veroni213 Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 [quote name='St. Benedict' post='1138348' date='Dec 8 2006, 06:28 PM'] I'm upset to see the SSPX on the list. [/quote] I'm not. The rules apply to both sides.
oraetlabora Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 (edited) One can only hope this is the beginning of the end of groups like CTA, Women's Ordination Conference, et al. I am a full time youth minister and recently was invited to be a part of the national team for the NFCYM, only to find out that at their conferences they invite CTA board members as well as a founder of the Women's Ordination Conference to be keynote speakers. I contacted my local Diocesan Youth Minister only to have a meeting called with my pastor about how my information was totally off base, and they supported these conferences. Come to find out my business manager and pastor are members of CTA, as well the DYM doesn't have issues with these groups! Matthew 3:12 The SSPX was already excommunicated, this was nothing new. The Vatican had to hold up that decision, because it had already been made. N +JMJ+ Edited December 9, 2006 by Ora_et_Labora
Aloysius Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 I don't like seeing the SSPX on the list either. The situation with the SSPX is much different than it is with these other blatantly non-Catholic blatantly anti-Catholic societies. the SSPX at least professes filial loyalty to the pope and follows him in nearly all matters, if not all, of faith and morals of course, the bishop was right to act against them in this diocese where they were doing things completely unnecessary even for the promulgation of the tridentine mass. but to lump them into this crowd is simply innaccurate. their degree of schism is far smaller. they should not be considered 'in the same boat' as despicable societies like the freemasons and call to action. the things they stand for are explicitly Catholic things; just wrongly emphasized and wrongly practiced in many cases.
Jesus_lol Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 (edited) so what exactly is wrong with the Call to Action group? most of their suggestions make sense. yes even the chastity of the preist thing, while i understand its a devotion thing its probably a contributing factor towards the "elephant in the catholic room" child abuse. well ok, creeps are everywhere, but the church shouldnt turn a blind eye to their existence and sweep them under the carpet. and some of the best pastors ive listened to were women, they definitely are just as "divine" as men. so whats wrong with this group? what else do they stand for that isnt on that list? facts not speculation please Edited December 9, 2006 by Jesus_lol
Aloysius Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 married clergy (protestants) and married school teachers have a higher incident rate of child abuse. no one is excused for any reason based on any comparison of any sort, they're all monsters, but this does show that celibacy does not contribute to child abuse. as a matter of fact, statistics suggest a lower rate of child abuse for folks who have made vows of celibacy because they are more in control of but that is not their issue. the issue is 1. disobedience to bishops and 2. heretical teachings-- female sacramental priests are against Catholic doctrine-- i.e. the very basis and foundations of our religion. females can give great advice till the sun goes down and such women should clearly have psychological practices or something and be helping people... what they can't do is consecrate the eucharist and absolve sins: according to Catholic doctrine (which one must believe to be fully Catholic, otherwise one is simply not Catholic and that has been their choice) women can no more perform these sacramental actions in the person of the male God-man Jesus Christ than men can give birth and breast feed. ex-communicate: to put outside of the communion. one who seperates himself from the communion of the Church by believing contrary doctrines are not part of the communion of the Catholic Church. sure, perfect excercise of free will there: the free will choice not to be Catholic anymore.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now