Era Might Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 How would you respond to this (common) objection to God and/or religion, that religion has led to the deaths of millions?
EcceNovaFacioOmni Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 First I would ask for some background information about this belief that religion has led to millions of deaths. Which religion? Exactly how many? It seems like a very broad claim to make. I would then bring up Nazism, Communism, various revolutions, wars, and abortion as being far more deadly.
thessalonian Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 "I did not come to bring peace, but the sword". In fact, religion (including aethism) is probably the cause of most of the worlds violence. That does not make the pursuit of truth a waste of time, nor does it mean that there is no truth.
Red Knight Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 [quote name='thedude' post='1142459' date='Dec 14 2006, 05:21 PM'] First I would ask for some background information about this belief that religion has led to millions of deaths. Which religion? Exactly how many? It seems like a very broad claim to make. I would then bring up Nazism, Communism, various revolutions, wars, and abortion as being far more deadly. [/quote] Good call.
avemaria40 Posted December 14, 2006 Posted December 14, 2006 I'd also bring up Ghandi, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., Mother Teresa, the children of Fatima, and many missionaries.
beatty07 Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 "Religion has led to the death of millions" is almost certainly true." "Religion is responsible for most of the problems in the world" can only be uttered from either staggering ignorance or willful deceit. We should give people the benefit of the doubt and assume the former. So I agree with some above that a gentle educational nudge is in order. Just remind them of the death toll: Chinese communism (atheist utopianism): 50 million? We'll never know. Soviet communism (atheist utopianism): 20-30 million? We'll REALLY never know. National Socialim (atheist utopianism): 12 million + WWII That's a good start. It's surprising that we can get through grammar school history without realizing how utterly terrible the 20th century was. The word "bloodbath" comes to mind. This doesn't get across, in my opinion, because so many of us have this ridiculous dogmatic faith in "progress."
Era Might Posted December 15, 2006 Author Posted December 15, 2006 I have a hard time responding to people about sinners in the Church. If someone brings up an issue of whether this or that doctrine is true, I can deal with it from a solid source: Divine revelation. But when someone brings up sin in the Church, and particularly the clergy sexual abuse scandals, I feel like I go speechless. I don't know how to explain to someone that the Church is the Church despite the sinfulness of her children. I have this sad feeling because something like that would keep someone from seeing the Church as the Mystical Body of Christ; it's not a doctrine that's hard to swallow, it's something that could have been prevented if we were faithful to Our Lord. It's hard to put it into context without sounding like I'm excusing it or not taking it seriously enough; people see the Church as a thoroughly corrupt and evil institution.
kujo Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 [quote name='Era Might' post='1142919' date='Dec 15 2006, 11:24 AM'] I have a hard time responding to people about sinners in the Church. If someone brings up an issue of whether this or that doctrine is true, I can deal with it from a solid source: Divine revelation. But when someone brings up sin in the Church, and particularly the clergy sexual abuse scandals, I feel like I go speechless. I don't know how to explain to someone that the Church is the Church despite the sinfulness of her children. I have this sad feeling because something like that would keep someone from seeing the Church as the Mystical Body of Christ; it's not a doctrine that's hard to swallow, it's something that could have been prevented if we were faithful to Our Lord. It's hard to put it into context without sounding like I'm excusing it or not taking it seriously enough; people see the Church as a thoroughly corrupt and evil institution. [/quote] Someone once told me that the Church is our Mother. But they didn't mean it in the usual sense; rather, this person said that the Church is like our actual earthly mother, the woman who birthed us. She is beautiful, loving, consoling and wants the best for us. God has given her to us to be our guiding light and we are to honor her. But here's the crux of what this person was saying... Our moms aren't perfect. They sin, they make mistakes, and we'll inevitably have disagreements with her. But none of that takes away from her mom-ness. Furthermore, we are called, as sons and daughters, to [i]love our mothers despite and because of her imperfections.[/i] I think that takes care of the human side of the Church. We are to love our Catholic Church, even when Her members screw up. Nothing anybody can do will take away from its God-given authority (Matthew 16:18). I hope this helps, Era.
Groo the Wanderer Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 I would have to modify that to say "Ignorant people, not following the tenets of their respective faiths have, in the name of religion, caused the deaths of millions." Religion did not cause any deaths. People did. The corrolary is "People failing to form a moral center because of a lack of religion, or in failing to follow the tenets of thier faiths, have also caused the deaths of millions." This would encompass the abortion industry as well...
kujo Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 Stupid people do stupid things. Most of what you're talking about falls within that statement. Stupid people (manipulated by religion and/or false theology) do stupid things (such as murder which is pretty much a violation of every organized religion). I know it's more complicated than that but that's my 2 cents.
jswranch Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 Share the story of some Christian martyrs killed by anti-religion movements.
peach_cube Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 Power and Greed is the cause of all problems, it can infiltrate religion, but it is not limited to it.
N/A Gone Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 weird Era...we were both asked this same question
desertwoman Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 You can look at any culture and see the same thing. It's not a religion thing, but a sin thing... a man thing. If there wasn't any religion, man would still kill, rob, thieve, and the like because he can and wants to for man is a despicable creature at the root. Why do bullies bull other people around. Is it cause of religion? Why do robbers steal, is it cause of religion? Why do rapist prey on the innocent, is it cause of religion? When any one of these people get into power, they will continue to do the same things for this is their nature. Instead of the person saying that they are doing it because of God, they are doing it for their own perverted reasons. Look at all the monstrosities that occurred and religion was not even a part of. (This is something I've been thinking about for awhile... so if it sounds like a stream of consciousness it is)Plus, if religion is man made according to atheists, than man is at the root of the problem to begin with anyway. Why would a man tell you to kill someone else if there is no God? Why would he do that? Did the person who started religion actually believe that there is a God, or did he/she do it just to control people like many free thinkers believe? Does this make them like politicians? Do they just want power, and status? More later on when I get something to drink.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now