Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Population Control


Recommended Posts

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

You can move this to Debate Table if you like for a discussion. But I just put it here for quick exposure. I have to answer this as part of my take home final for an environmental science class. I can do number 5 no problem, but I could REALLY use some help with the other four. Some advantages and disadvantages of this approach for each perspective. And it doesn't really matter if you don't think there are any advantages to population control. It's a liberal class and I have to come up with whatever a liberal answer would be. But I can't think of what it would be...


________________________________________________________________


In Part 3 of the course we discussed the impact of resource use on the environment. Specifically, we looked at how an unsustainable demand for resources due to increasing population can lead to conflict among people and with the environment. The most common means of addressing this issue is to determine ways to make resource use more efficient (eg, use vehicles with higher gas mileage). A less common but obvious alternative is to see how people can reverse the rate of population increase.

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of this approach (population control) using each of the following perspectives:

1) A democratically-elected Politician
2) A mother with a newborn child
3) A villager in sub-Saharan Africa
4) A U of A (or any university) student in the year 2050 AD
5) Your own perspective


(No repeating advantages and disadvantages among perspectives.)

Edited by goldenchild17
MissScripture
Posted

You probably wouldn't be able to use this and get a good grade, but here's my thought on an advantage: Those of us who don't believe in "population control" will soon rule the world, because the other people will control their population out of existence.

I know, I'm not of much help, but good luck with that.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Is it moral to help you with a final exam, take-home or otherwise?

Groo the Wanderer
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1141269' date='Dec 13 2006, 12:01 PM']
1) A democratically-elected Politician
2) A mother with a newborn child
3) A villager in sub-Saharan Africa
4) A U of A (or any university) student in the year 2050 AD
5) Your own perspective
[/quote]

1. shoot all the politicians
2. have the child raised Catholic
3. have her abstain until she is married
4. phaser death the liberal profs (method not the same as #1)
5. I do not believe in poulation control

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1141275' date='Dec 13 2006, 01:19 PM']
Is it moral to help you with a final exam, take-home or otherwise?
[/quote]

Sure I don't see why not. We have to look up all our answers on the internet. He said however we get the information is fine.

goldenchild17
Posted

I mean I understand the concept of how population control purportedly can be good to help conserve our resources. But I can't think of specific advantages and disadvantages in each of these situations (except the last one. I can do it from my perspective just fine.)

Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1141269' date='Dec 13 2006, 12:01 PM']
1) A democratically-elected Politician
2) A mother with a newborn child
3) A villager in sub-Saharan Africa
4) A U of A (or any university) student in the year 2050 AD
5) Your own perspective
(No repeating advantages and disadvantages among perspectives.)
[/quote]

1) Depends on his voting base. If they are rich and powerful, then population control will help him maintain his office. Why? Because population control, wherever it has existed, has [i]always[/i] been the control of the poor population by the rich. Fewer poor people, proportionally, means better election results. On the other hand, if the poor tend to be the ones who elect him, then he will have a selfish interest in not limiting their numbers.

2) Disadvantage: As someone whose whole heart is wrapped up in completely defenseless person, she should be concerned to make the world a place where such persons are cherished and welcomed. A world where babies are seen as "little threats to the environment" (Janet Smith's phrase) is not a good world for her child. In addition, more people will usually mean a stronger economy, and that means more comfort, more security, and better medicine for her child in the future. Advantage: in the case of economic depression, more people would probably make it more difficult for her child to find work, and would worsen the inflation of food prices.

3) Disadvantage: These communities tend to survive by subsistence farming. That means more people, more labor, more specialization, more efficiency, more food for everyone. In other words, three people can grow more than three times as much food as one person. Furthermore, the constant threat of epidemic, war, and famine means that population decimation could happen anytime. Survival will be difficult if the population is barely at sustenance level already. Advantage: In the case of such a famine, food stores will be depleted more slowly. (this is really BS, since more people could generate larger food stores to begin with).

4) Hard to make a helpful generalization about this group...speculative to the point of uselessness in my opinion. In other words, I can't think of anything!

5) I like people. I believe that human labor is creative; that we actually generate wealth by our work. This is obvious. However, population control people (and democratic financial policy) seem to assume that wealth is a zero-sum game. If somebody gets wealthier, than somebody else must have gotten poorer. That translates to other people being threats, rather than partners. An example of why this is foolish: Bill Gates has made all of our lives better. His vast wealth was not taken from other people who are now poor; rather, he found a way to make the world a much wealthier and more productive place in general.

There may come a time when our ability to generate food is outstripped by the Earth's population. At that time, it will be our responsibility to use moral means of limiting our families. JPII himself said in Crossing the Threshold of Hope that prudence in family size is a moral responsibility! But we're nowhere NEAR that point yet, in my opinion. People starve because of selfishness and corruption, not because we can't grow enough food. There are mountains of wheat left to rot every year in the Heartland. We still pay farmers NOT to grow crops.

Meanwhile, there are more AIDS orphans in Uganda every minute, and our ridiculous litigation-driven overuse of antibiotics makes it a real possibility that we'll all start dying of TB again soon. And yet, here we have these filthy rich white guys (Ted Turner, Bill Gates) who are donating TEN-FIGURE sums to stop poor brown and black people from reproducing. I believe their intentions are good...but isn't there something awful sinister about this?

wow, sorry...end of rant. I need to cut down on the coffee.

goldenchild17
Posted

No, ranting is fine :). That helped a lot. Thanks. I can work with that quite a bit. I don't necessarily think that the earth will ever be completely stripped of it's resources, but that's not really the point :). THanks.

Posted

[size=1]"Save the trees, get an abortion"
[/size]

goldenchild17
Posted

That's basically what they're getting at I know :).

Posted

[quote name='CrossCuT' post='1141397' date='Dec 13 2006, 02:50 PM']
[size=1]"Save the trees, get an abortion"
[/size]
[/quote]


But, there are more trees in North America now then there was when Europeans landed. I just don't get it! :idontknow:

Posted

oooh, if I had this as an assignment I sure would give that professor a mouthful!

although I think it's really dumb that you can't repeat advantages or disadvantages for any of the people. the thing about it is, population control doesn't have a different effect on each person, it affects the entire human community. I really don't quite feel right giving you specific suggestions for a take home exam though... :unsure:

You could always look up what others have said about advantages and disadvantages for particular groups of people though - I'm sure there's a lot of that out there for the advantages. The disadvantages - for each you could focus on a different aspect of how killing people/artificially limiting births is dehumanizing. Also, don't forget to mention how of course it is important for a family to be responsible and not simply make babies regardless of material support for these children, but conventional "population control" methods are not needed for this to occur. :)

Just a few ideas....

Posted (edited)

I always thought that homosexuality was a way of population control, for they can not produce kids.

Edited by desertwoman
goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='morostheos' post='1141671' date='Dec 13 2006, 08:09 PM']
oooh, if I had this as an assignment I sure would give that professor a mouthful!

although I think it's really dumb that you can't repeat advantages or disadvantages for any of the people. the thing about it is, population control doesn't have a different effect on each person, it affects the entire human community. I really don't quite feel right giving you specific suggestions for a take home exam though... :unsure:

You could always look up what others have said about advantages and disadvantages for particular groups of people though - I'm sure there's a lot of that out there for the advantages. The disadvantages - for each you could focus on a different aspect of how killing people/artificially limiting births is dehumanizing. Also, don't forget to mention how of course it is important for a family to be responsible and not simply make babies regardless of material support for these children, but conventional "population control" methods are not needed for this to occur. :)

Just a few ideas....
[/quote]

Hey don't worry about it. This is only one question among many on my final and we were supposed to go out and find the answer however we could. I have a few leads though so I'm good. And honestly I don't think I will go into the whole idea of natural "moral" family control. I can't support NFP or Rythm or anything like that so that wouldn't really work for me.

But thanks for the ideas guys, you did good :cool: .

[quote name='desertwoman' post='1141688' date='Dec 13 2006, 08:29 PM']
I always thought that homosexuality was a way of population control, for they can not produce kids.
[/quote]

Yeah, quite effective it is. :mellow:

Posted

lol. that and greed, selfishness, and pride... oh yeah, lack of patience.

goldenchild17
Posted

Okay, well I totally overstepped my paragraph per answer, but at this point it doesn't matter. Let me know what you think. What can I tweak, what do I need to completely restart? Thanks:
p.s. if you haven't noticed I completely ditched the liberal answer they are looking for :). Maybe it'll hurt me. We'll see.

1. The advantages and disadvantages of population control in eyes of a democratically-elected Politician can vary depending upon which side of the fence the individual in question is playing for. For one politician it would be advantageous in that his constituents would support him in his efforts to protect the environment and provide a future for later generations. For many of the constituents it would also give them a reason to support practices such as abortion, euthanasia, birth control etc. However the very thing that is to his advantage would be also his disadvantage because in supporting such measures to control the population he would then lose support from many people who are against such an idea. Of course this would depend on how far he took it. If he restricted it to a practice such as birth control, then it might not be considered such a high price. However if he really wanted to reduce population growth in a major way he could go to the other extreme of infanticide, euthanasia, and forced child-limits (such as those in China). The advantage of supporting population control is that one can see a highly effective way to treat the problem of disappearing resources. But in doing this, he creates his disadvantage, many do not see such a practice as morally stable.

2.) A mother with a newborn child can see advantages to population control. Such a measure could provide her and her child with the provisions they need to survive which they otherwise might not have been able to get. She would be much more able to sufficiently support just the two of them, if more children are not to be had. As the population decreases due to the measures, the mother can see a brighter future for her child who will have less competition when (s)he grows up and has to provide for herself. On the other hand, when she looks at her child she realizes that her baby will not have the brothers and sisters that she grew up with. She realizes that as she holds her child, that she cannot support the deaths of millions of unborn babies just so that the rest can live comfortably. She is not able to accept that so many, unborn children and elderly alike have to be put to death, just so that the rest can be happy. No man should prosper because of another man’s suffering.

3.) A villager in sub-Saharan Africa might welcome methods of population control. Many in such a person’s situation are living at a mere existence level and there would be no way to feed all the extra children running around resulting from unprotected intercourse. These extra children are just extra mouths to feed and are taking up resources that should be left to those who work for them. However, from the other perspective, a villager such as our example will eventually age and become unable to care for himself, be unable to gather the food that he needs to live. At this time he is going to wish that he had children who could take care of him. With population control methods in place, he is able to feed himself for a time but not forever. If he had children he would initially have to give a little. Yet, before long his children will grow and be able to contribute to gathering resources for survival, many ready to help at quite a young age. These children will then be able to care for their father in his old age, just as he did for them when they were young.

4.) For a University of Arizona student living in the year 2050, if these population control methods are put into place today, he would be in a nice position as the population should already see a decrease. There will be less competition and more food and other supplies to go around for all of those who lived until then. Life would be looking good. Less people, no children for the student to look after or plan for after he graduates. He could put his money into savings. Or could he? There is one problem with this. Not only are there fewer young people coming along the way, but the population is now aging. As people get older and retire they will want to collect their social security checks. Who pays for that? The college student will pay for this for many years. With more and more seniors than ever, his taxes will continue to increase. You are bitter that you have to pay for their comfort. More and more of his fellow students feel the same way, until they’ve had enough and clamor for the institution of more euthanasia/assisted suicide practices to be enforced. It becomes a vicious cycle. Without the children coming behind them the pressure falls on fewer and fewer citizens to split the tax for government programs such as social security.

5.) Now for my perspective, although I think I may have given that away slightly in some of the above responses. I honestly cannot think of one worthy advantage that population control would bring to me. It is completely unnecessary and even harmful to the betterment of mankind. From an environmental standpoint, we still have resources available to us. If necessary we can drill in places that we would like not to, such as ANWR. This isn’t the ideal situation, but if the resources are available then we can use them. We are a smart people, we have been exploring alternative methods of energy usage and conservation for years. From solar panels to windmills to changing the lightbulbs in your house and keeping your car in tune, all of these things are ways that we can help conserve energy.

I do not believe that we would have been put on this earth if there were not the sufficient means for sustaining us during our time here, no matter how long. I think we have been given this earth for our use, not our abuse. I think many countries, especially the United States, have gotten far too carried away in its abuse of fossil fuels. There is absolutely no reason for us to be wasting as much as we are on many things that are, frankly, not that important.

I guess I can think of one advantage to population control and it is this, we will be able to keep our entertainments. We have everything a person could want: big screen tv’s, state of the art entertainment systems, you name it we’ve got it. Just imagine how much gasoline is being used in all of those NASCAR races. Think about how much food goes to waste in all of our restaurants, companies throwing away food that is no more than fifteen minutes old. Now, I’m not saying that any of these things, NASCAR and Burger King are bad things, not at all. But is it really worth it to kill unborn children through abortion, prevent young couples from starting a happy family because of birth control requirements, institute euthanasia/assisted suicide of those who happen to be a “drain on our society” at an old age, just so that we can continue to indulge in our pleasures? If so, then we as a society as far more gone than I could have ever imagined.

No, there are still many things that we can and must do before such an awful idea even comes into our minds. Use what we have more efficiently, cut back (notice I don’t say eliminate completely) on those pleasures in life that aren’t crucial for a happy life. Put our best scientists and researchers to work to find new and better sources of energy. I put my support fully behind any and all of these measures, but, being the oldest of nine children, support such practices as those that would eliminate happy families like mine, that I cannot do.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...