Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

I got an email from a student yesterday, and let's just say that now I feel like a total failure as a youth minister. And looking at how well written this email is, I think this student's mom wrote it. Which makes me feel even worse about myself. Please pray for me, as I have youth group tonight and I don't feel very confident. Actually, I haven't felt very confident for weeks now and this just brings my confidence level to a new low.

homeschoolmom
Posted

Please keep in mind that people are quick to complain and slow to praise. I'm sure there are many kids who have benefited from your ministry who never bothered to say anything.

:console:

Posted

I've learned this the hard way--important things that need to be said, sould NEVER be communicated through a written letter or e-mail or anything like that. [b]Especially[/b] if the person writing the letter is angry or upset. It just makes things worse...they think it's a great idea because they can write everything and not miss anything, but then the recipient invariably reads something very different from what the writer meant to write, and it just creates a ton of misconceptions and grief that would have been avoided if they had the guts and common sense to meet you face to face.


I only say this to tell you that an inflammatory e-mail should be taken with a few grains of salt.

Posted

I remember the one year where 8 members of my youth group had and "intervention" with me. It was an hour long session on how bad I sucked.

One time I got an email from a youth that said that I "permanently tainted" the youth group forever.


Oh and just to put this in the proper light, I was one of the most sought after youth ministers in our diocese.


Not bragging mind you... just putting it in perspective.


Honestly the greater the impact you have on the community, the more vocal some detractors will be.

Posted

i can't say that this student (or the mom, whatever) doesn't have some valid points. which only makes it worse. if it was nothing that made sense, i would blow it off. i don't know. this student is in junior high and has a sibling in the high school youth group that loves to come (i don't know how much the sibling gets out of it though).

basically, the email said, i don't get anything out of youth group, and then i don't pay attention when i come; it seems like all we do is play games that don't have anything to do with our faith; i'm switching to another youth group that makes faith engaging; etc, etc, etc.

:sadder: i'm very depressed

Posted

I kinda know what it's like to feel like a total failure. :mellow:


Prayers, most definitely.

Posted

prayers, Red.

it could be, as hot stuff indicated, a sign that you are doing 'something right'

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

ask em to come in and talk with you one on one...your office DOES have a large window right? tell em how interested you are in their feedback.

then...ask the big one...what do THEY want to see? here's where you learn if it is really something about you or the program or if it is just a 'cry out' about another deeper issue...

Just try to remember...it's not YOUR ministry...It's God's. You will not be able to reach every single kiddo. On some of them, all you can do is plant a seed and let the Holy Spirit do the rest...

prayers for you and for your peace :bigpray:

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1140538' date='Dec 12 2006, 02:39 PM']
i can't say that this student (or the mom, whatever) doesn't have some valid points. which only makes it worse. if it was nothing that made sense, i would blow it off. i don't know. this student is in junior high and has a sibling in the high school youth group that loves to come (i don't know how much the sibling gets out of it though).

basically, the email said, i don't get anything out of youth group, and then i don't pay attention when i come; it seems like all we do is play games that don't have anything to do with our faith; i'm switching to another youth group that makes faith engaging; etc, etc, etc.

:sadder: i'm very depressed
[/quote]
How nice of them to come to you with their concerns after the decision has been made to leave rather than bring something constructive to the table. <_< I've always found "I don't get anything out of this" to be one of the biggest cop-outs ever.

Posted

I was just about to mention how I am trying but failing in having some sympathy for the people who left on you.

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

Ditto everything that everyone else said.

Red, you've got my prayers. :love:

MissScripture
Posted

Would it help if we told you we loved you?

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' post='1140568' date='Dec 12 2006, 01:00 PM']Would it help if we told you we loved you?[/quote]:sadder: thanks. i just talked to my hubby, and cried on his shoulder over the phone. i just wish i would've gotten this on thursday, instead of a youth group night where i'm going to obsess about this at tonight's youth group and tomorrow night's youth group.

Posted

yes yes. That's what he's there for. Talk to him for hours on end if need be. He shouldn't mind. Even if he does...tough noogies on him. This is where a man needs to be a man. :)


And we most definitely love you.

Posted

I think anyone who does Youth Ministry is wonderful. Also, if the Mom really wants to do something constructive, she should meet with you and the kid. And no one is a"total failure" because one kid didn't get much out of a group, especially not a person who serves out of the love of the Lord as you so obviously do. no one gets it right all the time. Plus I'm mad they didn't talk to you in person. Email is great but in some circumstances it's cowardly and rude.

Prayers,
Piamaria

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[[hugs]]
If this person isn't getting anything out of youth group, what are they personally offering to do to improve it? Dt they want to come and run it for a month?

homeschoolmom
Posted

Here's a question:
You said this was probably from the parent... have you [i]seen[/i] this parent outside of "pick up the kid" time? Did s/he offer to help? Make a suggestion? Etc... You see where I'm going with this?

Posted

Red....
If you dont make a few enemies you are doing something wrong.

Take what you can get good out of the letter and chalk it up to experience. I am sure your youth group is both engaging, interesting and a lot of fun.

Besides you have to look at it this way. Was this person bringing anything to the table? Faith in all forms is not only what you can get out of it, but also what you put into it.

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1140538' date='Dec 12 2006, 02:39 PM']
i can't say that this student (or the mom, whatever) doesn't have some valid points. which only makes it worse. if it was nothing that made sense, i would blow it off. i don't know. this student is in junior high and has a sibling in the high school youth group that loves to come (i don't know how much the sibling gets out of it though).

basically, the email said, i don't get anything out of youth group, and then i don't pay attention when i come; it seems like all we do is play games that don't have anything to do with our faith; i'm switching to another youth group that makes faith engaging; etc, etc, etc.

:sadder: i'm very depressed
[/quote]


Prayers, my friend, it will get better. trust Him he'll make things all better. provided in His time of course.

Anyway, your in my prayers. ^_^

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...