thessalonian Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 I am currently reading this book. A lutheran friend lent it to me. It started out good in comparing what Catholics and Evangelicals have in common. There were good discussions on what we have in common on the Bible, trinity, etc. but went downhill from their. For instance it accuses Patrick Madrid of saying that Tradition is more reliable than scripture from a quote from his magazine which is exagerated. Then later broadbrushes this to be the view of all Catholic Apologists and the Church. Very sad. He takes the Catholic counterings of Protestant reasons for rejecting the Apocrypah (i.e. protestants say that the apocrypha aren't quoted, we counter with other books aren't quoted and the Septuagint is quoted by Jesus and the Apostles) out of the context in which they are intended. They are not main arguements and proofs but counters for weak arguements from Protestants. In general it raises the Catholic case in a way that makes it look weak and illogical and then knocks it down. I'll be reading more and saying more in the days to come. But here are some pretty good refutations of the book. [url="http://www.geocities.com/rick_g22/biblefil.html#2B"]http://www.geocities.com/rick_g22/biblefil.html#2B[/url]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 What a delightful string of strawman fallacies. One of the priests at my parish was an evangelical, atheist (I think he said that), fundamentalist, Anglican (an Anglican priest), and is finally now a Catholic priest (a married one, no less)...he's great for getting the truth behind some of the Protestant arguments and it sounds like this sort of reasoning is fairly common. He works with lots of Catholic organizations: [url="http://www.catholic.com/media/ryland.asp"]http://www.catholic.com/media/ryland.asp[/url] I'd recommend some of his books be loaned to your Lutheran friend.
RonRule Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 I loaned my Father-in-Law, who is Reformed Baptist, Keating's [b]Catholicism and Fundamentalism[/b], and [b]Surprised by Truth[/b]. Couple weeks ago I noticed he was reading Keating along with the book you mention. He hasn't brought up his opinion on either to me. I know he's also read some ECF's lately. Pray for him, if you would.
N/A Gone Posted December 15, 2006 Posted December 15, 2006 I bought and read this book at the start of my trip and the lack of charity convinced me that the evangelical people do not only lack any proper answers, but lack the unity to develop any proper answers. Geisler is a great systematic theologian, but he is an idiot here.
thessalonian Posted December 16, 2006 Author Posted December 16, 2006 He makes the statement at one point that the Catholic Church is as much devided than Protestantism. Then justifies it with all the dissenters out there. Comparing them to liberal protestants. But then theirs is the whole other group that are not liberal and subscibe to a host of beliefs "Biblical" about baptism, the Lord's Supper, soterology, i.e. Once Saved Always Saved, Arminianism, 5 pt. Calvinism, potential loss of salvation, varying levels of church authority and government, pentecostalism (Geisler says that miracles ceased), etc. etc. etc.. He says "oh but we agree on the essentials". Whose essentials. I've seen those who say belief in Jesus is essential (and say that non-trinitarians can be saved), lists of 6, 10, 20, and 100, essential Christian doctrines. In general he throws out shotgun blasts of objections and inserts his own confusion about the doctrines. Then uses it for justification for believing anything you want as long as you don't disagree with some list of 10 things he thinks are essential. On the canon he says the early church did not judge it. They were a witness to it. Distinction without a difference. They came up with a canon from a pile of books. We accept their New Testament canon but say they made a mistake on the Old Testament. So in other words we cannot say they were infallible on the New Testament either and somehow the Jews were infallible on the Old Testament after the New Testament times had started. But they are among the damned and unregenerate. Very odd. He glosses over the reasons why the papacy is wrong, gives a few, adds some straw men and then procedes to bowl it over. Pretty sad. No question Peter was the head of the Apostles and if you read Is 22 and see how it parrellels Matt 16:18 it is not to be doudted that there was succession. Not to mention it is historically provable. He put his blinders on with regard to history. Then does the usual Honorius arguements. I can never figure out how they only have one or two very borderline possibilities where infallibility could be questioned and they think they have a case. Two or three questionable incidents in 2000 years! And of course they have to throw out the rules of Vatican II to make a case against them. Then he says infallibility is unimportant because it has only been used a few times. What he fails to note is that it has been used by every pope in the statements they did not make that would contradict Church teaching had they made them. If one traces and understands the teaching of the popes for instance on slavery they were incredibly consistent in the matter on what they did say and never once proclaimed a contradiction to official Church teaching. Ron, I will pray for you FIL. I could go on and probalby will later.
thessalonian Posted December 21, 2006 Author Posted December 21, 2006 I was thinking about Geisler and Meckenzie’s argument that the Pope and Bishops are not successors of the apostles this morning on the way in to work. He bases this on the reasoning that because they don’t do miracles, they don’t write scriptures, they are not direct witnesses to Christ, and a few other reasons I can’t recall off the top of my head, they are not successors of the Apostles. Well I guess I would respond in saying that they are not Apostles. They are successors of the Apostles. There is a difference. The difference can be seen in the founding fathers of this country. They helped fight the revolutionary war, They wrote the Constitution, the signed it as witnesses, they voted on it, and some went on to run the government. There were presidents and congressman and Senators after them who were not writers of the constitution, they did not sign it as witnesses and vote on it, they did not fight the war. Yet we can certainly say they are successors because their power and authority was laid down and legitimized by what those founding fathers did. Anyone who asserts authority outside of what the founding fathers established as the organization of the US Government is not to be listened to and many times will be imprisoned. There may even be a war over it as there was in the cival war. Now somehow we are to believe that those left by the Apostles are not successors in a like manner. Some protestants will even say that a Church governing system was not established by scripture and so the various forms of church government by all the denominations are just fine. Yet we know that the Apostles did choose men to run the Church that was founded by Christ through them. They had to have had a means of choosing those who would succeed those whom they had chosen. Thoughts
LouisvilleFan Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 Stepping aside for a second, and having read a good bit of both Catholic and Reformed/Calvinist/Baptist apologetics during my whole searching phase, I think it's interesting how each side considers the other side to be complete unreasonable and unbiblical. It's almost funny.
thessalonian Posted December 21, 2006 Author Posted December 21, 2006 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1147082' date='Dec 21 2006, 05:18 PM'] Stepping aside for a second, and having read a good bit of both Catholic and Reformed/Calvinist/Baptist apologetics during my whole searching phase, I think it's interesting how each side considers the other side to be complete unreasonable and unbiblical. It's almost funny. [/quote] Actually I don't consider Geisler compeltely unreasonable and unbiblical. That is a misinterpretation of what I have said in this thread. Some things he says are unbiblical and I point those out. That does not however mean I don't agree with him in full or in part on many things and I do.
N/A Gone Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 yea, I own Geisler systematic theology(part 1 and 2) I think he is a brillant theologian, as I have said earlier in this post. But he is just wrong here. Often times a quality protestant theologian can bring great gifts and understanding to an issue, but when it comes to catholicism they will jsut be dead wrong. Sometimes it is bizarre, other times I just shake it of
Ziggamafu Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 I would like to create a website that promotes a target of 3,000 faithful Catholics dedicating themselves to a daily prayer for Geisler's full conversion. What a blessing it would be to bring well known evangelists like Geisler, McDowell, Strobel, White, and more into the fold of the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church of Christ!
LouisvilleFan Posted December 25, 2006 Posted December 25, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1147115' date='Dec 21 2006, 07:12 PM'] yea, I own Geisler systematic theology(part 1 and 2) I think he is a brillant theologian, as I have said earlier in this post. But he is just wrong here. Often times a quality protestant theologian can bring great gifts and understanding to an issue, but when it comes to catholicism they will jsut be dead wrong. Sometimes it is bizarre, other times I just shake it of [/quote] I've read quite a bit of Wayne Grudem's "Systematic Theology" halfway out of curiousity and halfway to have a reason to talk theology with this cute Baptist friend of mine. It's amazing how there seems to be few authoritative answers in his book. The Catholic Catechism tells you exactly what's up, but Grudem's book is like, "you could do it this way... or that way... or maybe something else... pretty much anything that you can pull out of the Bible." However, I know another Baptist seminarian who also isn't a big fan of Grudem's book and maybe that's part of the reason why. One thing that really surprised me was his criticism of the Catholic Church's prohibition of contraception. He says it causes division, feelings of guilt, and even broken marriages! I pointed out to my Baptist friend that every testimony I've heard states exactly the opposite... and she actually agreed with me, at least as far as contraception's side effects. [quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1147595' date='Dec 22 2006, 10:13 PM'] I would like to create a website that promotes a target of 3,000 faithful Catholics dedicating themselves to a daily prayer for Geisler's full conversion. What a blessing it would be to bring well known evangelists like Geisler, McDowell, Strobel, White, and more into the fold of the One, Holy, Catholic, and Apostolic Church of Christ! [/quote] That's a pretty darn cool idea. Of course, given the individualized nature of Protestantism, most people would just write them off as either predisposed (or predestined ) with some tendency towards sacramental theology or simply fallen off the deep end. However, such an event couldn't help but get some peoples' attention. How about taking that idea a bit further... let's get 3,000 Christians praying for Osama bin Laden's conversion! Now [i]that[/i] would turn some heads!
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now