Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hey guys, I posted this in a previous forum but I don't think it got too many hits, so I'll see what the people here have to say.

Is it a sin for my gf and I to share the bed if we're just cuddling/napping? People I've talked to, including a priest, didn't think it was too big a deal if that's just what we're doing but I want others opinions, too. Thanks. We've been doing it for a long time, so there's not really temptation to sin, but I realized if it is wrong, then I need to stop so I can make good confessions.

Posted

1. If its like one of those how far can we get till we're just not over the edge sorta things, quit now.
2. Even if its not threatening to ur and her purity, it is still a major temptation
3. If someone were to see you it could cause scandal.

Ask yourself this:

What would her dad say if he walked in......

Posted

Her parents don't care lol. As long as we keep the door open.

Posted

what if Jesus walked in.....?

Posted

Depends on the culture... In some places, that is considered normal... I find it to be a cause to scandal at least though... But, like i said, depends on culture.
I have a friend who does it with his girlfriend... But, it's exceptable from where they are from. To me, it seems scandalous and made me feel uncomfortable to walk in on to say the least.

littleflower+JMJ
Posted

You definitely do not belong there. You should probably be respectfully aware of your surroundings for each other. Doing what your doing is really not helping either one of you if you are striving for purity and for the best for each other...I would definitely NOT encourage it......not matter how well or innocent your intentions may be for each other. Its an occasion for sin, which means the potential will always be there since you two like each other, and we are always suppose to remove ourselves from occasions of sins. As well as what Fr. Pontifex mentioned, the appearance of scandal and responsibility we have to others.

Props to asking for clarity on this, shows your character and how your working on your relationship. Keep it up and know its always a work in progress. I'm glad you asked this question. ^_^

Welcome to phatmass too! :welcome:




PS the Question and Answer forum is only answered by the Church Scholars only of Phatmass, who are educated with theology degrees to answer your questions or are ordained Catholic priests who are helping answer questions. The Church Scholar who answered your question is one of the Phatmass' priest :priest:

Posted

We don't care if the door is open or whatever, we're not trying to get alone or anything like that, just interested in napping together on her dorm bed.

Posted

I wouldn't, simply because I'd want it to be special for when I share a bed w/my spouse. I also don't think my future husband would be very happy to hear about me sleeping w/another man even if we were actually sleeping and it was before I met him. I'd want to make it special for just me and him.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

Napping together on a bed, especially on a dorm bed, is not a good idea. How old are you? If you're at an age when emotions run wild, it's especially not a good idea.

There's a good rule of thumb used by Franciscan University: at least three feet on the ground at all times, no hands touching inappropriate places, no torsos or pubic regions together. It's a pretty good rule.

I would recommend especially not cuddling in a dorm room. First, there are many people there who might say, "oh, look...Rosco cuddles with his girlfriend and he's religious, so it must be moral." Now, even if it's not a near occasion of sin for you, it might be for them, so you need to go the distance to avoid scandalizing them.

You always need to be clear with your girlfriend on what you are both morally comfortable/uncomfortable with.

You also should define cuddling. Are you leaning on each other? Is she resting her head on your arm or chest? Is she resting her head on a pillow on your lap (in such a case, a thick pillow should be used so that you're not close enough to arouse each other)? Is she sitting on your lap/knees and hugging you (generally a bad idea, given the risk of arousal and awkwardness). Are you spooning (that should definitely be saved for marriage)?

I live off-campus, but my fiancee and I are very careful not to go anywhere near a position that would be tempting to either of us. If my housemates are watching a movie in the living room and we want to watch a movie, we'll go to my room (we have to close the door because of the noise of both movies...but my housemates know both of us well enough to know that we wouldn't be seeking to do anything immoral in there and they wouldn't be scandalized). Now, in my room, the only comfortable place to sit for a movie is the bed. We developed certain rules we were comfortable with to make sure that neither of us would be aroused. I ran the situation by two of the Phatmass priests and they approved; I also ran it by trusted friends who know us both and who are themselves very committed to chastity and they approved. You must be certain to find rules and limits that both of you are comfortable with...what's okay for you may not be for her. You should also make sure that you're not doing anything that's of the type of "let's see how close we can get." That's a bad attitude to have in any situation and I know people who thought that way and have gone places they never meant to go. Instead, you should seek to be close to your girlfriend while respecting her dignity and approaching the situation in a way that truly says, "I love you so much that I want you to get to heaven more than I want pleasure for myself, so anything even remotely morally uncomfortable for you, I want to avoid it." It helps to have an attitude where you are seeking marriage and nothing less than it. I want union and children with my fiancee very, very much...but I really want a marriage (which will, of course, include those). Keeping marriage in mind, I wouldn't desire all the sexual pleasure in the world I could get from her or give her...I want a marriage and nothing else will do, so nothing else interests me.

Only follow this following advice inasmuch as the suggestions are not near occasions to sin for you.
The way we handle the situation is to do essentially no more than we would be doing if we were watching a movie while laying together on the floor. Get comfortable individually but together. What I mean is...get comfortable without regard to her...as if she wasn't there and it was just you...but be individually comfortable together. Don't try to get comfortable together, that is, in relation to her. Also, don't get too comfortable. When I lay down to watch a movie with my fiancee, we lay down apart with our feet off the short end of the bed (it helps not to lay the long way, which is "too" comfortable). Our feet are then usually propped up on my computer chair, which isn't too comfortable, but comfortable enough that we're not shifting around the whole time. Also, keep your torsos and pubic regions far apart...my fiancee and I pretty much only have our feet and our shoulders touching...there should never be any embracing (it's also wise never to stretch an arm over her body, since that psychologically indicates an embrace and may be arousing). An occasional kiss may be okay, but it must be brief and simple and occasional (better to kiss on the cheek or the forehead, too). Remember: until you are married, you are not one. Therefore, the intention should be to enjoy the movie as a couple, not to enjoy each other with a movie in the background. You will find yourself enjoying her more if you are doing your own things with her (that is, each of you watching the movie individually, but doing that together, rather than you together watching the movie). Finally, don't ever get under a blanket...one of you can have a blanket, but not both of you under one blanket (in fact, one of you under one blanket can add another shield for chastity.

It's important to know how people slip into lust. In movies, characters are generally lustful and slip into it really quickly because it's normal to them. If you are striving for chastity, though, it's different. Satan will try to tempt one of you to do something small, the other will react for or against it, and it will go on until you don't really care anymore what happens. That is why it is important that you are both of the understanding that the moment either of you is aroused or tempted in a way that is an occasion to sin for you, you let the other know. It is a little embarrassing to tell your beloved, "please don't do that, it's too tempting to me," but it must be done and, if she loves you, she will not only understand, but appreciate that you are open and honest enough with her to tell her that, especially since it is a very personal thing.

Remember, sex is a good thing. Love is a good thing. Showing your love is a good thing. However, there are certain expressions of love which are reserved for marriage alone. It's not that you want to get as close as possible to the line...it's that you want to do what's appropriate for your relationship (boyfriend/girlfriend) and do it with great love. You don't want to go anywhere near the line...you just want to love her as you should.

Anyway, my point is this...don't get too scrupulous about it...there are ways to get close...but don't be trying to get closer than your state in life (boyfriend) gives you a right to.

Finally, find a good, moral priest who knows you well and knows your moral life and how you are tempted so that he can advise you on what ways you can enjoy time with your girlfriend without trying to push it to the limit.

Anyway, I would definitely not be cuddling on a bed or napping together on a bed, as the first implies that you're embracing and the second implies that you're sleeping close together. Once, when my fiancee were up late (she had an adoration hour in the early morning), we were both exhausted, but the rest of the house was noisey, so we both took naps on my bed...2.5 feet apart from each other, each of us curled into the fetal position, facing different directions...it wasn't a risk at all to our chastity. For some people, it may have been. Another time, she wanted to stretch out on my bed while studying, meaning that I couldn't be on the bed anymore without it being unchaste, so I napped on the floor while she studied on my bed. Take care to protect each other's chastity. :)

Seek to love your girlfriend by preserving her chastity and her soul and you will find yourself loving her more deeply than you had ever imagined.

God bless,

Micah

Posted

Best scriptural example I can think of for this would be David and Bathsheba.

David first caught sight of her bathing on the roof. Scripture simply tells us the facts, but there's an important question to ask here: what in the world was the King doing on a roof, watching a beautiful woman bathe? Would he not, being the King, have known that women might be bathing there?

David succumbed to temptation and ended up being an adulterer and a murderer. This was probably the greatest example of sexual sin that we are shown in the Bible. And this from a man that was "a man after God's own heart."

It's folly to think your fatih is stronger than David's. My advice would be this: stay off the roof. We have to be cautious; being cautious is NOT cuddling and napping.

Scripture does not tell us to avoid sexual temptation, it tells us to FLEE from it.

This may not be searching after it, but it is certainly not fleeing.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='Diamond' post='1150506' date='Dec 27 2006, 02:14 PM']
Best scriptural example I can think of for this would be David and Bathsheba.

David first caught sight of her bathing on the roof. Scripture simply tells us the facts, but there's an important question to ask here: what in the world was the King doing on a roof, watching a beautiful woman bathe? Would he not, being the King, have known that women might be bathing there?

David succumbed to temptation and ended up being an adulterer and a murderer. This was probably the greatest example of sexual sin that we are shown in the Bible. And this from a man that was "a man after God's own heart."

It's folly to think your fatih is stronger than David's. My advice would be this: stay off the roof. We have to be cautious; being cautious is NOT cuddling and napping.

Scripture does not tell us to avoid sexual temptation, it tells us to FLEE from it.

This may not be searching after it, but it is certainly not fleeing.
[/quote]

Well, I'd say some clarification is needed...some people define cuddling as just leaning on each other, which is certainly fine (that's not just you...clarification is needed all around), I would say, leaning on each other is even fine if [b]sitting up[/b] on a bed.

But yes, not putting yourself in what is going to be a near occasion to sin for you is vitally important.

Theologian in Training
Posted

Rosco,

If, after asking others, including a priest, it still bothers you, that is the way for your conscience to tell you something is not right. I am not going to repeat what others have said here, but I would encourage you to ask yourself if you yourself think it is sinful to do so. You have been given all the answers, and you seem to want to justify your behavior, however, at the same time, you cannot fully justify it because it still bothers you. This, in itself, seems to be an indication that, for you, it is indeed a near occasion of sin and possibly a cause of scandal, so it is now up to you to change that behavior and find something more conducive to a chaste relationship.

God Bless

Fr. Brian

Posted

[quote name='rosco22' post='1150210' date='Dec 26 2006, 11:47 PM']
Hey guys, I posted this in a previous forum but I don't think it got too many hits, so I'll see what the people here have to say.

Is it a sin for my gf and I to share the bed if we're just cuddling/napping? People I've talked to, including a priest, didn't think it was too big a deal if that's just what we're doing but I want others opinions, too. Thanks. We've been doing it for a long time, so there's not really temptation to sin, but I realized if it is wrong, then I need to stop so I can make good confessions.
[/quote]

So, how many times are you going to play russian roulette before the gun goes off?

I am a mother and I can't believe you are doing something so incredibly irresponsible. You have a girlfriend. The two of you obviously share such intimate feelings for one another that you can comfortably share a bed. And you want to keep doing this until there comes the time that you make love???

Get a grip, get out of that bed, and if she's tired, send her home!

Posted

Well, Micah sure had a lot to say.

But I got a lot out of it too..
Ever since birth, I had the "marriage before sex" hammered in my head. Needless to say, I slipped.. badly.. and ended up sinning hardcore. It seemed innocent in the beginning.. just a kiss or two or holding hands while walking around somewhere. Let's just say that it got worse. Wayy worse.
Now I'm trying hard to reform my life and make some changes that needed to be taken care of a really long time ago. I want to be saved = ]

Theologian in Training
Posted

[quote name='Mary-Kathryn' post='1150895' date='Dec 28 2006, 12:09 PM']
So, how many times are you going to play russian roulette before the gun goes off?

I am a mother and I can't believe you are doing something so incredibly irresponsible. You have a girlfriend. The two of you obviously share such intimate feelings for one another that you can comfortably share a bed. And you want to keep doing this until there comes the time that you make love???

Get a grip, get out of that bed, and if she's tired, send her home!
[/quote]
:lol:

Spoken like a true mother! :)

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...