Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='phatcatholic' post='1159278' date='Jan 8 2007, 07:07 PM']
You're opening a can of worms with that question........
[/quote]


Never saw the can.


It is starting to bother me how certain posters (not just you More) feel like they can make fun of something the church has determined in a practice. The church is the shepherd you are the sheep. You are the child, they are the parent. Quit talking back. You sound like a bloody protestant.

:maddest:

/rant

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1161864' date='Jan 12 2007, 01:13 AM']
way to come down hard on Lexi06, :rolleyes: but i'm pretty sure Lexi said that they confessed receiving in a state of mortal sin.

bolded emphasis mine.
[/quote]

In his defense, what St.ThomasMore said is true. The charity which I'm sure he says these things with just doesn't seem to come across, I agree. It is also very important not just to know something is wrong but to understand why it is wrong as well. I thought he did a pretty good job explaining it.

Posted

the Church herself has consistently tried to put the reins back on the idea of EMoHCs. the Church herself says that they must be used only in extra-ordinary cases when, without them, the wait would be far too unbearably long (and seriously, people should be able to wait 10-20 minutes... we should be talkin like if the wait would be 40 minutes at least then maybe add one or two EMoHCs to curb the time)

also, of course, lay men can be instituted as permanent deacons. and, of course, Pope Paul VI supressed the minor orders so that lay men could be instituted as Acolytes, a much more stable ministry with the authority to distribute Holy Communion. it has been a few decades and the bishops have refused to use this option and form a program for the formation of lay acolytes.

the prevelancy of EMoHCs is an abuse. under Church law and allowance, if it becomes necessary to use extra-ordinary ministers on a weekly (or daily for daily mass goers) basis, then the bishop ought to institute acolytes.

why won't the bishops do it? perhaps to be PC, because only men can be deacons and acolytes.

why should they do it? aside from the fact that the Church declares it preferable as a more stable ministry; an acolyte more fully represents an extension of the priest. it is the priest who ought to distribute communion, in keeping with the symbolism of Christ feeding His sheep; you are to be fed by Christ, or by one who is acting in Persona Christi, or, if that is not possible, by one who is an extension of the one acting in persona Christi.

the problem with EMoHCs is that they are an extension of the laity, brought up in order that the laity might feed themselves. in extreme emergency extra-ordinary situations this is allowable by the Church because, in an extra-ordinary situation sometimes we must abandon symbolism and just get the absolute necessity of the distribution of the sacrament.

it is not supposed to be ordinary. there are many ways to establish more ordinary means; first with deacons then with acolytes. such people are instituted by the bishop and able to act and dress as extensions of the priest in distributing communion.

EMoHCs are not to be made ordinary, not to be used on a weekly basis witha schedule, nor dress like the clergy in any way. On those rare occasions when they are used, it is to be clear that they are extensions of the laity, there only for an extra-ordinary situation.

this isn't talk-back to the magisterium, this is what the highest levels of the magisterium have been saying for years. but because of the collegiality of the bishops, Rome does not directly intervene and command the bishops to step in line. nonetheless, this is what Church law says ought to be done: if a state persists in which EMoHCs are absolutely necessary, more deacons and acolytes ought to be installed.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...