Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

This past weekend the pastor of our parish told us to find a different church to go to. I've never really heard of this in a Catholic church before, any thoughts or advice? :idontknow:

Posted

WEIRD.

do you know why??

it happened at our Church once...but that's because someone had a restraining order against this lady who went there. the poor woman is a German war bride and has been through a lot. people at our Church were never very Christ-like to her. ....granted she was never very Christ like to anyone else. she once called my sister and i a derogatory name for being altar servers. :ohno: but our old Priest was very very tolerant of her. she'd get up and yell during homilies and he'd just patiently keep on preaching while she'd walk around the church and scream.

Posted

Its sort of a long story. I'll try to give the quick overview.

The parish is sort of traditional and had a very wonderful priest for many years. He passed away in Feb. In October we finally got a pastor, and in the bulletin for the first week that he was there h e said he wanted to respect our traditions. But then by the second week he was already getting rid of the use of the communion rail. The past two months they've been changing the way people go up for communion, but they were allowing people to line up either at the rail or down the center to stand to receieve.

This weekend he said that nobody was supposed to line up for the rail any longer, if you want to use it you have to go up the center, then move over to the rail then he will walk over and give it to you. After Mass my Mom went up to him and asked if he would reconsider phasing out the rail because it means so much to the people at the church and he said no. Then she said that he had said he wanted to keep our traditions and this was our tradition and he said not to come here for that and to find a different church. He said it several times, she asked if he was telling her to find a different church he said yes, and she walked away.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

I hope one of our priests will respond to this thread. :( I certaInly would not leave a parish for such reasons!

Posted

[quote name='isilzha' post='1150497' date='Dec 27 2006, 12:03 PM']
Its sort of a long story. I'll try to give the quick overview.

The parish is sort of traditional and had a very wonderful priest for many years. He passed away in Feb. In October we finally got a pastor, and in the bulletin for the first week that he was there h e said he wanted to respect our traditions. But then by the second week he was already getting rid of the use of the communion rail. The past two months they've been changing the way people go up for communion, but they were allowing people to line up either at the rail or down the center to stand to receieve.

This weekend he said that nobody was supposed to line up for the rail any longer, if you want to use it you have to go up the center, then move over to the rail then he will walk over and give it to you. After Mass my Mom went up to him and asked if he would reconsider phasing out the rail because it means so much to the people at the church and he said no. Then she said that he had said he wanted to keep our traditions and this was our tradition and he said not to come here for that and to find a different church. He said it several times, she asked if he was telling her to find a different church he said yes, and she walked away.
[/quote]

I'm so sad that this happened. I realy feel that your Bishop, as the Chief Pastor of the Local Church, needs to hear about this.

Prayers.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted
:( It always upsets me when priests come to a parish with an agenda to get rid of perfectly orthodox and pious traditions. It's like when a school hires a principal who comes in and fires all the orthodox catechists.

Pray for him and for the bishop.

Edited to add in response to dUSt's post below: yes, be obedient to your priest, but pray for him nonetheless to respect your traditions...keeping in mind, "Thy Will be done." ;)
Posted

Unless your priest is out-of-line with church teaching, you really should be obedient to him. Stay at your parish. Fall in line with his instruction. Talk to him, work things out, and maybe persuade him to become more traditional--but in a cooperative and charitable manner.

A priest has authority over the laity, and we shouldn't forget that. When parishes get it turned around the other way, it's not good.

Posted

Go to your bishop.

No priest should do this- at all.

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='dUSt' post='1150504' date='Dec 27 2006, 02:12 PM']When parishes get it turned around the other way, it's not good.
[/quote]
:yes:

Posted

We haven't done anything disobedient, and to be obedient we have to leave.

We're already looking into the other parishes in the area, but I think the way he did this is just really bad. This is the sort of story you'd hear about happening to someone and they'd leave the church for 30 years, luckily my family is very committed to the church, but my Dad is taking RCIA, and I hope this doesn't sour his experience with the church.

Posted

What city in Illinois are you?

[quote name='isilzha' post='1150523' date='Dec 27 2006, 01:40 PM']
We haven't done anything disobedient, and to be obedient we have to leave.

We're already looking into the other parishes in the area, but I think the way he did this is just really bad. This is the sort of story you'd hear about happening to someone and they'd leave the church for 30 years, luckily my family is very committed to the church, but my Dad is taking RCIA, and I hope this doesn't sour his experience with the church.
[/quote]

Posted

I live in Illinois, but my church is in Wisconsin.

Posted

It seems to me that the Pastor is at variance with Canon Law. If the bishop is sympathetic then approach him. The relevant canons are:

Can. 213 Christ's faithful have the right to be assisted by their Pastors from the spiritual riches of the Church, especially by the word of God and the sacraments.

Can. 214 Christ's faithful have the right to worship God according to the provisions of their own rite approved by the lawful Pastors of the Church; they also have the right to follow their own form of spiritual life, provided it is in accord with Church teaching.

The key is the last part ..."provided it is in accord with Church teaching."

Posted

Your priest is between a rock and a hard place. I am sure not all members in your parish agree about everything. With any new priest comes new ideas. Count your blessings that you have a priest. In my parish we share a priest with 2 other parishes. We never see him.
Pick your fights, a railing is physical...worry more about his spiritual ideas. He is your spiritual father, if you cant join in with him, find a new parish.
I have not seen an altar rail in many, many years. Did not know they were still around except in old churches where they are part of the architecture. I am surprised that people consider them of importance(Now, don't jump down my throat, am offering my opinion, it may not be yours)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='alicemary' post='1150538' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:41 PM']
Your priest is between a rock and a hard place. I am sure not all members in your parish agree about everything. With any new priest comes new ideas. Count your blessings that you have a priest. In my parish we share a priest with 2 other parishes. We never see him.
Pick your fights, a railing is physical...worry more about his spiritual ideas. He is your spiritual father, if you cant join in with him, find a new parish.
I have not seen an altar rail in many, many years. Did not know they were still around except in old churches where they are part of the architecture. I am surprised that people consider them of importance(Now, don't jump down my throat, am offering my opinion, it may not be yours)
[/quote]

I agree with that... I feel sorry for any Priest who has to replace a beloved Priest at any Parish... He is not the same person and of course, will not hold all the same ideas.
Maybe your mother should talk to him again, but about leaving the parish and why he would tell her to (it sounded like a suggestion after an argument... Like "if you don't like what I am doing, go elsewhere")

Maybe your mother was the 50th person after Mass to complain about the rail being phased out? Maybe he's been getting hounded about it since he's gotten there? Maybe he's heard more "why are you doing this and not this" instead of "It's nice to have you Fr. Thanks for being here," ect... Maybe some people are pressure to phase it out? As said, he can't make everyone happy.

A Priest is human just like everyone else... Think of what good he has done for your Parish and such... Then you have to decide is it worth leaving the Parish over a Communion rail?

Just my :2cents:

Edited by CatholicCid
Posted

Maybe she was the 50th person to say something, does that make telling us to leave in the way that he did right?

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='isilzha' post='1150557' date='Dec 27 2006, 04:13 PM']
Maybe she was the 50th person to say something, does that make telling us to leave in the way that he did right?
[/quote]
I don't know about you, but I know that I have gotten upset with someone who has brought something to my attention when I've heard the same thing from others many times already. Priests are human, too. They lose their temper just like everyone else.

Is it right to take it out on someone who's innocent? No. But it happens to all of us.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

So why is he removing the altar rail in the first place?

Posted

Its not being physically removed, just that its use is being phased out.

Posted

That's just plain stupid- when a meaningful and old custom has existed for so long it's not supposed to be done away with.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...