phatcatholic Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 [b]Apologetics in the Pre-Catechumenate Period of RCIA[/b] Apologetics, or the defense of the faith, plays a very important role in the pre-catechumenate period of the RCIA process. People often come to this rite with nagging and persistent questions about the Catholic faith, and it can be difficult to continue the process and to accept everything that the Church teaches as long as these questions remain. Apologetics helps to remove those obstacles by providing a clear and concise explanation and defense of Catholic doctrine or practice as it relates to those pressing questions. A clear and concise explanation: this is very important. If we present the faith in a way that is not systematic, or that does not follow a discernable train of thought, we can lose our audience. Thus, a clear presentation will be organized and structured so as to lead one to the necessary logical deductions. Clarity also means using words that accommodate your audience and their current progress in the journey of faith. RCIA is a gradual process of revelation through stages. The catechist does not want to present concepts that are more advanced than what the audience is ready to receive. This also means using vocabulary that they will understand, or at least explaining words before you use them. A concise explanation is one that is both to the point and robust with meaning. Often, the catechist’s greatest challenge is fitting the breadth of Catholic teaching into a one-page handout, or a 30-minute presentation. This is difficult, but it is also necessary. If the catechist belabors his audience with lengthy dissertations, the audience is likely to feel overwhelmed and insecure in his ability to actually learn the Catholic faith. Furthermore, on a practical level, the catechist has to remember that attention spans are often very short. If he wants his audience to truly listen to and understand what he is teaching, he must accommodate their ability to remain alert and focused. Finally, the catechist must note that he has a lot of ground to cover in the 7 months between September and Easter. If he is not concise, even with his spiritual exercises during the stages of less instruction, he will deprive his candidates and catechumens of the preparation they need to enter into the Church. So as to provide an example of clear and concise apologetics, I have included the following handouts, each one on a different Sacrament of the Church [see the files attached to this post]. Each handout is one-page in length and is divided into three sections: “Definition,” “Reasons for the Sacrament,” and “Support from Scripture.” There are many reasons why I have decided to format the handouts in this way. The “Definition” section is important because it is often unclear to many what exactly the Church teaches about a specific doctrine. Purgatory, for example, is often misunderstood to be a middle-ground between those who aren’t good enough for heaven, but not bad enough for hell; or it is a place where you can work your way into heaven even though you didn’t initially deserve it. Providing a clear and concise definition of the subject will dismiss these errors at the onset and allow the audience to know the subject for what it really is. For each handout, I have used the Catechism of the Catholic Church as the source for my definitions. The Catechism has made as its goal the presentation of the faith, and it begins the majority of its sections with a short definition of whatever is about to be explained more fully. Thus, the Catechism is well-suited for the first section of each handout. Plus, it is always good for people to become familiar with the Catechism and to come to see it as a worthwhile and authoritative source on Catholic doctrine. The “Reasons for the Sacrament” section is perhaps the most difficult one to complete. Even when Catholics know what they believe, they often don’t know why. Defenses from Scripture or from the Tradition of the Church don’t really answer the question. Yes, we believe in the authority of Peter because of Mt 16:18, but why do we need this authority in the first place? Why would Jesus build his Church on a person? Why would he institute a papacy? As Catholics, we often do not think of these questions, but potential converts to the faith ask them all the time. Thus, this section of the handout attempts to answer the most fundamental questions about Church teaching and to present the logic, coherence, and inner-consistency of what the Church believes. Each handout concludes with the “Support from Scripture” section. This section is necessary, for one, because it shows that all that the Church believes is well-grounded in the Word of God as it was written down in the Bible. This is especially important for Protestants, who regard the Bible as the sole rule of faith. However, in utilizing the Bible we are also showing the person who has little or no regard for it that the Bible is a work that the Christian turns to for guidance and spiritual nourishment. We would not bother ourselves with what the Bible had to say if the Bible was not a reliable witness to the teachings of Christ and the Church. Of course, quoting Scripture also has the effect of helping the audience to grow familiar with its content. All of these sections help not only the prospective Catholic, but the catechist as well. In defining doctrine, he comes to know the faith in its most concise expression. In listing the reasons for a doctrine, he forces himself to ask questions that he has never asked before, to plum the depth of and purpose for what we believe, and to place himself in the position of the uninstructed. In finding the support for a doctrine in Scripture, he grows more and more acquainted with that which is the very heart of catechesis.
phatcatholic Posted December 21, 2006 Author Posted December 21, 2006 lemme know what u all think of the handouts
sweetpea316 Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 From a catechumen... great job and thank you!!
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 21, 2006 Posted December 21, 2006 Wow...I can tell the differences in our styles. My paper had a different approach.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1147119' date='Dec 21 2006, 06:15 PM'] care to share how Raphel? [/quote] Well, I'm not as liberal with posting my papers. I've been told by the head of catechetics not to post some of my projects before...a concern that others will steal ideas for their papers, I think. Anyway, I simply stated that it is difficult to cover apologetically as wide a range as may occur in RCIA sessions and that efforts should be made to relate to general human understandings during lessons in the pre-cat (i.e., if I have a class with a former Wiccan, a Methodist, a Calvinist, and a Unitarian, I shouldn't try during the lesson time to cover all these bases in relating a particular doctrine, but should instead give a more general treatment based on things all these persons may be able to accept). Then, only after lessons, question and answer sessions may occur where, having had their minds turned toward a certain method of thinking about the doctrine, they will more easily be able to see where they stand in reference to it. It's what I do here, really...I give a general treatment, see what issues they bring up, and then go into those, breaking them down and putting them into a proper theological context as necessary, so that the person I am evangelizing may be able to see why it is reasonable based on what we know, either from Revelation or from the light of human reason itself. It's really not that complex...it's just a method that complements the way people think...but many apologists don't use it because many apologists see their task merely as defending the truth instead of clarifying the truth for the sake of bringing another to Christ. In order to do the latter, we have to meet people where they are and learn to get inside of their minds so that we can better see where they are coming from, but we also have to let them see where we are coming from in a general way so that they may properly orient their thoughts. This is because most people ask the wrong questions...they want answers and get frustrated when the Church can't give them answers, but it's because they're asking the wrong questions...questions that are often loaded or based on different vocabulary, etc. For instance, let's say Jack Chick walks into my RCIA class wanting to see what Catholics believe. Let's say that the topic for this session is the Blessed Virgin. He's going to be coming from a worldview where Catholics worship Mary. In my lesson, I will teach quite simply what the Church does teach regarding Mary, not dealing so much at that time with objections, but trying to state the Church's faith in a way that gets them to see where we're coming from, where we are, and where we're going. Now, the objections will likely remain, but Mr. Chick will hopefully be able to think more thoughtfully about what points to bring up as objections. If I talk about the Blessed Virgin Theotokos, he'll at least know what Catholics do teach regarding the Mother of God. If he still thinks that Catholics say that Mary predates God, then that can be brought up during a question and answer session, but instead of saying, "Catholics worship Mary as God's creator," which is blatently false and, quite frankly, implies that Catholics are idiots, he might say, "Catholics see Mary as God's Mother; in light of that, do they believe that Mary predates God or did God predates Mary?" Now you see what effect that should have? By giving him first a survey of the teaching, he comes from a better background to ask the really relevant questions. You see...the lesson gave him a small foundation in what the Church believes...now instead of asking ignorant questions (in this case, ignorant because of anti-Catholic bigotry), he can ask intelligent questions. Furthermore, look at what it gets him focused on...the question could easily be brought into the mystery of the Incarnation...of the Creator being born to the creature. Once we get into that, it should become apparent that Catholics don't adore the Blessed Virgin...he may still ask, but he won't be thinking that Catholics view her as creator (as he may have before)...instead, any objection he may make at this point might be a question from confusion ("but...I thought you prayed to her). It is always a sign of intelligence to seek an answer in times of confusion; it is not such a great sign to seek an answer from a question whose answer should be obvious (i.e. whether, having been given this information, Catholics worship Mary in spite of it, which either shows that he hasn't been listening to what Catholics believe or that he thinks Catholics are too dumb to figure out that they shouldn't worship creatures). In short...a general treatment should come first and then the points addressed in it should be articulated further in accordance with the questions later asked (questions made intelligent and rational by the points addressed in the lesson). Thus, on the catechist's side, he is giving the audience a good, brief foundation in the doctrine so that they can ask the right questions...on the inquirer's side, he is picking out which points he doesn't understand (given that his background didn't prepare him for it), so that he can ask intelligent questions based on what has been set before him, rather than solely on his own, often contradictory, impressions and biases.
N/A Gone Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1147187' date='Dec 21 2006, 09:24 PM'] ...a concern that others will steal ideas for their papers, I think. [/quote] Isnt the point to get the message out? jp. I think both of your methods have value. To be honest I have read almost everything of Phatty's I could get my lil grubs on. I think both of your methods have value and will reach different people in different ways.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 [quote name='Revprodeji' post='1147204' date='Dec 21 2006, 10:51 PM'] Isnt the point to get the message out? jp. I think both of your methods have value. To be honest I have read almost everything of Phatty's I could get my lil grubs on. I think both of your methods have value and will reach different people in different ways. [/quote] Oh, I agree. I wasn't trying to pump up mine at the cost of Nick's. I was just saying...I think I focused more on the broader topic of apologetics in the sense of helping people get over their biases and such, whereas Nick focused more on the details of apologetics properly speaking. Oh, and yeah, the point is to get the message out...but for those in catechetical training, it's to teach them to be catechists...we have to do their own work.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now