2xbob Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 Ok, this thread may last awhile because I plan on repeatedly hitting yous up for help. Lets start with my first question. For two people, both who are most certainly set on marriage when is the right time to propose. I was thinking or 1yr or 18mon anniversary. I have prayed about this and my life is too filled with coincidences for it to be wrong. On the other hand, I don't want to be rushing it and set us up for a rocky start. There are soooo many more questions but I will save them depending on the responses I get from this question (no use taking off is someone took the wings).
Sojourner Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 I don't think there's a "right time" to propose. If it's the right person, and you both feel that it's right, I think 4 months can be fine. Or 18. Or 7 years. Although 7 years is a little long ... but I think the key is to hit a time that you both feel comfortable with. If you're both already talking about marriage, and even talking about marriage to each other and are comfortable with that, then I think it doesn't so much matter when the conversation takes place.
Jaime Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 Getting it off the ground might begin with spelling it correctly
Veritas Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1147531' date='Dec 22 2006, 05:52 PM'] Getting it off the ground might begin with spelling it correctly [/quote]
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 My parents got engaged after two months and have now been married happily for 32 years. I wouldn't recommend that for everyone. Take your time, do it when it seems right. About any uncertainties you may be having (since you mentioned that you might fear a rocky start and it sounds like you may be having them), remember to discern between real doubts and idle doubts. If you have doubts that are like, "I really don't know...we seem to be having a really tough time and I don't know if I can take a lifetime of this," then you may want to reconsider it in prayer. If the doubts are just general nerves about marriage, providing for a family, et cetera, then everyone has those and you shouldn't put much thought into it.
Romans1513 Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 Having no experience whatsoever and therefore no authority on the subject , I would add, make sure its not too long before you would consider getting married. If you're still in school for a few years and definitely don't want to get married til you graduate, for example, you might want to wait a bit. Maybe its just my opinion. My sister is engaged, and they're not getting married until October 2009. A three+ year engagement is a little much I think.
IcePrincessKRS Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 [quote name='Terra Firma' post='1147524' date='Dec 22 2006, 06:39 PM'] I don't think there's a "right time" to propose. If it's the right person, and you both feel that it's right, I think 4 months can be fine. [/quote][quote name='Raphael' post='1147536' date='Dec 22 2006, 07:02 PM'] My parents got engaged after two months and have now been married happily for 32 years. [/quote] Or a happy middle ground of 3 months. : I think most people are more confortable with a longer dating phase, but if you both KNOW that you want to get married I see no real point in waiting to get engaged (engagement may last longer, mine was about 18 months--we probably would have gotten married sooner but I wanted to graduate with my BA first so I "made" him wait), it just makes official what you already have plans for.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 22, 2006 Posted December 22, 2006 [quote name='2xbob' post='1147509' date='Dec 22 2006, 05:57 PM'] Ok, this thread may last awhile because I plan on repeatedly hitting yous up for help. Lets start with my first question. For two people, both who are most certainly set on marriage when is the right time to propose. I was thinking or 1yr or 18mon anniversary. I have prayed about this and my life is too filled with coincidences for it to be wrong. On the other hand, I don't want to be rushing it and set us up for a rocky start. There are soooo many more questions but I will save them depending on the responses I get from this question (no use taking off is someone took the wings). [/quote] If you two are on the same page as to goals, ambitions, and dreams then propose whenever you want. What is an important date in your relationship?
2xbob Posted December 23, 2006 Author Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='hot stuff' post='1147531' date='Dec 22 2006, 06:52 PM'] Getting it off the ground might begin with spelling it correctly [/quote] CURSE YOU FAULTY SPELL CHECK. Ok, moving on. We are both in college, I was thinking next Christmas eve at her family Christmas party I would propose but that would put the wedding two years after that (yay masters degree supper senior). We have already talked about marriage and are willing, to put off the proposal too long would be to delay it needlessly except for the fact that we are entering a bit of hardship (some time of distance) so I will use that as my final qualifier (maybe God is making sure we are ready). That would put my planning for proposal at one year (a good enough time for research) with the wedding two years after (I heard that it is good to allot LOTS of time to this part, you only get one), assuming that my plan does not run afoul with God's plan.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='2xbob' post='1147564' date='Dec 22 2006, 07:24 PM'] CURSE YOU FAULTY SPELL CHECK. Ok, moving on. We are both in college, I was thinking next Christmas eve at her family Christmas party I would propose but that would put the wedding two years after that (yay masters degree supper senior). We have already talked about marriage and are willing, to put off the proposal too long would be to delay it needlessly except for the fact that we are entering a bit of hardship (some time of distance) so I will use that as my final qualifier (maybe God is making sure we are ready). That would put my planning for proposal at one year (a good enough time for research) with the wedding two years after (I heard that it is good to allot LOTS of time to this part, you only get one), assuming that my plan does not run afoul with God's plan. [/quote] Personally, I'd find a more private place to propose. People feel pressured when there are lots of people, especially family. I proposed at the outdoor Stations of the Cross at Franciscan...thought it was pretty secluded...I found out later that there was a large group praying on the upper tier that stopped to watch when they saw me get on one knee.
2xbob Posted December 23, 2006 Author Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='Raphael' post='1147586' date='Dec 22 2006, 09:42 PM'] Personally, I'd find a more private place to propose. People feel pressured when there are lots of people, especially family. I proposed at the outdoor Stations of the Cross at Franciscan...thought it was pretty secluded...I found out later that there was a large group praying on the upper tier that stopped to watch when they saw me get on one knee. [/quote] This post made me . You do have a good point with the seclusion. I am a person who loves presentation when it comes to gift giving. Something that will make a memory. The party can be used for the announcement. Hmmm, to craft something ingenious but what . Oh I do love giving suprises PS:OT: Just another sign that God takes care of me. I had thrown some wet logs into the wood stove to dry over the coals while I took a shower after which I would increase the air and light up the now dry wood. Well, when I got out of the shower I found the logs on fire... with the air to the stove shut off... which shouldn't happen with dry wood let alone wet wood. Nice little surprise not to freeze out of the shower.
Veritas Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='2xbob' post='1147590' date='Dec 22 2006, 08:58 PM'] This post made me . You do have a good point with the seclusion. I am a person who loves presentation when it comes to gift giving. Something that will make a memory. The party can be used for the announcement. Hmmm, to craft something ingenious but what . Oh I do love giving suprises PS:OT: Just another sign that God takes care of me. I had thrown some wet logs into the wood stove to dry over the coals while I took a shower after which I would increase the air and light up the now dry wood. Well, when I got out of the shower I found the logs on fire... with the air to the stove shut off... which shouldn't happen with dry wood let alone wet wood. Nice little surprise not to freeze out of the shower. [/quote] + Wow. Where do you live, Maine? Personally, I'd like to be proposed to in Church. Not after Mass, but some quiet time when it's just the two of us. Is there a beautiful Church or Shrine nearbye where you could make a pilgrimage? Or, you could propose near a chapel of the Holy Family and consecrate your engagement and marriage to the Holy Family You could even consider a honeymoon trip related to the place you proposed! (probably somewhere in Italy!) and then have your marriage blessed by the Pope, while you're there! Just my 2cents.
2xbob Posted December 23, 2006 Author Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='Veritas' post='1147593' date='Dec 22 2006, 10:06 PM'] + Wow. Where do you live, Maine? Personally, I'd like to be proposed to in Church. Not after Mass, but some quiet time when it's just the two of us. Is there a beautiful Church or Shrine nearbye where you could make a pilgrimage? Or, you could propose near a chapel of the Holy Family and consecrate your engagement and marriage to the Holy Family You could even consider a honeymoon trip related to the place you proposed! (probably somewhere in Italy!) and then have your marriage blessed by the Pope, while you're there! Just my 2cents. [/quote] Hey, your selling yourself short, thats 4cents at least. I don't know of anywhere too nice that would also be nearby and religious. I can't go anywhere all too extravagant for the proposal alone (did I mention I was a college student). I also can't go and have a proposal related to my honeymoon, while a romantic idea, long term plans suggest an Alaskan cruise so unless I propose in an ice-box that probably wont tie together... unless I propose when its snowing but around here (PA) all we normally get is rain. I would like a blessing from the pope but as its looking I will have to settle for a bishop (but it will be annoying getting a blessing when the person can only move diagonally). Also as an aside, I read "consecrate your engagement and marriage to the Holy Family" as 'consummate your engagement and marriage to the Holy Family' and was all about it.
Veritas Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='2xbob' post='1147635' date='Dec 22 2006, 09:54 PM'] Hey, your selling yourself short, thats 4cents at least. I don't know of anywhere too nice that would also be nearby and religious. I can't go anywhere all too extravagant for the proposal alone (did I mention I was a college student). I also can't go and have a proposal related to my honeymoon, while a romantic idea, long term plans suggest an Alaskan cruise so unless I propose in an ice-box that probably wont tie together... unless I propose when its snowing but around here (PA) all we normally get is rain. I would like a blessing from the pope but as its looking I will have to settle for a bishop (but it will be annoying getting a blessing when the person can only move diagonally). Also as an aside, I read "consecrate your engagement and marriage to the Holy Family" as 'consummate your engagement and marriage to the Holy Family' and was all about it. [/quote] Thanks. p.s. I meant "nice" like the cathedral or a basilica in your diocese, or just a pretty Church with a beautiful chapel to Mary or Joseph or another saint, who is important to your girlfriend -not Fatima or Lourdes or anything! I must confess, an Alaskan Cruise is one of my "hope to do someday" adventures (the other was a trainride through the swiss alps and I got that a couple years ago). So, nice choice! Although, I don't think there's Mass aboard... which always kind of thought I would miss...
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='2xbob' post='1147590' date='Dec 22 2006, 08:58 PM'] This post made me . You do have a good point with the seclusion. I am a person who loves presentation when it comes to gift giving. Something that will make a memory. The party can be used for the announcement. Hmmm, to craft something ingenious but what . [/quote] Put it in her stocking. : Seriously....making a presentation has to be done by you...you know your beloved, so you know what will mean the most.
suuran Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 "...is what bwings us togetha, today." Sorry. Back to your thread :.
MrsFrozen Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 I think probably 18 months is a good idea. My husband and I met and were married 9 months later. We had a rocky start to our marriage, but things are going very well. I doesn't work out that way for everyone, though. It took a lot of work. We've been married 5 years.
2xbob Posted December 23, 2006 Author Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='Veritas' post='1147648' date='Dec 22 2006, 11:00 PM'] Thanks. p.s. I meant "nice" like the cathedral or a basilica in your diocese, or just a pretty Church with a beautiful chapel to Mary or Joseph or another saint, who is important to your girlfriend -not Fatima or Lourdes or anything! I must confess, an Alaskan Cruise is one of my "hope to do someday" adventures (the other was a trainride through the swiss alps and I got that a couple years ago). So, nice choice! Although, I don't think there's Mass aboard... which always kind of thought I would miss... [/quote] Agh, I never thought that there wouldn't be any mass aboard. I would very much like to have our first mass together. Who knows, maybe in three years there will be a mass... or I could just invite the priest I'm friends with . I don't think she has a favorite saint yet, since shes still planning on going through the adult initiation (cant remember its abbreviation). [quote name='MrsFrozen' post='1147979' date='Dec 23 2006, 06:33 AM'] I think probably 18 months is a good idea. My husband and I met and were married 9 months later. We had a rocky start to our marriage, but things are going very well. I doesn't work out that way for everyone, though. It took a lot of work. We've been married 5 years. [/quote] Eep, the 28th is our 9month. I'm glad that everything worked out, I heard that most marriages have a rough start, its hard to sync with someone else for a change.
IcePrincessKRS Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 My husband proposed to me by a river, it was early spring, right before Easter, and still alot of snow on the ground (and he still got down on one knee.... this is, of course, after his first proposal which happened over the phone... we had a long distance relationship lol). He took me to the place where he first told me he loved me. It doesn't have to be extravagant, just special. [quote name='2xbob' post='1148007' date='Dec 23 2006, 09:14 AM'] Eep, the 28th is our 9month. I'm glad that everything worked out, I heard that most marriages have a rough start, its hard to sync with someone else for a change. [/quote] Many do, my husband and I were pretty lucky. The long distance stank, but it really forced us to work on our communication skills and I think, for us, that really helped make the transition an easy one.
Thy Geekdom Come Posted December 23, 2006 Posted December 23, 2006 [quote name='IcePrincessKRS' post='1148053' date='Dec 23 2006, 11:23 AM'] Many do, my husband and I were pretty lucky. The long distance stank, but it really forced us to work on our communication skills and I think, for us, that really helped make the transition an easy one. [/quote] Agreed. While Jen and I aren't married yet, we're quite good at the communication thing, at making sure the other is doing okay, of going out of our way to make the other happy or help the other after a hard day...I don't even have to say anything most of the time, she just knows how my mind works and can tell what's going on in my head. :
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now