N/A Gone Posted December 20, 2006 Posted December 20, 2006 1st guy.. [quote]I tend to think most Christians are war mongers who love to hate others who don't believe what they believe and like to molest children. As for debating whether god is real or whether god was brought to life in the making of Jesus, I chose to not be so preposterous. You my friend can tell every Jewish person you meet that they are wrong and you can prove it. Or maybe fly to the middle east and make a power point presentation as to how you can prove that Jesus died for their sins. Personally I tend to let people believe what they believe, especially when it comes to a topic that has started the majority of wars. (*he also made some obscence coments about "proofs" to God's existence)[/quote] 2nd guy.. [quote]I think it's all hogwash. Both pro and anti. In my mind it's a waste of time. People are going to believe what they believe. I think it's good people have beliefs one way or the other, just as long as they're not forcing them on anyone else. For people that are so intent on labeling others, I guess I would be closer to agnostic than anything. But even that I think is carp. It's funny, I think the church is a joke, and even though I was baptized Catholic, I came to my own personal conclussion that it's all a giant scare tactic. And even with those beliefs, it's funny because I'll watch any pro/anti religious based program on the History channel or any movie in relation to pro/anti religion. I do this because it's interesting to me to hear and learn about both sides. I think even in my post here I've been wishy-washy back and forth, I think. That Mayans or Aztecs believed a person had to be sacrificed every day to get the sun to come up the next morning. They might have been slightly wrong on that. When it all comes down to it, I think my belief is that religion(Christianity, Islam, Judiasm,etc...) is just a way to explain the things we don't understand. It's all fairly primitive. My beliefs, don't really give a **** if you agree or disagree, so don't bother trying to "prove" me "wrong". I'm interested in other's thoughts, until they try changing my own. Also, many of my own beliefs come from personal experience with the church, as well as seeing friends, girlfriends, co-workers, etc who believe in one form of religion or another, and than seeing them be completely hypocritical in what they like to preach on about. Like my bible-thumping ex-girlfriend who claimed to be a "good christian girl", that had no problem getting high any time I wasn't around, and then got a job at Rick's Caberet 6 months after we broke up. "Good Christian Girl" my ass. I'm a little annoyed, though, by people who feel that religion is the basis of right and wrong. Nah, I'd say common sense is. I work for a non-profit company, that does have some Christian under-tones, and I volunteer about 20 hours a week to kids that are't mine and I have no direct connect to, other than I like seeing them succeed. I rarely drink, never done an illegal drug, smoked maybe 3 cigarettes in my life, and never been to jail. I help out anyone in need that asks for it, even if it puts me at a disadvantage. I don't do these things because the imaginary guy in the sky told me to, I do it because I'd like to think it makes this **** up world a better place. And I gotta live here too, beaver dam it. [/quote] Any response ideas?
Didacus Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 Not much room to discuss with this caliber of ignorance and stupidity. My response would be not much more than< "Wether you like it or not, there is a God, and one day you will meet Him. good luck with that."
N/A Gone Posted December 21, 2006 Author Posted December 21, 2006 dunno if that is really productive..might make more of a spam war
peach_cube Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 [quote]I tend to think most Christians are war mongers who love to hate others who don't believe what they believe and like to molest children. As for debating whether god is real or whether god was brought to life in the making of Jesus, I chose to not be so preposterous. You my friend can tell every Jewish person you meet that they are wrong and you can prove it. Or maybe fly to the middle east and make a power point presentation as to how you can prove that Jesus died for their sins. Personally I tend to let people believe what they believe, especially when it comes to a topic that has started the majority of wars. (*he also made some obscence coments about "proofs" to God's existence [b]First thoughts, to be technical power and greed has started the majority of wars. I would pose that the underlying motives in ALL wars are power and greed.[/b] I think it's all hogwash. Both pro and anti. In my mind it's a waste of time. People are going to believe what they believe. I think it's good people have beliefs one way or the other, just as long as they're not forcing them on anyone else. [b]Really, if you don't believe in God everything and anything can be a waste of time in "your mind." You will die and no one will remember, everything you will have done will be meaningless. With God however...[/b] For people that are so intent on labeling others, I guess I would be closer to agnostic than anything. But even that I think is carp. [b]It's quite difficult to do anything without "labels," it is a quick way of knowing were people are coming from. Just because this chap has not put much thought into his religious beliefs, he passes it off as unworthy of his time[/b] It's funny, I think the church is a joke, and even though I was baptized Catholic, I came to my own personal conclussion that it's all a giant scare tactic. And even with those beliefs, it's funny because I'll watch any pro/anti religious based program on the History channel or any movie in relation to pro/anti religion. I do this because it's interesting to me to hear and learn about both sides. [b]Personal conclusion? More like mind numbed, cultural fed conclusion. Did he get that thought while watching the Family Guy? History Channel [/b] I think even in my post here I've been wishy-washy back and forth, I think. That Mayans or Aztecs believed a person had to be sacrificed every day to get the sun to come up the next morning. They might have been slightly wrong on that. When it all comes down to it, I think my belief is that religion(Christianity, Islam, Judiasm,etc...) is just a way to explain the things we don't understand. It's all fairly primitive. [b]What about physics? Does it try to explain things we don't understand in a modern way? Does it do it any better? The world is built on trying to explain the things we don't understand. Without religous philosophy we don't have science as it is today. Even science cannot explain many things, does this disprove science?[/b] My beliefs, don't really give a **** if you agree or disagree, so don't bother trying to "prove" me "wrong". I'm interested in other's thoughts, until they try changing my own. [b]Obviously he gives a **** otherwise he would not reply. If you can't handle an exchange of opinions on the subject then don't post. People don't try to change your thoughts, they give things to think about and consider.[/b] Also, many of my own beliefs come from personal experience with the church, as well as seeing friends, girlfriends, co-workers, etc who believe in one form of religion or another, and than seeing them be completely hypocritical in what they like to preach on about. Like my bible-thumping ex-girlfriend who claimed to be a "good christian girl", that had no problem getting high any time I wasn't around, and then got a job at Rick's Caberet 6 months after we broke up. "Good Christian Girl" my ass. [b]People are hypocritical because they are people. Should we abandon democracy because politicians are hypocrites? Should we abandon helping the poor and hungry because it is hypocritical for us to do so as americans?[/b] I'm a little annoyed, though, by people who feel that religion is the basis of right and wrong. Nah, I'd say common sense is. I work for a non-profit company, that does have some Christian under-tones, and I volunteer about 20 hours a week to kids that are't mine and I have no direct connect to, other than I like seeing them succeed. I rarely drink, never done an illegal drug, smoked maybe 3 cigarettes in my life, and never been to jail. I help out anyone in need that asks for it, even if it puts me at a disadvantage. I don't do these things because the imaginary guy in the sky told me to, I do it because I'd like to think it makes this **** up world a better place. And I gotta live here too, beaver dam it. [/quote] [b]Good for you, that is quite wonderful. Imagine if more people would do that.[/b] The best thing I think to do is to try and find a common ground and point out flaws in logic. If you can do that at the very least they may not approach religion with such strong bias. Good luck.
Didacus Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1146692' date='Dec 20 2006, 09:23 PM'] dunno if that is really productive..might make more of a spam war [/quote] Yes, agreed. But with that kind of person and attitude there is really not much that can be said or done. I've learned to keep a distance with that kind of person to be honest with you, and some of them are my brothers and sisters.
N/A Gone Posted December 21, 2006 Author Posted December 21, 2006 (edited) [quote]And rev, you just proved my every belief. 1.) Family Guy, never watched a full show of it. I don't really get off on "stupid-funny" shows. Family Guy, Southpark, Old School, American Pie... Shows/movies like that do nothing for me. They're, in my opinion, boring. 2.) A god isn't needed to remember people when they've passed on. Up until 8 years old my best friend in the world was my maternal grandfather. We hunted, fished, boated, snowmobiled, etc pretty much every weekend together. I remember eating cole slaw and baked potatos with the skin, all the time. It was a blast. Also meant a lot to me because I moved around a lot as a kid because my parents were divorced and my mom worked very hard to get to where she is today. I don't need a religion to help me remember that or to give meaning to it. That's assanine. And when I'm dead, I'm dead. If people remember the things I've done in my lifetime, that's great, if they don't, eh I'm dead, remember? 3.) I've put a lot of thought into what my beliefs are, on religion and other subjects. I don't pass religion, or thinking about religion, off as unworthy of my time. I've read the bible, I've read parts of the Qu'ran, and Torah. Am I an expert on any of the three, no, but I've learned enough where I feel comfortable talking about the three. Not that it's much to brag about, but I've taken 3 or 4 college courses on World Religion and other like subjects. Hearing how other people think interests me. Doesn't mean I'm going to change my beliefs, but I like hearing where others are coming from. As long as it's an exchange of beliefs, and not an attempt to change one's beliefs. 4.) Like I said originally, and either you didn't understand or didn't care... I posted because I have a belief on the subject, I am interested in others beliefs, but if someone feels they need to personally degrade my beliefs and pick them a part, it's kind of a waste of time. You actually end up making yourself look worse in the end, not that you care. 5.) Maybe a VERY, VERY, VERY simple way to put it would be comparing favorite NBA teams. 1 guy might like the Spurs and can give 152 reasons why he does. I like the Wolves, and I can give my reasons. Now I might think the Spurs smell of elderberries, but I have no interest in trying to change his mind. It's his opinion/belief/whatever, and he can have that. Just like I don't expect him to try to change my opinion/belief/whatever. That doesn't mean we can't talk basketball, though. Again, that's an extremely simplistic way of putting it. Figure it might help explain my thinking. I can definitely handle a discussion about religion. I'm not the one that quoted and picked apart each individual thought. You're welcome to your beliefs, and they actually interest me. Not because they'd change my beliefs, but because it helps me learn about your thought processes and where you're coming from. 6.) I'm not the average moron that sees something on TV and buys it as fact. I put my own research on both sides of issues, throw out what I think is carp and keep what I think is good. An example would be politics. I don't toe the party line of Republican or Democrat. I study the candidates and vote for who I think is the best candidate. I would say more often than not that leans Democrat, but because of my beliefs on issues matching more towards Democrat, not because Howard Dean tells me so. I would say I probably vote 60/40. And I've voted Independent or third party, when that candidate has matched closer to what I believe. You mentioned "mind numbed, cultural fed conclusion", but couldn't the same be said for a good number of Christians, Muslims, Jews, etc... in that they only believe what their parents taught them and haven't truely put any thought into something different? I can't say "most" because I don't have any true numbers, but I would say a good number of Christians believe what they believe solely because that's the only thing they've been introduced to, and not because they've actually study all beliefs, and then came to the conclussion of what they belief. Maybe not as much today as 5 years ago, but Islam in some areas of the country and in some people is seen a "negative" religion because people don't have the facts on Islam. They buy the carp they see on TV, what they hear from friends/family, what they hear in church, or because the word "terrorist" is linked to Islam in the world today, or whatever their reason is. When truthfully, most of those people haven't really put any study into Islam. 7.) My current girlfriend, and likely future wife, is a strongly devoted Christian. She attends church every Sunday, was a former youth group leader, and reads the bible frequently. I have loads of respect for her because she came to these beliefs on her own because her parents are "typical" Christians. I say "typical" because I can't think of a better term, but also it's because what I personally see most often. Christians who claim to have a set of beliefs, but are very hypocritical in the actions they choose to take everyday. Her and I frequently sit down and discuss what we believe. I read through the bible and ask her about certain passages that I'm not sure about, or that I want her opinion on. When we first started dating she had a hard time accepting my differing beliefs, but when she learned it's very much possible for us to have different beliefs, to sit down and talk about those beliefs, and to end the conversation with still differing beliefs, but still loving each other, our relationship got better. We've discussed the whole "how will we raise our kids in regards to religion" talk. The only thing that frustrated me with her is the whole abstinence thing. But that's another topic. LOL. 8.) This next point is where my thoughts sometimes confuse myself. I think religion is partly based on the fact that humans are egotistical. They don't like the fact that when we die, we just die. That we get our 72.6 years on this planet and then poof, we're worm food. Also humans like to think we're special and in this 100billion galaxied universe and 100billion starred galaxy, we're the only intelligent life form. But is that rational though? That in that inifinite space of all those stars and galaxies and planets and moons, that Earth is the only place life exists? That might be twisted to be a reason for God as well, I suppose, but I think it's one way of disproving it. Not that I'm out to disprove it, it's your beliefs, I have zero issues with you having your beliefs. Religion is like a tree. Have thirty people stand 50 feet away from that tree, and make a giant circle surrounding that tree. Now give each person a piece of paper and some crayons and have them draw a picture of that tree. Each person is going to give you a different picture because they're seeing it from a different angle, but they all drew the same thing. That's kind of like religion. Everyone's looking at the same thing, they're just drawing a different picture because they have a different view. Does that make sense? I guess that's part of why if you want to use a label, I choose Agnostic. I also find it interesting that "athiest" is used in such a negative light by some people. I don't understand why it is, but it's interesting. 9.) Kant, I remember hearing about, but at nearly 11pm of a VERY long day, I can't recollect anything about him/her. If you could point me in the right direction, I'd be interested in reading more. I love obtaining information, even if it differs from my personal beliefs. I hope that all makes sense. Some of the WAYS you chose to respond I didn't appreciate, but I might have read them wrong, too. It's tough to judge tone on an online forum. But I do appreciate that you did respond. Sharing one's ideas and beliefs interest me, trying to change other's beliefs does not.[/quote] Edited December 21, 2006 by Revprodeji
Groo the Wanderer Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 Just my 2 cents... From some of the comments made by the atheists/agnostics, I think it wise to remind everyone that we evangelize others by our lives, not so much by our words. How we live will either turn peeps toward God or away from him. Think where the Church would be today if every Christian lived a Christian lifestyle all the time. It helps me personally when I am about to open my yap with something inappropriate or uncharitable to remember the crucifix around my neck. I think of it as a uniform and I am repping God. If I do something unChristlike in public, THAT is the image others will remember. Lord help me to always look at every person and say to myself "that is God's child" before I say anything else.
beatty07 Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 (edited) I'm struck by the contradiction in his insistence that nobody try to change his beliefs. He keeps harping on that. But if our beliefs are true, then we MUST try to help others see the truth. If his beliefs are true, then it doesn't matter what anyone believes and we shouldn't try to convert each other. If everyone's beliefs were to be respected, then you would have to respect his failure to try to convert you, and he would have to accept your obligation to try to convert him. But he won't tolerate your beliefs. He insists that you operate according to his. I wonder if he would recognize how silly that is if you pointed it out? Also, he seems to be a person of at least some strong ethical conviction... is he open to discussing ethics? That's a good way to get at God. Modernism is coasting along on Christian ethics having discarded the foundation. In reality, there is absolutely no basis for ethics if there's no God. What makes him better than Charles Manson? Popular sentiment? Is rape wrong? Says who? You? Some people seem to think it's perfectly appropriate. Why does your opinion count and theirs doesn't? Cause there's more of us? In that case we can take a vote to decide whether, for instance, it's okay to exterminate Jews. Unless there's a higher standard than any of us. And what could that possibly be? You can just keep asking, "Says who?" The agnostic/atheist is stuck there. Edited December 21, 2006 by beatty07
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now