Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Losing Faith


Recommended Posts

Guest confuzzled
Posted

I know that this is probably not the most appropriate topic since it's Christmas and all, but I need to get this out there. I've been struggling with a faith in God for about three months now. I used to be a really strong Catholic. I thought I had given my life up for Jesus. I thought I was solid in my faith. I don't know though. Somewhere along the way, something changed. I first noticed it during Mass. I would feel God's presence in church, but I couldn't feel His love. I don't know if anyone else besides me can differentiate between the two, but believe me, I know the difference. Maybe an example to demonstrate: Pretend that you're married and that your spouse is in the room, but he or she is sitting with his or her back to you. You know that he or she is there, but you can't really feel any affection. That's how I feel with God. I needed a change. I can only go so long without any affirmation. I prayed, and I prayed. I sincerely prayed that God would move in me, let me feel Him. I know that He doesn't owe me anything, but I know that He does want people to believe in Him. He also knows that I'm struggling to even believe in Him after months of unanswered prayers. I'm beginning to doubt His mere existence now. I'm sick of the carp that this is a test or it's all for the best or it's part of His plan. I just want to love Him and for Him to love me, for me to feel it. In these months that I've been wavering, I've taken an interest in philosophy in an attempt to shed some light. The only light that's been shed has been...well, the antithesis of light: darkness. Most philosophical arguments only lead to a conclusion of there is no God, in my opinion. For example, the infamous stone problem: can God create a stone so heavy He can't move it? If He can, then He's not omnipotent because He can't move a rock. If He can't, well, He's still not omnipotent because He can't create that rock then. Dilemmas such as that one are plaguing my mind, clouding my faith, or lack thereof. I don't really know what to do. Everything that's happening in my life points to no God. "Waiting it out" just doesn't cut it for me anymore. I've tried, and I've tried with no progress. I can't do it anymore. I know that if I believe the Bible to be true, then I must be Catholic. Catholic practices and doctrine follow most closely to those in the Bible. That, I am sure of. I have researched and researched that, forming solid conclusions. However, it's the part about believing the Bible is true that I can't be so sure of anymore. Anyone have anything to offer?

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='confuzzled' post='1149624' date='Dec 25 2006, 11:48 PM']
I know that this is probably not the most appropriate topic since it's Christmas and all, but I need to get this out there. I've been struggling with a faith in God for about three months now. I used to be a really strong Catholic. I thought I had given my life up for Jesus. I thought I was solid in my faith. I don't know though. Somewhere along the way, something changed. I first noticed it during Mass. I would feel God's presence in church, but I couldn't feel His love. I don't know if anyone else besides me can differentiate between the two, but believe me, I know the difference. Maybe an example to demonstrate: Pretend that you're married and that your spouse is in the room, but he or she is sitting with his or her back to you. You know that he or she is there, but you can't really feel any affection. That's how I feel with God. I needed a change. I can only go so long without any affirmation. I prayed, and I prayed. I sincerely prayed that God would move in me, let me feel Him. I know that He doesn't owe me anything, but I know that He does want people to believe in Him. He also knows that I'm struggling to even believe in Him after months of unanswered prayers. I'm beginning to doubt His mere existence now. I'm sick of the carp that this is a test or it's all for the best or it's part of His plan. I just want to love Him and for Him to love me, for me to feel it. In these months that I've been wavering, I've taken an interest in philosophy in an attempt to shed some light. The only light that's been shed has been...well, the antithesis of light: darkness. Most philosophical arguments only lead to a conclusion of there is no God, in my opinion. For example, the infamous stone problem: can God create a stone so heavy He can't move it? If He can, then He's not omnipotent because He can't move a rock. If He can't, well, He's still not omnipotent because He can't create that rock then. Dilemmas such as that one are plaguing my mind, clouding my faith, or lack thereof. I don't really know what to do. Everything that's happening in my life points to no God. "Waiting it out" just doesn't cut it for me anymore. I've tried, and I've tried with no progress. I can't do it anymore. I know that if I believe the Bible to be true, then I must be Catholic. Catholic practices and doctrine follow most closely to those in the Bible. That, I am sure of. I have researched and researched that, forming solid conclusions. However, it's the part about believing the Bible is true that I can't be so sure of anymore. Anyone have anything to offer?
[/quote]

I've been going through a similar problem for quite some time. Pope Benedict, while he was still Cardinal Ratzinger, wrote a book that began with an examination of a problem noted by St. Therese of Lisieux. In her deathbed, she told her superiors that she was "tempted to every kind of atheism," but she did not give in. The cardinal went on to elaborate that there comes a point in life when the faith is all built up quite nicely in one's mind. He used the imagery of a castle...it's beautiful, it's well-build, well-structured, it stands firm...but then you look to the foundation and find that it's sort of just hanging...is there a foundation there or is there a chasm? The question is no longer about individual aspects of the faith and trying to put it together...the question becomes, "is it all true at all?"

First, you should take courage in that many saints have experienced what you are describing.

God wants your love for Him to be based on faith, not on feelings. This is why He weens us off of the feelings. After a while, when we begin to realize that nothing has really changed (i.e. even though we have no great feelings of piety, our lives are going well and we're still seeing that God provides), except that we no longer rely on feelings, we begin to see that our feelings are not what determines the truth. Our love for God deepens because it is based on a firm conviction that He is here with us, despite the darkness in our lives.

Additionally, how introspective are you? Do you spend a lot of time examining your thoughts, your actions, your motives, your sins, etc.? Do you think a lot and not take much time to live? Are you often troubled with anxiety about God and the Church and the state of your soul? I don't know about you, but I'd answer yes to all of these...and I think this has something to do with it. Satan fell because he turned his gaze inward on himself and away from God. This can be done out of pride, but it can also be done out of fear or self-hatred. You cannot allow yourself to gaze inward. There is a place for examining your conscience and your thoughts, but it should not be constant. You are supposed to contemplate God, not to examine your thoughts on God. This may not apply to you, but I find it helpful.

I find it helpful also to take time to think about the great things God has done for me and thank Him and praise Him. We do too much asking and too little thanking.

Anyway, you may wish to read this message from Pope Benedict, as well:

[quote]A Christmas Surprise

"Tonight He Will Come"

VATICAN CITY, DEC. 24, 2006 (Zenit.org).- Here is a translation of the address Benedict XVI delivered today before reciting the midday Angelus with several thousand people gathered in St. Peter's Square.

* * *

Dear Brothers and Sisters:

The celebration of the holy birth is here.

Today's vigil prepares us to live intensely the mystery that tonight's liturgy will invite us to contemplate with the eyes of faith.

[b]In the divine infant, who we will place in the manger, our salvation is made manifest. In the God made man for us, we all feel loved, taken in, we discover that we are worthy and unique before the eyes of the Creator.[/b]

The birth of Christ helps us to be conscientious of what human life is worth, the life of each human being, from the first instant until natural death.

[b]To whomever opens their heart to this "baby wrapped in swaddling clothes," who lies "in a manger" (cf. Luke 12:12), is offered the possibility of seeing with new eyes the reality of everyday. He will delight in the ability of the interior seduction of the love of God that can transform even pain into joy.[/b]

Dear friends, let us prepare to encounter Jesus, the Emanuel, God with us. By his birth in the poverty of Bethlehem, he wants to accompany each one of us on our life journey. In this world, from the moment that he decided to make it his home, no one is a stranger.

It is true, we are all here in passing, but it is Jesus who makes us feel as if we are at home on this Earth, made holy by his presence. He asks us, nonetheless, to make is a hospitable home for all. This is precisely the surprise give of Christmas: Jesus came for each one of us and in him we have become brothers.

From here comes the commitment to overcome each day more our prejudices, to take down the walls, and to eliminate those differences that divide us, or even worse, that set people and nations against one another, so as to build together a world of justice and peace.

With these sentiments, dear brothers and sisters, we will live these last hours that separate us from Christmas, preparing ourselves spiritually to receive the Child Jesus. Tonight he will come for us. And he will also enter us, to live in the heart of each one of us.

For this to take place it is indispensable that we be available and ready to receive him, and be willing to give him room in our hearts, in our families and in our cities. May his birth not find us unprepared to celebrate Christmas, forgetting that he is precisely the protagonist of the celebration.

May Mary help us to maintain the indispensable interior recollection necessary to experience the profound joy that the birth of our Redeemer offers. To her let us direct our prayer, thinking in particular of those that live Christmas sad and alone, sick and suffering: May the Virgin bring consolation to all of them.

[At the end of the Angelus, the Pope greeted pilgrims in several languages. In English he said:]

I am happy to greet all the English-speaking pilgrims and visitors present for this Angelus.

Today is the Fourth Sunday of Advent and also, this year, Christmas Eve. The Liturgy of today's celebration invites all believers to welcome joyfully the promised Messiah who comes to us through the Virgin Mary.

I wish you all a pleasant stay in Rome, and a blessed Christmas filled with the peace of Christ our Lord and
Savior!

[Translation by ZENIT]

© Copyright 2006 -- Libreria Editrice Vaticana[/quote]

Second, the philosophy you stated above is based on a lack of philosophy. A theoretical situation that cannot exist (a rock so heavy God could not lift it) cannot disprove God because non-realistic premises can't lead to realistic conclusions. For instance, it would quite clearly be nonsense to say, "if a cardinal were a Martian, could he be elected pope?" The fact that there is a fictitious, unrealistic premise means that the question is posed in an unrealistic world. Conclusions in unrealistic worlds have no bearing on the real world. God is, by definition, all-powerful, and therefore can lift anything. A rock too heavy for God to lift would, by definition, have to be an infinitely heavy rock. Material things can't be infinite; therefore, the question is framed in a non-realistic world. It's an illogical problem Satan has used to dissuade people for quite a while, but it's simply not an argument against God.

Third, get yourself a trusted spiritual director. No one hear is qualified to help you spiritually beyond a point of offering suggestions or sharing experiences. Someone with training, experience, and knowledge of you as a beloved and unique creature of God has to help you through this.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

[quote name='confuzzled' post='1149624' date='Dec 26 2006, 02:18 AM']
it's the part about believing the Bible is true that I can't be so sure of anymore. Anyone have anything to offer?
[/quote]

Raphael,

Is that THE issue for your struggle?
If you stopped doubting the Bible, then you would be ready to move forward?
You probably know a lot of things about the Bible that make it sound true.
Focus on those things that make it sound false. I mean, by research.
You can get through it and then help others with the same exact things.

Peace,
Paddington

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Paddington' post='1149718' date='Dec 26 2006, 05:02 AM']
Raphael,

Is that THE issue for your struggle?
If you stopped doubting the Bible, then you would be ready to move forward?
You probably know a lot of things about the Bible that make it sound true.
Focus on those things that make it sound false. I mean, by research.
You can get through it and then help others with the same exact things.

Peace,
Paddington
[/quote]
No...that's not the struggle for me. The struggle for me goes more to the very core of truth itself. It's not a doubting of what's in the Bible (I'm a theology major...the beauty and truth of the Scriptures astounds me)...often, it's a sort of emptiness, a temptation to separate the truth from reality...a temptation to see the truth of the faith as a sort of idealism that doesn't play out in the real world...something diametrically opposed to the Incarnation. It's a struggle that hits many theologians, I think. It was once pointed out to me that we haven't had many theologian saints since the Council of Trent, the reason being that theology became too much about the head and too little about the heart. Sometimes in studying such lofty things, our feet leave the ground and we no longer see the ideal of God as the real of earth, but our faith is all about these two being one.

Anyway, whether it's specifically what the original poster meant or not, I think it's similar.

I should clarify...it is a temptation, not something I cling to. It is a part of my cross...and it challenges me to have a bold faith...so, in the end, it is good. I find that the greatest cure is pure joy...laughter at innocent things. When you laugh in a pure (non-sinful) way, your soul sings praise to God in a way that it completely natural, but also provides great room for the supernatural joy of the saints to enter in.

Anyway, this thread is about the original poster. I wouldn't like to take away from any help anyone may provide him.

Posted

Raphael,

I'm kinda "slow on the uptake." I totally meant that reply for "confuzzled." I even copy/pasted from confuzzled's post.
I wonder about me sometimes. *shrug*

But thanks for replying. I enjoyed reading your take.

:) Paddington

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='confuzzled' post='1149624' date='Dec 25 2006, 11:48 PM']
I know that this is probably not the most appropriate topic since it's Christmas and all, but I need to get this out there. I've been struggling with a faith in God for about three months now. I used to be a really strong Catholic. I thought I had given my life up for Jesus. I thought I was solid in my faith. I don't know though. Somewhere along the way, something changed. I first noticed it during Mass. I would feel God's presence in church, but I couldn't feel His love. I don't know if anyone else besides me can differentiate between the two, but believe me, I know the difference. Maybe an example to demonstrate: Pretend that you're married and that your spouse is in the room, but he or she is sitting with his or her back to you. You know that he or she is there, but you can't really feel any affection. That's how I feel with God. I needed a change. I can only go so long without any affirmation. I prayed, and I prayed. I sincerely prayed that God would move in me, let me feel Him. I know that He doesn't owe me anything, but I know that He does want people to believe in Him. He also knows that I'm struggling to even believe in Him after months of unanswered prayers. I'm beginning to doubt His mere existence now. I'm sick of the carp that this is a test or it's all for the best or it's part of His plan. I just want to love Him and for Him to love me, for me to feel it. In these months that I've been wavering, I've taken an interest in philosophy in an attempt to shed some light. The only light that's been shed has been...well, the antithesis of light: darkness. Most philosophical arguments only lead to a conclusion of there is no God, in my opinion. For example, the infamous stone problem: can God create a stone so heavy He can't move it? If He can, then He's not omnipotent because He can't move a rock. If He can't, well, He's still not omnipotent because He can't create that rock then. Dilemmas such as that one are plaguing my mind, clouding my faith, or lack thereof. I don't really know what to do. Everything that's happening in my life points to no God. "Waiting it out" just doesn't cut it for me anymore. I've tried, and I've tried with no progress. I can't do it anymore. I know that if I believe the Bible to be true, then I must be Catholic. Catholic practices and doctrine follow most closely to those in the Bible. That, I am sure of. I have researched and researched that, forming solid conclusions. However, it's the part about believing the Bible is true that I can't be so sure of anymore. Anyone have anything to offer?
[/quote]
To the me the question has never been is the Bible true, but is the Church true, since the Bible came from and is guaranteed by the Church. I answer that question by thinking about history. Nothing else organized in the history of the world has lasted 2000 years. Countries and civilizations have come and gone but the Church remains. So obviously its had divine guidance, since most things tend towards chaos over time, not greater organization and theology.
I have never understood the feeling part about God. I have never in any particular way felt loved by God, never had any great emotional highs etc, so I cannot relate to this. The Bible says God loves us, so I'll take His word for it :) I see love as an act of will - a choice. I have never looked for an emotional high in relation to religion - in the great scheme of things I think its transistory and a trap. You look to replicate a feeling, instead of working on an obedient relatinoship.
C.S.Lewis talks a great deal about this seach for an emotional feeling in his book Surprised by Joy.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

On the topic of philosphy, I was just listening to some of Aquinas' proofs for the existence of God. Our very existence and that of our universe is one thing, since the universe couldn't come into existence on its own power. Another one is motion. Everything in motion is set into motion by something else, so who or what set things in motion to begin with?

Posted

I'll be praying for you. There are many times I feel like that myself. Remember, even when you can't feel His love, He loves you infinitely more than you can imagine. :)

Posted

[quote name='avemaria40' post='1150457' date='Dec 27 2006, 06:35 PM']
I'll be praying for you. There are many times I feel like that myself. Remember, even when you can't feel His love, He loves you infinitely more than you can imagine. :)
[/quote]

Amen! I know I don't always feel His love, nor do I always feel like loving Him, but marriage has taught me that love goes much deeper than emotions and "feeling" like it. I'll be praying. :)

Guest confuzzled
Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1150445' date='Dec 27 2006, 01:11 PM']
On the topic of philosphy, I was just listening to some of Aquinas' proofs for the existence of God. Our very existence and that of our universe is one thing, since the universe couldn't come into existence on its own power. Another one is motion. Everything in motion is set into motion by something else, so who or what set things in motion to begin with?
[/quote]

To this, I would respond, if everything is set into motion by something else, what set God into motion? It's a self-defeating argument because if you're arguing that everything was caused by something else, then there can be no first cause (God) since that itself needed something to cause it. In addition, to believe that there is a first cause despite flawed logic is just as difficult to believe as it is to believe that there is an infinite regression of causes in the past, aka no first cause at all. Afterall, if we can imagine an infinite progression of causes in the future, it isn't that much of a stretch to believe the same about the past. I have studied Aquinas' arguments for a first cause, so I'm very familiar with this all. I sometimes have problems relaying my thoughts into written language, so I hope you can gather at what I'm getting without much confusion.

To everyone else, I appreciate all of the suggestions. Unfortunately, nothing has been very helpful so far. I don't mean this as a negative thing to all of you, but nothing is clicking yet. I know that emotions are the basis for anything, or at least shouldn't be, which is fine because I'm not an emotional person at all, making this even more ironic. It's just the fact that I can only hollow myself out for so long, and I shouldn't have to do that for something like God.

About my Bible comment: I said that to put things into perspective, kind of. I know that if the Bible's true, Catholicism is the way to go. I have no doubt of that. Catholicism is useless, though, if the Bible isn't true. My qualm with the Bible comes through God. If God exists as the 3-O God, I believe that the Bible is His written word. The Judeo-Christian God is what I'm doubting. I hope that clears things up a bit.

Thank you for the prayers everyone.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='confuzzled' post='1150532' date='Dec 27 2006, 03:11 PM']
To this, I would respond, if everything is set into motion by something else, what set God into motion? It's a self-defeating argument because if you're arguing that everything was caused by something else, then there can be no first cause (God) since that itself needed something to cause it. In addition, to believe that there is a first cause despite flawed logic is just as difficult to believe as it is to believe that there is an infinite regression of causes in the past, aka no first cause at all. Afterall, if we can imagine an infinite progression of causes in the future, it isn't that much of a stretch to believe the same about the past. I have studied Aquinas' arguments for a first cause, so I'm very familiar with this all. I sometimes have problems relaying my thoughts into written language, so I hope you can gather at what I'm getting without much confusion.[/quote]

The argument isn't self-defeating. It's clear from human reason that everything is caused by something. Since the material world can't be infinite (nor eternal), there must be something that caused it first. Atheists and theists alike have to agree with that. Atheists might try to say that it all started with the big bang, but that had to be caused by something, too. So, by your logic, there is no explanation, since your logic rules out anything that must have a cause (the big bang would be obvious, and you include God Himself as well). If there is no first cause, then there is no causation, no movement, and no sequence. If there is no first cause, then we do not exist. We know clearly that we exist (if we didn't, we couldn't be discussing this), so that must not be the case. Therefore, there is a first mover.

Now, the problem with your logic is that you are trying to place God at the beginning of the sequence as a single point along the sequence. To illustrate this, imagine a line of standing dominoes...to your philosophy, God is simply the first domino. You'll ask, "but what about the finger that hits the domino?" I'll reply, "but what about the mind and will that moves the finger?" Then you've got to ask yourself: does anything move the mind and the will? If you believe in free will, then no. The free will considers certain things and perhaps is influenced by them, but it is not another domino...if it were, it could choose whether to fall or to stand. Now, God is pure volative being. He is not influenced by anything. He has pure will. He doesn't require a previous domino. If you believe in a first mover, and you logically must, then that first mover is pure volition. You said above: "It's a self-defeating argument because if you're arguing that everything was caused by something else, then there can be no first cause (God) since that itself needed something to cause it." This is not true. We never said that God needed to be caused. When we speak of the dominoes, we're talking about things in creation, not about the mover Himself. Not "everything was caused by something else;" rather, everything was caused by the first cause, in sequence. Spirit can be eternal and God is spirit. Therefore, God is the one eternal volative Being which willed everything else into existence. Now, we can't delve into every aspect of the mystery of God and understand completely, but we do know from logic that there must be a first mover and that this first mover must be eternal (and thus spiritual) since He has no cause and that this first mover must be pure volition, since He willed all things into being. We can explain that these things are true. We can't explain [i][b]how[/b][/i] they are true, but it is clear [i][b]that[/b][/i][b] they are true.

[quote]To everyone else, I appreciate all of the suggestions. Unfortunately, nothing has been very helpful so far. I don't mean this as a negative thing to all of you, but nothing is clicking yet. I know that emotions are the basis for anything, or at least shouldn't be, which is fine because I'm not an emotional person at all, making this even more ironic. It's just the fact that I can only hollow myself out for so long, and I shouldn't have to do that for something like God.[/quote]

Of course you are an emotional person. All human persons are emotional.

I don't want you to take the following in a harsh way, but it needs to be said. Please know that I struggled for a few years in my teens with these thoughts and occasionally still struggle with them.

St. Anselm had a famous saying, "faith seeking understanding." Faith seeks understanding, not the other way around. We believe, and so we wish to understand. When we seek to understand so that we may believe, we get lost. We make it all about knowing and understanding instead of about believing. Do you see what this pursuit has done...you are near denying the most obvious fact in the world: that God exists and made all things. If you exist, then someone put you here. Your very being cries out that you are a creature of God, but in the pursuit to understand, you have left behind the common sense that you should take as a given. It happens to many who try to understand...they say, "well, if I'm going to understand, I need to understand based on things I can see, because things I can't see don't count as proof." In doing so, you start to look for concrete facts...numbers, statistics, scientific proofs...all to back up God's existence, even though God's existence is a matter of common sense...it's a given premise. This sort of thinking is like knowing that 2+2=4, but saying, "but I only know that because teachers told me that...I have to prove it to myself..." and so you start to try to define "2" and "4" and "plus" and "equals" and you realize, "wow...I really have no proof that the essence of '2' is what I thought it was...it's just an arbitrary digit assigned by someone at some point in history." The fact is that that someone in history had enough common sense to sit down and say, well, I have two of the same thing...more than one and less than three. It's a given...it's what we call self-evident. It doesn't need to be proven based on abstract concepts. Furthermore, science only measures things that can be measured. If you can't measure God, that doesn't mean He doesn't exist, it simply means that He's infinite...which only substantiates that He's God.

[quote]About my Bible comment: I said that to put things into perspective, kind of. I know that if the Bible's true, Catholicism is the way to go. I have no doubt of that. Catholicism is useless, though, if the Bible isn't true. My qualm with the Bible comes through God. If God exists as the 3-O God, I believe that the Bible is His written word. The Judeo-Christian God is what I'm doubting. I hope that clears things up a bit.[/quote]

Will you accept "givens"? That is, if God were to stare you right in the face or let you know quite clearly that He exists, would you accept it, or would you try to rationalize it, test it, see whether it can be proven based on facts, etc.? Because our God doesn't always obey the laws of physics...and yet, we see that those things which don't obey the laws of science, what we call miracles, are nonetheless real...they're right in front of us...and they prove to us that we can't explain God. God is not against nature or its rules...but sometimes He works on a higher set of rules.

These things can't be proven with science, let alone understood, yet they are no less real than you or me...will you accept givens?

[url="http://www.therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/lanciano.html"]http://www.therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/lanciano.html[/url]

[url="http://www.evanderputten.org/special/newmexico/loretto.htm"]http://www.evanderputten.org/special/newmexico/loretto.htm[/url]

[url="http://www.therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/a3.html"]http://www.therealpresence.org/eucharst/mir/a3.html[/url]

God bless,

Micah

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='confuzzled' post='1150532' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:11 PM']
About my Bible comment: I said that to put things into perspective, kind of. I know that if the Bible's true, Catholicism is the way to go. I have no doubt of that. Catholicism is useless, though, if the Bible isn't true. My qualm with the Bible comes through God. If God exists as the 3-O God, I believe that the Bible is His written word. The Judeo-Christian God is what I'm doubting. I hope that clears things up a bit.
[/quote]

Here is where you have it backwards. The Catholic church predates the Bible as we know it today by several hundred years. So if Catholicism isn't true, the Bible is just a collection of stories.

Guest JeffCR07
Posted

*YAWN* *STRETCH* The name of St. Anselm has awoken me from my phatmass slumber! I just can't resist a topic where he's mentioned! :banana:

But seriously, confuzzled, please know that I have gone through the same experience you are going through, and I would be glad to help you clear up any philosophical difficulties that you are struggling with. I've found from experience that sometimes these boards are not be best places to really grapple with issues like these (and that is not to say that the points made by raph and others are wrong). Feel free to PM me anytime, or IM me at JeffCR07. Either way, know also that I will be praying for you, and I truly believe that you are going to get through this.

Your Brother In Christ,

Jeff

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='confuzzled' post='1150532' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:11 PM']
To this, I would respond, if everything is set into motion by something else, what set God into motion? It's a self-defeating argument because if you're arguing that everything was caused by something else, then there can be no first cause (God) since that itself needed something to cause it. In addition, to believe that there is a first cause despite flawed logic is just as difficult to believe as it is to believe that there is an infinite regression of causes in the past, aka no first cause at all. Afterall, if we can imagine an infinite progression of causes in the future, it isn't that much of a stretch to believe the same about the past. I have studied Aquinas' arguments for a first cause, so I'm very familiar with this all. I sometimes have problems relaying my thoughts into written language, so I hope you can gather at what I'm getting without much confusion.[/quote]

I'd answer that God is not in motion. God is basically "it." God is defined as that which has no cause, no beginning, no creator because He is the cause which effected Creation and the beginning and the end. To suggest that something must have set God into motion denies the definition of who God is.

Having said that, I have often wondered how we can understand what God was "doing" before Creation. And why is God the way He is, as in this perfectly just, merciful, and loving supernatural being? I hardly understand these kinds of big questions well enough to ask them and the answers are probably far beyond my finite self. I think ultimately our understanding is restricted by the dimension of time, which God created. We really can't relate to the fact that outside of Creation, there is no concept of time because time is a part of Creation.

[quote name='confuzzled' post='1150532' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:11 PM']To everyone else, I appreciate all of the suggestions. Unfortunately, nothing has been very helpful so far. I don't mean this as a negative thing to all of you, but nothing is clicking yet. I know that emotions are the basis for anything, or at least shouldn't be, which is fine because I'm not an emotional person at all, making this even more ironic. It's just the fact that I can only hollow myself out for so long, and I shouldn't have to do that for something like God. [/quote]

Why shouldn't you have to hollow yourself out for so long for God's sake? Look at the lengths to which some people sacrifice their own interests for the sake of someone their in love with, one of their children, and sometimes even complete strangers. Why shouldn't we be willing to pour ourselves out complete for God since He is so much greater than these others?

I like something I heard on an EWTN podcast about Mary where they talked about Mary and Joseph searching three days for Jesus until they finally found him in the Temple. I think they were quoting someone who said that God pursues people who are far from Him and runs away from people who are close to Him. In other words, as much as God longs to be reconciled with us, He longs even more for us to chase after Him (just like Mary and Joseph searched for Jesus) because we miss being near to God. And when we finally find Him, the joy we experience leads us into a deeper love for God and other people than we would have ever known otherwise.

Edited by LouisvilleFan

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...