [/quote] Me too. Some. Loving the traditional hymns doesn't mean there can't be new ones. I hope our generation can add to the beauty of religious music.
Noel's angel Posted December 6, 2006 Posted December 6, 2006 [quote name='cappie' post='1136042' date='Dec 6 2006, 04:31 AM'] Traditional hymns were once contemporary. [/quote] I also agree that it depends on the hymn. Being contermporary doesn't automatically make a hymn worthless. If its theologically correct and doesn't sound like a pop/rock song, its perfectly fine for me.
suuran Posted December 7, 2006 Posted December 7, 2006 I actually really like some David Haas..."You Are Mine" brings tears to my eyes every time. I'm open to the idea that they're better outside Mass, though.
catholicinsd Posted December 7, 2006 Posted December 7, 2006 There are some old hymns that bore me to tears... but its at at Mass so it all works. There are some old hymns that bore me to tears... but its at at Mass so it all works.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now