Maria Posted January 4, 2007 Posted January 4, 2007 The celebration of the feast on Monday reminded me of numerous conversations I’ve had with protestants of all stripes. After explaining that the point of the title is to be a triumphant assertion that Christ has 2 natures (human & divine) and that his person is the 2nd person of the Blessed Trinity (God), they usually concede the validity of the title, even if they are uncomfortable with it. I have, however, come across some objections to the title that were not resolved, and they both concern the nature of motherhood. In one of them, the person felt comfortable calling Mary ‘Theotokos’, but felt that ‘Mother of God’ was inappropriate. She felt that the title of ‘mother’ implied a certain co-operation in the creation of a child, which would not have been possible re: Mary & Jesus. In the other argument, the person held that parents are parents of natures, not persons. I don’t know what line of thought led him to this conclusion. All this goes to show that the title not only says something about who Jesus is, but what it means to be a mother. It’s something to be explored further.
thessalonian Posted January 5, 2007 Posted January 5, 2007 (edited) I don't know why people keep arguing against God and the Bible on this one. How hard is "How is it that the MOTHER OF MY LORD should come to me?" to understand. Was Jesus her Lord because he was human? No, because he was devine. If he had just been human he would not have been her Lord. The word translated throughout scripture to Lord is the four letter word for God, YHVH. So it is "Mother of my YHVH", ie. God. i.e. Mother of my God i.e. Mother of God. Yet they continue to argue against this. It is so sound biblically and literal that it is just stubornness to deny it. Jesus existed as a baby in Mary's womb for 9 months. He passed through the birth canal and came in to this world. She cared fore him as he grew. That's a mother to me. God creates naturea and places them in the body. God is the creator of the soul and so saying that Mary is not the mother of God is saying women are not the mother of their children because they did not create the soul and ensoul the child. It's baffling how they can deny this. They must not think. Their bias against Catholicism must force them to ignore the blatant scriptural truth. Edited January 5, 2007 by thessalonian
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 5, 2007 Posted January 5, 2007 Just to refute the two points that were brought up against you: 1.) Mary [i]did[/i] cooperate with God in the creation of the Christ child. Her fiat was her consent that the will of God be done, and it was only after giving such a fiat that the Spirit overshadowed her and she became with child. Moreover, Christ's physical body came from Mary, and along with it came his human nature. If that isn't "cooperation" I don't know what is. 2.) This point is, quite simply, wrong. Mothers give birth to [i]people[/i] not "natures." We know this both by common sense and by philosophical reasoning. Common sense could never deny the personhood of a newborn child, and that child has a mother. Philosophically, "natures" are not Platonic hypostases and do not exist on their own as seperable entities. Moreover, even the most staunch platonist or exaggerated realist would deny the claim that hypostatized nature would be seperable into individuals, rather, they would argue that the universal is itself a hypostatized entity in which individuals partake. From all this, it follows that Mary is not the "mother of christ's human nature alone," but rather, that Mary is the mother of the [i]person[/i], Jesus Christ, and that person has two natures, a divine nature, which he has from the Father, and a human nature, which he has from Mary, his mother. Your Brother In Christ, Jeff
Maria Posted January 7, 2007 Author Posted January 7, 2007 (edited) [quote name='JeffCR07' post='1156820' date='Jan 5 2007, 04:15 PM'] Just to refute the two points that were brought up against you: 1.) Mary [i]did[/i] cooperate with God in the creation of the Christ child. Her fiat was her consent that the will of God be done, and it was only after giving such a fiat that the Spirit overshadowed her and she [/quote] Yes, but that doesn't deal with the problem, because that's Mary co-operating with the creation of the human nature of Jesus. If we say that who Jesus is is God, then it's not co-operating in the creation of who Jesus is. Do you begin to see the problem? BTW, the guy who advanced the second argument (this was a while back) now doesn't know why he advanced it. "Only thing I can think of is that I must have been identifying the non-caporeal aspect of our being, our soul, as distinct from our flesh and considering mothering as giving birth to flesh. My mother did not birth my soul, God did ;-)" He still objects to the title, saying that the line of thought includes a "subtle yet illogical switch from one person to three". Apparently he thinks that the noun 'God' must always refer to the three Persons. Edited January 7, 2007 by Maria
phatcatholic Posted January 12, 2007 Posted January 12, 2007 some articles to help you with this, if you are still interested: [url="http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/13"]http://www.phatmass.com/directory/index.php/cat/13[/url]
Guest JeffCR07 Posted January 13, 2007 Posted January 13, 2007 If the noun "God" must always refer to the three persons, then it follows that he is asserting that Jesus, considered as a seperate person from the Father and the Spirit, was not God. In that line of thinking, Christ is only God when he is considered alongside the other persons. Such a position is quite simply false. Its not like God = Father + Son + Holy Spirit. The Son [i]is[/i] God, pure and simple. The Father [i]is[/i] God, pure and simple. The Holy Spirit [i]is[/i] God, pure and simple. The Father and the Son considered together are the same God as the Father or Son is considered alone. So too with the Father and the Holy Spirit, and the Son and the Holy Spirit. To say that it isn't "God" unless it is all three squares neither with Scripture nor Tradition, and is philosophically and theologically indefensible.
brookemz Posted January 14, 2007 Posted January 14, 2007 I've recently had to defend this title, also, and defend the rosary. Our neighbors are Protestant, and our daughter plays with theirs quite a bit. Not too long ago, the girl came over and asked why my daughter couldn't go to church with them. She said, in a quite disdainful manner, "She said she couldn't go because she's going to be Catholic." I told her that we were Catholic. A few days later, our daughter came home from there and said that the girl had told her that we were going to hell "because we just got sprinkled with water." Well, that sparked a whole debate. I had to end up explaining to the parents that we don't worship Mary and the Saints, that we converse with them in hopes that they will intercede on our behalf. Then the rosary and the title "Mother of God" came up. I gently pointed them toward the appropriate (and, as thessalonian pointed out, very clear and obvious) scripture. They conceded to that, but now, unfortunately, our kids don't hang out because the girl still tells our daughter at every turn how we are wrong. (my daughter is 5 and their daughter is 8, if anyone was curious.)
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now