Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Feeling That Being Catholic Was The Wrong Choice!


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi everyone,

I thought I would stop by and add a brief update.

Well...... *sigh*......from 4 friends dead to 10 dead......I'm having a shocking start to the new year........ :shock: :shock: :shock:

I'm sorry.....but I simply cannot be catholic right now.......[b]it hurts sooooo much[/b]....please pray for me feeling totally lost................ :ohno: :ohno: :ohno:

Belinda

Posted
:weep: :weep: :weep:

Prayers for you for sure.
Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1171209' date='Jan 20 2007, 10:28 AM']
Hi everyone,

I thought I would stop by and add a brief update.

Well...... *sigh*......from 4 friends dead to 10 dead......I'm having a shocking start to the new year........ :shock: :shock: :shock:

I'm sorry.....but I simply cannot be catholic right now.......[b]it hurts sooooo much[/b]....please pray for me feeling totally lost................ :ohno: :ohno: :ohno:

Belinda
[/quote]

I will pray.

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

[quote]I'm sorry.....but I simply cannot be catholic right now.......it hurts sooooo much....please pray for me feeling totally lost................ [/quote]

Oh, you poor thing. I'm aching for you. Grief is never easy. At the moment I'm in the frightening position of not knowing whether a close friend of mine is going to die or whether she's going to make it, so I understand a small bit of what you are feeling. :(

It is difficult to think about religion at times like this, but I would like to give you to things to remember. Firstly, Jesus couldn't stop being God even when the hurt of it was killing Him.

Secondly, "There are exchanges of love that only take place on the Cross." (Blessed Elizabeth of the Trinity.)

Bl. Elizabeth was a Carmelite nun who died at a very young age as a result of Addison's Disease, physical and spiritual. There were no sophisticated painkillers back in the nineteenth century and she was nearly driven to suicide by the agony of it all. She felt completely trapped. I will ask her to help you bear this.

:sign:

Posted

Are you able to tell us how these friends died? I will keep you and them in my fervent prayers.

God bless you :sign:

Posted

My friends were murdered :sadder: :sadder: :sadder: :weep: :weep: :weep:
The local parish....they are no help at all......they really don't care :ohno:

My non-Christian friends have been wonderful......they have been there, held my hand and in some cases have reached out from across the world to hold me.......

I'm sorry......becoming catholic was a mistake................. :ohno: :ohno: :ohno:

Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1172037' date='Jan 20 2007, 09:53 PM']
My friends were murdered :sadder: :sadder: :sadder: :weep: :weep: :weep:
The local parish....they are no help at all......they really don't care :ohno:

My non-Christian friends have been wonderful......they have been there, held my hand and in some cases have reached out from across the world to hold me.......

I'm sorry......becoming catholic was a mistake................. :ohno: :ohno: :ohno:
[/quote]

Oh hun, I'm so sorry! :weep:

But, you know what? Your faith, your religion isn't your parish. I'm so sorry that you don't feel comforted by your parish, but I've heard that experience as well. . . not in the same situation as you, but that, in their time of need, someone within their parish wasn't of help. I myself felt a little 'off' regarding my parish as a teen. . .I left the church for several years, and returned, realizing that it wasn't the Church that was an issue, but the church. . meaning the parish. The Catholic Church, like [b]every[/b] church, is made of humans, fallible, sometimes selfish and even sometimes not-so-good humans, but humans nonetheless. You have to recognize why you've become a Catholic. You became a Catholic, in part, I'm sure, because of Jesus, fully present in the Holy Eucharist, is not present in other religions. The Catholic Church is the one faith that is complete. You know? You don't remain Catholic because of people, who will always let you down in some way or another. You remain because of Christ, our Hope, our Love, and our Desire.

I will pray for you. :sign:

cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

Jesus Christ also experienced this abandonment, Belinda. He was let down unbearably...by His own followers. I know, because I am one of the many who have betrayed Him.

I'm so sorry to hear about your friends. So, so sorry. :sadder: I don't understand why your parish isn't offering more comfort, but it might be because they aren't sure how to react. I had a similar experience once. A close friend of mine (who is now close to death) was self-harming seriously, starving herself towards the grave, and refusing to seek help at all. She got this way as a result of sexual abuse that began when she was just a little girl. I managed to persuade her to tell a trusted teacher what she was doing to herself and I felt so relieved afterwards. I thought the teacher would help. I really did. But she didn't do a thing, and a few days later Sophia took a near-fatal overdose.

I still can't believe that the teacher was callous or uncaring. Perhaps she just didn't know how to react when a fourteen-year-old student came to her and started pouring all this out. Some people just turn numb when they hear of tragedy. They can't take it. As Christians we should be able to take anything, but the sad fact is that not all people are capable...yet.

May you know the love of Jesus and the comfort of Mary at this time. If you can manage it, try meditating on the Stations of the Cross or the Sorrowful Mystery of the Rosary. Mary understands. :weep:

Knight of the Holy Rosary
Posted
:sadder:

I will pray for you.

Look for comfort in our Lady's Rosary and our Blessed Lord's compassion.
Im so sorry your parish didn't reflect either of these.
Posted

Belinda,

The God who created your non-Christian friends, is the same God that you and I worship as Catholics. It is He who imprinted in their hearts and conscience the natural light of reason, whether or not they know and believe it, and they used that God-given reason to comfort you in your time of need. So, it is really God who is reaching out to you through them. The fact that your friends have helped you, and the local church members have not, only shows how far that God would go to reach out and comfort you, in that, He would use non-believers in order to reach you.

Christ is not limited by the actions of any one or several members of His body, that is, if some of His members fail to carry out His mission in the world, then He will use whomever He wants in order to accomplish His mission, and His mission is ultimately to incorporate all the people of the world into His Body the Catholic (Universal) Church. He desires that relationship with you and desires all of us into one body, one communion, and Him being the Head of us all. The only thing that Christ will never do is force you to love Him. He is a lover, not a rapist, He seeks you out in your pain, and desires to walk with you, and sometimes the way He seeks us may not make sense to us, like the example here of unbelievers, instead of local believers, comforting you.

Belinda, when you became a Catholic, it was the greatest thing you could have ever done in your life, even though it is very hard for you right now to see that. Becoming Catholic means that you've accepted Christ's invitation of a love-relationship with him, and in a love-relationship, one needs to be patient when confronting the trials of life, and never quit the relationship. It is especially through hardships that the relationship must become closer and stronger. God has promissed that nothing will separate His love towards you, and He will seek you until the end. In turn, don't give up, don't separate your love towards Him. Life is meaningless without Him. The pain you are going through right now is nothing compared to the pain of being without Him.

He created the Church for you, to help you, and if the local church is not accomplishing His will, seek out other members of His Church. For one, this is a good forum, and there are several faithful Catholics on here who will pray for you and comfort you in the way that they can. If I knew you in person, I would give you a hug.

God loves you Belinda, stay strong.

Rony

Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1151854' date='Dec 30 2006, 12:31 AM']
[b]Post disclaimer- person posting has had very little sleep for several weeks now and is grieving the violent death of 4 four friends, so please take what is said in that context![/b]

Hi Pham,

I guess in the spiritual sense I have hit the hall. The more I study the churches doctrine the more I find that I believe the opposite.....

The main areas of conflict are-
primacy of the Pope/Rome
Holy Spirit proceeding from the Father/Son
ordination of women
contraception
abortion (use in rape not allowed, so I'm told?!?)
and a few other issues.....

I have put the brakes on discernment......and I am wondering if by being baptised the right choice was made??????????????????

Right now I could walk away from the church and not bat an eye lid....yet there are aspects and doctrine I love.....

Your advice please.

Belinda
[/quote]

Belinda, you said you're going through a tough time right now and that is most probably the source of your difficulty.

Faith is a bit like vitality: illness decrease our vitality, likewise certain things can decrease our faith. Sin can decrease our faith, but anything that scars us emotionally can also do that. We just have to endure to end and ask Jesus to help us with our Cross.

In difficult times, the best thing to do is cross yourself and talk to Jesus, Mary, your guardian angel, and Saints.

Your objections seem to reflect a "liberal" line of thinking. I think it's appropriate to ask why some of us naturally incline to that "liberal" line of thought. I think it has to do with the fact I was raised and inundated with liberal teaching from childhood. Just about all my teachers were liberals and so naturally my conscience was molded that way. For years I never questioned things like abortion because I was taught it was right. This however is unacceptable. God gives us the grace to see the ugliness in such things, we need only to accept it, and strive to acquire a Christian mind set.

Lastly, for any problem like Primacy I suggest going to the foundation. Take a look at Matthew 16:18. Jesus' Church is built on Peter, and that Church will never be destroyed. If you look carefully you'll see Jesus is making a prophecy. The Pope sits on the chair (See) of Peter, and hence all those in union with the Successor of Peter are part of that Church Christ established. Those who deny this, say something silly like "Jesus was referring to Peter's confession." Any thought I had of rejecting Petrine Primacy was shattered with this verse, I simply can't reject the fact that Jesus is referring to Peter and not his confession. It's simply too obvious.

Well, those are my 3 cents ;)

God bless,
Mort

Posted

I encourage you to turn to Catholicism and stay strong in it. Satan attacks those he thinks are weak. He wants you to leave the Church because he knows it will harm you to do so. I also encourage you to receive the Eucharist daily, and while doing so, pray for the strength He provides. Above all, seek God and put your trust in Him. Give your life to Him. Offer everything as a sacrifice of love for Him who sacrificed himself for you.

Posted
:) Waving hello again.

Just wanted to post a quick update of sorts.

While my questions have not been settled, I am finally starting to heal up.

Discernment is still on ice, but I will be making my oblation with Tyburn all the same.
Once strong enough I'll dig into my questions, but not until I am ready.

catch you all later,
Belinda
cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1180855' date='Jan 30 2007, 09:10 PM']
:) Waving hello again.

Just wanted to post a quick update of sorts.

While my questions have not been settled, I am finally starting to heal up.

Discernment is still on ice, but I will be making my oblation with Tyburn all the same.
Once strong enough I'll dig into my questions, but not until I am ready.

catch you all later,
Belinda
[/quote]
Take you time and heal dearie, the Church will still be there :)
God bless.

Posted (edited)

[quote]The main areas of conflict are-
primacy of the Pope/Rome
Holy Spirit proceeding from the Father/Son
ordination of women
contraception
abortion (use in rape not allowed, so I'm told?!?)
and a few other issues.....
[/quote]

These are hard issues to deal with. I would be happy to talk with you about these Belinda, I have loved ones at this moment going through these exact same issues. Please, think about these issues and open your mind to the loving word of your Phat-Phamily.


[quote]abortion (use in rape not allowed, so I'm told?!?)[/quote]

Also on the issues of Abortion. Many, many pro-abort doctors, and people use the argument against pro-life Christians that in case of rape children [b]have to live and be a nightmare to the victim their life[/b]. After speaking to a close family friend who is a doctor, he has stated that most people who fall prey to that type of logic do not realize that 95% of women, sadly who fall prey to rape [b]do not become pregnant[/b]. Horrifically, some of them go the opposite direction and end up not being able to have little ones of their own. Abortion organizations are realizing the threat of the pro-life movment and they are willing to use any type of crafty logic they can get their hands on, this includes throwing mud at religious organizations that are strictly pro-life and say that in case of rape they child has to live.

However, in a sheer case when the woman does become pregant, sadly the child normally is a stillborn baby and 9 time out of 10 does not make it out of the womb alive. Even if the child did live, and you didn't abort it you could give it up for adoption so a [b]life is spared and you don't have to live with the nightmare[/b]. Please pray about this highly controverisal issue.

Edited by GloriaIesusChristi
cathoholic_anonymous
Posted

Let her breathe. Let her rest. Let her heal. It is hard to study Catholic doctrine when your mind and her heart are sore. :(

I am praying for you, Belinda.

brandelynmarie
Posted

Pax Christi & :sign:

Posted

[quote name='In His Light' post='1180855' date='Jan 30 2007, 06:10 PM']
:) Waving hello again.

Just wanted to post a quick update of sorts.

While my questions have not been settled, I am finally starting to heal up.

Discernment is still on ice, but I will be making my oblation with Tyburn all the same.
Once strong enough I'll dig into my questions, but not until I am ready.

catch you all later,
Belinda
[/quote]

Belinda

Keep us updated on how things go with your oblation. I am still discerning Tyburn in England, but now I am also thinking about the Mobile Alabama Visitation convent! I would be interested in hearing how Tyburn works for you.

As for all your other theological concerns, about the controversies surrounding the Catholic Church: Mother Teresa simply said, on many occasions: they are temporary - they will pass.

I am so sorry about your friends and pray that God will heal your heart.

  • 2 weeks later...
Posted

Hello again,

Well I come to ask your prayers as I have a most difficult choice to make...... :ohno:

Phamily.....my catholic spiritual life has fallen to bits. My faith in the church is shattered. My faith in some of her people is shattered....and I do not feel that I can call myself Catholic any longer.....

I ask your prayers, this one last time......I am ready to walk away.......

Belinda

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...