jswranch Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 From a diologue with a charitable, educated, and logical Reformed prot. [quote]John, What you explained still sounds the same as what I have said before. Christ's death has allowed you to save yourself. At justification the slate is wiped clean, but after that you can incur new penalities for which YOU must now expiate. So it seems Christ's work on the cross was only the payment of original sin and any sin that occurred b/w birth and justification (which is really shortly at birth since in your Church Baptism confers justification) and after that you are on your own so to say. Again, the ultimate ability to actually make it to heaven when you die is dependent on you. Christ may have given you a kick-start and may even help you along the way, but ultimately you are responsible for crossing the finish line. That means your salvation is not based on Christ alone, but on some combination of you and Christ. And that then means that Christ's death was not sufficient to save you since you believe that some who start the race (with Christ) will eventually fall away. Yes, you cannot save yourself without Christ, but if you can lose your salvation even though Christ was involved at some point, then your salvation is ultimately dependent on you. [/quote] Without further research and guidance, the best I could hope for is a 3rd grade confirmation explanation of infused grace, imbued righteousness.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 [quote name='jswranch' post='1145045' date='Dec 18 2006, 02:37 PM'] At justification the slate is wiped clean, but after that you can incur new penalities for which YOU must now expiate. So it seems Christ's work on the cross was only the payment of original sin and any sin that occurred b/w birth and justification (which is really shortly at birth since in your Church Baptism confers justification) and after that you are on your own so to say. [/quote] Incorrect. We are justified by cooperating with the grace that comes from Jesus Christ (we can't be saved without cooperating...that would be God forcing His grace on us). It is therefore the grace which justifies us and our cooperation which allows the grace to work within us. Now, penance that we do after Baptism is our cooperation with grace. Grace helps us to make room for itself in our souls (cooperation). However, as before, it is still the presence of grace that saves. Since all grace comes from the Cross, it is still Christ who saves. However, we must cooperate. Anyone who says we don't need to cooperate denies that humans have a choice in being saved. [quote]Again, the ultimate ability to actually make it to heaven when you die is dependent on you. Christ may have given you a kick-start and may even help you along the way, but ultimately you are responsible for crossing the finish line. [/quote] Well, it depends on how you define "ultimate." I would say that Christ ultimately is the one who saves us because He did the saving, we simply do the cooperating. Naturally, however, we can reject grace...and if that means that we're ultimately responsible, then I suppose we're ultimately responsible. As for crossing the finishing line, it seems to me that St. Paul told his followers to finish the race and to compete so as to win...I'm pretty certain that he meant it. Now, if we weren't supposed to be responsible for crossing the finishing line, why would he tell us to do so. If it was just Christ's responsibility, why would he even bother addressing us on that? [quote]That means your salvation is not based on Christ alone, but on some combination of you and Christ. And that then means that Christ's death was not sufficient to save you since you believe that some who start the race (with Christ) will eventually fall away.[/quote] St. Paul says that some will fall away. We can't just make up our theology based on what seems right to us. God has revealed that we can fall away after starting the race. Naturally, we have to cooperate with Christ's work in us...otherwise, Christ, by saving us, would be violating our free will and thus our human dignity. Since God gave us our human dignity, it would make little sense for Him to violate it. [quote]Yes, you cannot save yourself without Christ, but if you can lose your salvation even though Christ was involved at some point, then your salvation is ultimately dependent on you. [/quote] Well, yes...if we can accept it, it is somewhat dependent on our choice to accept it or to deny it. That does not, however, mean that man saves himself. Christ saves man. If you are dangling off a cliff and someone holds out his hand, you have to take his hand if you want to live. Once you have done so, would you say that you saved yourself or that the man holding out his hand saved you? I suppose you could make the case that you both saved you, but it seems clear that one really did the saving act and the other just cooperated with it in order to be saved.
beatty07 Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 (edited) Well, a good deal of that is quite true. Of course our salvation depends partly on us. Romans 2:6-8, Romans 6:15-19, we could go on and on. Matthew 25:31-46 could hardly be more clear. Romans 3:20-26 is sometimes thrown up as though it contradicts the rest. It doesn't, we believe both. They're BOTH true. Salvation is unmerited and a free gift of grace, AND works have something to do with it. It's entirely by Christ's grace and merit, AND we must cooperate in some way. Your friend's statement leads straight to the conclusion that anyone who goes to Hell is there because Christ failed to save them, or maybe could have but didn't want to. What happened to God is love? What happened to "God wills that all be saved?" The Scriptures are clear that God wills that all be saved, and yet our salvation depends partly on us. Your friend surely agrees. Perhaps he or she says we are justified by faith, not works. Whose faith? If it's not really ours, then on what possible basis does God judge us? And if it is ours, then we're admitting that salvation depends partly on us. Regarding post-Baptismal sin, your friend is arguing against a position that no one really holds. Of course it is in Christ that all our sins are forgiven. But we can cooperate in our flesh with Christ's redemption, always in grace. It's not a question of me atoning for some sins and Christ atoning for others...that's silly. It's a question of cooperating in His work (Col 1:24). Does Paul mean that Christ's suffering was insufficient? He can't. But neither does he mean nothing. He must mean that our lives and Christ's atonement can cooperate. Grace can do that! This is the Council of Trent, 6th session, and really sums it up. Notice how human freedom and complete dependence on grace are both present: CANON I.-If any one saith, that man may be justified before God by his own works, whether done through the teaching of human nature, or that of the law, without the grace of God through Jesus Christ; let him be anathema. CANON II.-If any one saith, that the grace of God, through Jesus Christ, is given only for this, that man may be able more easily to live justly, and to merit eternal life, as if, by free will without grace, he were able to do both, though hardly indeed and with difficulty; let him be anathema. CANON III.-If any one saith, that without the prevenient inspiration of the Holy Ghost, and without his help, man can believe, hope, love, or be penitent as he ought, so as that the grace of Justification may be bestowed upon him; let him be anathema. CANON IV. If any one shall affirm, that man’s freewill, moved and excited by God, does not, by consenting, cooperate with God, the mover and exciter, so as to prepare and dispose itself for the attainment of justification; if moreover, anyone shall say, that the human will cannot refuse complying, if it pleases, but that it is inactive, and merely passive; let such an one be accursed"! Denial of I-III makes us "saved by our own works" Pelagian heretics. Denial of IV makes us robots and renders our choices and lives ultimately meaningless. Acknowledge your friends' concerns: that is really, really is important not to think you are earning salvation, or that your works can ever merit heaven. He or she is right to be concerned about that. But the answer must not set Scripture aside; somehow a synthesis must hold both together - all is grace, AND human freedom - without dropping either. Keep insisting on Matthew 25 and watch the intellectual acrobatics that ensue as your reformed friend argues that it doesn't mean what it obviously means. One final thought, remember the Parable of the Sower in Luke 8. Your friend is only allowing for two possibilities (the good seed and the trampled)... the truth is a little less simplistic. Hope you get a better answer, but anyhow there's a few thoughts. [edit: a lot of this is redundant with Raphael's post, not to mention less clear... sorry, we were typing at the same time I guess.] Edited December 18, 2006 by beatty07
sweetpea316 Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 jackpot! I'm discussing this same type of thing with someone and this will be very very helpful. thanks guys.
sweetpea316 Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 I've been in a similar discussion about justification and was faced with a section from the Council of Trent. Canon IX- If anyone saith, that by faith alone the impious is justified; in such wise as to mean, that nothing else is required to co-operate in order to the obtaining the grace of justification, and that it is not in any way necessary, that he be prepared and disposed by the movement of his own will; let him be anathema. Can someone explain this? I somewhat understand it, but the wording of it all kinda confuses me. Thanks.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 [quote name='sweetpea316' post='1145654' date='Dec 19 2006, 05:16 PM'] I've been in a similar discussion about justification and was faced with a section from the Council of Trent. Canon IX- If anyone saith, that by faith alone the impious is justified; in such wise as to mean, that nothing else is required to co-operate in order to the obtaining the grace of justification, and that it is not in any way necessary, that he be prepared and disposed by the movement of his own will; let him be anathema. Can someone explain this? I somewhat understand it, but the wording of it all kinda confuses me. Thanks. [/quote] In laymen's terms: If anyone says that faith alone justifies, that is, that cooperation with grace is not required with justification, and that cooperation is completely unnecessary, but that merely a movement of will and not an act of cooperation based on it (i.e. willing to be saved, but not acting in accordance with that will), let him be anathema.
beatty07 Posted December 20, 2006 Posted December 20, 2006 yep. Think of it in terms of Matthew 7:21-23: Not every one who says to me, ‘Lord, Lord,’ shall enter the kingdom of heaven, but he who does the will of my Father who is in heaven. 22 On that day many will say to me, ‘Lord, Lord, did we not prophesy in your name, and cast out demons in your name, and do many mighty works in your name?’ 23 And then will I declare to them, ‘I never knew you; depart from me, you evildoers.’ and also good old James 2:14-17... 14 What does it profit, my brethren, if a man says he has faith but has not works? Can his faith save him? 15 If a brother or sister is ill-clad and in lack of daily food, 16 and one of you says to them, “Go in peace, be warmed and filled,” without giving them the things needed for the body, what does it profit? 17 So faith by itself, if it has no works, is dead. The Lord's words in Matthew are particularly scary. On one hand, they show that works don't mean everything... people who prophesy, cast out demons, and do mighty works in Jesus' name can still go to Hell? Wow. But it's also not enough to just say "Lord, Lord." You must DO the will of the Father. So the Trent Fathers are saying that it's erroneous and dangerous to think that simply having "faith", without any transformation in one's life, can save you. They make a very sly move here; they're implying that when Luther says "justified by 'faith'", he is really saying we save ourselves by "the movement of our own will." See how they turn the tables on Luther? If you say "I accept Jesus Christ as my personal Lord and Savior", for example, that's a work! It's your will, your belief, your action. That's not enough to save you either! That's "cheap grace," not life-transforming, world-transforming, kingdom-bringing grace.
sweetpea316 Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 Thanks guys. That's very helpful. My next question about justification is... As a Lutheran, justification was defined as 'God declaring us not guilty of our sins' and we were given the example of being declared not guilty in a courtroom, which makes it seem like a one time thing that happens when we come to faith in Christ. But then the Catholic view is that it's 'the action of God's grace by which we are freed from sin and made holy' which seems to combine justification and sanctification. Is this accurate? Being actually transformed, rather than the whole 'dung covered in snow' thing? Also...throughout Scripture 'saved' is used in a past, present, and future sense. Would it be incorrect to substitute the word justified for saved? Would the past tense refer to when we were initially saved by Christ through His death on the cross? What exactly are the present and future usages referring to? Some examples for each would be... past- Romans 8:24, 2 Tim 1:9, Tit 3:5 present- 1 Cor 1:18, 1 Cor 15:2, Phil 2:12, 1 Pet 2:1-2 future- Rom 5:9, Matt 10:22, Matt 24:13 Thanks so much. I'm having a hard time wrapping my brain around all of this but really want to understand it and explain it to others too.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 [quote name='sweetpea316' post='1147036' date='Dec 21 2006, 03:14 PM'] Thanks guys. That's very helpful. My next question about justification is... As a Lutheran, justification was defined as 'God declaring us not guilty of our sins' and we were given the example of being declared not guilty in a courtroom, which makes it seem like a one time thing that happens when we come to faith in Christ. But then the Catholic view is that it's 'the action of God's grace by which we are freed from sin and made holy' which seems to combine justification and sanctification. Is this accurate? Being actually transformed, rather than the whole 'dung covered in snow' thing? Also...throughout Scripture 'saved' is used in a past, present, and future sense. Would it be incorrect to substitute the word justified for saved? Would the past tense refer to when we were initially saved by Christ through His death on the cross? What exactly are the present and future usages referring to? Some examples for each would be... past- Romans 8:24, 2 Tim 1:9, Tit 3:5 present- 1 Cor 1:18, 1 Cor 15:2, Phil 2:12, 1 Pet 2:1-2 future- Rom 5:9, Matt 10:22, Matt 24:13 Thanks so much. I'm having a hard time wrapping my brain around all of this but really want to understand it and explain it to others too. [/quote] Grace regenerates us, that is, it gives us new birth and therefore renews us. Protestants have the idea that we are guilty, but that God finds us not guilty because Christ paid the debt for us. Catholics know that this can't be, because it would require God to be unjust (releasing the guilty) in favor of being merciful. Rather, we know that mercy and justice are not opposed. Christ came in mercy to die for our sins to repay God for humanity's offenses in justice. Christ therefore died by offering Himself completely to the Father and was saved from death in the Resurrection. His salvation cannot merely be attributed to us as a whole. All of humanity offends God and Christ redeemed all humanity, but not each and every human accepts that...some reject that salvation. The individual has to accept it in order for God to look at him/her and see him/her as righteous. So far, Catholics and most Protestants would agree. The problem arises when Protestants say that simply accepting the salvation by a movement of the will is enough to be saved. We don't agree. In fact, there are Protestants who say that, having accepted salvation, we should sin more and more because it brings God greater glory, since it will mean that He is all the more forgiving. This has no origin except in the mind of Satan. Dr. Mark Miravalle, a professor of mine, says that a lady called into his radio show to say that she'd been to a Lutheran wedding where the priest actually told the couple to make sure they committed sexual atrocities together for that very reason. Granted, that's a long string of hearsay, and it is an extreme position, but there are those out there who hold it. The problem is that it would be a lie for God to say that we are innocent just because we accept Christ. That's not enough to make us innocent. God doesn't just want to put us in heaven; He wants to restore us. The Catechism says that the human heart is a type of heaven. In Protestant theology, God wants to put us in heaven; in Catholic theology, God wants to put us in heaven and to put heaven in us. He wants to restore us...and that makes sense, because we're His creatures. Furthermore, as St. Paul says, He chastises us as a loving Father. A loving father chastises his children because he wants them to learn and to become better, not simply out of retribution. Thus, for the Catholic, grace comes into us and removes the weeds that keep God out. This can only happen with our cooperation. Grace moves us to go pick weeds, to till the soil, to fertilize it, etc. Grace also gives us the strength. When we do this, grace is also our reward...it comes and fills our souls more fully. All this is so that we may come to share in Christ's sacrifice, dying with Him so that we might also live with Him, being brought to dwell in Him, so that He and the Father may dwell in us, especially in His Mystical Body, the Church...all so that we may be joined to Him as branches on the Vine, so that His Holy Spirit, the sap of that Vine, may come to us and bring about good fruit through our cooperation...in order to make us worthy of heaven by being in conformity with Christ, who came not only to reveal God to man, but to reveal man to himself, and thus to restore man's likeness to God by offering Himself to us in the Eucharist, which (we are what we eat) restores man to God's likeness and allows man to share in Christ's Passion and Death and Resurrection. Do you see then how beautiful our faith is? It's so complete and makes such perfect sense out of all the Scriptures. This thread might also be of use to you: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?showtopic=58464&st=0"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/index.php?s...=58464&st=0[/url]
beatty07 Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 (edited) [quote name='sweetpea316' post='1147036' date='Dec 21 2006, 03:14 PM'] My next question about justification is... As a Lutheran, justification was defined as 'God declaring us not guilty of our sins' and we were given the example of being declared not guilty in a courtroom, which makes it seem like a one time thing that happens when we come to faith in Christ. But then the Catholic view is that it's 'the action of God's grace by which we are freed from sin and made holy' which seems to combine justification and sanctification. Is this accurate? Being actually transformed, rather than the whole 'dung covered in snow' thing? [/quote] for what it's worth, it seems to me that you've nailed it there. It strikes me that "declaring not guilty" is almost the opposite of forgiveness. "Forgiveness" is always the forgiveness of guilt. Real forgiveness says "hey, that hurt, and you shouldn't have done it, but it's okay." Now I know that "it's okay" isn't exactly theologically precise, but isn't this something we all know about innately? Think of a really tough forgiveness, like cheating on your S.O. If they say "it's no big deal, let's just forget about it", that would undermine the relationship. If it's no big deal, you must not love me very much! Real love and forgiveness says "you just ripped me apart... but, it's okay." Is that relevant to this? The Scriptural question is a really interesting one...I hope I get a chance soon to do some Greek/Commentary study on that. Edited December 21, 2006 by beatty07
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now