Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Hello

I have had this thought buzzing around in my head, and want it cleared up, especially when questioned on the issue.

1) It is my understanding that Catholics cannot publically pray in places of worship belonging to other denominations or other religions, under pain of mortal sin? This would be 'communicatio in sacris' (spelling?)?

2) I know that our current Pope recently entered a mosque and simulated prayer towards Mecca. Now I realise (presuming 1) is correct) that for any ordinary Catholic to do that, is to commit a twofold sin, that of scandal, and of communicatio in sacris. Now how is it that the Pope is allowed to do this? (I do understand that the Pope is not endorsing the religion of Islam, but be applicable to actions nevertheless, my question is still there).

(I am not trying to create a contraversy, and no, I am not of the SSPX. )

3) Is it permissable for a Catholic to privately hold the opinion that such actions are imprudent, and should never have had happened? What about expressing this opinion, not in overtly public ways, but amongst other individuals?

Thank you. I realise I have posted 3 questions, but still, they are all relevent to the topic.

Posted

JMJ
1/10 - First Wednesday per annum

Hirsap,

1.) We are encouraged to regularly pray with non-Catholic Christians, perhaps even in their own houses of prayer. What we cannot do (and what they cannot do with us) is worship God in a sacramental sense. Thus, it is [i]communicatio in sacris[/i] to receive Anglican Penance or Lutheran communion, but not just to pray with them.

2.) The Vatican made it clear that same day that the Pope was not praying, but simply meditating. Anyone can meditate anywhere they want at any time.

3.) Perhaps, assuming that the person in question knew everything about the situation. I may be allowed to think the Pope's actions were imprudent, but I could very well be wrong. He was there, he knew the situation, and he took what he thought was the prudent action. The safe thing to do is defer.

Hope this helps!

Yours,
Pio Nono

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...