cappie Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 Irish doctor incensed over children "inhaling" at church Irish MP and medical practitioner, Dr Jim McDaid, has again lit a firestorm of debate over his warning of the potential danger for altar servers breathing incense smoke at church services. Reporting on the comments of Dr McDaid, who first raised his concern for incense smoke in 2003, Dr W Gifford-Jones of Canada Free Press says there are unknown health problems associated with the Christian tradition lighting candles and burning incense during masses. "Here you have quite a thick billowing type of smoke. Sometimes you see children with this instrument which is down normally around their ankles, and the smoke keeps coming up", says Dr McDaid, who is a Minister of State for Ireland, was quoted as saying. Dr Gifford-Jones says "it takes a brave man to criticise current traditions and clerics who have confirmed ideas about the burning of incense". In another story, the Canada Free Press also warns that care of children is especially necessary at Christmas. The journal cites the case of a two-year old boy with a history of recurrent right-sided pneumonia since 10 months of age whose bouts of lung infection started a few months after his first Christmas. Initially, doctors detected nothing abnormal after examining the lungs with a stethoscope, and the boy was otherwise healthy. But x-ray continually revealed a right-sided pneumonia. Eventually an X-ray and CT scan showed a round mass in the lower portion of the boy's right lung that surgery showed to be a small branch of an evergreen Christmas tree that the child had swallowed. "So keep an eye on toddlers who have a tendency to taste and swallow objects this Christmas," the Free Press warns. [url="http://www.canadafreepress.com/2006/health121806.htm"]http://www.canadafreepress.com/2006/health121806.htm[/url]
SeekingHisPlan Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 [quote name='cappie' post='1145131' date='Dec 18 2006, 06:20 PM'] Irish doctor incensed over children "inhaling" at church Irish MP and medical practitioner, Dr Jim McDaid, has again lit a firestorm of debate over his warning of the potential danger for altar servers breathing incense smoke at church services. Reporting on the comments of Dr McDaid, who first raised his concern for incense smoke in 2003, Dr W Gifford-Jones of Canada Free Press says there are unknown health problems associated with the Christian tradition lighting candles and burning incense during masses. "Here you have quite a thick billowing type of smoke. Sometimes you see children with this instrument which is down normally around their ankles, and the smoke keeps coming up", says Dr McDaid, who is a Minister of State for Ireland, was quoted as saying. Dr Gifford-Jones says "it takes a brave man to criticise current traditions and clerics who have confirmed ideas about the burning of incense". In another story, the Canada Free Press also warns that care of children is especially necessary at Christmas. The journal cites the case of a two-year old boy with a history of recurrent right-sided pneumonia since 10 months of age whose bouts of lung infection started a few months after his first Christmas. Initially, doctors detected nothing abnormal after examining the lungs with a stethoscope, and the boy was otherwise healthy. But x-ray continually revealed a right-sided pneumonia. Eventually an X-ray and CT scan showed a round mass in the lower portion of the boy's right lung that surgery showed to be a small branch of an evergreen Christmas tree that the child had swallowed. "So keep an eye on toddlers who have a tendency to taste and swallow objects this Christmas," the Free Press warns. [url="http://www.canadafreepress.com/2006/health121806.htm"]http://www.canadafreepress.com/2006/health121806.htm[/url] [/quote] Oh my goodness! I would say there is a world of difference between inhaling a little incense smoke and swallowing a piece of a Christmas tree. No wonder the kid was sick. Poor little guy!
Piamaria Posted December 18, 2006 Posted December 18, 2006 Irish doctor incensed over children "inhaling" at church Holy Smoke :
MissScripture Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 If there are unknown health problems, how can they be associated with anything? THEY DON'T KNOW THEM!
Paddington Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 [quote name='MissScripture' post='1145296' date='Dec 19 2006, 02:20 AM'] If there are unknown health problems, how can they be associated with anything? THEY DON'T KNOW THEM! [/quote] I had asthma growing up. I basically grew out of it. I remember hearing something about incense risk, but I don't remember it ever happening to me. BUT, I have a friend who has asthma more seriously and he walked into a Russian Orthodox Church during Divine Liturgy and the incense got to him instantly. He turned around and got the heck out of there. He said it wasn't safe for him.
scardella Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 The only people I could see having issues w/ the incense are severe asthmatics. For them, there are any number of Masses which do not use incense anyway. Universally banning incense at Mass for a tiny minority of people is like universally banning peanuts at restaurants because a tiny minority of people are allergic. It's just ridiculous.
MissScripture Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 [quote name='Paddington' post='1145379' date='Dec 19 2006, 02:07 AM'] I had asthma growing up. I basically grew out of it. I remember hearing something about incense risk, but I don't remember it ever happening to me. BUT, I have a friend who has asthma more seriously and he walked into a Russian Orthodox Church during Divine Liturgy and the incense got to him instantly. He turned around and got the heck out of there. He said it wasn't safe for him. [/quote] But, you see, that is a known health problem. Incense makes me sick to my stomache (well, most does, anyway) and it can make me very dizzy, but that comes from anything with a very strong scent. Asthma would be brought on by any smoke. It sounds to me as if the doctor just wanted to pick on something, because you really can't have unknown things associated with anything!
Tindomiel Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 (edited) If the incense is a problem, walk out of the church. I'm majorly allergic to the stuff, even though I love the way it smells. But I'm not going to make some huge stink about health risks. If I can't breath, I just walk out. Honestly, some of these doctors! Edited December 19, 2006 by Tindomiel
LouisvilleFan Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 I really thought this was going to be about kids inhaling drugs at church. From what I hear, you can do pretty much anything you want during a youth lock-in at some churches.
Old_Joe Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 I love the smell of incense. I think it'd be kinda cool to see a cologne that smells like it. I can see it now: "Benediction: by J. C. Heavenly Fragrance"
catholimaniac Posted December 19, 2006 Posted December 19, 2006 I thought laying down a nice thick smoke screen was one of the perks of being an altar server.
MilesChristi Posted December 20, 2006 Posted December 20, 2006 [quote]Dr Gifford-Jones says "it takes a brave man to criticise current traditions and clerics who have confirmed ideas about the burning of incense".[/quote] What a brave guy. I suppose when Ash Wednesday rolls around he'll stand up to those mean priests who clog our pores with filth. I would hate to think that a church tradition might damage someone's complexion.
Balthazor Posted December 20, 2006 Posted December 20, 2006 My priest told about one time when the deacon did not fill the censor.... so he just went through the motions of incensing... the funny thing is... he said that there were people coughing and complaining about the incense, even though there was none.
Resurrexi Posted December 20, 2006 Posted December 20, 2006 doesn't the Bible somewhere prohibit the useage of ecclesiastical incence for profane purposes (such as making your home or yourself smell good)?
Old_Joe Posted December 26, 2006 Posted December 26, 2006 [quote name='Balthazor' post='1146435' date='Dec 20 2006, 06:13 AM'] My priest told about one time when the deacon did not fill the censor.... so he just went through the motions of incensing... the funny thing is... he said that there were people coughing and complaining about the incense, even though there was none. [/quote] We had that happen once. The look on the priest's face priceless. Do you know why incense is used?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now