Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Does baptism of desire (BOD) always signify an explicit desire for baptism? Like if a catechumen dies before his baptism day, he would likely have BOD. But is it also possible to have an implicit desire in order to have BOD? And if so, then of what would this implicit desire consist? Surely it wouldn't merely be that if they knew it was necessary then they'd automatically desire it, as that would mean that all non-baptised people would have it.

thessalonian
Posted

Well first of all I don't believe that anyone has it before death. If what you are saying is true the Church would be conditionally baptizing everyone, as they do if they are uncertain if someone has had water baptism or not. Secondly it is not normative and therefore falls in the realm of God's judgement of the hearts of those who are before him on the day of their judgement. He, knowing what grace he has given them will judge whether they did the best they could with what they had. If he judges them so, then he takes care of the baptizing, i.e. cleansing of the sin, as he did with the theif on the cross. Speculatively speaking I believe that it could in fact include someone who did their best to follow God as they knew him and would have been baptized had they known about baptism.

The same question can be applied to the Eucharist. The scriptures say "unless you eat of the flesh of the son of man and drink his blood you shall not have life within you". Yet the Church seems to indicate that Protestants can have God's life within them, but do not partake of the Eucharist. The only way I can reconcile this is from the standpoint of ignorance and if they had known and had the grace to know (which includes the case you are questioning) then they are culpable, but if not then they of course are in ignorance and had no ability to know. With regard to the passage there are those who were there and heard his words. The ones who rejected them, both his disciples and the Jews, were accountable for what they heard. Therefore the judgement of the words, "you shall not have life in you" rests on them. Those of course who accepted them are sanctified by them. But there is of course the group that did not hear them from the mouth of Christ and may have imperfectly heard them from us or not heard them at all. Some may well be culpable as they heard them adequately. God is left as the judge and if he wants to baptize and sanctify them who am I to say. God is not bound by his sacraments.

goldenchild17
Posted

[quote name='Dave' post='1154646' date='Jan 2 2007, 01:26 PM']
Does baptism of desire (BOD) always signify an explicit desire for baptism? Like if a catechumen dies before his baptism day, he would likely have BOD. But is it also possible to have an implicit desire in order to have BOD? And if so, then of what would this implicit desire consist? Surely it wouldn't merely be that if they knew it was necessary then they'd automatically desire it, as that would mean that all non-baptised people would have it.
[/quote]

I'm not finished in my study in this area but right now I believe it applies to those to explicitly desire it such as the catechumens, or a person (for example) like Rich Mullins who was directly on his way to his baptism when he died; or any non-catholic (usually children) who are prohibited from being baptised by their parents but who directly and openly wish to recieve it, but die before being allowed to.

Thy Geekdom Come
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1154704' date='Jan 2 2007, 02:34 PM']
I'm not finished in my study in this area but right now I believe it applies to those to explicitly desire it such as the catechumens, or a person (for example) like Rich Mullins who was directly on his way to his baptism when he died; or any non-catholic (usually children) who are prohibited from being baptised by their parents but who directly and openly wish to recieve it, but die before being allowed to.
[/quote]
I think the Church pretty clearly includes those who followed the good they knew, i.e. the natural law written on their hearts, to the best of their ability.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

Maybe your church. There is an element of invincible ignorance that exists but I can't accept it the way V2 on teaches because if anybody that followed what they knew to the best of their ability went to heaven, then pretty much most people would go to heaven and it takes away the necessity of the graces given through the Church. I can't accept that and neither can my Church.

"Perfect conversion and penitence is rightly called baptism of desire, and in necessity at least, it supplies for the baptism of water. [b]It is to be noted that any conversion whatsoever cannot be called baptism of desire[/b]; but only perfect conversion, which includes true contrition and charity, and at the same time [b]a desire or vowed intention of baptism[/b]" (De Sacramento Baptismi, Liber I cap. VI).

Edited by goldenchild17
thessalonian
Posted (edited)

[quote]because if anybody that followed what they knew to the best of their ability went to heaven, then pretty much most people would go to heaven and it takes away the necessity of the graces given through the Church. I can't accept that and neither can my Church.[/quote]

This is a judgement. We do not in fact know how many do or don't go to heaven. It is presumptuous to assume that ANYONE outside the visible confines of the Catholic Church would go to heaven if they died or even if they would, would persevere in the grace they have been given. Your church is a distorted one. A schismatic sect. It is interesting that by your interpretation of EENS you are among the damned. However I won't judge you.

Blessings

Edited by thessalonian
Guest JeffCR07
Posted

anyone who speaks of "my Church" is not speaking of Christ's Church. True Catholics profess faith that the Holy Spirit guides the Church infallibly, and, as such, we see the Second Vatican Council as a legitimate expression of the Magesterial authority of the Church. As such it must be taken in line with all of the other Holy Councils of the Church, and its continuity must be maintained.

Now, with regards to this issue, it is my view that thessalonian is correct, but some qualifications must be made. Invincible ignorance can provide an implicit baptism of desire, provided the individual genuinely strive to follow the natural law written in the hearts of men. However, it is also universally true that someone who is in a state of mortal sin cannot aquire heaven. It is also true that the surest way to guard against such a state is through the Sacraments of the Church. Given this, we must say that while it is theoretically possible for someone to be saved through an implicit baptism of desire, the extreme difficulty of living one's entire life in accord with the natural law in such a way that one does not fall into a state of mortal sin without the ability to avail oneself of the Sacraments is an extremely difficult thing.

As such, we can neither limit God's power to save, nor claim that we know it in its entirety, but we must also be active in our striving to convert, for we know what a true difference the sacraments make.

thessalonian
Posted

Agreed.

Posted

[quote name='Raphael' post='1154770' date='Jan 2 2007, 04:51 PM']
I think the Church pretty clearly includes those who followed the good they knew, i.e. the natural law written on their hearts, to the best of their ability.
[/quote]

Yay Raphael! That's what I believe, only I put it in too many words, and don't say it as well....

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...