Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Is It Ok To Sin If...


Recommended Posts

Posted

Just curious for your view on this. Also, please don't try to get specific with it because it's not intended to be a specific question.

Is it right to sin in order to aid someone you love? (Assuming there's no other recourse.)

Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1152358' date='Dec 30 2006, 07:03 PM']
Just curious for your view on this. Also, please don't try to get specific with it because it's not intended to be a specific question.

Is it right to sin in order to aid someone you love? (Assuming there's no other recourse.)
[/quote]
maybe someone else will be able to answer this, but, from what i can tell, there are just too many extenuating variables involved to answer this question in a general way. in other words, i need more specifics.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

The ends don't justify the means. It is never okay to sin.

Think of it this way: one may want to sin to aid someone s/he loves, but one should love God above all, and all sin offends God. If a person sins in order to aid a loved one, then that person puts that loved one above God (though I wouldn't think the person would be consciously aware that the particular instance is a violation of the first commandment).

Depending on circumstances, culpability may be diminished, but it's never objectively okay.

However, there are some things which may be sins in certain circumstances but are not in others. The popular example is stealing to feed one's family (assuming they cannot afford to purchase food). Stealing is intrinsically wrong, but in this situation, it wouldn't technically be stealing in the eyes of God, due to the principle of the common destiny of goods. Stealing is only stealing when it is an unjust taking away of the goods [b]rightfully[/b] belonging to one and not to another. We may possess goods, but we are primarily stewards of goods for one another. Therefore, if another person is in need (not want, but need), it is a moral obligation to dispense with one's rights to goods in order to share, thus serving the higher purpose of goods. In times of need, likewise, those goods necessary for human life cannot rightfully be claimed by one over another but must be shared, since the primary purpose of the goods demands this. As you can see, if it's not stealing, then no one can say, "it's okay to steal in times of need." It is never right to sin.

Posted

It is better to die then to sin.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...