jswranch Posted December 9, 2006 Posted December 9, 2006 Does anyone have a quick schpeal on this doctrine? Articles and scriptures would be appreciated. also, someone smarter and better educated than me check this: No priest has ever transubstantiated a piece of bread. However, Christ infused within an ordained presbyter, transubstantiates. Likewise, it is not me that performes good works, but Christ within me that does it. I simply use the grace in me as a Christian to learn to love Jesus and to stop giving into my sinful temptations (concupiscience). In doing so, God uses me to further His kingdom.
beatty07 Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 Well, since no better reply is forthcoming, here's my best shot. "Imputed righteousness" is the idea that God the Father attributes Christ's righteousness to us. This is incipient in Luther, but really becomes necessary in the theological framework of Calvin. We are, in this view, excrement. Actually worse, since excrement is the way God intended excrement to be, while we on the other hand are sin right through... utterly opposed to God. This remains the case even after Baptism!!! Therefore, our salvation is solely a matter of God "imputing" the righteousness of Christ to us. See how far that is from the authentic teaching of the Church? For all the endless talk about justification, the Reformation idea of justification is a hollow, gutted version of the truth. Now that I've slammed it, time to back up just a tad and point out the kernel of truth that is contained. Which is: that ANY righteousness we have is absolutely the work of grace. So is everything that exists, for that matter. So we agree that there is no righteousness apart from God. But God's grace is real, and it really changes us. God doesn't just let us in to Heaven because He pretends we're righteous. He makes us righteous that we may live in Heaven! Luther and Calvin thought in merely legal terms. We think in Sacramental terms. That's what the much more Catholic idea of "infused grace" means. God's grace really touches us and makes us better, first in Baptism, and especially (though not exclusively) in the Sacraments. Contrasting to the Reformation idea, in which we stay bad and Christ gets us out of jail free, the idea of infused grace is that salvation really changes things for us. We're not totally depraved or utterly corrupt. God's grace is really part of who we are. The tradition is as clear as can be on this, from the New Testament through all the Fathers and Councils. [quote name='jswranch' post='1138825' date='Dec 9 2006, 02:57 PM'] check this: No priest has ever transubstantiated a piece of bread. However, Christ infused within an ordained presbyter, transubstantiates. Likewise, it is not me that performes good works, but Christ within me that does it. I simply use the grace in me as a Christian to learn to love Jesus and to stop giving into my sinful temptations (concupiscience). In doing so, God uses me to further His kingdom. [/quote] This is steeped in that Calvinism I was talking about. Partly right, but seriously off-kilter. First of all, what's right: it is true that it is Christ who principally acts in all the Sacraments. As Augustine says, "when anyone baptizes, it is Christ who baptizes." In the Orthodox tradition, this is emphasized by the baptismal formula which, instead of "I baptize you" goes "you are baptized." That's a very deliberate statement about who's really doing the baptizing... we believe the same. And yes, any good that Christians do is Christ acting in us. We are His body, nourished by His very self. As Paul said, "and now I live, not I, but Christ lives in me." BUT this doesn't mean it's incorrect to say that we do good. We do! Luther and Calvin couldn't see that God's freedom and our freedom don't conflict. God's bigger than that! Christ acts in us. We act. Both are true. If it was a matter of you and I, there would be a conflict because we're both finite actors. But between you and God, there is no conflict. God's freedom is perfect and does not compete with ours! To stay with the example from Augustine, compare what he said above with this: "When anyone baptizes, they don't really baptize, because it is Christ who baptizes." Catch the difference? This formulation assumes that Christ and we can't both be acting, as though we are competing with God. Can I try a rephrasing of that quote? I'm sure it's far from optimal, but here goes: "No priest has ever transubstantiated a piece of bread on his own. When he confects the Eucharist, it is Christ who confects the Eucharist. Likewise, any good that I do is inseparable from Christ working in me. God has given me all this grace, though I never deserved it, and in His grace I am able to grow in love of Him, and to stop giving in to my temptations. In this way, God can use me to further His kingdom." See the difference? It really is an important one. I hope this makes some sense...
jswranch Posted December 13, 2006 Author Posted December 13, 2006 Yes, this was helpful. A holy cross novice also recently helped in disucussing how we become partakers in divine sonship as members in the body of Christ. In protestant speak, Christ living in me (a new creation and a member of his body) can and does spread grace around when I do his will, even unknowingly.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now