Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Do You Believe The Magi Were Real?


True Existence of Magi  

67 members have voted

You do not have permission to vote in this poll, or see the poll results. Please sign in or register to vote in this poll.

Recommended Posts

Theologian in Training
Posted

I do not want this to end up in the Debate Table nor do I want it to end up in the Transmundane Lane, because I am not looking for any proofs or arguments (maybe a little justification, but that is it). I am trying to write my Q&A for the bulletin and I am having a hard time writing it.

thanks

Laudate_Dominum
Posted

Si senor. Because the bible told me so.

Posted

Hmmm.

I never questioned it. I always assumed that they were historically real.

:idontknow:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

IF the star was real why wouldn't the magi be real? It probably took them a year or so to travel, but that is no reason to doubt the story...

Here's the earliest preserved meditation on Matthew's star of Bethlehem story, by Ignatius of Antioch in his letter to the Ephesians in the early second century:

CHAPTER 19
19:1 And hidden from the prince of this world were the virginity of Mary and her child-bearing and likewise also the death of the Lord -- three mysteries to be cried aloud -- the which were wrought in the silence of God.

19:2 How then were they made manifest to the ages? A star shone forth in the heaven above all the stars; and its light was unutterable, and its strangeness caused amazement; and all the rest of the constellations with the sun and moon formed themselves into a chorus about the star; but the star itself far outshone them all; and there was perplexity to know whence came this strange appearance which was so unlike them.

19:3 From that time forward every sorcery and every spell was dissolved, the ignorance of wickedness vanished away, the ancient kingdom was pulled down, when God appeared in the likeness of man unto newness of everlasting life; and that which had been perfected in the counsels of God began to take effect. Thence all things were perturbed, because the abolishing of death was taken in hand.

homeschoolmom
Posted

I had no idea this was even a question....

IcePrincessKRS
Posted

I always believed they were real. When I saw this thread I got a little nervous and started thinking maybe I'm the only moron and they're actually just symbolic or some story someone made up. Don't scare me like that. lol

Posted

I'm interested to hear from the person who thinks they're symbolic ...

Posted (edited)

They're real.

It's often a small step from declaring particular events and characters in the Gospels to be myths or "symbolic" to a "Modernist" interpretation in which much of the Gospel is dismissed as fable or symbolic, including Christ's divinity and Resurrection.

Edited by Socrates
Posted

[b]They are real. [/b] Pope Benedict XVI prayed before their relics in Cologne, Germany during World Youth Day.

Posted

Many people think they are a mid-rash, just a rephrasing of the shepards story...


Common evangelical belief

Posted

Um, exactly what I was thinking, St. Benedict. How could they not have been real if we have their relics? :idontknow:

MilesChristi
Posted

Real.

[quote]Many people think they are a mid-rash, just a rephrasing of the shepards story...


Common evangelical belief[/quote]

Images of the wise men dated from the beginning of the second century can be found painted in the catacombs of St. Priscilla in Rome. It seems that folks back then considered them to be real, and Catholics still do today. Another example of the saying, "To be deep in history is to cease to be Protestant."

Posted

The mid rash would not have been developed in time, rather something Matthew used to describe the wise men as a midrash for the sheperads is just a theory that neither of us can prove and I do not see as mattering to soteriology

homeschoolmom
Posted

[quote name='Revprodeji' post='1155585' date='Jan 3 2007, 08:28 PM']
Many people think they are a mid-rash, just a rephrasing of the shepards story...
Common evangelical belief
[/quote]
I would hardly say "common."

Posted

[quote name='homeschoolmom' post='1155638' date='Jan 3 2007, 10:43 PM']
I would hardly say "common."
[/quote]
I'd say more common among modernists and liberal protestants than Evangelicals.

Theologian in Training
Posted

I was obviously doing research for the Q&A about Epiphany, and so many times, and I was taught, that the Magi were merely symbolic figures, but not real in any sense of the word. I, of course, disagree with this, but wanted to see what the general consensus was as well.

Thank you this has been very helpful

Posted

I voted yes, but one thing that bothers me is how people "know" where their relics are. I visited the Cologne Cathedral in 2005 during WYD and while it was very impressive, I just don't see how anyone could be certain that the bones there are anything special.

heavenseeker
Posted

never been givven reason to question it

Posted

your right the term "common" cant be used because the common evangelical doesnt know the term midrash and could care less.

Protestantism is nicely divided in a civil war, liberals and fundis. the fundis take the story as absolutly real and to question is it damning im sure.,

where as the remainder are open to the possibility that it is a midrash

do i carE? no..not one bit, I dont think faith, or anything is changed in this issue. Go back in time and tell me for certain that it wasnt a mid rash. It wont change anything. I really dont care if it is literal or he is using a common jewish writing tech

Posted

I believe they were real. I take everything in the New Testament fairly literally (and most of the Old).

And as a former Evangelical, I would have to say that anyone who didn't believe in the Magi were real (and therefore doubted the Scriptures) isn't an Evangelical, at least, not a good one.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...