missionseeker Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 So for my final for composition tomorrow, the prompt is basically, 'should American Health care be socialized' I was looking for opinions from people who know first hand about socialized health care. I can see the benefits, they are pretty obvious for the most part. But I also think that socializing the health care would create problems with the government controling what proceedures doctors can and [b]must[/b] do. It seems to me they would be able to say 'since we pay for it, we decide that you must abort this kid rather than give birth to a severely mentally ill child' I also think that in America, because private companies pay for it, there is more work in the research field. I could be wrong but that seems like what it is- i have to look that up. I would like to know from Canadians about the organization of it in a large country. Any help would be greatly appreciated! ~Cat
God Conquers Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 Doctor's don't have to do abortions. You kinda do have to go about things a certain way though... it's difficult not to have to prescribe Birth Control and stuff. The main problem isn't socializing medicare... it's about how far and how serious you take it. In Canada medicare is a "sacred cow". No one can touch it. And even though there are serious problems of waiting times for operations and room space and emergency care at our hospitals nothing can be done because it is too controversial. In fact, I would definately look at Norway, France or Germany as better models. Canada's strict monopoly on insurance and care is equal only in two other places: North Korea and Cuba... Great. So we have problems. But I still love my medicare. oh... and also don't forget that we pay 50% or more of our salaries in taxes because of it. So it's give and take.
homeschoolmom Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 Okay... here's a situation (not to get tangential... just curious). So, I think I may have strep yet again. I called the clinic and asked if I could come in for a throat culture. They said, "sure, what time do you want to come in?" I gave her a time and it's all good. I asked her if it were possible that my kids were carriers of strep but not producing symptems. She said it's possible and did I want to bring them in, too. I said yes and she looked at the appointment records because one of my kids hasn't been seen in over a year (so he has to be seen by a doctor before getting the culture)... after all that, I decided to wait and see if, in fact, I have strep before getting the kids checked. All this to say... I would have been able to get us all in this morning and I was wondering if, given the same situation, I would have been able to do so in Canada.
God Conquers Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 ya, you could just walk into a clinic off the street and get it done, no cost. (cause you already paid it in taxes)
homeschoolmom Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 cuz you know the stereotype is that you have really long waits for routine stuff... and I was just wondering how true that is... The things Americans worry about with socialized health care: Long lines Cutting care to save money Huge tax increases to cover it.
Veritas Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1141250' date='Dec 13 2006, 11:21 AM'] cuz you know the stereotype is that you have really long waits for routine stuff... [/quote] + The big problem is quality. In Italy, for example, I will ALWAYS have private coverage and go to private hospitals... the public ones are scarry. Socialized health care is BAD for good quality!!!!!!
homeschoolmom Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='God Conquers' post='1141247' date='Dec 13 2006, 11:15 AM'] ya, you could just walk into a clinic off the street and get it done, no cost. (cause you already paid it in taxes) [/quote] but I already have no cost, (because I already paid for it in insurance)
God Conquers Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 Well see there ya go. But ya, wait times are bad sometimes. And there's a shortage of GPs. uh... and there's still "privilege". As if the PM would have to wait as long for knee surgery as my grandma.
Sojourner Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='God Conquers' post='1141258' date='Dec 13 2006, 10:44 AM'] =uh... and there's still "privilege". As if the PM would have to wait as long for knee surgery as my grandma. [/quote] we're all equal, but some are more equal than others ...
homeschoolmom Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1141259' date='Dec 13 2006, 11:45 AM'] we're all equal, but some are more equal than others ... [/quote] I really like that book.
MissScripture Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 From what I've heard, it's not the everyday stuff that is the problem. It's the surgeries and some diagnostic procedures. I've also heard that there's a severe lack of specialists, because they don't get paid any more than a regular doctor, so it's not really worth the extra schooling. Like I said, this is just what I've heard from people I know living in Canada. I also don't think Americans would be able to handle socialized medicine, because we are far too demanding. We like control over what's going on and I don't think you always get that in socialized medicine.
homeschoolmom Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 [quote name='God Conquers' post='1141258' date='Dec 13 2006, 11:44 AM'] And there's a shortage of GPs. [/quote] Do you have Family Practice there? It's a "specialty" of sorts.... they have extra training in geriatrics, pediatrics, obstetrics, phychology and internal medicine. (I think that's right.... ) Anyway, many of the FP doctors around here and no longer delivering babies (but they will see the mother for prenatal care) because the cost of malpractice insurance is outrageously high. So, it's now (almost) required to go to a specialist for a normal delivery.
God Conquers Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 Ya there are... just not enough of them. Specialists do get paid more here. The shortage is because medical schools are too elite and marks based instead of focused on choosing the right type of people for the job. And there are not enough family doctors b/c alot of the people are in it for the money, they want a 9-5 and don't want to be on call or responsible for patients.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 The Economist magazine recently had several articles of the problems of socialized medicine in England. Try there. I am currently recovering from surgery for a ruptured chest muscle. I called my GP on Tuesday, saw them on Wednesday, the surgeon on Thursday. If I could have cleared my schedule [ and I couldn't] my pre-op would have been Monday and the surgery on Wednesday. And I have lousy insurance. My Canadian and Brit friends assured me it would not have been that quick in their respective countries.
Sojourner Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 I've been researching universal health plans ... they are definitely sprouting up in states all over the US, since no federal plan has come through. Massachusetts was the first; they're requiring that all adults over age 18 have some form of health insurance by July 2007. Other states -- lots of them -- are exploring similar options, mixing state and federal funding. Several states are using Medicaid waivers -- expanding Medicaid services up a few steps on the income scale. I can see that it could definitely end up being a trade-off: people who otherwise would not have access to proper medical care because they lack insurance will be able to get access, but the care that's provided is lower than what people who have always had access are accustomed to being able to get. One interesting thing I've heard about, even before I started this research, is the effect that universal healthcare has on the pharmaceutical industry. Pharma research is funded by the huge prices they're able to charge for medications now; if that changes, then not as many advances will be able to be made. I have several friends working for a large pharmaceutical company in Indianapolis and they tell me that the U.S. has made many, many more medical discoveries than other countries because pharmaceutical companies are able to charge huge amounts for drugs. The trick is to ensure that everyone has access to adequate care without shutting down the opportunities for innovation, and without losing quality care in the increased volume.
missionseeker Posted December 13, 2006 Author Posted December 13, 2006 I thought I have heard of times in Europe where the government decided what medical proceedures would be done. There was one set of siamese twins and if they disconnected them one would die. the parents didn't want the to but the government made them do the surgery anyway. I'm not sure of all the details but I remeber hearing about it. Even if the government doesn't say what has to be done yet, isn't there a big risk that it will? I mean it distrubutes the money so it decides what gets done, right?
Groo the Wanderer Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 I personally find it amazing that any sane person want to trust the management and adminstration of healthcare to the govt. This is the same entity that pays $2000 for a toilet seat, loses my mail regularly, sends SSA retirement notices to my neighbor's dog, makes the instructions for filling out a personal tax return longer than those to import cantaloupes from Guatemala, champions the cause of mutant wood owls, but turns a blind eye to the life of the unborn. I just don't get it...
prose Posted December 13, 2006 Posted December 13, 2006 I like our system. I am comfortable knowing that I can get sick whenever and get the help I need. I am even more comfortable knowing that it isn't limited to just me because I am wealthy enough to afford insurance, but to everyone. Long waits, that happens. But from what I understand, that happens anywhere. I could have my babies in a private room in a hospital of my choice. That was nice. I never had to worry about cost. There are more benefits than non I think....
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now