Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

wow, i've never met so many people so adamant about keeping something that's unhealthy and doesn't change the flavor of food at all before. Do you want them to put lead back in paint as well?

wow, i've never met so many people so adamant about keeping something that's unhealthy and doesn't change the flavor of food at all before. Do you want them to put lead back in paint as well?

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

[quote name='Totus Tuus' post='1137549' date='Dec 7 2006, 05:17 PM']
I dunno, it seems to me if you're eating french fries or doughnuts you know darn well what you're putting into your body (hazardous and harmful stuff). So that knowledge and consent business doesn't make much sense to me :huh:
:lol_roll: :lol_roll: :lol_roll:
[/quote]

Ditto.

[quote name='morostheos' post='1137628' date='Dec 7 2006, 07:12 PM']
wow, i've never met so many people so adamant about keeping something that's unhealthy and doesn't change the flavor of food at all before. Do you want them to put lead back in paint as well?
[/quote]

I don't think that people are recommending we gorge ourselves on the stuff, the point seems to be that making this a legal issue is extreme. If YOU choose to eat it is it really up to the government to force you to stop? Its not like smoking or drunk driving which is harmful to other people. Yes, people should limit their trans-fat intake, but that should be something we do on our own.

Posted

Why is that something we should do on our own though? When they found out formaldehyde caused cancer, they took it out of shampoos and such.

Trans fat is not something that is naturally occurring. It was created by the food industry as a cheap substitute, and it is very dangerous to our health. The way I see it, had the effects been known when it was introduced, it would never have been allowed in the first place. But of course the effects weren't known then. Now they are. Why continue to allow it?

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1137628' date='Dec 7 2006, 06:12 PM']
wow, i've never met so many people so adamant about keeping something that's unhealthy and doesn't change the flavor of food at all before. Do you want them to put lead back in paint as well?

wow, i've never met so many people so adamant about keeping something that's unhealthy and doesn't change the flavor of food at all before. Do you want them to put lead back in paint as well?
[/quote]


Methinks the huff is not really about keeping something that is indeed unhealthy. It is about the further intrusion into our lives of the government. The USA is slowly becoming a nanny state wherein nobody takes personal responsibility for anything and the govt has to be the one to tell us what is good for us because it believes we are all too stupid to figure it out for ourselves.

"But nobody ever told me that eating McDonald's every day for 30 years would make me a fat tub of goo. There should have been a warning label. Now I'm gonna sue someone!"

[quote name='morostheos' post='1137992' date='Dec 8 2006, 05:26 AM']
Trans fat is not something that is naturally occurring. It was created by the food industry as a cheap substitute, and it is very dangerous to our health. The way I see it, had the effects been known when it was introduced, it would never have been allowed in the first place. But of course the effects weren't known then. Now they are. Why continue to allow it?
[/quote]


Population control? It's a conspiracy by the garden tool industry I tell you!

Posted

[quote name='Groo the Wanderer' post='1138092' date='Dec 8 2006, 09:38 AM']Methinks the huff is not really about keeping something that is indeed unhealthy. It is about the further intrusion into our lives of the government. The USA is slowly becoming a nanny state wherein nobody takes personal responsibility for anything and the govt has to be the one to tell us what is good for us because it believes we are all too stupid to figure it out for ourselves.

"But nobody ever told me that eating McDonald's every day for 30 years would make me a fat tub of goo. There should have been a warning label. Now I'm gonna sue someone!"[/quote]agreed

Posted

[url="http://www.foxnews.com/printer_friendly_story/0,3566,235317,00.html"]Junk Science[/url]

I will not argue the actual health effects of trans-fats, because I am not a doctor. However, i will argue the statistics and the media bias.

I am a fan of the Junk Science website, because i support strict adherance to the scientific method if you are claiming to have evidence that something is bad.

Read here:

New York City Bans Science

Thursday , December 07, 2006

By Steven Milloy


The New York City Board of Health this week banned the use of trans fats by restaurants. The decision is directly traceable back to the “research” of Harvard University’s Alberto Ascherio and Walter Willett, the promoters-in-chief of trans fats hysteria.

Now that the Board has deemed their dubious trans fats research suitable for dictating public policy, New Yorkers ought to hope that Ascherio and Willett don’t press the Board to implement some of their other published research that is similar in "quality" to their trans fats work.

New Yorkers could, for example, see restaurants banned from serving potatoes, peas, peanuts, beans, lentils, orange juice and grapefruit juice. Ascherio-Willett reported an increase in the risk of heart disease among consumers of these foods in the Annals of Internal Medicine (June 2001). Although none of those slight correlations were statistically meaningful -- and, in all probability, were simply meaningless chance occurrences -- a similar shortcoming didn’t seem to matter to the Board when it came to their trans fats research.

Indian restaurants could be banned from cooking with sunflower oil. Ascherio-Willett once found that consumers of Indian food cooked in sunflower oil were up to 3 times more likely to suffer heart attacks than consumers of Indian food cooked in mustard oil (American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, April 2004).

Sure it was only one study and even they acknowledged the need for more research -- but that didn’t stop Ascherio-Willett from recommending the switch in cooking oils.

Red meat might disappear, too.

Ascherio-Willett reported a 63 percent increase in the risk of type 2 diabetes associated with iron intake from red meat (American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, Jan. 2004). They didn’t bother to verify how much iron from red meat any of the study subjects consumed and, therefore, don’t actually have a firm basis for linking red meat consumption with the disease – but what the heck, they don’t really know the quantity of trans fats consumed by any of those study subjects either.

It’s not looking good for dairy products either. Ascherio-Willett reported in the Annals of Neurology (Dec. 2002) that consumption of dairy products was associated with an 80 percent increase in the risk of Parkinson’s Disease among men. Although they concluded at the time that the finding needed further evaluation, why should the Board wait for more research? That could take forever. If the inconsistent and contradictory trans fats research doesn’t require further evaluation, I can’t imagine why it would be necessary for dairy products.

Regular (sugar-sweetened) soft drinks ought to be history as well. Willett linked them with weight gain and diabetes in women (Journal of the American Medical Association, Aug. 25, 2004). It didn’t even matter that the same study also inexplicably linked diet soft drinks with a similar risk of diabetes.

It’s really odd that when their research inadvertently debunks itself and other food myths, almost no one learns of it. And that’s true for their trans fats research, as well.

The Board’s notice of its decision to ban trans fats tries to bolster its case by playing on popular misconceptions about saturated fat. The notice states that, “trans fat appears even worse than saturated fat.” The Board apparently isn’t familiar with the several Ascherio-Willett studies that fail to link saturated fat with heart disease and stroke.

The public’s 30-year long fear of saturated fat and the Board’s statement is, in fact, without a scientific basis. It’s simply astounding that the Board can get away with exploiting one debunked myth to help propagate another.

Just to show that not all the Ascherio-Willett research is about simply banning foods – after all, it is possible that at some point the public will tire of being nannied – the Board may want to consider requiring restaurant patrons to order caffeinated coffee with every meal. One Ascherio-Willett study reported that the risk of type 2 diabetes was reduced by a statistically significant 54 percent among men who consumed 6 or more cups of coffee per day (Annals of Internal Medicine, Jan. 6, 2004).

The Board might also want to mandate the daily consumption of pizza by men. Ascherio-Willett reported that men who consume more than 10 servings of pizza per week reduce their risk of prostate cancer by one-third (Journal of the National Cancer Institute, Dec. 1995).

It’s not that either coffee or pizza is a proven “health” food – far from it – but the Board should consider their great distraction potential. Just as the ancient Roman emperors distracted citizens with bread and circuses while taking away their freedoms, the Board could easily distract New Yorkers with coffee and pizza as it dismantles consumer choice in restaurants bit by bit.

Come to think of it, why is the Board’s trans fats ban limited to restaurants? What about grocery stores and convenience shops? If trans fats are so bad, why should you be able to purchase food in a store that is too dangerous to be served in a restaurant?

The Board’s trans fats ban has dramatically lowered the bar for scientific proof. It’s such a sad spectacle that the Board of Health ought to be renamed the Bored of Science.


Steven Milloy publishes JunkScience.com and CSRWatch.com. He is a junk science expert , an advocate of free enterprise and an adjunct scholar at the Competitive Enterprise Institute .

Posted

thanks red knight for the article :D:

Posted

ok, I've got one beef with that article - it debunks lots of straw men but hardly mentions why the trans fat research is bogus. that article definitely has not given a scientific arguement against anything, it just sounds like someone whining.

Posted

ok, since i haven't actually studied the effects of trans fats before, i did a little bit of reading up on it. here are a few things off the top of my head to debunk that other article:

1. all the other things mentioned in that article have at least some nutritional value - trans fat has none.

2. the ban of trans fat in NY is not the result of one study by Harvard scientists, there has been years of research on this topic

I highly reccommend the wikipedia article on the subject: [url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans_fat/"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Trans_fat/[/url]

Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1139827' date='Dec 11 2006, 01:27 PM']
ok, I've got one beef with that article - it debunks lots of straw men but hardly mentions why the trans fat research is bogus. that article definitely has not given a scientific arguement against anything, it just sounds like someone whining.
[/quote]

Notice that the article is not stating that trans fats aren't bad, but that the science claiming they are is faulty. That's the point. Public policy is being formed based on faulty science.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I am thrilled transfat is banned, andI hope its the start of a national trend. Transfat goes straight to your BELLY. Maybe your skinny people don't worry about that now, but wait a few years....

[url="http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1997/09/970909054726.htm"]http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/1997/...70909054726.htm[/url]

[url="http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/06/060619133024.htm"]http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2006/...60619133024.htm[/url]

[url="http://www.livescience.com/humanbiology/061010_bad_trans_fats.html"]http://www.livescience.com/humanbiology/06...trans_fats.html[/url]

homeschoolmom
Posted

belly fat is bad... :ohno:

Posted

[quote name='Red Knight' post='1139832' date='Dec 11 2006, 08:51 PM']
Notice that the article is not stating that trans fats aren't bad, but that the science claiming they are is faulty. That's the point. Public policy is being formed based on faulty science.
[/quote]

I know. But he doesn't say anything about why the science is faulty, he just knocks down about 50 straw men instead. This article is not based on science at all.

Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1139859' date='Dec 11 2006, 02:46 PM']
I know. But he doesn't say anything about why the science is faulty, he just knocks down about 50 straw men instead. This article is not based on science at all.
[/quote]


I believe the point to be made here, is that the report cited by the NY Board, written by Alberto Ascherio and Walter Willett, should be approached with a little skepticism. Stephen Milloy does a good job of showing that much of the research by these men is hoddy and comes to dubious conclusions. Who knows, they may be right about trans fats, but they have cried wolf a few too many times for me.

Posted (edited)

But he makes [i]no[/i] arguements as to why any of these reports should be approached with skepticism or why their research is "hoddy and comes to dubious conclusions."

Remember, correlation [i]does not[/i] equal causation and just because one instance (with trans fat) seems to indicate causation doesn't mean any of those other examples were ever meant to.

The only thing Stephen Milloy does a good job of is expressing his opinion - he makes no attempt at backing it up with any semblance of fact.

Edited by morostheos
chickens4life
Posted

I don't like the fact that this ban has been instituted, but it is not because I think that trans fats are good. As a matter of fact, I am very careful to avoid them compleatly.

My problem is with how much the government is trying to regulate. It is costly to make and inforce regulations.

I think that there are already to many regulations out there, it is hard to do anything with out having to jump thrue some liablity or licensing hoops already. The baning of trans fats don't necisarely make anything that I do harder, but it is the mentality that we should make "unsafe" things illegal that bothers me.

Posted

So what do you all think about the work the FDA does? Is it unneccessary? Should it be done away with?

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I think the FDA isn't doing enough to protect us, and should spnt less time relying on the dribble coming from the drug companies and more time doing more invesatigating.

homeschoolmom
Posted

My dad was a chemist for the FDA, so I'm biased.

chickens4life
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1140672' date='Dec 12 2006, 05:42 PM']
So what do you all think about the work the FDA does? Is it unneccessary? Should it be done away with?
[/quote]
Some of what they do is good, but I don't like alot of it.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...